From reading other reviews I came in prepared to be underwhelmed and in the end it was fine. Vibe: NH grandma vibes, the restaurant smelled like an old person's home and was furnished and decorated like one Service: Very good, our server (I think his name was Connor) was very pleasant and efficient. The food came out very quickly as well. Food: Overall it was fine, nothing special and nothing outright bad. Confit duck wings appetizer (special) - good texture and flavor, came with 7 pieces, the accompanying ?jam was interesting but was too thick to dip wings in and had to be eaten separately with a fork, was tasty though so would recommend Cod fish tacos - the rub on the tacos was overly salty but it was perfectly cooked and the rest of the taco elements were very tasty and overall was balanced apart from the overly salty fish. Hot honey fried chicken sandwich - Had just a bite of my partner's and it was a good bite although the chicken was a bit tough Value - 1 app, 2 entrees, and 1 beer came out to ~$66, portions were just right Overall had a decent dining experience but the off-putting smell and just okay food doesn't make us want to come back. read more

See all

Finally gave up going here, every time we've been there we've had at least one meal in the group that isn't even close to good. Rubbery chicken sandwich, tough short runs,cold potatoes. read more

My wife and I have had dinner at 74 Main twice in the past two months (most recently on Monday August 3, 2026). Each time was a disappointment, made worse by the extremely poor value 74 Main offers diners. The atmosphere is nice and they seem to have plenty of wait staff, but both times we waited a very, very long time for our server to even notice us. Throughout the meal, service was slow, inattentive and prone to basic errors (wrong drinks served, no utensils provided when our food was served (we had to grab a different server to provide us knives, forks and spoons, etc)). While the food may be pretty good, the prices for what one gets is ridiculously high. The old "Millstone" incarnation of this restaurant was far superior in just about every way. "74 Main" needs some quality competition in town. read more

Found this place while in town. So glad we stopped by, everything was tasty. And everyone was really nice read more

See all

Jaime was fantastic behind the bar and the drinks were fabulous. The food and menu were outstanding. Would highly recommend to anyone visiting or local to the area. The ambiance and atmosphere was welcoming and comfortable to dine in. Overall and epic experience at the Millstone At 74 Main! read more

See all

Millstone is a popular restaurant in New London. We have been here several times and when it's good, it's really awesome. But it's not consistently good. Case in point: we're here for brunch. I ordered the Quiche and my spouse ordered the Eggs Benedict. The kitchen sent a quiche and the eggs flatbread. Quickly changed but it's shades of our first time here when we were forgotten altogether for almost an hour. Having said that, the waitress noticed that and quickly made it right. Once the glitch was straightened out, the food was delicious the quiche was definitely fresh and soft. The Eggs Benedict were also superb with a well made Hollandaise. Presentation was great for both. Our waitress was superb and service was excellent and courteous. Ambiance included soft rock that complimented the ice day Solid quality even if they need a little "umph" in their management read more

Millstone At 74 Main - Quiche for brunch - Caterers Near Me - New London, New Hampshire

Went to this restaurant because of some folks we knew had gone there and had a good experience. However, I would say our experience for the cost of the meal was certainly less than ideal. We had to return our drinks because they weren't made even remotely correct and the food came out tinged or overcooked whichever way you wanna look at it. Certainly not a place we will be visiting again. read more

One of our favorites in the area. Excellent service by Lily. Crispy scallops with wonderful homemade tartar. Scallops were piping hot but French fries not as hot/fresh. Cole slaw was great! read more

See all

Have visited this restaurant in the past with reasonably good experiences, but this visit (23 October 24) was a disaster. After being seated it took about 20 minutes before our order was taken. It appeared that one waitress was trying to handle the whole place. Management seems to have neglected their staffing responsibilities. Food, when it finally came, was barely room temperature and quickly turned cold. Waitress was apologetic about the long wait times, but that did nothing to improve the poor quality of the meal. This experience convinced us it is time to take advantage of other opportunities in the area. read more

This used to be a restaurant I loved to hate. Bad food (bland and gloppy), indifferent service without any ambiance , full of cranky old people. Then they got a new chef and voila, excellent food , kind and efficient service , and although the restaurant looks the same, it just seems more inviting. As far as the old people, maybe I'm just one myself now! read more

It had been a few years since my last visit. Reservations were made at open table. Indoor and outdoor dining. We sat in the back and that was amazing. Huge wine list. Limited cocktail menu but it's full bar so you can ask for anything. The ahi tuna app was delicious. The spinach dip also delicious. I had the gyro. Not impressed. More veggie to meat ratio and I did not like the bread. It wasn't really bad but I would not get it again. Nice dessert menu. 4/5 only because our waitress had 0 personality. I definitely will return. read more

See all

The food is delicious and plated gorgeously, the service is professional and warm and the ambiance is quiet, clean and lovely. I recommend this excellent restaurant wholeheartedly and without reservation. read more

I recently visited Millstone at 74 Main and had an okay experience. The food was mediocre, pricey and the meals arrived cold. The wait staff was friendly and the service was acceptable. I'm not in a hurry to return. read more

Our dinner at the Millstone was excellent. The food was prepared perfectly and the waitstaff was friendly and available when needed.

We picked up "to go." No delivery. My mother and youngest sister ordered hamburgers and were pleased with all. My other sister and I ordered the 74 greens salad-delicious! BUT while my sister's salmon filet was delicious and a good size. My added protein was the shrimp. While tasty the shrimp were medium-sized and cost an additional $12 for four. Very disappointing. read more

In the neighborhood for impromptu romantic getaway and decided to try the local cuisine. We arrived at around 4:45pm and the hostess checked her reservation list and obliged us with a table. It appears this place books up on reservations early in the day (this was in Mid March and still pretty much ski season). So early timing was lucky. We were given a cozy nook of a table right near the bar which was fine for us since we weren't exactly dressed to impress. The offerings were what I would considered "upscale pub food" and prices were commiserate to that. So when in Rome... as they say .. we opted for the very upscale Lobster poutine. Being with a Canadian, this was a pretty risky choice! The huge pile of shoestring fries came out in a lobster bisque type gravy with medium chunks of lobster and hefty amount of melted curd cheese. The Canadian was blown away with the twist on poutine and we enjoyed it thoroughly. Since the appetizer was heavy, we opted for a lighter fare for dinner - I chose the yellow fish tuna poke bowl and the Canadian choose the salad with steak tips. (Any of the salad options you can add a protein such as steak, chicken, shrimp for an extra charge). Absolutely loved the poke bowl - the tuna was dressed with a light yet tangy sauce! Steak tips on the salad were cooked to perfection. As we were finishing up our meal, a musician was setting up and the tables were getting ready for the evening rush. The ambiance was definitely transforming . We loved it! read more

What a huge disappointment. We've eaten here several times with varying experiences. We sat for an hour before our first course. My gazpacho had a nasty aftertaste. perhaps, the olive oil was old? The Cohoes salmon, the restaurant evening special, was vile. The fish was dried out and sat in an oily base of stewed tomatoes and capers (?). I couldn't finish it. My wife ordered the same dish and her's was equally inedible. Our guest order mussels which came with, of all things, a bed of soggy French fries. What an amazingly stupid combo. The fries were goo. It'll be a while before we go back... maybe when they get a new chef. There are so few upscale restaurants in our area, so it's a disappointment when the one we thought was dependable, wasn't. Perhaps, the Inn at Pleasant Lake deserves another look? read more

What a delightful little gem. Took a long drive for my husband's birthday and stumbled upon the restaurant via Yelp. We were immediately greeted by a gregarious duo . Jean and Aaron allowed us to pick whichever table we would like to be seated. Unfortunately our first choice of Lamb chops were sold out but opted for the steak tips. I don't usually choose red meat but something told me to give them a try and they were cooked to perfection. My husband had their French onion soup which he said was amazing. We both shared the potstickers as an appetizer. Trust me I could have eaten those all myself! Jean, our server was attentive and never obtrusive. Over all great dining experience! read more

Upscale menu, very chic decor. Service is top-notch. Horrendously over-priced. Food is excellent, but for me and the wife, not worth the expense. We probably won't go back. read more

We had dinner (December 28th) it wasn't very busy. Service was terrible and food was not even warm. Waiter never check on us. So very disappointed. I won't be returning read more

Love the consistency of the food - fish tacos are great - service and delicious options

Good: food is fantastic. Perfection is everything we had. Bad: small parking lot. The decor was pretty random and didn't make sense but not distracting. Ugly: the service is lacking. My water glass was never refilled and after we were done with our entrees, it took 20mins for the server to come by. Never came by after we got them either. Tldr: get the food to go. read more

Dining out here for the first time in many years, we were pleasantly surprised at the updates to the decor and the delicious meals. Service was pleasant, thorough, but obscure and not interruptive. Our meals were beautifully presented, proper temps and delicious. We would definitely return. read more

I'm not going say what I think; I'll let you infer what I think by sharing my experience, completely objectively: - I made a reservation for a "standard table" via Open Table - My wife and I arrive and are seated at a high table near the bar - not a standard table - After dusting off the crumbs to this fully-made table, we wait nearly 15 minutes for someone to arrive at our table - We politely ask our server if we can be moved to an actual table, like I had reserved. (My wife is short and high tables are uncomfortable for her). We are seated outside, which is nice. - We order, and our food arrives shortly thereafter. - After serving us, our waitress asks if there's anything else we need; I request a refill of water, my only drink. - The "crispy" rice noodles in my lettuce wraps are so hard they are impossible to chew, so I set most of them aside. - Ten minutes after completing my meal, our waitress arrives and asks if I'd like a refill of water. I politely explain that I needed the refill twenty minutes ago, when she had first asked me. (At no point during the entire meal did she or anyone stop by our table to see if we needed anything.) She apologizes and explains that they are short-staffed - which, of course, if the standard excuse every restaurant seems to give. - We pay the bill, leave our server 20%, and decide we are never going back again. read more

Two of us had dinner on August 3. My haddock dish was tasteless (the string beans and harissa were fine) . My partner's entree, crab and cod cake, tasted okay, but was missing the crab part --no evidence of crab could be detected. The accompanying string beans and some unidentifed vegetable (scallions?) were burnt and inedible. The quality of the dishes certainly did not justify the price. The most charitable way to put the matter is to say "Someone in the kitchen was distracted." Re-reading my positive review from 8/6/2017 makes me wonder what's happened to this restaurant. read more

Great burgers and the dessert was soo yummy! Recommend the truffle fries also to go with your burger! Definitely get the mixed berry crisp!!! read more

Millstone At 74 Main - Mixed Berry crisp - Caterers Near Me - New London, New Hampshire

See all

Getting back to normal! Delicious, relaxed and overall enjoyable experience last night. Last time we were there, we had drinks and apps outside, which was nice. With the rain, we were inside at the bar and it was great! Friendly server.. always a good start:) My date and I shared lobster roll w/slaw and fries... Nice lobster chunks, yum...and chicken fingers with sweet chili sauce, also yum. Happy to be helping a local restaurant... If you're in the area, worth a visit for good food and/or drink! read more

We had dinner here while in town on business. The cider sangria was delightful and surprising. The wine list was value conscious but still tasty. And the food.... oh yum. The spinach/ artichoke/ bacon dip was awesome and the Cajun steak and Mac and cheese special was a delightful surprise. Don't know if I'll pass this way again, but thanks for a great meal!! read more

My husband and I decided to give 74 Main a try for our long awaited date night. Sadly, we were left wanting more. The food was mediocre but would have considered it acceptable if not for the extremely slow and odd service. Servers appeared to be simply switching tables on and off which seemed to cause confusion which resulted in an initial delay of service. Our server spoke minimally, appeared confused and apathetic with no real desire to "earn" a quality tip whatsoever. She failed to even check on us once outside of taking the order. As a fellow restaurant person it pains me to leave 3 stars but there is a lot of room for improvement and I think the feedback is necessary to make some positive changes. read more

I've been to this restaurant before, and it's been good. Today it was terrible! I recommended that a group of six of us go. The eggs Benedict was cold and the hollandaise sauce was more like a paste that had little flavor. My mother's fish tacos were loaded with sauce that was extremely salty my sister got the quiche special, there was no egg in it. I'm not kidding when I say there was no egg in it. What a disappointment. read more

On the way back from dropping children off at camp we decided to have lunch. a quick google search and we picked millstone. good reviews, great menu. we ordered Rhode island calamari for an app. very small plate and dried out. like they cooked it and sat it under heaters for an hour. Don't waste your money and skip calamari hubby had a chicken sandwich, he said it was ok. his fries were really good. i had a salad with chicken. ehhh. it was an ok salad. a bit soggy. Waitress was snarky. i asked for a glass of wine but we were almost done with our meal and it hadn't arrived so my husband found the waitress and told her to forget it. 2.5 star at best. read more

Great food, delicious, and nicely presented. Very good service. Pricing is appropriate; As appetizers we tried calamari and mussels. As entree, the veal chop was amazing. I was going to order trout, but wasn't in the menu anymore. Highly recommend! read more

Millstone At 74 Main - Veal chop...amazing - Caterers Near Me - New London, New Hampshire

Don't often give 3 stars & am bummed when it's due.... The menu here falls short. My husband & I looked at it for a good 10 minutes and couldn't find anything we really wanted to order so we settled for the corn chowder, the flatbread of the day, and the Smoked Turkey Sandwich.... It took about 15 minutes for the chowder & flatbread to come out. The chowder was ok. A little watery & missed seafood. The flatbread looked like something that would be microwaved. It tasted ok. When we received the Smoked Turkey Sandwich we were pleasantly surprised of how tasty it was. It definitely made up for our first two picks. The atmosphere was clean & reminded us of a hotels restaurant. The hostess & our waitress were very quiet & barely said a word to us. Not that we minded. Maybe we came in at a bad time. read more

Millstone At 74 Main - Caterers Near Me - New London, New Hampshire

See all

OMG! Made a reservation for a late lunch (4pm), & asked to be seated "outside " (Covid restrictions, & both of us are health care professionals). We were early. The staff was shoveling off the back deck (January in NH), apologized for not having it done already, set up the propane heaters, lit a fire outside, set the tables & invited us to the patio We were fine inside! SO incredibly hospitable!! Thank you! You even recognized my name. Highly recommend read more

DELICIOUS! We a perfectly cooked medium rare filet mignon accompanied by pillowy potatoes and crisp asparagus. Such a great early Valentine's Day dinner and our waitress suggested an amazing red wine to go with our meal. So delicious, recommend! read more

First, the restaurant is now called 74 Main. Second, our experience there was disappointing on several important levels, and if Yelp allowed it, we'd give the restaurant a rating of 1.5 stars. Instead, we're being a tad generous with two. Our issues had to do with food and service. First, we ordered a Mojito for a pre-dinner beverage. Twelve minutes later (no kidding!), our waitress appeared to announce the bartender had never heard of the drink but was reading a book and consulting with servers and would have it ready soon. When the drink finally arrived, it wasn't bad, a concoction of Barcardi and soda, but it really wasn't a Mojito. Oh well .... The service was erratic. Our waitress disappeared for long periods, and we were served by someone who appeared to be a manager. There were delays. The food was of mixed quality. The beef carpaccio appetizer was delicious, the chicken wings tasty. But the snapper was seriously overcooked and tasteless, and the "crispy potato cakes" were soggy and difficult to cut even with a knife. The dessert, a chocolate mousse pie, was good, but the chocolate sauce would have been much better served warm than refrigerated. We liked the attractive interior with booths and small table lights, but we found way too many problems with service and food to recommend 74 Main. read more

My wife and I dined here for the first time a little over a week ago. The hostess was short and not very friendly, only greeting us with "Do you have a reservation?!" She brought us to a booth, where we were greeted by Eliza, a beautiful, smiling waitress who happily engaged in conversation with us about her future plans while asking us about our hobbies and taking great care of us! She was quick to make sure that our water glasses stayed full, quick to replace our cocktails (made by the great bartender Jen), and brought out our food promptly Tbe atmosphere of the restaurant seemed hectic- the brown haired waitress with glasses next to us was running around like a chicken with her head cut off, making it difficult to enjoy our meal We were delighted to have Eliza, who remained calm, cool, and collected. We will certainly return soon and hope to have her as our waitress again! read more

This place deserves 5 stars for it's placement in mid-state NH, almost in the middle of nowhere. I have been here for several great dinners with my lovely grandmother. Jackpot! You get hot freshly made (can you say homemade?) bread with butter before your meal arrives. The food is inventive and fun - I had the lamb lollipops for an appetizer then tried the cornish game hen with saffron risorro. Accompanied by a nice glass of Cabernet Sauvignon you have yourself a wonderful feast. If you are in the area check this place out! read more

Food gave my mother food poisoning and the kitchen area seen from the parking lot looks unsanitary. This was over a year ago. So maybe it was cleaned up. But once food poisoning attacked not again. read more

I notified the bartender of my allergy and they assured me food would be safe. It was not safe and now I am severely ill.