I was super excited to order from this company after seeing it on TikTok and all the outstanding comments. I ordered on 10/10/2025. It would have arrived on time if not due to USPS shipping it elsewhere, which was not on Molly's end. But what was on there end was them not shipping half of my paid-for order, and how it was shipped when I received it. Pictures attached will show what makes me not want to order anything else from this company. The level of care is not given when shipping is crazy. If it scuffed the small item, I can't imagine what that could've looked like as a buckle and receiving one damaged. I called them on 10/23/2025 and spoke with the customer service representative, who is amazing and takes her time trying to make heads or tails out of what happened. She is really amazing every time I speak with her. But she claimed they would overnight me the second part of my order, which was a chain to complete the order by Tuesday, 10/28/2025. They instead had only printed the other. And did not ship it until 10/28/2025 putting it way behind. I receive no tracking, no email, no nothing, just a complete space from Molly's themselves. So I called again on 10/28/2025, and they claimed it was shipped, but they had no clue how they shipped it. They also did NOT ship it overnight as they promised, which means more than likely to lose it or receive it damaged, again. Again, the customer service representative is outstanding, and honestly, whatever you pay her, it needs to be doubled because while these mistakes are not on her end but the company's end themselves she goes above and beyond to help tend to the issues. Finally received the 2nd part of my package on. 11/1/2025 which is way after if it had been over nighted as promised. If it wasn't for the customer service representative who had helped 2 times, both times I had called. I would more than likely look elsewhere to get our wedding buckles made. But I am going to assume if I add the details like she described onto my shipping notes, and order it way in advance to hope I get my order on time, we will be all good in the future. But just in general the lack of communication and other things, quality to details in shipping make or break it for me. The quality of the cowtag I had ordered was not the issue at all. Besides how it was shipped, out of the package and seemed thrown in there (can happen because of shipping), but it was not secured in its packaging from Molly's themselves. But ordering from them was easy, it was a quick process, and pretty much an easy walk through to finding what I wanted and the pricing guides. read more

See all

Custom buckle was better than I expected Customer Service is extraordinary I would highly recommend Moly's to anyone who enjoys the finer things in life read more

Terrible Experience - Look Elsewhere Order a year in advance if you actually need something on time, because this company is painfully slow and shows little concern for its customers. While the product quality is good, the customer service and fulfillment process are unacceptable. We ordered custom spurs for a major local event--over two months in advance--and even offered to pay extra for partial delivery. Despite repeated follow-ups, the order never arrived. Their team claimed it was in "final stage of production," yet provided no solution. What makes it worse is they're only about 100 miles away from us--yet they failed to deliver and provided zero customer support. For a Texas business, this is not the kind of partner you can count on. read more

Do not do business with these people. The buckles were horrible quality...rope trim falling off, lacquer tinted, blobbed and chipping, paint goo that wasn't cured for our logo. Gave them a second chance and no change. After we disputed the charges, they attempted to send a third set of buckles...AFTER OUR EVENTS! Run away... read more

Terrible customer service, king wait times on products, scam contests on social media to get more "followers" Do not waste your time and money. What a disappointment read more

This place is a fraud mill. Pretty pictures and crappy workmanship. And worse customer service. Do NOT order a belt from Molly's Custom Silver. You WILL be sorry. I ordered a belt two Christmas's ago and the order is still not complete. Awaiting a pin or screw that attaches the belt tip to the leather permanently so it won't fall off and get lost when you don't notice. Worst thing I've ever done. And the first belt they made and wanted to ship looked like a kid's high school project. Now they don't answer at all. My daughter is coming home for four days for Christmas. She was supposed to get this belt last year. And it is still not finished. This remains an ordeal. Stay away. You have been warned. read more

Ordered a buckle for Christmas a month before Christmas and got it one month after in February. Wore said buckle for a month and a stone fell out, excellent craftsmanship right, so we sent it back and its now been back at Molly's for 6 weeks to repair ONE STONE that fell out. So if you want to pay a premium for a terrible product and customer service then Molly's is your place but I would not recommend them to anyone nor will I ever order from here or send anything back for repairs again. read more

Ordered the first belt and buckle set back in early December 2024 and did not receive until Feb 2025. Horrible communication and misleading info in emails (lies, really) throughout this first ordeal. Over 60 days to receive. A manager named Evert called me after this debacle and offered me a free belt as a way of apologizing. I decided to give them another shot as I understand things happen especially during holiday season. Evert told me to let him know if any issues arise on this order. Placed a second order 3/16/25 (non holiday season) and as of today, still haven't received and still not even completed yet. 70 days and counting. This order has become worse than the first. After 55 days had passed, I left 2 messages on 2 separate days with a worker at the store for Evert to call me. No return call. Finally spoke to him on day 60 bc he got caught answering the phone. He said he would immediately check on this and call me back. He never did. Their website clearly states shipping time between 40-50 days. Very misleading, unprofessional, and non truthful company. read more

Molly's Custom Silver - Still waiting. - Trophy Shops Near Me - Arlington, Texas

We order more than 9 buckles 3 times a year for our horse club. They are always BEAUTIFUL. Order, you won't be disappointed. read more

Molly's Custom Silver - Trophy Shops Near Me - Arlington, Texas

I've been dealing with this company for 9 months and if I could give it 0 stars I would. The customer service is abysmal at best. Long and short of it, I ordered buckles after confirming I could cancel within a week and being told 4 times yes you can do that. Called a week later saying I needed to cancel and got the nope can't do that we've already got them in the art department, after being told by the same individual a week prior it takes a few weeks before production.. For the next 3 months I got the run around after putting a hold on the order till we got something figured out, till around August I was told someone would be getting the manager involved. September the same person called to ask me if I'd like to proceed with my order, after mentioning the situation they said oh yes sorry, we're working on it. Didn't hear a word about it after that.. Finally this year I found someone who would buy off some buckles from me and what not. They were able to completely REDO the entire buckle, color, text etc etc, which tells me they never started them to begin with. After getting some artwork sent back to me I noticed a charge so I called and was making sure I wasn't about to get charged again. They said no no, because you're only getting 5 buckles on this order and don't need the 17 we will issue a refund. I said holy smokes how hard was that to do. Then four hours later they email me after hours saying nope that's false we can't do that. It's been a nonstop hassle with these folks and I cannot recommend them with any good faith to anyone. I saw where someone else said fraud center and they are correct. Absolutely the worst customer service I've ever had on anything. read more

buyer beware!!! they control their reviews they are posting... not honest. Late delivery... poor workmanship... I've used them for years... last year was horrible... this year is even worse! DONE!! so many other choices out there. Find one read more

I am floored about the negative reviews on here. I ordered a custom belt buckle and it turned out phenomenal. There were two incidents where I had to reach out to customer service because the website stopped working for a little while (they were updating the website for a Black Friday sale) and when I recieved the buckle they forgot to send the wood case I also purchased. They sent it out 2-day express which was clutch. From quality and selection, to customer service, I am 100% satisfied and will be coming back. read more

Very happy with the custom bracelet I ordered for my granddaughter. High quality and great price.

The buckle itself is gorgeous and very well constructed, and exactly as I customized it, would definitely buy another. But as far as service goes, it depends. I firstly emailed with questions, and it was never responded to, so I called and the person I spoke to on the phone was very vague and not what I would describe as helpful. He was almost agitated that I had questions, and didn't answer them at all. So as a last resort I went to TikTok, the person who I assume runs the account was extremely helpful and friendly, and finally answered the questions I had. so like I said the service depends on who you speak to, unless the guy was just having a bad day, we all do, but wasn't exactly a great first impression with the company. With all stated, you are with no doubt getting what you pay for, they're worth the chunk of change you pay for them. They're made to last and they're eye catching. read more

ordered a cross pendent and it took multiple months to arrive. it looks dirty and very cheaply made. does not look like what it is advertised as. the chain that i got from them was so cheap and looks like it was bought at the Dollar Tree. pretty disappointed with how long the process was and expensive it was. don't recommend. read more

total fuckin bullshit. told me its still in production but the system says i owe them an additional 37.71 in order for them to mail it and cited the wrong order number read more

Another great trophy buckle for a great price. As always ease of ordering online is awesome and the finished product is beautiful! Always excited to open up the little black box when a new buckle comes in. read more

See all

I had been putting together an outfit for one of my business personas, "The Funslinger," a character who tells everyone how much fun driving an electric vehicle is. I needed one last item, a rodeo-style belt buckle. A quick Google search found Molly's Custom Silver. What a great site they have! It has many styles of buckles and you can customize them for your specific needs. So many styles were shown that it took me a while to select one from many great choices. Customization was VERY easy and I submitted my buckle design on February 8th, hoping I could get it in time for an upcoming appearance on March 11th. The site states that "it takes up to 30 to 60 days for each buckle," and my event was just 31 days away. My buckle arrived exactly 28 days from order placement. The website kept me apprised of my project's progress, every step of the way, so I didn't need to keep calling and checking on status. I did call one time to see if they thought I could possibly receive it by the date of my event. They couldn't guarantee it, but the very courteous gentleman I spoke with said there was a small possibility and that he'd see if he could do anything to make sure it progressed quickly. When it arrived, it was in a nice presentation box and looked BEAUTIFUL! There is a wide range of prices, but I started on the "Specials" page and worked from there. I ended up selecting the "Placerville" buckle, which I felt was pretty affordable. However, after it arrived, I almost felt like I had taken advantage of Molly's! The quality and polish was outstanding. FYI: The default size of 4-1/2" X 3-1/2" is perfect for me. I'm 5'6" tall and it isn't too large or small for my frame. I was concerned that it might dig into my stomach when I sat down, but it doesn't. Very quickly, it feels just like any other buckle, but it looks way better. Whether you're having a rodeo or creating awards for your business' top producers, Molly's is definitely a vendor you should check out. Thanks, Molly's for a great experience! read more

Molly's Custom Silver - I'm completely blown away by the quality! - Trophy Shops Near Me - Arlington, Texas

See all

I agree with the other reviews about poor customer service. We will never order from Molly's again. We ordered and paid in plenty of time. We didn't have awards for our award ceremony due to no fault of our own. Very disappointed in Molly's Custom Silver. read more

Cow tag necklace turnt green in 1 week poor quality and it took them 2 months too send that piece of shit!!.

I waited a couple of months to receive my order which was expected. On delivery a stone was missing. I called customer service immediately. Customer service is less than satisfactory. The only option I was given was to send it back and wait an additional month!!!! read more

Molly's Custom Silver - Buckle - Trophy Shops Near Me - Arlington, Texas

For the most part everything was ok. Took 3 whole months to receive necklaces. The one was incredibly thin and looked cheap and tacky sadly, it also was not as the picture advertised very deceiving. Also, on another order the stone color was nothing like the color I had selected or the color it said it was going to be on the confirmation stage. It was a completely different color when shipped. read more

I recently ordered a belt buckle from Molly's custom silver as a 90th birthday gift for my dad. Because I was unsure what I wanted, I had to make several calls for help, and each time I called the person who helped was patient and gave good advice. The buckle was awesome and the hit of the party. I was extremely happy with the buckle with no complaints about anything at all. Comes in a nice box too. Highly recommend - I did not have a single issue of any kind!! They update your order at every step - you can see the progress they are making right up to the time it is shipped. read more

I have been a long time customer of Molly's. I recently ordered 14 buckles and was told 45-60 days. On day 61 I called and was told the buckles were shipping by Friday, the following Monday I called and was told they were going out soon...we are now at day 75 and was promised shipment and overnight for arrival on 3/24. I called today to be told they are now shipping today! The worst customer service I've ever experienced! Customer for over 10 years and no longer read more

I would like to give a zero star. I ordered my buckle March 27. Still have not received it, today is June 1. I have called many times checking on the buckle to make sure I receive it on time. Last week they told me they would over night it. That was Tuesday, today is the following Monday and it still has not shipped. They refused to refund my shipping cost. Never again will I use them again. read more

***BUYER BEWARE*** Absolutely the worst customer service and I never received a buckle- they charged my credit card back in early March and here it is May 27th and still no buckle.. Emailed, called many times, And as another review mentioned very robotic they get very rude as if it's our fault that they're making promises they can't keep and this is simply for one buckle. How in the world could they produce 14 buckles every few months at this rate of service.... I always ask to speak to somebody that can explain what's going, on I get random people could never find anybody that's in charge and Im told promises they even so much as called to verify my address saying it didn't exist and My product would be shipped in 2 days and nothing..... As I dug deep and started searching for other reviews and other complaints, this seems to be very common. Never even offered an option to make this right.... read more

Rude treatment by Randy. Very poor communication and customer service. Missed our deadline by a week. I had to obtain a refund through our credit card company. Will not use again and would not recommend. read more

I purchased a couple of custom belt buckles for my daughters birthday present. The buckles were a pair that shaped a heart when put together, they were beautiful. Thank you for everything. I highly recommend. read more

We were very pleased with this company and couldn't be happier. We ordered a belt buckle for our son that represented his high school and sport he played instead of a class ring. We have ordered 3 belts since because of the quality and professional process of ordering. read more

Molly's Custom Silver - Belt buckle for our son - Trophy Shops Near Me - Arlington, Texas

Never again will I order from this company. Extremely poor customer service. They turn into robots when you ask about an order and repeat the same line over and over. This is my 3rd order this year to not be at the show in time. Leaves me handing out ious for buckles. Absolutely ridiculous. Yah their buckles are cheap but I will gladly pay to have my buckles actually there to hand out at the awards ceremony. Now I will be out $150 to ship all these buckles to the winners. read more

Ordered buckles in Feb for an event at the end of May. Called 2 Weeks before the event and a week before was told the guy would watch my account make sure they would be here on time. Called 2 days before my event, was told the buckle cups were bad they had to ship them back and they're waiting on new ones.... (why wasn't I told this 2 weeks ago) spoke to a manager who said he'd call when they shipped and they would ship on Thursday. Never got a call and they didn't ship until Friday. Got them on sat 4 days late from when I needed them. Poor poor communication. I should of been notified when there was an issue with the cups and wouldn't get them on time but I had to keep calling until someone would admit what was going on and then for the manager to drop the ball is even worse!! read more

Orders our buckles at the end of November for a show we were having the last weekend of January. Called a month before asking on timeline. Repeatedly told they were rushing them only to hear at the end "something went wrong with production and they won't have them to us". Each customer service person says the exact same thing on the phone like they are used to having unhappy customers and have a script they are reading from. For our next event I will use another company. read more

BEST buckle company I've ever come across!! Not only did they create beautiful buckles, they did it in record time. Many thanks to Denise for all the help!! Highly recommend! read more

Avoid this business if you are looking to have your items in a timely manner. Highly disappointed and embarrassed that this business does not stand behind their words. I guess rush order means nothing or a follow up conversation in which employees state items are in the "final production stage" are just false words. Honesty is the cornerstone of any business and let's just say the ball has been dropped in respect to being honest. To all those who read this please avoid, unless you like being lied to. read more

Great experience for me! Ordered a custom buckle for a gift. They delivered way ahead of time and it turned out great. The product tracker was neat too so I could keep tabs on where it was at in production. I'll be using them again. read more

Be afraid. Be very afraid. This company makes no effort to provide decent customer service. Emails and phone calls are seldom returned, you will wait for weeks longer that you were told to, the quality of their work is shoddy at best, and they do not provide adequate details while buying. We bought a buckle thinking it was a smaller than what we received and this company not only lied to cover up their mistake, but then made no effort to fix their mistake after their dishonesty. DO NOT DO BUSINESS WITH THIS COMPANY. read more

DISAPPOINTED! I ordered a pendant for my wife on Mollys Custom Jewelry website and what I received is costume crap from China. The pendant looks nothing like that which was on the website. This is false advertising and Junk Jewelry! Buyer Beware! Don't buy this junk or you will be sorry! Seriously, steer clear of this sellar. J. Dan Weathers, M.D. read more

Beyond frustrated and disappointed in this company! I ordered a belt buckle for my daughter's graduation on April 19, website states 30-60 day turnaround time, ok great, it'll be here in enough time. I thought wrong! Checking order status daily and it didn't move for over a month. I emailed in May to check on the status and was told "it takes time and will be completed soon" emailed again beginning of June as now I'm starting to freak out a little bit with her graduation party coming up on June 18 and her gift hadn't arrived, I was then told "it will take approximately 2 weeks to complete, but if I notified them of the date of her party they could put a note on my order and hopefully complete". Two weeks later on June 17 I reach out again and was told they never told me 2 weeks, but would send me a picture of her buckle that I could print out and frame to give her at her party-WHICH THEY NEVER SENT!!! I had to have a conversation with my daughter and apologize to her that her present from me would not be here in time even though I ordered it in April. Now here it is June 21 more than 60 days after the artwork was approved and the order on the website still isn't finalized. I will definitely NOT be recommending anyone to order from this company at this point. My last email to them on Friday June 17 has still been unanswered. It's not everyday your kid graduates school and is recruited by a college for equestrian team and you want to honor that with a belt buckle they can wear while competing nationally. Guess I'll be finding another buckle for her to wear. read more

I had Molly's make me up a custom, one of a kind, buckle for a special event and it looks unbelievable! And for a custom, one off order, the price was very fair. read more

Extreme unprofessional treatment by the owner (Randy) on my recent order. I have been a customer of Molly's for 6 years. I only produce 2 shows a year but I have been pretty loyal to Molly's over the years and in fairness to them they have done a good job for me up until now. I don't usually write reviews but this recent experience has not only prompted my low rating but I will be taking my business elsewhere in the future. I placed an order for my Championship Show sometime in late March. I paid for it when the artwork was completed on April 2nd, our show was scheduled for May 22-23 and I requested delivery May 19th. This timeframe (about 6 weeks) is the same that I have given them for all orders in the past. Their website states buckles will be completed between 30 and 60 days. I was told there would be no issue with on time delivery at the time I placed the order. On Tuesday, May 18th I followed up to confirm that my order would be received on May 19 and I was calling to request a tracking number. I was told my order was still in production and could not be completed on time. I let them know that it was not acceptable to me to miss my date. I was never informed that there were any issues with my order nor was I ever told that my deadline could not be made. I was referred to Jesus who informed me that orders now take 75 days - that is almost 11 weeks! I was never informed of that at the time I placed my order and their website still states 30 to 75 days. My buckles were a standard design with no custom changes. I was clearly unhappy to be informed of this one day before my order was expected. Jesus offered to mail my buckles to my winners. I let him know that would not work for us. If my buckles did not arrive it was my intent to give a cash award and I would be requesting a refund from Molly's. Jesus asked me what my absolute last day to receive my buckles would be and I told him Sat May 22. He said he could rush the order and ship them overnight on Friday to arrive Sat. I agreed with this and I let him know again that a miss would not be acceptable to me. I never received a call on Friday with a tracking number. I had no further contact with Mollys. My buckles did not arrive as promised on Sat. The following Monday I contacted Mollys to learn that my buckles had not been finished or shipped as promised. I asked to speak to Jesus and requested a refund as was our agreement. He let me know he would look into it and would call me back. Instead of getting a call back from Jesus, I got a call from the owner Randy. He was quite rude. He refused to give us a refund and refused to even let me talk, he talked over the top of me to tell me that the buckles had been mailed on the 19th as agreed (his own employees stated otherwise). He also told me that he had gone so far as to pull up my facebook account and could see that I had another show scheduled in the fall and I could use the buckles then. What does this mean? If I was a new customer and only had one show I would have gotten a refund? Not repeat customers who should have been treated as a bit of a higher priority? I have an image of the state of Oklahoma on my buckles as this was a State Championship. My next show is a Regional Championship - however that is really not any of Molly's concern. Molly's is a deadline oriented business and my use or lack thereof or my future ability to use the buckles or lack thereof does not change the fact that they missed every deadline they promised without calling to inform me at any time. I was treated rudely and lied to by the owner who told me the buckles were shipped on the 19th when in fact they were actually shipped on the 25th and received today the 27th. I received a refund through my credit card company and I will not be using Molly's again in the future. read more