Absolutely fantastic experience! The staff provides very friendly and trustworthy service…read more Welcoming atmosphere. They have a wide, valuable, and unique selection of Pokémon cards, including Japanese. A must-visit shop!

The owner Andrew reached out to me, and was *more* than accommodating; as I'm not a Madison local,…read morehe mailed the card discussed out to me at-cost, at an extremely fair price. Without a doubt, my old review is no longer a point of concern for me. Andrew & Gamer's Library made this more than right. Next time I'm in town visiting family I'll be making another stop by to say thank you in person. Stellar owner, cozy shop. Please give this store a visit.

Best game store! Always something new to find, great prices and outstanding service! So many games…read moreto choose from!

I've been a long-time buyer of their used stock but only recently had the pleasure of doing a…read moretrade-in myself. Noble Knight gave me a generous offer and covered shipping from Canada as well. The process was smooth, easy and Noble Knight's staff communicative and professional. I was worried it would be a difficult thing what with tariffs and the chaos of the current state of shipping, but it was remarkably easy. Fantastic service!

Went here once with my friends a couple years ago, and it was honestly a cool experience. They have…read morea lot of great boards games and games that involve cards. I think its pretty sad that I didn't know about this before!! The guy at the counter was super nice as well. 10 out of 10. It honestly showed me to value smaller businesses because they can be better than those bigger stores

Cool little spot in downtown Stoughton with games as the focus, specifically card and board games…read more Cards such as Magic: The Gathering and Pokémon, that type of card game. They have lots of board game options and want people to play on site. They have snacks and drinks for sale as well. Cool place that focuses on those "nerdy" (I say that lovingly) subcultures

This place is every nerds dream come true!! Every game you can think of is either sold here or can…read morebe ordered. There is also a game room where you can play your friends. This is a really cool place to hang out at if you like board games. You can also sell your games here and purchase new games. Overall great place, I will definitely be coming back here with coworkers!

Stopped by a couple times to purchase dice for DnD. The store was presentable, had a nice selection…read moreof dice and board games; some of which I had never even heard of before. The employee was polite and prompt when ringing me up. All in all, my experience here was nothing extravagant, but it was nice and I will be back.

Strolling down State Street, doing some window shopping. Found this gem of a card store. Love shops…read morethat have a wide selection of greeting cards and other gift items. The staff were friendly and helpful, and able to point me in the right direction. Found a bunch of hilarious (somewhat sarcastic) cards that almost had me rolling on the floor. Thought I was ready to be checked out, and then found a few more fun items at the register. I had to will myself to leave the store before I found more items (and spent more money). A great place for cards and other thoughtful gifts.

This store has a lot of cute cards, stationery, and little gift type items. Some of it is a little…read morepricey, but a lot of it also seems to be locally made. I didn't purchase anything so I can't speak to the service, but it was a fun shop to look around in.

I came during an after-hours event and the shop was great!…read moreThe gems and crystals seem appropriately priced. When you purchase any gems or crystals you have to write down on one of their pieces of paper what and how many your purchasing with the price. They also have a large selection of incense, small tubes, and dried herbs. I had a great time looking through their collection. The owner and employees were super helpful and knowledgable.

Very helpful staff, lovely books, crystals, cards, incense. We wandered in just to look around, and…read morefound really interesting things to purchase. We will visit again soon.

Adorable kids toy store small business with a wide variety of items and super friendly staff!read more

Love this little toy store. Great selection and the owner always has great knowledge of his…read moreproducts

I experienced inexplicable and outright disrespectful conduct from the owner, Bruce, during my last…read morevisit to Capital City Comics. Despite the multiple 1 star reviews citing Bruce's erratic and rude behavior, I decided to give him the benefit of the doubt and support a local comics business. I came here a few times over the past year or two and bought a few things with no issue. Recently I went in and grabbed a giant pile of graphic novels to buy, ~$200 worth. The last few times I came in, he charged books at cover price and is generally amicable and friendly. This visit, he said he could not sell the pile of books I wanted because he had to "do some research" to "save me a few bucks" so that he wasn't "over-charging me". I told him that I don't need to save a few bucks and would just like to buy the books as-is and would pay whatever price he wanted, I didn't care about price, I just wanted the books! He grabbed the pile of books and hid them behind the counter and refused to sell them to me. His mood quickly changed to rude and abrasive. He made multiple abrasive comments, effectively ending the conversation. I left the store feeling quite perplexed as I had been nothing but courteous and kind during the visit, and I couldn't fathom what brought about this spate of complete irrational behavior. Is he developing dementia? I can't explain why the owner of a store would NOT want to sell books to someone. These were all books with multiple printings, all of which I've since found on eBay for 1/2 cover price, so I don't think he was trying to rip me off. I can't put it together. I had ~$1000 set aside to spend on graphic novels over the next month, and needless to say it will NOT be spent at Capital City Comics. Life is too short to put up with being treated disrespectfully. I strongly recommend avoiding this place. People like Bruce give comics a bad name, which is a shame because there are so many good and kind people who read comic books. I would rather pay 10x the price for books than be treated like that again.

Local comic and book store that's been around since the 70's. Packed with inventory but we'll…read moreorganized. Super friendly and knowledgeable owner who is also honest about the value of comics. Support this local Madison gem!