All the food here is good. Pizza is good, has a sweet sauce, plates have plenty of food on them…read more But when I come here it is for the Muffaletta! For me, it's the best in the area. I'll get a whole one and eat half that night and save the other half for lunch cold the next day. Always with the extra olive salad. Love the sports memorabilia in the case and the old Superdome seats to wait on your order.

Order at the counter and wait to hear your number. The pizza always comes out HOT!!…read more I always order a cheese pizza slice -its the size of your head - and a meatball. The meatballs are tender and juicy and packed tight. They come in Mo's delicious red sauce which is great for dipping the crust in. It's a tad one the sweeter side and made fresh!! Sprinkle a lil parm on the slice and eat away!! The pizzas come in two sizes small and enough to feed an basketball team large!! There are familiar faces every time I go & its very nostalgic with old broken pizza boards and NoLa charm as part of the decor. I highly recommend you go Enjoy a slice!!!

I finally had the opportunity to try Il Supremo and they did not disappoint!!! Entering the…read morerestaurant you're met with the nostalgia of a cute retro pizza diner that is connected to Super Witch ice cream (will post and cover them later). Despite not placing an order ahead of time (highly recommended) our pizza came out 30 minutes earlier than expected! Service was great and pizza was delicious. Definitely recommend the experience at least once, but you'll for sure return to try everything else (get their pistachio basil ranch!!!) They also do specials and I pray they return with the Birria pizza so that I can try it!!!

While the food was good, the service was frustratingly slow and disorganized. The staff could hand…read moreout pizzas quickly, but anything extra threw off their workflow, resulting in near missed items for multiple parties. They completely forgot our pasta, leaving us waiting 30 minutes while our pizza sat in the heating drawer--and they never called us up when it was ready. Being from Chicago, we've been pleasantly surprised by the decent pizza and pasta scene around Metairie and New Orleans, but will most likely not come back. Edit for date we visited was Sunday 7/5 around 6-6:30 pm

The Tavern at St Pizza is excellent. Could have been a red table cloth Jersey joint and that is a…read morehigh compliment! Very good thin crust pizza and pasta, great service and ambience. Our waitperson, Noelle, was terrific. The meatballs are of a size to make two sandwiches at home. Highly recommend, Waldo the Jersey Boy

My Wife and I have visited this place I believe 5 or 6 times now. Each visit has been great and the…read morefood was fresh, hot and delicious. I posted pics from our last visit in which we ordered the fries, caesar salad, bianca pizza and tomato pie. In previous visits we also ordered the chicken parm, tiramisu and chocolate chip cookie. All were good and worth the purchase. The serving sizes are great at this place. The salads, fries and main dishes are great portion sizes and you get arguably more than what you paid for. The fries at here are a must get imo. They go great alongside the salad and/or pizza. The drinks are also good and sitting at the bar is the way to go if it's just you and your spouse or a buddy.

This was the best pizza I had in New Orleans! I was informed that it would be great before arriving…read moreand I was not disappointed. I went during happy hour and enjoyed their crawfish pizza and draft beers. I sat at the bar and received great service. The location also features an open area to view the pizza being assembled and one family was partaking in assembling their own pizzas. Overall, I highly recommend!

Very disappointing experience at Pizza Domenica. Our party of three ordered pizza, chicken wings,…read moreand pasta, and the meal had far more misses than hits. For starters, they were out of pepperoni - a pizza restaurant out of pepperoni?? The wings were tasteless and covered in a strange dry rub with a texture that reminded me of wet chalk. They didn't taste fire-roasted at all; they seemed more like they had been baked or microwaved. Service was also frustrating. We ordered a beer, wine, and water, but the water never arrived despite reminding our waiter three times. I eventually had to get it myself. The pasta arrived so late that two of us were already halfway through our meals. Unfortunately, it wasn't worth the wait, it was terrible and couldn't finish it. The bill came to $130, including a 3% administrative fee, which felt particularly insulting after spending $39 on three glasses of overpriced wine. Several staff members, were high and the guys in the kitchen, appeared extremely impaired. The positives: The Calabrese pizza was genuinely good, and our waiter was friendly and pleasant despite the service issues. Unfortunately , one good pizza and a friendly waiter weren't enough to overcome the poor quality food, slow/inconsistent service, and extra fees.

I was really excited about this pizza after a long day but when I arrived to pick up my order, I…read morebecame very disappointed. First, nobody greeted me, and I was unsure as to where I should pick up my order. Second, after I told them I was here for a pick up - I was told "to sit right here. It'll only be a few more minutes until it was ready." Then, the cook let me know they had to remake my pizza so it would be another 20 minutes. Now, I don't know if they did not communicate with each other or if he was just trying to avoid bringing up the fact that I was going to have to wait double the amount of time I should have. Yes I do appreciate remaking the pizza (as you should when it doesn't come out how it should be served.) However, the reason I order it in is so I don't have to wait. I'm just disappointed in the customer service recovery here -- no apology, no discount, no complementary drinks or food. I didn't ask for anything because I don't want anything -- I just want you to try to make it right and you didn't even try to do that so that's why I'm posting this review. I will be eating pizza else where in New Orleans. Maybe just stick to beer here.

Decent slab but not the best I've had in Nola. The pie was a little greasier than I like which I…read moreassume could be due to a lesser grade of ingredients than some of your higher end pizza joints. Overall not bad just not my favorite in the city but I'd say it's in the top 5 for sure.

Theo's is definitely the definition of a mid, just-alright pizza spot. I stopped here for lunch…read moreafter walking around Magazine Street. The restaurant was quiet with a nice vibe, and the staff was friendly. I ordered the loaded garlic bread, a cheese pizza, and a large Powerade. I loved that they had Powerade on tap! The garlic bread was pretty mid. It wasn't very flavorful and seemed a little undercooked. The pizza had a very crispy crust, almost like a cracker, with cheese that kind of clumped together. It filled the hole, but I don't think I'll be back.

For the past at least half dozen times we've ordered the house salad & it's bare minimum. Basically…read morelettuce for $20 it's pathetic. I'm including photo of what we received this time versus what they display online.

I get pizza delivered from this location probably once a week, I just ordered my normal a Quattro…read morewith prosciutto... and there is definitely an A team here and a B team here depending on what day I order it. So maybe whoever the team is tonight can meet with the A team and see what they're doing differently. Feels like what's missing is heart... lol but it's probably more technical than that. Sometimes it's literally the best thing I've ever had like literal foodgasm and half the time it tastes like something I wouldn't order again. But then I do and it's amazing and then I do again and it's terrible... get me out of this cycle!

Tried REGINELL'S and grabbed a slice of their Detroit-style pizza with pepperoni and sausage,…read morethick, hearty, and full of flavor. The crust had that perfect balance of crispy edges and soft, airy inside, and the toppings were generous without being overwhelming. I also really enjoyed the atmosphere. The photos lining the walls add a lot of character to the space, and the wine selection displayed on a bottle was a pretty cool touch that stood out and made the place feel thoughtfully designed. Solid pizza, great vibe, and definitely a spot worth checking out if you're in the mood for Detroit-style done right.

By far the best pizza in Nola IMO! This is a New York pie, crispy, no flop, great sauce, I mean I…read morecan't say anything bad about this pie. If you are looking for a fantastic pizza in Nola look no further than Mid City Pizza!

Always looking for decent pizza by the slice! They had cheese slices only, so I could add on any…read moretoppings I wanted...I opted for pepperoni and jalapeños. The staf was cool and got the slice warmed up and out to me in about 5min. It wasn't the world's best pizza but, it was totally fine and a great value for such a large slice at $4.50! I'd stop back in for something quick if I was in the area.