Very clean and neat with plenty of indoor seating ice cream shop. I give a lot of credit to the…read moreworker here, since after I came in for ice cream, all the other customers came in talking on there cell phones rather than actually ordering and she was very patient and polite with them, despite all rude indecisive people walking in making her wait to serve them. This place also out of all ice cream places in Middletown has the largest and best selection for if you dairy ice cream or sorbet. I had cannoli ice cream it was good , but white chocolate raspberry Rocky Mountain ice cream was amazing, definitely never seen before and would recommend easily.

Great Ice cream...but terribly unreliable at being open. They post hours and times, then do not…read moreadhere to them. Face book posts being now open all year, but that is not the case. I have ordered delivery from here several times, only to find out they didn't open that day! Disappointing..

Ooof. If contracting Norovirus from the self proclaimed contaminated employee wasn't bad enough - I…read morestill went back and this is also knowing that their gas prices are $0.11 higher than all surrounding stations in the area. I do this to myself. Todays special treat was the surprises behind door number 1 and 2 of the bathrooms. Door 1 was bodily fluid all over the seat and floor. Door 2 was some kind of special sauce smeared on the mirror and door handle once inside. I think it's time to find a new morning coffee spot.

I haven't been to this location for a few months because I hate the service…read more The normal opener has an attitude unless a customer walks in with an attitude, in which case she turns into a puppy. For example, once I asked her if a milkshake refresher was included in a refresher special, and she had an attitude saying it was while pointing at the ad. When I mentioned the add placement throwing me off, I she roughly said something like "refresher" is written on them before walking away with a scoff. I grabbed a basket and picked up a few, but they rang up as normal priced. When I noticed, I said I think there is a mistake or maybe the ad is just for the non-dairy refreshers. I wasn't sure which, but I thought the mistake was probably us. She got nasty again this time barking something like I couldn't expect her to give it to me for the ad price as if I had just demanded that she change the prices or something. I never said anything like that, but I did ask for a refund because of her attitude. Her vibes were as if I was trying to scam her or something, and she was rude when I said I wanted my receipt. Another example is of when I went in to buy several sleeves of rolls. She said the store didn't have any, but I was watching her make buttered rolls when I entered. When I said that the rolls didn't need to be sleeved and I'll even take whatever she was preparing to put on the counter, she copped an attitude about not having rolls. As if my eyes were playing tricks. She was back to preparing the nonexistent rolls before I even left the store. Those are just two examples, but I think they illustrate her demeanor well. Minus her and I don't have any problems with the store. I haven't had any issues there outside of opening hours, either, or whenever there was a different opener. It's just that's the most convenient time for me to make a Stewart's run, so I just avoid this location because she'll probably be there to start my morning off with bad vibes.

Good place for rolled ice cream!…read more The 25 Below kiosk is located on the lower level near the center of the mall. They offer handcrafted ice cream rolls for $6.50 plus tax (9 signature creations or create your own with 1 or 2 available ingredients & choice of whipped cream and up to 3 free toppings). They also offer handcrafted regular ice cream ($3.75-$4.75 plus tax) and milkshakes ($5.49-$6.48 plus tax). You watch the staff make your custom creation in front of you.  I stopped by 25 Below for dessert recently. I ordered one of their signature rolled ice cream cups and chose 7. Ms. Taro - taro cream mixed with nuts topped with whipped cream, cookie dough bits, peanut butter chips, and M&Ms. After ordering and paying, I watched my creation being made with liquid cream base poured onto the metal frozen surface with nuts and prepared by hand with arm strength and ice cream is rolled. Toppings and whipped cream are put on top as the finishing touches for a very nice looking dessert of rolled ice cream. As I expected, the taro rolled ice cream, though a bit milky, was not too sweet, in comparison to the sweetness of the added toppings. This was a good refreshing dessert, especially after having a greasy lunch in the food court.

I just return to this place for the nostalgia. I've been visiting since I was a kid, even though I…read moredidn't live in the area. My friends' mom would bring us on hours long roadtrips to her favorite childhood haunts hoping to make them our own, which we did as adults. I still don't know what any other flavor but Smurf tastes like. It's honestly not my favorite flavor of ice cream as an adult, but it was back in the day, and I relish it for the memories it resurrects. Unfortunately, my friends have passed. The place looks different now, but a cone still brings me back to the days. I keep hearing that the place is so different now, but I feel that's only aesthetically.

Honestly this place is bit sad considering it's in bad location you think would good since it on a…read moremain road, plus with decaying stuff in back. The guy here was very nice and friendly hope he gets more business with summer coming up, got a small sundae with cake batter ice cream and honestly was pretty good, only got a small since wanted ice cream but not oding on it. Prices here were pretty fair, but honestly not much of place to sit and enjoy it, more like order and leave.

Still great customer service and a clean establishment. Ordered a pink drink and a jelly donut! So…read moreso good and fresh. My ordered was ready promptly! I always enjoy stopping in and it's always great!

This place has the best snacks and doughnuts and the customer service is amazing. The staff is very…read morefriendly and you get a complimentary mini doughnut when you order coffee. They definitely know how to make return customers. Lastly, they have so many creative doughnuts that taste amazing.

Love this place! Haven't been here in a long time so it was way over due! Stopped in for date night…read morewith girlfriend and I had my absolute favorite "pasta del la Nona". Location is perfect because then after dinner you can hit the brewery just around the corner to continue a date. Perfect date night scenario. Service is awesome, ambience is perfect and I love this place. Give me pasta or give me death!

After a long stretch on the road between Acadia and Blackwater Falls, we landed in Middletown, NY…read morewith the energy level of two tired turtles. Going out was not in the cards -- pajamas and take-out were the vibe -- so we ordered from Cosimo's, hoping for comfort food without fuss. Success. The crème penne was creamy, soothing, and exactly what travel-weary souls need, and the light pear salad brought a fresh, bright balance that made us feel like we were still making respectable life choices. Portions were generous enough to stretch into a second meal (a road-trip blessing), and everything arrived well-packaged and warm. Simple, satisfying, and perfect for tired travelers who just want to eat well and crawl into bed.

My wife absolutely loves their chocolate crumb ring, my sister also loves there large cookies. So…read moremoist and sweet, you walk in and it's hard to look at one thing, everything looks so good! This place is a gem of a bakery, you can't go wrong here!

Best cakes and pastries. Not overly sweet. I order 6 birthday cakes between April and June every…read moreyear. DELISH!!!!​