Overpriced for sub par underwhelming food. We have tried to like Mick's. We have tried Willow Street, Lititz and Mt. Joy We have ordered everything from appetizers to entrees. There only redeeming quality is their beer selection and that can be found at a lot of other establishments that have far better food and in some cases, at far better prices. read more

Pricing is terrible for what you get. Cheesesteak was like a 7 inch Stromboli was maybe 10 inch and lacked meat and cheese. I should have went with my gut, local pizza shops have twice the food, and significantly less in price. Never again Micks. With the soup it was over 40 bucks. Save your money. read more

Terrible service. Many open tables but we were directed to the bar to take 2 open seats. Only to be told by a patron that the seats were taken. read more

$52 got us Captain & Cokes with double shots, 2 sandwiches with fries & chips. We were in a rush on Valentine's Day, movie theater is next door. Seated quickly. Greeted quickly. Served quickly. Plenty of parking. Good portions. Good food. Good prices. Highly recommend our server Janessa, she was a sweetheart and so accommodating. read more

See all

I are a brat and German potato salad from new fall menu . Brat was good, potato salad tasty but runny. Service by Janessa was excellent. Phillies and Eagles games overlapped and she accommodated customers with both games on adjacent TVs. It was a good evening so far as games still in progress. Mick's is always a good place for sports and service. read more

Friendly bar staff. Good food. If you are there during Happy hour, make sure to clarify what food and drink items are included in the specials. read more

Seriously?? I don't even know where to start, or to finish, for that matter. The "food" is a joke. One star for good drinks. read more

We had a party of five and arrived at Mick's at 4 PM. There was a few people at the bar and several tables full. The bartender was also the waitress of the entire place. She did a great job taking care of us. We have been going to Mick's on and off for eight years. It is clear that budget cuts are affecting the quantity of food. One of our meals ordered was a meatloaf served over mashed potatoes with broccoli. The meatloaf was cut up into small chunks to make it appear as though there was a large amount of meatloaf, but there was really probably one thin slice. Mixed in with the gravy. I ordered the steak and spinach salad. I had about 6 2 inch slices of meat. Very small portion of meat. The wings as always were still delicious and cooked as we asked.. very well done. One of our orders was also as cheesesteak which was delicious. As well as the fajitas, but they were also $27. For what? I'm not sure. I did ask for blue cheese and ranch and extra celery of which we were charged one dollar extra for the blue cheese, which should have come with the wings. One dollar extra for the ranch which also should have come with the wings. And $.75 extra for the celery. The bill came to 160 which was not bad for five people which included appetizers and two drinks. I would recommend going for the wings. read more

Mick's All American Pub - chicken wings in a styrofoam container - American Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

They have some pretty good food. Definitely recommend if you like fried pickles. They are really good here.

They just rolled out a "new" menu with new crazy outrageous prices! They have also change their once delicious tomato bisque. It now tastes more like a taco soup with a strange after taste. My salad had wilted brown lettuce in it and was not edible. Service was slow and they don't remove your plates when finished with an item. I over heard a guy at the bar complaining about his burger and another upset patron had to come to the bar to get his check. He said he was waiting 1/2 hr and no one came around. I would not recommend eating here. read more

Horrible experience with Mick's and Grubhub. First, placed an for 6 wings and asked for no sauce. My order total was close to $60, but they still updated my to add a $3.00 fee for no sauce. Second, order arrived 30-minutes late. I know it gets busy, but 30-minutes is crazy. Third, all the food was cold. We order quite a bit from different locations. We know that delivered food is never as great as in the restaurant, but this food had clearly been sitting somewhere for a long time. Finally, the we ordered the southwest chicken rolls and these were closer to a quesadilla. read more

Mick's All American Pub - quesadillas in a styrofoam container - American Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

Service has gone straight into the gutter since before "COVID." They just don't seem to be able to find good help! The food is and has been "marginal" and the prices keep climbing, it seems, weekly! We drive by and go elsewhere. read more

The service is great, but the food is a constant disappointment. My family loves the wings but I think they're dry and overcooked. I used to go for the Pub Salad-- but the field greens are lifeless. (Hint: add romaine to your mix. And go easier on the onions. Ask for the chicken tenders and fries on the side as they further wilt the lame lettuce.) Tonight I had the red beet deviled eggs, having been enticed by the promise of horseradish in the egg mix. Totally couldn't taste it. The mini red beets were standard. For the entree I opted for the Spinach Cobb. It was good, with plenty of bacon and tomatoes. Sadly the chicken breast was dry and chewy. My family keeps forcing me to come back for the Charlie wings they enjoy. (Tonight they're overcooked and dry. Again.) Please Mick. I want you to succeed. But you're phoning it in. And based on your reply, constructive feedback isn't welcome. read more

Wanted to catch a quick meal before our movie and thought we had plenty of time to do so. Food took 40min for two people, so we had to get it to go because our movie had already started. Waitress was nice and gave us a discount. I opened the box after the movie, and they gave me bone in wings instead of boneless wings like I asked for... read more

I have been to Mick's several times and have never been disappointed. On my most recent trip, I ordered a salad that was amazing! My husband had a cheesesteak and said it was one of his favorite that he has had. read more

Mick's All American Pub - a plate of food - American Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

Came in tonight and the beer is ice cold - coldest in the land, we joke. Five stars for their bar service. Kelly and Ashley at the bar are always smiling, working hard and go above and beyond for good service! read more

Takeout was subpar. Obvious to see that they just heated up the food in the microwave. Soggy fries, burnt soggy nachos (how do you burn nachos?). Go to the Sandwich Factory, it's a way better spot and has more options. read more

Mick's All American Pub - a tray of nachos - American Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

Not really too much I can say about Mick's. This was my first time at this location. We were forced into coming here as Penn Cinema has inaccurate movie times online and we needed to kill time. It was nice to have this option so close to the theater especially since I'm told that inaccurate movie times are common. The pub was small but well lit, which is unlike their Manheim location which I dislike for that reason. This location had more of a pub vibe than a restaurant. My friend ordered a crab pretzel just because we had to order something in order to sit there. I sampled it and thought the crab was too runny and tasted like tuna salad vs crab. I wasn't a fan and thought the texture was faux crab meat. My friend said she liked it but left a quarter of it behind. I ordered two Kalua and creams. I'm not a drinker and not familiar with many drinks nor current pricing. I did inquire about the price first - $4.50 - which I didn't find bad for a mixed drink. It was refreshing although I tasted no alcohol and after having guzzled down two rather quickly expected to at least feel a little something since I never drink. Nope, nothing. I wonder how much alcohol was even in it. Our waitress could have been more attentive. Had to flag her down for our check and other than bringing the food (in which I asked for a second drink) she never checked back. Probably wouldn't come back unless I was in the same situation again. read more

Never again. Ordered a steak Stromboli and it came out looking great until you realized the kitchen filled it with meatloaf.

We were just at Mick's tonight for "happy hour" for $1 off drinks and $2 off apps, the food was fantastic and the service was as well. This is where the praise stops. Nowhere in the menu does it have asterisks for what is discounted and what is not. The waitress says that money is taken off automatically but when confronting about the discrepancies they say well it doesn't apply to this or that. I would warn you that this is not happy hour but regular prices as long as no one questions the bill. The drinks are not labeled for cost on the menu so who knows what they are to cost. I know we are just one couple and may not matter but tonight was the last that this establishment has seen our business. The rating is for the piss poor business tactic and does not reflect on the service or food. We have brought this to the owner the last time and hoped it didn't fall on deaf ears but here we are. read more

I got some really good Nacho's I thought I make good Nacho's airits are really good got me feeling good with three glasses 1 red wine 2 peach sangria and three peach habanero margarita got me feeling good got 20 drinks at the casino drinks aren't too strong, just appropriate amount for the occasion and the Amber wings beat I ever had it was so good I made a Yelp for the first time and the customer service was top notch 10/10 read more

Went here after hearing good things. The server was sweet and they have a really good chipotle ranch but that's about all the positive things I can think of lol. My food was kinda cold and moist when I got it. I ordered the fish and chips. My coleslaw was also expired and I didn't realize until someone else took a bite and let me know lol, I had just thought it was really bad. Someone else in my party was also unimpressed by their beef that they got on the taco salad. In addition it was pretty busy but we waited a really long time. Probably like 30+ minutes at the table with a 20 minute wait until we were seated. Like I said, it was busy so this wouldn't really bother me but I watched some other tables that came in after us get their food like 10 mins before we got ours and we didn't have anything that should've taken super long. Overall really disappointing after hearing good things. read more

It's fine. Very American chain. The wings were good but could have been cooked longer. read more

See all

Overpriced, service is terrible and the chili was so thick and old you could've plastered walls with it.

Mick, with all due respect it's time for you to start managing your organization. Today's experience was the worst. Lousy service, food that was just thrown out of the kitchen. And the staff that looked as though they would rather not be there. The "I can't find staff" excuse won't cut it anymore. Chips and salsa. Chips were cold out of the refrigerator. French onion soup had not been properly prepared. And yes, your age old favorite, fajitas were pathetic. read more

Are here today in between my son's soccer games. The staff was extremely friendly, the food was absolutely amazing!! Our server, Nakaiah, was the most friendliest, pleasant and efficient server I've had in a very long time! Much appreciated and we will definitely be back! read more

Great black bean burger and amazing tap selections! Will come here again when we're in the area for Avengers Endgame! read more

Mick's All American Pub - American Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

Recently had the opportunity to bring our entire entourage from my son's wedding over from the hotel we were staying at. Unfortunately the Doubletree hotel lied about allowing us to have an after party, so they lost out on all of our business. I do not recommend them to anyone as apparently they have a history of telling guests anything they want to hear to get them to book and then saying they don't know anything about it. Thank God for MICKS and the great bartenders they had. I wish I could remember the two women's names. We showed up as Mick's was closing and they reopened for us saying they would accommodate us all for one drink. They ended up staying open for about 2 hours, pouring a lot of drinks, all with a smile and great attitude. They were great! We had lots of fun there and would go again. It was also Karaoke Night. read more

We ordered the Spicy Chicken Eggrolls and they came out as giant flour tortilla "quesadillas". We questioned our waiter if they were truly the Eggrolls and he grimaced, advising that unfortunately they were. Thank goodness we decided to order the "Eggrolls" and wings instead of the "Eggrolls" and quesadilla! Virtually the same dish. I'm sad to say that although the wing sauce (Amber) is AWESOME... The chicken wings were little baby pigeon wings... They were actually 'cute'. 1 star fir location and 1 star for Amber sauce :) read more

Mick's All American Pub - Spicy chicken EGGROLLS?! Huh??? - American Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

See all

Stop policing businesses about covid. If you are afraid of getting COVID-19, stay home.

One of my go-tos when I'm in the Lancaster area. Had the chicken pot pie (with a crust, not that Amish-dumpling version). Very good. Waitstaff was attentive, but it was a quiet afternoon, so that may have been part of it. Can't think of a time I've gone and been disappointed. read more

Decided to grab dinner here before going to a movie at Penn Cinema next door. Restaurant was at roughly 75% capacity. Some high tops, booths and seats at the bar were open. As soon as I walked in the smell wasn't "clean." It smelled like dirty carpet. I looked down and sure enough the carpet was a dark gray. Tough to tell if the carpet was dirty, but it sure smelled like it. Got seated pretty quickly. Server greeted us within a few minutes. She was friendly, but her long fingernails tapping away on her handheld computer was a bit distracting. How does someone maintain good hand cleaning with long fingernails like that? Ordered a citrus crush from the bar. I've had many orange and grapefruit crushes and this one was very sweet, but didn't taste any liquor. Tasted more like a carbonated lemonade. Ordered some mozzarella sticks as an app. On a scale of 1-10 I would rate them as a 5. The batter was bland and the cheese was ok. For dinner I had fish and chips. Fish was good and dipping sauce was good as well. Fries were cooked properly. Friend had crab Mac and cheese and he didn't want the leftovers. Just ok. So all things considered, if you are looking for a quick bite, and you don't have high expectations, then Mick's is your place. If you want a great memorable meal then don't go here. Owner, please investigate that smell. read more

Had a movie at 7 pm. Arrived at Mick's at 5:20. Food took forever to come out. Barely made the 7 pm showtime. The lone bright spot was the bartender who worked hard and fast non-stop. read more

Music is really good. Food is good. Been here a few times now before the movies and only once was the service not great. And even that time once they realized we had been missed they made up for it. Personally love the Stephanie sandwich and their fresh cut fries are great. The salads are huge! Big enough to share. read more

Living in Lititz for 3 years now, we had heard great things about Mick's, but, despite it being a mere 10 minutes away, had never tried it. We found ourselves with a child free evening and decided to check it out. The location is great, with an abundance of parking, and being connected to a movie theatre can't be bad for business. It was fairly busy for 5pm on a Tuesday (yes, it was happy hour), with many full tables. We were promptly seated, and our server approached quickly. I started off with a drink they call a "crush." The menu states it is 2oz of Smirnoff flavored vodka, fruit juice and lemon lime soda. There were a variety of combos, and I opted for cherry (cherry vodka and lime juice). My husband ordered a Yuengling, which was on special. I can't say I was disappointed with my drink. It tasted great and gave me a bit of a buzz (I'm a lightweight), but I was a bit disappointed in, what I can best describe as, the false advertisement. When you think "crush," you think sno cone ice-like. The ice was just bar ice (cubes), and the drink was basically just a vodka sprite with a garnish. Am I being picky, maybe, but in my opinion, it changes the dynamic of the meal. It did not meet expectations drawn from the name. We started our meal with wings. It's our go to for a place know for it's pizza, wings, and overall bar fare. This was a mistake. We ordered half a dozen with hot sauce. They came out extremely dry and overcooked, and looked as though they were sauced and dropped back in the fryer (ie there wasn't any..they were dry). The "sauce" wasn't remotely hot. Again, greatly disappointed. We were losing hope for this meal. I decided to order the South Philly Pork Sandwich and my husband opted for the French Dip. I decided to upgrade to french fries and he stuck with the chips, so we could share. The Pork sandwich is described as pulled pork with broccoli rabe, provolone and parmesan cheeses on a hoagie roll. It came as such, but... the pork literally lacked any seasoning. It was as if it was simply boiled until it was pullable. The broccoli rabe, which is known for it's bitterness, was abundantly present, and, with the lacking seasoning on the pork, overpowered the sandwich. I wound up removing most of it, and adding salt and pepper, and sadly ketchup, to my sandwich. The fries were, unlike the wings, undercooked and limp, as if they didn't care to cook them properly and drop them into the fryer twice. The French Dip presented well, but again, was technically flawed. It stated on the menu that it came with a crock of french onion soup. That can be forgiven for a french dip, as au jus is the base of french onion soup. We did not expect it to be the full soup crock, complete with bread/croutons and the cheese topping, resulting in difficulty dipping. The sandwich itself lacked flavor. The beef was under seasoned. The horseradish lacking. But the chips were good. Lol. The overall appearance of both dishes looked as if they had sat in the window under the heat lamp too long, which is surprising to me, because we, and it seemed every table, received our food from food runners. It really wasn't busy enough for food runners, therefore, food should have been received promptly upon being plated. My favorite part of the meal and probably the only reason I would return (if it wasn't a special), came from the bar. Mind you, the bartender was slow as molasses, (and this was affirmed by our server who suggest i order my dessert drink when I received my meal to get it in a timely manner), but the drink made up for it. It was a Salted Caramel Martini, and it was divine! The rim was coated in caramel and pretzels (tho i think she did mine in graham cracker as they also had a smores martini on the menu) and the drink itself reminded me of a caramel mudslide. Seriously best part of the meal. Our overall suggestion: ignore the kitchen, sit at the bar, have a drink, go see a movie, grab some popcorn and candy, and your night will be great. read more

Mick's All American Pub - Best part of the meal!!!!!! Salted Caramel Martini. - American Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

well we tried Mick's on Columbia Ave and were not impressed. We happened to be near the Lititz location and gave it another shot. I ordered the Fish and Chips..I got 4 tiny, soggy fish sticks on a bed of unseasoned fries. . Never again.. read more

Here at Mick's All American Pub, you will be sure to find what you want on the menu. Their menu has a great variety of foods, and you will defiantly be able to find something that your stomach desires, and something to fit your cravings. As a vegan, I was even able to find a fresh salad that was too good to not add into my review. Now about the service. Our wait time was about 20 minutes at 6:45pm. This was a little frustrating, but we understood. Our food came about 30 minutes after we ordered it which was not too bad, but defiantly not perfect. Waiters and waitresses were perky, and happy to wait on us, and there was even a staff member who checked on us to see how our night was going. That was defiantly big for me. The bathrooms were definitely not very cleanly. There was dirt an mildew along the bottom siding of the bathroom stalls. There was also a dirty toilet plunger on the floor of the bathroom. The big stall toilet was filled with toilet paper and was clogged. Not a very good look for them. My last complaint would be the music. The music taste they played was first of all, too loud, and second of all, not likable to all people. My friends and I were practically screaming at each other to talk. Otherwise, everything else was great. read more

Mick's All American Pub - American Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

Delish definitely recommend the sweet potato fries with a tad bit of sugar, great location you get to walk right out of your movie and sit down and enjoy a great burger. Came for the wings Sunday what a steal So resistible! read more

I ordered take out from here last night. Everything arrived correctly, and was still hot. The wings were fantastic. They were crispy and meaty. The Amber sauce I chose, an interesting combination of BBQ, garlic parmesan, and medium, was very tasty! The burger was pretty small. The bun was good quality, but bigger than the burger itself (which was okay since the bread was yummy). Tho the burger was small, it was filling. You can tell they are hand formed burgers, not frozen patties. So deff worth it for the taste and quality. The fries had no seasoning and were kinda of blah and tasteless until salt was added, and then they were very good. I will deff be ordering their wings again, and trying other menu items. read more

The only reason this has two stars is for the great performance from the waitress. Food was 45 minutes late, prime rib came as end cut dry as bread. My friends soup had to be sent back to be warmed, a stale sandwich for the other. The wings were the only beacon of joy for this dining experience. read more