Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Matthews Garage

    5.0 (5 reviews)
    Closed 8:00 am - 5:00 pm

    Services - Matthews Garage

    Auto battery or electrical system repair

    Auto brake repair

    Auto engine repair

    Matthews Garage Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Matthews Garage

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Joe R.
    37
    23
    18

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Auto Repair 2,150 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Glen's Auto

    Glen's Auto

    4.5
    (15 reviews)

    Great techs and support across the board! The team was very responsive and helpful with a variety…read moreof outstanding repairs and selecting tires. Will continue to depend on their service and support with confidence in the future.

    *Edited 5/23/25* After leaving this my original review,…read moreWyatt called me up to talk to me about my review. He took full responsibility on the shop not taking the time to thoroughly address my concern with the noise that I was hearing. He went out of his way to try to right the situation as best as he could and I greatly appreciate his efforts and attentiveness. I'll start with the good about Glens -I like how you can schedule service online and the text/email updates -The person who I spoke to on the phone while my vehicle was in the shop was knowledgeable and kept me up to date with everything they were doing to try to solve the issue Now for the bad: I have never taken a vehicle here before and honestly only booked an appointment with them because Southern stables was farther booked out (who I have used) and needed the issue to be fixed sooner. Based on their reviews I figured I'd give them a shot. The issue with my wife's chevy equinox was the Stabil Trak and power steering light were coming on and off driving home in the rain. They spent 3-4 days diagnosing the issue and let me know what they found out and it was ready for pickup (I also had them do the yearly inspection while it was there). I go at lunch time to pick it up, drive back home (I live less than a mile away) and noticed a clunking noise coming from the front passenger side. Also they left the passenger side interior kick panel not attached all the way (it was hanging down). I didn't have time to take it back so my wife ran it back up to have them check out the noise and fix the panel. They reattached the panel and gave a quick noise is good to go and off she went. She told me she still heard the noise (this was on 5/15/2025) on her way home. I had to go that night up to York and it made the clunking noise to and from York. I took it Friday morning (5/16/2025) first thing for them to check it out to see what the noise was and I even recorded a video of the noise (windows up) where you can hear the clunking. The tech took it for a spin and put it on the lift and his conclusion was that the strut is old and needs replaced which is causing the banging. The woman working the counter also made sure to mention that "the safety inspection will pass with bad struts because they aren't considered safety issues". Ok fine whatever, I ask so is it safe to drive like that and she told me yes. I drive the equinox back home. Saturday 5/17/2025 I hop in the equinox to drive down to Annapolis to dj a prom. Still making the clunking noise, but now on RT 50 I start hearing a ting ting ting noise and then a noise of something falling off. When I apply the brake I can feel vibration. I go to pull off to the shoulder to see what is going on and the brakes are making a lot of noises and then all the sudden the front passenger wheel locks up as I come to a stop. Now I have to scramble to get my dj gear to the prom (thankfully I was only 2 miles a way and was able to get there on time from one of the people in charge). Had the equinox towed back home (650 dollars later), jacked the equinox up and took the wheel out (tire blew out when it came to a stop as well) and low and behold, the top bolt from the caliber bracket had came out, resulting in the the bracket to shift to the right which caught the wheel and cracked the rim. Ended up getting a new rim, new tire and new bolts for the caliber. Got everything put back together and guess what, no clunking noise. So thanks Glens for addressing my concerns about the clunking noise with so much concern and care. Since you guys acknowledge the noise but were so quick to say it was a strut instead of actually diagnosing the issue (which I would have been fine leaving the car there to be properly diagnosed) you guys ended up costing me close to a extra thousand dollars with the "yeah it is safe to drive". Congratulations on giving a great first impression experience to a customer you'll never get to come back.

    Meineke Car Care Center

    Meineke Car Care Center

    3.2
    (9 reviews)

    Great guys, the manager Bryan and the mechanic Chuck. No issues, oil change and tire rotation. I…read moretold Bryan I wanted to get my brakes checked and he advised that they check over the vehicles and nothing raised any flags. Which I appreciate, as a woman we often get bamboozled into getting unnecessary repairs, etc.

    mechanics ready to help. Get directions and stop by for service today!…read more MapQuest https://www.mapquest.com Meineke Car Care Center, 201 N 2nd St, New Freedom, PA 17349, US "I have taken my car there multiple times over the years for inspection and the service is fantastic! I have no complaints. Recommendations were made but not ... Facebook · Meineke Car Care 5 followers Meineke Car Care | New Freedom PA Not yet rated (3 Reviews). Meineke Car Care. 19h · . . Don't sweat it, we've ... Meineke Car Care Center can help! Call us now at 7172192945. May be a ... 5.0(3) Nextdoor https://nextdoor.com Meineke Car Care Center - New Freedom, PA Jan 28, 2021 -- The center is praised for its punctuality, effective communication, and friendly service. Whether you need a tire shop, oil change station, or ... Missing: reviews | Show results with: reviews People also ask How much does Meineke charge for oil changes? Does Meineke charge a diagnostic fee? Does Meineke guarantee their work? How much do Meineke Car Care Center managers make? Feedback Better Business Bureau https://www.bbb.org Meineke Car Care Center | BBB Complaints | Better Business ... Before I go any further the communication is bad with this company especially coming from the * G M ****. He has told me three time about calling me back from ... CARFAX https://www.carfax.com Top Rated Auto Repair near New Freedom, PA Meineke Car Care Center. 1.2 mi. Meineke Car Care Center star rating: 4.5 out of 54.5. 68 Verified Reviews. "Went for an inspection. All ... Reddit · r/bloomington 60+ comments · 3 years ago WARNING: do not take your car to meineke for service. : r/bloomington In summary, meineke stole my money for an alignment, and did not do it. When I questioned the quality of their work, they made up a reason as to ... Missing: freedom | Show results with: freedom Sponsored Meineke Car Care Center - New Freedom 4.7(441) · 2.7 mi Auto repair shop · Closes soon 6PM New Freedom · 201 North 2nd Street 1st image of type map 2nd image of type exterior Meineke Auto on Carlisle St - Come in Today to see the Meineke Difference. Affordable, Reliable with a National Warranty Call Website Directions Products at this location Services Read reviews (441) About this business Results are personalized - Try without personalization 17327, Pennsylvania - From your device Update location Terms Jon Francis 3 reviews 8 minutes ago New This meineke is money hungry for your hard earned money and they will try to take advantage of customers lack of knowledge. The first time they got me on an inspection was for lug nuts. They said they needed to be replaced and pretty much couldn't drive my car until they did this. Retail price for luggage nuts were $3 at napa and they charged $9. Fool me once shame on me. This time they tried to get my wife with their service report. States 5 critical items and not any that would fail it for inspection. #1 is state inspection #2 cabin air filter #3 engine air filter #4 serpentine belt damaged #5 windshield washer fluid low. Reality :#2 Cabin air filter was replaced by dealer at 4000 miles ago and no photo to show dirt. I call BS. #3 engine air filter in their own photo is not even dirty again BS. #4 the serpentine belt damaged was again BS. I bought a new one and a new tensioner from the dealer and when I took the old one off there was no visible damage at all. While the grooves were not as deep, no cracks or fraying. The picture they send is of the belt from 3 feet away with no damage shown. Total BS. #5 not worth mentioning. Shame on you for trying to fool me again. How they sleep well at night knowing they try to rip people off is the question I want answered?? They use the inspection to get you to service stuff they dont know if it was serviced or if visibly serviced still recommend it done again. Thinking of the mark up on lug nuts, my guess is they would charge close to 1000 for retail price of 200 in parts and my own labor of 1 hour. Please dont get fooled!!!

    County Transmissions

    County Transmissions

    4.8
    (106 reviews)

    Overall: 15/10 An honest and professional shop that has…read moreearned my lifelong business. Service: 10/10 My primary contact was Mike, however I spoke with many other staff in person and over the phone over the course of a week after I had my Crosstrek towed in with a destroyed transmission system. Everyone was courteous, helpful, and responsive. The new transmission they procured was practically brand new and installed professionally. The experience they provided me as a customer was as excellent as the final bill and they are now my go-to shop for transmission and suspension work. Thus, I strongly recommend this business. When I had my car towed in, it was after hours, but conveniently they had an overnight key/car drop off system that was secure and easy. The lobby was clean, organized, and offered free cold water.

    Had my vehicle being serviced at local mechanic and they notified me that the PTU (Power Transfer…read moreUnit) that is part of transmission on all-wheel drive vehicles was leaking badly and needed to be replaced. They did not work on transmissions and advised me to take it to a transmission repair shop. Called the Ford dealership and they told me to replace it would run around $3300. For comparison I called some transmission shops and got ahold of County Transmissions and spoke with Hampton. He told me that it would run $2300 including labor if it needed to be replaced. They had good reviews so I decided to take it to them and save the $1000. Took it there on a Monday and Hampton told me they would have it done in several days. By Friday had not heard from anyone so I called them and was told that it was next in line to be looked at which would be the following Monday. My vehicle had been there five days and had not been looked at. On the following Monday, Hampton called me and said that it did need to be replaced and to replace it would run $3200. This was $1000 more than $2300 as he had initially told me and about the same as what the dealership would charge. Mentioned this to him and he said that the $2300 was for a used PTU that they would get from a salvaged vehicle, and a new one was $3200. He had not told me this when I first called and I had of course assumed the initial quote of $2300 was for a new one. Didn't even know they would consider putting a used one a vehicle because how would you know it didn't have issues. In light of this new information and for the fact I feel it was a bait-and-switch, I decided to take my vehicle to the Ford dealership and have them do the repair. The dealership's warranty on the PTU was much better and I know am getting a genuine Ford part. With an independent shop am probably getting a cheap aftermarket part. If I moved to another city or say was traveling and had an issue with it, I could take my vehicle to any Ford dealership and they would honor the warranty. If County Transmissions had done the work, then I was out of luck. Had to take an Uber back to County Transmissions and pick-up my vehicle and then take it to the Ford dealership. This costs another $50 on top of the $50 Uber charge had already incurred when I took my vehicle there and had to take an Uber to get back home as I live far from them. I opened up my SmartTag GPS tracking app as had placed an Android SmartTag GPS tracking device inside the vehicle awhile back. Was very surprised to see my vehicle had been driven around Vienna and appeared they were using it to run errands as it was stopping at various locations. So in the end I was out $100 in Uber fees, they had my vehicle for a week and nothing was done after Hampton telling me they would get to it in several days, plus they apparently used it to run errands. I would certainly not recommend this company in light of everything that happened. Note: Saw that Hampton had posted a rebuttal on my initial review where he states that the initial quote was an estimate to repair the PTU, but this is not true. The PTU is something that is replaced, not repaired, and he gave me a quote of $2300 to REPLACE the PTU. Plus they didn't need to be driving it around to determine where the leak was coming from since it was obviously leaking when I took it in and it had to be replaced. When I called him on Friday he said they hadn't looked at it yet; however they had been driving it around before that Friday. He mentions that they have a shuttle service and I asked about this but was told it didn't go to where I live.

    Matthews Garage - autorepair - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...