Many thanks to Manny, Josh, Joey and Logan for their excellent service, attention to detail, and quality craftmanship. This picture does not do justice! I just picked up the bracelet today and couldn't believe how brilliantly the diamonds sparkled in the sunlight. Simply amazing! A special thank-you to Josh who helped me out six years ago when I was recovering from a divorce. He gave me a generous offer for my jewelry at that time. This was my way of remembering him. Thank you, Middleton Jewelers! read more

Middleton Jewelers - 2 ct VS clarity diamond tennis bracelet - Jewelry Near Me - Middleton, Wisconsin

My husband purchased/sized all of our wedding rings and bands here and it was a great experience. Recently, I stopped by on a week night to get my band sized up a little to match my engagement ring. It was a little before close, so I was expecting to have to leave my band there for them to work on it, but they were able to work their magic in the time we were there and get the ring to finally fit my finger comfortably. Would highly recommend this place for purchasing rings! They have great customer service and a nice selection. read more

Went in to have a watch band repaired and Wow - they were so great. No waiting and they offered to clean my wedding band as a bonus. It has 16 diamonds on it. I didn't realize how dull it was looking until it came back cleaned - practically needed sunglasses it was so sparkly! Very nice staff and so helpful - I'll definitely go back for my jewelry gifts! First class all the way. Thank you Middleton Jewelers! read more

Thank you Manny and team for resizing my watch and getting my engagement ring so beautifully repaired!

I stopped by for a watch battery replacement, as they were offering a free battery coupon. I was glad they were limiting the number of people inside (I had to ring a doorbell to be let in). I was very surprised that the gentleman opening the door was without a mask - he didn't even have one around his neck. I felt very uncomfortable but decided not to say anything. I thought masks were mandatory indoors. He took the watch to the back room and returned to tell me the watch didn't work even after getting a new battery. That may have been the case or maybe not but I left far less than satisfied. read more

Overall, I think that these guys are clever and talented and very professional. I was a bit frustrated in the process of them making a custom ring for me. In total, I probably spent three or four hours over email and visiting the store in order to get my rings away that I wanted it. I provided lots of photos for added support. The ring is still not 100% how I wanted it, but it has been over a year now since I started the process and I am going to settle for what I have. The more that I look at it with my other rings the more that I like it. I would recommend this store to other people who are looking for a good selection of gemstones and pretty reasonable prices and great service. I don't think that I would select them for a custom jewelry piece though unless you have a lot of patience and flexibility if the piece veers off track with your original vision. There is definitely a difference between this shop and one of the big box jewelry stores. If you are shopping for a wedding ring or a piece of artsy gold jewelry, it really seems like this place may be the ticket for you. read more

Middleton Jewelers - White gold ring was made by Middleton Jewelers. - Jewelry Near Me - Middleton, Wisconsin

So pleased to have found this jewelry store. I just needed a new band on my Swiss Army watch, and they ordered the band and contacted me as soon as the work had been done. I will be back - for the friendly, knowledgeable staff and the beautiful, tasteful jewelry in the store. read more

My fiance was thrilled to find a place that actually listened to her - they respected our budget, offered design options based on her requests, and explained the reasonings behind their recommendations. Joey and Manny made a big decision much easier to navigate. Very competitive on price, and I can't imagine receiving better service. read more

Wonderful experience shopping for jewelry pieces in the new pregomesh collection. I was able to view some items in person and an employee went through all other options on their website with me. Very happy with my husband and mines new jewelry pieces.​ read more

Don't get me wrong, Middleton Jewelers is straight up great in its own right, but after what I went through in the weeks leading up to finding them??? These folks turned out to be absolute angels sent from above. I had visited two other major jewelers on Wisconsin's west side to fix a broken prong on my wedding ring. It wasn't the tallest order, yet I encountered spectacular price gouging, nonexistent customer service, and stunning sexism. The moment I called Middleton Jewelers, I knew I found the right place. I felt heard! I felt valued! They charged me a fair price and did absolutely beautiful work. Not only did they fix my ring - they made it better than the original. They identified the parts at risk (which really were problematic), talked me through the fix *beforehand,* and maintained the delicate aesthetic of my ring that I love so much. I truly couldn't be happier. I've recommended them to everyone and will continue to do so. Locally-owned, community based - there is a real sense of pride here that was totally absent from the other places. Also, Manny is a gem (get it?) and I love that I get to see him when we run into each other at the Willy Street Coop. read more

I was recommended to try Middleton Jewelers by a close friend and they have exceeded my expectations. I live in CA and, despite the distance, I would continue going back to them for my future jewelry needs. A special shout out to Manny, who went above and beyond to help me in the process of making my ring. I would highly recommend Middleton Jewelers to anyone! Thank you! read more

I needed a resizing and repair for my wedding and engagement rings, and everyone at Middleton Jewelers flocked to assist me. Joey gave me wonderful customer service, was very friendly and made sure I got exactly what I needed and more. Highly recommend this business to anyone looking to purchase or repair their jewelry! read more

I went in asking about all sorts of different options, and they helped me look through all sorts of options and finally wound up ordering something just for me and setting me up with a great deal. When I picked up my neckless, their ON SITE goldsmith noticed something on it and fixed it right then and there, immediately, before I even saw anything wrong! The owners, Josh and Manny, are great. Really nice, funny, always dressed really snazzy, and have jumped through hoops to make me happy. These guys are as good as they get. read more

I came into MJ wanting to make a custom engagement ring for my girlfriend. Logan, the goldsmith, worked with me to make sure every detail of the ring was what I wanted. Manny, one of the owners, walked me through the process and made sure the timeline and pricing could hit my targets too. All in all the experience was great and the ring came out looking better than I even expected. These guys do amazing work. read more

I had a ring set completely restored by Middleton Jewelers. I'm very happy with the price, customer service, and most importantly the beautiful job they did restoring my rings. And it only took about 9 days! Middleton Jewelers exceeded my expectations. read more

I walked in and had a great overall experience. Joey provided truly incredible customer service and gave me a great deal on a ring with a stone. Overall 11/10 would recommend to anyone. read more

I recently brought a sentimental piece of jewelry in for an appraisal and cleaning as I was planning to pass this diamond and ruby ring on as a gift. I was warmly welcomed even though I arrived at the brink of closing time. Manny explained the cost for the appraisal, and also gave me choices and options; which left me feeling like I wasn't being boxed in - which was pleasant. I was told when the work would be completed, and I received an email to notify me, which was a great notice that it was time to pick up my ring. When I went to pick up the ring, I was greeted again with respect and a smile. The ring was appraised, the appraisal was explained to me, including the opportunity to have the appraisal updated in the future should I so desire. I'm not a big jewelry person, but I do have a few nice pieces and Manny and I had a clever conversation about ways he could help me update some "older" pieces so that I could begin enjoying them again. He was not over bearing, or pushy. He just made me aware of the services they could offer. I did not shop for jewelry here, but the showroom was clean and neatly appointed. Parking was ample, and the area well lit. If I do decide to refresh an old piece of jewelry or treat myself to something new in Madison I will delightfully come back to Middleton Jewelers. The price for the services I received are reasonable compared to other experiences, and I was very delighted that they were able to provide a presentation box for this gift. read more

I live in California, but was recommended to Middleton Jewelers by a close friend for my fiance's engagement ring and wedding band. I was very pleased! Manny and the staff were great throughout the entire process. We talked through the design via video chat and then he sent me multiple views of the proposed design to approve. He and his staff were very communicative and the ring arrived on time. Plus, the craftsmanship and final product was stunning. They matched the custom wedding band with the engagement ring seamlessly. I would wholeheartedly recommend them to any friend or family member! read more

This is a great local jewelry store. They provide excellent customer service and my ring is absolutely gorgeous. I get so many compliments on it. read more

The team at Middleton Jewelers are amazing! They went above and beyond with a special request and earned a customer for life. More recently I purchased a gift that wasn't quite on spot with the recipient and they were again more than willing to work with me to make the gift perfect!! Manny, Josh & Logan are doing something right!! read more

After receiving two wildly different estimates for resizing and repairing my mother's diamond wedding and engagement rings, I went to Middleton Jewelers on the basis of a friend's recommendation and their very good reviews. Josh received us warmly, gave us great advice and personal attention, introduced us to Logan, the on-site jeweler, and offered us a wide range of options tempered with expert recommendations. Within 2 hours, I had my mother's beautiful rings on my finger. Sparkling, fitting perfectly, safe to wear, and with other extras thrown in without cost. Josh said, "Now you are family." We HIGHLY recommend this locally owned store with the most personal care for my treasured family "hand-me-down" that we could have imagined. read more

Lovely store, lovely people, and just so helpful even if it's just a question. They helped with selling a ring and were very honest about how we could get the most for it. 10 out of 10! read more

We originally entered Middleton Jewelers as we won a drawing at a bridal show. I cannot thank them enough for the financial help for our wedding bands which were perfect! They offered us a great deal and the bands were exactly what we wanted! I cannot believe how friendly and welcoming they were and even remembered things we had said when we stopped in to pick up our rings. The rings arrived within a few days and the whole process was smooth sailing. It was an excellent experience working with Middleton Jewelers and I would highly recommend them to any and all family and friends! read more

I first went here to have my great grandmother's ring resized and they were extremely attentive and caring. This ring is special to me, I went to other jewelers and I did not get the same level of care about her ring so I kept looking until I found Middleton Jewelers. The ring turned out so well that my boyfriend went to the guys to have them help design a perfect Celtic necklace for me. My necklace looks awesome and the emerald they picked out for it is absolutely gorgeous. If they care this much about the small pieces I can't imagine how much they care they will put into the larger pieces. read more

If you are looking for someone to help you design and create a custom piece of jewelry then you need to meet Manny at Middleton Jewelers. I was searching for a custom jeweler that would help me design a pendant for my wife in celebration of our 30th wedding anniversary and Manny was excellent in talking me through the possible options in regard to the design, diamonds and pearls. The final product was amazing and more importantly my wife loves it! read more

I contacted Middleton Jewelers after seeing an ad in the local Advantage mailer. I was looking for a jeweler to restore the hammered finish on our wedding bands which had worn off over the last 13 years. I spoke to Josh, one of the owners, who let me know he could do the job. I dropped off the rings the following day and was told 7-10 days, however, when I mentioned I was going out of town in 6 days, Josh said he'd do his best to have the rings ready by then -- and he did! I picked them up and was blown away by the job he did in restoring the hammered finish to the platinum inlay of the rings. They looked as good as they did on my wedding day! Pricing was fair, and a coupon made it an even better deal. I highly recommend this local business to anyone looking to buy, sell, or have custom pieces made. read more

Recently I broke a necklace that I've been wearing daily for the past ten years. It has very little monetary value but has immense sentimental value. Middleton Jewelers was one of the only places in Madison that offered to work on my necklace. Other places would not accept it because it was not a precious metal. Personally, I believe a good jewelry store that offers repairs ought to be able to work on any metal, as jewelry is not confined to a price tag. Middleton Jewelers gave me a very reasonable quote, and told me that my piece would be done in a week. I received a call the following day informing me that since it meant so much to me, they spent some extra time working on it and my piece was ready for pickup. The staff was very friendly and welcoming. I strongly recommend this place to any person looking for jewelry repair or simply a good jeweler. read more

Terrible customer service. I went in to design a custom eternity style ring. Went in twice--once to meet with the owner and another time to meet with the goldsmith to discuss what I wanted. I did not receive a call back, as the owner had promised me, with a price quote. I even called back and left messages and STILL didn't get a call back. In hindsight, this is probably a good thing because although they advertise as a custom jeweler, their portfolio was rather small and uncomplicated. They were also very vague when I asked who created their CAD designs and how involved I would be in the process. read more