We have eaten here many times over the past decade. We have never been disappointed, the menu is very good and we have always had good service. We love the ambiance of the location. I especially like the duo tartare read more

Great fresh seafood market that I would come Back to again and again. Came twice during our stay and both times the quality and service was outstanding. Prices seemed on par for the region and felt that the quality of options for fresh was wide. Scallops, grouper, salmon, and Key West pinks all came home with us for the week and didn't break the bank. Dinner for four each night was about $30 in seafood and really it was almost too much. Loved the service with a smile and check out the weekday special dinner for four on the wall for take out!! read more

Merrick fish tale grill lives up to the hype. Gorgeous ambience, stellar service by Nicholas, yes if you know I need something before I do, you are amazing at your craft. Delicious seafood, creative cocktails , what I call " dining perfection". Brad the manager is a great ambassador for your business. So worth the drive from Ft Myers. I absolutely loved it. Perfect first visit. You guys rock. read more

See all

Celebrated my Birthday Dinner with my family. Great service, full house, and fun atmosphere! I ordered the Cajun seafood stuffed Redfish and it was fantastic!!! Ended the meal with a cleaverly created platter displaying my birthday and a slice of Italian cheesecake!! Will be back soon!!! read more

Merrick Seafood - Seafood Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

What a beautiful restaurant...the brunch on Sunday is incredible!! The live music is just so much fun. The seafood is just so fresh and very tasty. Our waitress/waiter's always so helpful and knowledgeable about the menu. The inside part of the restaurant I feel is like a NY atmosphere.. I highly recommend to come here with family and friends! Caryn w a "C"...NY read more

The Trio! Always a culinary adventure. The slider bun was a little hard and would've been wonderful if it had been toasted. Usually they put their Trio offering on their FB page but not today, but I was happy with it. Normally Jason is my favorite Monday server but he wasn't working. Today was Melissa C. read more

Merrick Seafood - The Trio - Seafood Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

See all

Outstanding atmosphere, food, service, drinks and price!! Easy to park as well!! I highly recommend the pasta seafood dish and the sea bass! read more

Merrick Seafood - entrance - Seafood Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

See all

Wow...the food has really gone down and the price has really gone up! I known it has been several years since we have been there, but I cannot tell you how disappointed I was. Our party of 5 had the crab cakes (which were bland and fishy), the Grouper Piccata (bland fish, unseasoned vegetables, and overly acidulated artichoke leaves), Hot Lobster Roll (sent cold rubber lobster back first time and then received cold unseasoned slightly less rubbery on the second try), and crab stuffed shrimp (fishy and under seasoned). I dont know why anyone would ever want to go to this place. Stay away and spend your money (it was very expensive) elsewhere! read more

Had dinner the other night and I had the special which was marinated roasted octopus! Absolutely delicious! The server, Melissa, has waited on us before and his top notch! This is an A+ restaurant in Cape Coral as far as I'm concerned! And the bar and the music is always great! read more

Merrick Seafood - Seafood Cobb salad $28. Check out the lobster tail on top!!! - Seafood Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

See all

What an expansive selection of food at Merrick Seafood. Service was exceptional and was only exceeded by the food. The restaurant has a very Floridian atmosphere with fish as the highlight. read more

Easy, quick pickup for fresh seafood. We picked up some fresh Gulf shrimp to cook at home for dinner. Everything was very fresh, delicious and priced reasonably. read more

Food not the best. Much overrated & prices way too high. Waitstaff was very nice but the owner is rude. I'd much rather go to Twisted Lobster or Papa Joe's Italian in Cape Coral. Better seafood, better portions, and in my opinion they appreciate their customers. Would not recommend Merrick Seafood Company to anyone hoping for a nice meal and dining experience. read more

We go for the Sunday brunch. Grade Lobster Benedict. Service has been great. Music outside so we usually are with friends and go inside. Certainly would recommend this restaurant. read more

We got there ten minutes before opening and they were already seating people. (Sunday Brunch). Service was great, food was amazing, atmosphere was great. Live music. the Loaded Fishtale Mary was a meal in itself. Highly recommended! read more

Merrick Seafood - Loaded Fishtale Mary. - Seafood Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

We had high hopes from all the friends that had gone to the restaurant. Maybe it was a bad night but the food was so so and not worth the price read more

I look forward to coming to Merrick seafood every time I come to Cape Coral. They have the best seafood! Their new outdoor area is very pretty. Live music offered most nights. This year we just ordered a couple of 2lb. Lobster to go back to our house. They were cooked perfectly! Merrick's is a must for restaurants in Cape Coral. read more

Merrick Seafood - 2 lb.er's back at the beach house! - Seafood Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

I tried the sea bass at Merrick Seafood today. The food itself was tasty, but the portion felt too small for the price. Unfortunately, there was a very loud band playing, which made it hard to enjoy a conversation with our friends--we found ourselves shouting just to be heard. That really took away from the experience and makes me hesitant to return. It seems many Cape Coral restaurants have live music, but in this case it felt more like a distraction than an enhancement. Overall, I'd rate my visit 3 stars. read more

Great atmosphere outstanding food and drink. Music was very nice, short wait time around 10 minutes. Spring break crowd is out read more

Absolutely the best grouper I have ever had. Grouper with cranberry and macadamia. Blackened scallops were delicious. Backed potatoes on point. Lobster bisque awesome. Clam chowder fantastic. Possibly the best dish I have had in Florida. Our service was excellent. Super nice place. read more

See all

We tried coming here in season and we couldn't get a table. We were finally able to sit down and dine this month and I highly enjoyed it. I did find that the menu was limited to my liking but what we did order was fresh. We sat outside and there was live music, it was so great, it made us feel like we were on some caribbean island. I think that was the disconnect for me, while the food was fresh and delicious, I did want it to have more spices or be more carribean. Regardless, we enjoyed what we ate and will be back. read more

Merrick Seafood - Seafood Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Went to Merrick's for dinner while on vacation. Our waitress was the best part of Merrick's. She was attentive and on the spot for drink refills. We ordered the fried scallop dinner and fried clams dinner. I will say do not expect this to taste anything like New England style fried seafood. The batter was very heavy on the scallops and separated from the scallops when I went to cut into a scallop. The breading on the clams was very heavy. The waitress did offer to replace my scallops with something else as she could see how separated the batter was from the scallops, oddest fried seafood I have ever experienced. Service was wonderful but we do not plan to return. read more

Stopped in for happy hour drinks and a snack. Sat at the outdoor bar where service was attentive and entertaining. The spicy margarita is on point and can be customized for (less) sweetness. We had the lump crab cake appetizer. The crab cakes were full of flavor, good sized pieces of crab, and not too bready. It should be noted that the price was the same as the attached seafood market with no upsell in cost for preparation/presentation. After our happy hour experience we popped to the seafood market to get fresh, local prawns to take home for dinner. The counter clerk did not mention the daily specials and we ended up buying more expensive prawns. Overall the seafood was fresh and the dining service was good- would recommend a stop here but be sure to check the daily specials. read more

We bought a seafood pot pie and had friends over and this was amazing. So much seafood and tasted fantastic

This restaurant was recommended to us by a long-time local, so we decided to check it out for lunch. I ordered the blueberry pomegranate margarita on the rocks. The flavor was okay, but I was a little disappointed it was not served in a margarita glass. Given that this establishment clearly goes the extra mile for food presentation, I would've thought that effort would also translate to their beverage service. For starters, we ordered a cup/mug of chowder, the wedge salad, and the coconut shrimp. All items were tasty. For entrées, Hubby spoiled me with a pound of Alaskan King Crab legs ($75, but it was my birthday) and he chose the Chilean Sea Bass. For mine, I wasn't asked what I wanted for sides; it just came with smashed potatoes and asparagus. For the sea bass, about a minute after it was delivered to our table, someone from the kitchen brought the topping that was supposed to be atop the fish. He said it left the kitchen before he had a chance to put it on. It was just a little awkward. All is all, the food was good, but we'll likely try out some of the other seafood restaurants on our list before returning. read more

See all

Along with friends, we had a lovely dining experience...comfortable, good food, priced right and charming staff.

Food was great.. nice ambiance..service meh. Food was good no happy hour kind of expensive

The restaurant isn't huge but they do have outdoor dining. Great server who made suggestions and the best thing we did was follow her advice. Great service and food. read more

Always busy so make sure you get there to decent time especially in season. We both had the 2 pounds of crab legs and they were absolutely delicious. Lots of great options for appetizers and our martinis were made perfectly. If that's not the perfect evening :-) Staff was very friendly and the place itself is pretty cool. Definitely check it out if you're in the area. read more

The first visit a couple months ago was really good! So we thought, let's go back! My husband ordered the lobster @ $49 and I ordered the fried oysters. The lobster got to the table COLD, and whatever they call 'butter' looks more like oil was cold as well. Our waitress was lovely, and said no problem, returned it back to the kitchen and 10 min. later out came another one. It was hot, but the "butter/oil" was cold. They just couldn't get it right. When we spend $100 on a dinner I really expect the food to be really good! My oysters were okay, but about 1/2 of what I got 2 months ago. So, for $26 I got maybe 10 fried oysters. When I spoke to the manager on duty, he said, I'm sorry. Thanks for that, but told him we would not be back. I guess they don't care about return business here. Be aware if you visit! read more

This is a great place to dress up or down, the food never disappoints. Service is top line and you can pick up seafood to cook tomorrow.

Date Day! Lite bites and a cocktail. Tuna Trio was great, extra wasabi (.99¢) was the perfect kick. Tuna Tacos were bursting with tuna. My Frozen Fishtail Fishbowl was a tasty rum drink (hard to hold but I got over it) read more

See all

Great service and food! Called at the last minute and asked if they could seat 7, they were very accommodating and our waitress was fantastic dealing with our large group. read more

Currently the front is under construction so it was hard to tell if they were even open. The walkway isn't marked and honestly was a bit dangerous as it was raining and the blacktop was slippery and there are no rails to hold on to. I had the fish and chips as did my dad. Mine was very good. You get a big piece of cod battered dipped and fried. Dad didn't like his as he said it tasted very fishy. The other two in our party had the lobster tails. Neither liked them, they said they didn't have much flavor. The inside has a small counter where you can buy the fresh seafood as well as a dining room and bar area. For desert we split the cheesecake and the bread pudding. Both were okay. The cheesecake is more dense like a cake vs creamy. The bread pudding was also dense like a cake. For the price, it doubtful that we will return. read more

See all

Enjoyed Sunday brunch this week and it was perfect !Great portions ,fantastic high quality fresh ingredients and very pleasing flavor pairings!! Nick our server was great with providing details on drinks and was an expert at uncorking and serving our wine choice !! read more

Merrick Seafood - a variety of appetizers on a white plate - Seafood Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

The food and service were great... we had a big party and lucked out to be seated right away

We visited early on a Friday evening and sat at the bar on the veranda, we very much enjoyed the space. Great vibe. First set of live entertainment was very pleasant and performed at an appropriate volume. Lobster bisque was the highlight of our meal, thick with lobster meat and delicious. Pine Island clams, quickly drownding on their ice bed and, unfortunately served along quite unfresh, incipit, horseradish and cocktail sauce, were fortunately saved by a decent mignonette. Lobster/crab spring rolls which, with obvious quality ingredients should have been the star of the show; disappointed with over oily wrappers. But, the real fly in the ointment was the service. After the soup was served we were forced to scavenge silverware setups from another table ourselves. When the clams and oysters were served we had to ask that seafood utensils be provided. Bar service and finished plate removal were quite slow, especipally qiven the very few other outdoor patrons. All in all I'd say that service couldn't be rated satisfactorily. I won't say we'll not ever visit again but we have no plans to do so soon. read more

Went for a late Friday lunch around 2 ish. Server came immediately when we were seated. We ordered our drinks. One of them was a Banana Cabana, Tito's and soda with 2 limes and an iced tea. The server was trying to be funny and said how about 3 limes . I said sure . The drinks came and the vodka soda had 1 lime , Banana Cabana definitely had an ingredient missing , I personally believe it was the cream coconut. Iced tea cane and we had asked for sweetener. Finally sweetener cane with the refill. So we got last that and ordered our meals. I ordered the Manhattan clam chowder . This came after our meals. Caesar salad . Shown in picture . Chef Ramsey would have been all over that. I asked if the kitchen had GREEN lettuce , she shrugged and said let me see. She never came back . We had to get up go inside and grab ketchup and get our own water out of the machine in the front. The manager or hostess was watching the whole time.... And it surely didn't cross her mind as to why a patron was serving themselves water and ketchup. I give this place 1 star and would not go back. It's to bad because this is a great location but management and staff just don't care. read more

Merrick Seafood - Fishtale Grill Caesar Salad - Seafood Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Great atmosphere, great food and amazing service! Savannah and Tyler were super attentive and helped make our date night one we can't wait to repeat! read more

Merrick Seafood - Seafood Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

My friends and I were there this last Saturday for a get together and my birthday. Sabi was our server and she was wonderful. Super fun and kind and we all had a great time. The food was outstanding and the new look and atmosphere was awesome! Can't wait to stop in again! Also, thank you, Gru! Haha read more

Merrick Seafood - Seafood Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

See all

Newly Renovated, New outdoor Aluminum StruXure Pergola, 1500 square ft of shade! The roof opens and closes with a touch of a button! The roof is almost done,looks like a few more days of work. The bar is not finished outside might be a few weeks away on that. I always stop here with friends because the food is the best on the Cape. Now that they have all this shade there is no reason not to stop buy. Great Brunch Today, with live Piano Music. I sat at the counter and had a surf and turf Benedict followed by a generous slice of Cheese cake. All in about $30 read more

See all