Lovely experience at this Adirondack gem. I ate a yummy steak sandwich and curly fries. Everything…read morewas hot and fresh. Next time I want to try the chicken wings, they looked so good.

Got the BOGO 50% off wings (pick up order) a couple months ago. I've tried a lot of wings in this…read morearea and always just once because they're all small, dry, and over priced. These are definitely worth going back for. Hot, crispy, and the perfect kick. The blue cheese was also a winner. Delicious!

Family run business that has been around for years and every time I come…read moreHome we will get pizza from there . Great NewYork style pizza .

Pizza is amazing, wings are great too and salads are decent. Love this mom and pop establishment…read more They are christian owned which we also love! Its wonderful to support a christian owned business.

Good pizza.,Someone else went in to pick up, but as far as I know service was fine…read more Other person is a regular, so it must be good

Would you like some sweat with your pizza!? The owner is an overweight guy sweating all over the…read morepizzas and has a very arrogant attitude when asked if I can get a slice without the sweat droppings. Sorry for being direct but I just don't need the extra MSG or DNA. The bathroom smelled like raw sewage. The floors had grime so bad you could see the buildup of cheese in the corners and the shades of grease on the floor behind the counter. Not my cup of tea or slice of pie! Knock yourself out though if you're into sweaty pizza.

We were in town on vacation and ordered a pizza and boneless wings to go. The order was ready…read moresooner than expected, the staff was kind and the impressive. It's a small place and cash only but this place is easily now in my top 5 pizza places! And they have good blue cheese.

From start to finish, our experience at Cristiano's Pizza was fantastic. We ordered carry-out and…read morewere so impressed! The staff was attentive, helpful, and very friendly when taking our order, and everything was ready quickly and exactly as expected. The food was excellent--pizzas were hot and fresh with generous toppings and a perfectly baked crust, mozzarella sticks crispy on the outside and gooey on the inside, and the antipasto salad was crisp and flavorful with plenty of tasty ingredients. There's no skimping on the salad. You can tell they put care into even the small details. Overall, fast service, friendly people, and food that tastes fantastic. Everything tasted fresh and clearly made with care. This little place delivers on both great service and amazing food. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a go-to pizza place!

We were in town for the baseball tournament at Dreams Park. It was like a second honeymoon. No kids…read morein tow and our son of course stayed in the barracks. It was wonderful. :-) We came here with friends also parents from the team. Easy parking. Fast service. We sat upstairs - it was like our own private dining room. We got a couple of different pizzas and some salads. Everything was very good. Absolutely recommend.

The pizza was very good, service excellent, and it was nice to find a restaurant in Cooperstown…read morewith on-site parking.

Ordered 2 pizzas for pickup 2 weekends ago: 1- Cowboy= Sweet…read moreand smokey sauce. Topped with mozzarella, chicken, red onion and smoked gouda. Personal size = 12.95 2- CBR= Chicken bacon ranch. Buttermilk ranch base topped with mozzarella, chicken, and BACON! Personal size = 12.95 Both were fantastic and ingredients were super fresh. LOVED the Neopolitan crust. I lived in Italy for 6 months so I've become a bit of a pizza snob.... and Puterko's has lived up to my standards! If I'm back in the area, I will definitely stop by to try their other specialty pies.

Heavenly hand-tossed pizza, adictive breadsticks and outstanding wings. You can't say much more…read morethan that, but wait there's more: the service is exceptional. All in all, this little eats spot smack dab in the center of Indian Lake is a definite must-visit pizzeria every chance we have.

There isn't a plethora of good pizza, wings, & sub shops in the area, and Fritz has been my goto…read morefor quite a few years, mainly because their Buffalo wings are solid, and they used to have an excellent chicken parm sub... emphasis on "used to". As you can see from picture, it is no longer very big, and the roll went from being a beautiful, freshly baked with a slightly toasted crust, to what is now an slightly oversized & soggy hot dog bun. It used to come with peppers, but now you apparently have to ask for that add-on... it needs something for sure! Anyway, the wings are still good, but ordering extra crispy still leaves them not-so-crispy (pic), but they're still tasty. Fritz's staff is always courteous and take out process is smooth.

Haven't tried the ''new'' Fritz's yet, but we're a little leery thanks to the old one. They used to…read morehave an excellent chef salad, but the last one we got barely gave two of us enough salad to go with lasagna I had made. It used to fill a large container, but not anymore, apparently. The lettuce was limp, scarce and the meats tasted old. Pizza we've gotten was either undercooked or burnt, so we stopped getting that from there years ago. Pizza Supreme's pizza is far superior, and their 8-cut is MUCH bigger for the same price, or maybe even a bit less. Fritz's also used to have great grinders, but the roast beef in the last one I got from there was a lot of gristle and sliced so thick all the meat pulled out when trying to take a bite. Calling them was always pointless, so all we can do now is hope the new owners have improved. Maybe someday we'll get the nerve to try it again, but at prices today, we're waiting to see some reviews since the new owners took over.

I love their Calzones!!! The service is great and the staff very polite and friendly. It was a…read morepleasurable experience all around.

Pretty good. Food was quick. Very hot inside. If I was on Barstool I would give the pizza a 7.0…read more Antipasti salad is the best item on the menu!

Waitress was very friendly, attentive and atmosphere calm, little chilly.French onion soup was…read moredelicious! Chicken Parmesan tender, crispy and flavorful, only complaint was cups of had more sauce on the pasta . Thick BBQ pork chops were moist and absolutely delicious perfection, could have used less BBQ sauce, next time I'd get it in the side! We'll definitely be back! Could offer GF pasta it's $3-4 a box.

A group of us started out great very nice waitress and then boom we ended up with a inpatient,…read more rude mmhello I am so and so I will be your waitress for today I instead we got what will it be?! Now what we got was do you know what you want?? 1. Attitude rùde 2 soup was the best thing 3. The drinks was loaded with alcohol 4 the food was still cool, dried up aitress was talking to the other girls about us we were able to hear due to the fact they suggested a drink and it was nasty so we were able to switch out per the first waitress. The 2nd one ran her mout and stormed off like a child. THis place will not be a place for us again nasty attitude and you dont have a waÿ to talk to the owner either!!! Nasty food

I had a very good lunch with a Salsicci panini. I was in town for a wedding and had spare time…read morebefore the fun madness begins. Great crusty ciabatta, nicely seasoned sausage (not spicy hot, well not for me! your mileage might vary), tasty chipotle sauce. It came with a house salad with a yummy lemon dressing. Discount for paying with cash!

We were in Cooperstown for several days and dined in Boca Osteria one evening. We had a salad &…read morepizza. Good food and quick service.