Man, I wish there were half-stars available on Yelp because so often I want to add a half! I want to give The Mile Away Restaurant 3.5 stars.
Made a reservation here on a whim on a Friday night. I had seen the restaurant from afar a few times while out on a run around town, and always wanted to check it out. Pretty green farmland frames the picturesque farmhouse and when you reach the entrance you are greeted by two large rich looking wooden doors. As soon as I opened the door I felt like I had left Milford. This place really doesn't seem to feel like it belongs in this small NH town. The food here is a Swiss/German style and it is reflected in the decor. Cozy roaring fireplaces, dark wooden beams, and pictures of European countrysides, mixed with average looking tables and chairs, give the restaurant the feel of both a romantic Swiss Chalet, and your German grandmother's house. I know, it sounds contradictory but it somehow works.
The price of your entree (prices range from $17.95-$26.95) includes an appetizer, salad and a desert. The appetizers include Vichyssoise, Soup Du Jour, Swedish Meatballs and Baked Stuffed Clams. There are also appetizers you can substitute for a small price, like Crab Cakes or Escargot. For your Salad course, you can choose between Caesar Salad or Mixed Greens and a choice of dressings for the mixed greens. The desert choices are selections from a pastry tray, sorbet and peach melba. The entrees consist of different types of Schnitzel, Marsala, Chicken Cordon Bleu, Rack of Lamb, and several Steak and Seafood dishes.
For my appetizer, I chose the Baked Stuffed Clams. Two large clam shells arrived brimming with golden brown stuffing. One of them seemed to have absolutely no clam in it and the other was pretty generously stuffed with chopped pieces of clam. The stuffing was tasty but a little dry (the food was super hot when it arrived so it may have gotten dried out during it's time in the oven). Overall, I was a little disappointed by my appetizer but knowing there were several other items heading my way all for less than $30, I wasn't bothered by it. Probably wouldn't order that appetizer again though. John had the Swedish Meatballs and he loved them. The serving is 3 meatballs and he was trying to think of ways to get more of them!
We both had the mixed green salad. Very fresh, mixed greens, and generous slices of tomatoes, and cucumbers. The dressings were very good also.
For entrees, I had the Chicken Oscar and John had the Weinerschnitzel. The Chicken Oscar was sauteed Chicken medallions with asparagus, crabmeat and hollandaise sauce. The Chicken was cooked perfectly, the crabmeat was soft and moist, and the asparagus was crisp. The hollandaise sauce though? Not so good. Hollandaise sauce is not easy to get right but when it's good, it's really good, and when it's bad, it's just wrong. Luckily there wasn't so much hollandaise sauce on my meal that it ruined it, I pushed aside most of t and ate the rest. The rest of the dish was very good. John's Schnitzel was very good. It was pounded very thin and the breading was thin but had a nice crust to it. He ate every bite of the enormous piece of veal.
We were ridiculously stuffed by desert, but it was included so what are you gonna do? I had the lemon sorbet and John had a piece of chocolate cake. Both were really good. The coffee was decent too.
Overall, The Mile Away has a couple of things going for it. It's a great value, has an adorable and comfortable atmosphere, generous portions, attentive and knowledgeable waitstaff, and quality homestyle food. What it lacks in Wow-factor, it makes up for in other ways. None of the food blew me away, but it was good, and tasted like Mom made it. I'll definitely be going back to try out a few other Entrees. I have hopes that items without hollandaise will be better! I will update this review when I do.
One last tip-make sure you are REALLY hungry when you go. It's a lot of food! read more