Expectations were high so I was more than disappointed. The salad bar was expensive for what it was, a small cart of bagged salad, the customary toppings, and some dressings. **see photo The pizza was, imo, on par for what you'd expect from a gas station with fresh pizza. The prices were a little high especially considering there are three other places for pizza in 15 minutes' driving time, one of which has the same quality, the two other better. On my pizza, and I know it could have been different for others, the dough was raw on the top half. **see photo What really irked me, and I hear it's changed now, was that you ordered at the counter and left a tip at that time. Before you even had service. Who was I tipping and for what exactly? I heard it's changed but this is a review on my experience. The service was nice, the atmosphere was alright, pretty much what it used be, with a fresh coat of paint, to when it was the former business. I find the interior a little cramped with the furniture they have. Just my .02¢ We will go back for a second chance. read more

See all

Suprisingly good pizza, both thin crust and regular.

I gave this a 3 because this was our first visit, and I can't make a determination based on one visit. This restaurant is where the former "Chinese Mexican Burrito" was, and they've done a great job of remodeling and updating the space. We went for dinner and ordered 2 10 inch pizzas, both with 1 topping, and 2 fountain drinks. With tax and tip, $30. A little steep when compared to other pizza in the area, but not outrageous. First, the good: the sauce is nice, not too sweet and not too thin. There was plenty of sausage on my pizza. The not-great: I suspect the crusts are pre-made. While the thin was really thin, it was still soft in the center. The cheese isn't gooey, but more gloppy. The "hot" sausage is just Italian sausage; not spicy Italian, just Italian. The questionable: the menu says the toasted ravioli is filled with nacho cheese. As a native St. Louisan, that is unforgivable. The salad bar is offered at $2.99 for a one-trip with a meal, or $4.99 unlimited. The "bar" consists of very basic iceberg mix, some cheese, and an assortment of dressings. If the selection is that limited, it should be really fresh and inviting. It was not. All in all, I'll give them more time to get settled, and try again. We love supporting local businesses, and hope this place is successful. read more

Great tasting pizza and they don't skimp on toppings. Love crispy crust and they can do it.

This is the Chicken Spinach Alfredo pizza! OBSESSED! 15 minutes and it was done and right around $20 for a HUGE pizza. read more

Mountain William Pizza - a cheese and asparagus pizza - Pizza Near Me - Forsyth, Missouri

Mountain William in Forsyth is the best restaurant in town. Just had dinner delivered (before the estimated time) and we had the Pizza before and will never go back to Casey's. But we just tried the pasta dinners. Wow! much, much better than we expected. The Manicotti was fabulous, the Spaghetti and meatballs was very tasty. And I want to say no matter what you order. Get some Mushrooms for appitizer. The BEST!!! Thanks Mountain William's you got a customer for life. read more

They use frozen "fried ravioli" and charge $10 for 6 pieces and you can get a box of 24 (Louisa brand) for $3.86 cents and heat them up in your own oven. Plus restaurants can get Louisa in bulk for much cheaper. Way over priced and not interested in wasting my money on frozen food I can make myself. read more

Mountain William Pizza doing the right thing by having just delivered or curbside service and closing their dining room. Not only are they keeping staff and customers safe, they have the best pizza, well worth the almost 40 mile round trip to pick it up! read more

Ehhhh, it ain't Pizza Hut but it's pizza. Over priced salad bar, cardboard crust, I'm sure the sauce had caraway in it. Who puts caraway in pizza sauce. I was underwhelmed. I ended up throwing out more than half the pie. read more

Just spent $24 on a small specialty pizza, 3 Bosco sticks, a very small dipping cup of ranch, and a very small dipping cup of salsa. Yes, salsa! We got home and found out that our overpriced marinara dipping sauce for our overpriced bosco sticks is salsa! Also, our pizza was half specialty and half pepperoni. Even though we paid the price for a whole specialty pizza (normal and expected), they also charged us for an additional topping at the price for a whole pizza. Even though we paid for three toppings worth for the entire pizza. Never been to a place that does that. I called to clarify the charges. They said it was not a mistake. I also mentioned the salsa and that we were unhappy about paying a dollar for a tiny cup of salsa when we wanted marinara. They said they would "try to remedy that next time." I said I don't think there will be a next time, and they hung up on me. This was their second chance from us. Our first time we got a different style of pizza and garlic bread. The pizza is average. Not bad. Not good. But not worth the price tag. The garlic bread was also average and overpriced. We will not be returning. Pizza World in Mount Branson is just a bit further away, cheaper, and much better. If you want pizza in Forsyth, then call Casey's. read more

When they first opened I was empresses with the pizza . Then we went a few other times and it wasn't good. I would Rather have a Casey's pizza. But I will say I went back a few days ago and I enjoyed my pizza. read more

Death by pepperoni you'd think it would be covered well they put some sliced on it and rest is pepperoni crumbles. Supreme pizza less than that. Let's just say pizza failed miserably. Second chance always given next time I'll try spaghetti read more

We have been really happy with this place since day one! Great local pizza with friendly staff!!! We can call and get a pizza in 15 minutes and pick it up and have a quick, easy, tasty, dinner. Great place overall!!! We will definitely continue to support them!! read more

This pizza was so yummy! We tried the gluten-free cauliflower crust and it was amazing! Toppings are quite generous---we had Papa's Deluxe and it was loaded! Glad to know we can get good pizza in Forsyth in a place we can sit down and enjoy it. read more

I ordered pizza for my mom to be delivered to her home. She is elderly and isn't leaving her home since is at risk for the Corona Virus. I live in another state so getting her groceries is difficult. I spoke to a lady on the phone, I didn't catch her name. She was very nice and offered to deliver my mom her meal earlier even though they usually don't do deliveries until after 4 pm. She brought my mom her meal within an hour. My mom was very pleased. She said the pepperoni pizza and cheesy bread sticks were delicious. Portions were large. I will definitely order again. Thank you! read more