I've taken all my cars to Andy's since I've moved into the area. He and his team are always honest…read moreand fair, and Andy never pressures or upsells you. If a repair has to be done now, he says so. If it can wait, he doesn't twist your arm to fix it immediately. Very budget conscious. It's rare to find an auto mechanic you can trust. Andy and his team are terrific.

Andy's automotive is hands down the best you will ever find! Friendly staff with every visit…read more They are honest and fair with pricing! Love them

Came to Forest Hill with my 2020 Subaru Crosstrek after a national chain failed my state inspection…read morefor obviously bogus reasons. As a mechanically competent person who does her most of her own car maintenance at home with years of experience on a military flightline, it was obvious they were trying to squeeze $$ out of me. Here's why you should choose Forest Hill- they don't just TELL you about your vehicle condition through questionable pictures via a "digital health report," they SHOW you. We walked through all the bogus claims from the chain (confirmed passable) and stood together under my car while it was on the lift to look at an actual wheel bearing issue that the chain completely missed. They were able to fix the issue same day at a fraction of the cost the chain quoted me for the non-existent issues - meanwhile I worked peacefully and productively on my laptop in their waiting area. They even let me borrow a car to quickly grab lunch while they worked on my Subaru. Within a few hours, my car was fixed, inspection stickers affixed to my windshield, and I left with peace of mind knowing my car was legal and ready for a long Labor Day weekend road trip. My husband has been taking his Tesla there for years, I should have been doing the same all along. If you want smart, reliable, friendly and trustworthy car care and live anywhere near Red Lion, this is the place.

After purchasing a CPO 3 Series earlier in the year, I was referred to Forest Hill Auto by friends…read moreand co-workers. I could not be happier with their service. They were super responsive to my concerns and checked the car from top to bottom. Thankfully Bryan found that two of my wheels were bent and scheduled a follow up service to have the wheels repaired. This shop is top notch and will be my go to shop for anything related to the BMW.

These guys go above and beyond to give you a good deal. The work is good and the staff is friendly…read more Nobody there will try to upsell you some nonsense like at the chain stores. They have even offered to drive me home when my vehicle was in their shop over night.

I'm not a mechanic but I can do most of my vehicle work myself. But whenever it's something major…read moreor more work than I want to do. I take it to Matthews; they've always been honest, and I trust their work and expertise.

Checked around to various automotive repair shops before heading their way. We found them to be…read morevery easy to work with. Their pricing fair and reasonable and they stand behind their work. Excellent from start to finish!

Went in because I had a coupon for an inspection sticker, thinking I would save some money. Just so…read morehappened my check engine light came on and I had them check it out. Turned out to be nothing, but their rates are a lot higher than my normal mechanic in Shrewsbury. Ended up paying a lot more, will not be using them again.

We were thrilled when we first discovered Daddario. At that time, we really trusted them…read more However, over the past year, it's been negative experience after negative experience. With them missing or forgetting to do what we needed. Their resolution is "we will get that next time." Not just once or twice. At least the last 5 visits. Most recently we had a car inspection. Needed an oil change but they didn't notice, and didn't offer. Decided to take that car to dealership who happens to be on the same block as Daddario but much easier to get in and out of, plus the dealership is open on Saturdays. Anyway, we go in for an oil change and the mechanic noticed a hole in the tire. A dangerous hole that could cause a blow out on the highway. How did Daddario miss this in inspection? The car had recently hit a bad pothole in neighborhood, left behind by utility company. The inspection was immediately after that incident. I feel like Daddario is in too much of a rush or their mechanics are lazy. They've lost our business. The only reason it's 2 stars instead of 1, is because the guys on the phone and at the desk are friendly. But, yet no accountability for missing and forgetting things.

I am a very difficult person to impress with auto mechanics. But this place consistently delivers…read moreand is always trustworthy. I feel like they really know what they're talking about and they don't push unnecessary upgrades. I find it's easiest to drop my car off first thing in the morning and just take an Uber back home. It gives them all day and they are always fast efficient and affordable, not like some of these tire shops that pushes services and don't care at all about you.

Ridiculously expensive! Never again. $114 for an oil change, everything is high and we were given a…read morelist of things they said were needed many that were just done.

I took my car to McKonley's Garage for a second opinion on the horrific noise my brakes were…read moremaking. My mechanic told me it was because of the metal in the brake pads. McKonley's diagnosed that they needed to have the parts greased and I had a bad caliper in one. I had them take care of it and the brakes haven't made that noise since. Now McKonley's will be my mechanic.

I've always been treated fair at Hallman's. They're outstanding mechanics and I've always felt that…read morethey do an excellent job no matter the problem. You can't go wrong taking your car there!

I have been going to Hallman's for years. Very honest and trustworthy as well as knowledgeable…read more There is no other garage I will take my cars to get inspected or fixed. Highly recommend! - Anne M.

Extremely helpful and fast. Gave great service and Had reasonable prices. I highly recommend them.read more

This is the best shop in the York area as far as craftsmanship goes. Nice family business, the guys…read moreare always there. I've been a long time customer since 2019 and have never been disappointed. They replaced my brakes, and when they wore out abnormally early, they replaced them free of charge. The owner always recognizes me, asks me how I've been, and it feels good knowing I'm more than just a number. Most recently they squeezed me in during their busy schedule as my tire valve cores broke and I needed them replaced ASAP and I'm extremely grateful. Their quality of work is the best around and I plan on returning next time I need them, as it has been for years.