Nice seafood restaurant and bar in Boothbay right off Main Street (walkable) to shops. Water view. Great friendly staff and bartender. (No "old" seafood smells like some restaurants that have a big seafood menu. That's a plus for me or anyone who doesn't eat seafood in a party who wants it. Bought a cute hoodie t-shirt with their logo on it here. Recommend - everything on menu is very fresh and good. read more

First time to BOOTHBAY HARBOR - We decided to go here for dinner. The A/C wasn't on and the room was very humid. We decided not to sit in the back as it was a crowd of people and it was already hot. I can't do hot while I eat - I made the best of it and we ordered food. We ordered fried calamari & scallops wrapped in bacon and we each had a clam roll. I can't eat white potatoes as it's inflammatory for my auto immune- no sweet potato was available - I do prefer them -or used to them- and so I got asparagus (odd for a substitute but it's veggies) this was a super treat I'm not sure how the crab should have tasted but it's not what I'm used to growing up so for me , I personally didn't like it and I didn't think the flavor was good - I added lemon- didn't seem to help. The atmosphere was great but the concentration was on that back room. The crab roll could have been better as I've had them before, calamari was good and scallops too. Also noting most of these restaurants never have NON COLA DIET SODA - It sits right in the harbor - the waitress engaged in conversation - a lot of these folks are immigrants on a work visa returning to the Harbor during summers & then fly to their countries until the next summer. read more

See all

Boothbay harbor is such a fun little town! I had the best time in the area, dinning options were few for a Monday night so we picked mcseagulls. The food was honestly really tasty and we enjoyed both of our dishes. However, the service wasn't great. We put in our drinks and food and then really didn't really get checked on again. She was close by on her phone but not checking any of her tables. We finished our meals by the time she came back, couldn't get ranch or salt for our food since she never checked on us. Waiting another 20 minutes to ask for our check. Really great food but wish we had a different server to make our experience better read more

See all

We tried a lot of lobster in various places and my husband said it was the best he has ever had! I had the braised beef w a side of Mac n cheese. The demi glaze was delicious. Our server was phenomenal! read more

See all

We had a late lunch here on a Sunday afternoon. The food was exceptional. Lobster bruschetta, shrimp cocktail, chowder, bacon wrapped scallops, all were delicious. Nice atmosphere, nice staff. Will return whenever possible. read more

We had a wonderful dining experience here and recommend this restaurant highly. All of the food we ordered was very tasty, our server couldn't have been better (thanks Calli) and the atmosphere and vibe was perfect for an evening at the harbor. Let's quickly get down to the good specifics. The raw oyster appetizer was just right for us: fresh, briny, large oysters (mere points, $36). The lobster bisque was thick, lots of lobster pieces ($12). The clam chowder not quite heavy enough for our preference but good and filled with of clams. Our added bonus was the yummy spinach and artichoke dip ($17). The 1 1/2 pound lobster for dinner ($39) was delicious; tasted as if hauled aboard only a few hours ago. Add in a plate of fried scallops ($34) and a Thai crunch bowl ($19) and we were thoroughly and completely satisfied. Oh yeah, a few good beers, too. Calli kept our drinks refilled and was a constant model of efficiency and good humor. The restaurant has a patio and pretty open dining inside right on the harbor. Conversation is lively but never overwhelming perhaps because it is open. We made a reservation which we'd recommend. In summer it obviously gets very busy. As it should be. read more

See all

Foodie review: Don't let the silly name fool you. It's serious food, one of the best lobster rolls we had, classic and traditional. But the lobster Mac and cheese is worth going for and just eating that. Our server mentioned it in passing it and we threw it into our order as an afterthought and we fought over it when it arrived. One of the best pastas you'll have on your trip. Fish tacos, excellent as well. read more

See all

This is a lovely and delicious restaurant! I had a reservation and we were seated in a great spot right on the water. I LOVE the clam chowder here. I had it once before. It's so good. The best I have ever had in my entire life. We also had the burrata and stone fruit salad. Delicious. I loved the blackened fish tacos. They made the tortilla so well, and even the fries were so great. I love this spot. read more

Came here on a Sunday at noon for a bite. They have a nice beer selection, and a beautiful porch outside. However, it was full so we ate inside. We ordered the lobster bisque , haddock bites, I had a sandwich, the fish tacos, and the fried clam bellies. The lobster bisque was OK not the best I've ever had. The haddock bites were fried crispy and very tender. The taco dish had two tacos with maybe chipotle mayo, but not very spicy quite good. The fried clams were amazing. They could have given us more of them, but they were very tender and large not just a little strips but the whole clam. They had a sandwich was Massive. There was a choice between blackened, fried or grilled, and my dining companion got the blackened. She said it was quite good. It is a real piece of fish. It came with fries as did all of the dinners. The fries were double fried and crispy. I thought it was a good meal. read more

McSeagull's Restaurant - Menu - Seafood Near Me - Boothbay Harbor, Maine

had mussels and fried clams the mussels must say where pre steamed they looked try and small exhausted from to much heat for 23 .00 a rip off I don't care where you located than mussels should be plump and appetizing looking the sauce was great they charged 5.00 for extra bread so yes a 28.00 appetizer want see me. again read more

Great food, great place... the lobster rolls are amazing...if you are in the area don't pass this place by... lobsters deliver fresh daily read more

McSeagull's Restaurant - Hot lobster rolls - Seafood Near Me - Boothbay Harbor, Maine

See all

Really nice waitress, lobster bruschetta was great. However, the rapidly flickering bulb above our heads put me in mind of an interrogation room. I kept thinking up alibis and trying to remember my lawyer's name and then remembering that I was in a restaurant. We begged and pleaded with various waitresses to turn it off, and were met with war criminal stares from the manager. My father, who is a Vietnam veteran with a neurological condition, finally had to get up and demand very curtly that they turn off the lights, goddamnit. Finally the manager did. She was, in her words, "a little offended." Tell it to The Hague. read more

CJ at the bar made great drinks! Great atmosphere during a hot day shopping. Outdoor bar was awesome. Thanks CJ!

Hungry after a whale watch trip, we saw this place and since we have had enough seafood and wanted something else, this menu worked. Took awhile to attract a server, but once they came, service was good. The beer menu is extensive and I found a brown ale which was good. The menu has lots of good choices, and my husband and I settled on splitting the cheesesteak with fries. Food came very fast and was nice and hot. The bread was fresh and the meat was tender. I would have liked more cheese, but it was still good. Fries were also nice and hot and enjoyable. All in all, a good sandwich. read more

See all

Have enjoyed them over the years. The Fish tacos were delicious. As we've been eating so much seafood over past few weeks we needed a burger & the smash cheese burger was perfect. Great char & cheesy goodness. Easy to return when food is consistently delicious. read more

Good food - good views of the harbor We Ordered the mussels and lobster bruschetta Both are delicious Ru Service was fast also read more

Love this place with a very friendly service. Chowder was so good, and Boothbay lobster dinner was exceptionally prepared. Oysters were okay, shrimps were perfect. Wine was poured generously in the glass and it paired perfectly with the food. Next time you're in town, don't miss the Boothbay lobster dinner, it was $39 end of December market price and it was soooo well worthed. Ambiance was great. read more

See all

I come here all the time they make one of the best painkillers I've ever had and the tuna crispy rice is to die for. Sometimes they are busy, but they are always nice and take the time to tell you about the specials. I can highly recommend this place and have been at least five times this summer already. read more

McSeagull's Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Boothbay Harbor, Maine

Excellent, plump & delicious mussels served by an attentive & nice bartender. Beautiful view,

Food: exactly as expected for a coastal fried food eatery. It was much better eating in than our takeout experience a few years ago. The batter on the haddock bites was flavorful and they were just right. The cole slaw tasted a bit different and the flavor grew in me - I couldn't stop eating. Ambiance: we sat outside and enjoyed beautiful views overlooking the harbor. On a beautiful day there were lots of happy customers enjoying food and drinks around us. Service: service was great. They weren't filling the tables because they didn't want to overwhelm the kitchen staff and the servers seem to split tables in various areas which makes it tough to get consistent and speedy service. However our service was friendly and we weren't in a hurry so we didn't mind the delays. read more

See all

We ate at McSeagulls last week while on vacation. The espresso martini was excellent. My choice of the Scallops with risotto, spinach, bacon, and a beurre blanc sauce wasn't a good fit for me as it had lemon in the sauce. If it had no lemon it would have been perfect for me. The Scallops were seared perfectly. The risotto was cooked just right. Our server was great. We sat on the deck and loved the views and atmosphere. Would definitely return but order something else. read more

This was our favorite restaurant from our week in Boothbay Harbor. The atmosphere was relaxing and we enjoyed sitting on the deck and watching the water. Our server was very friendly and helped us select what to order. The food came out quickly and was delicious. The scallops and risotto were particularly great. We would definitely eat here again!! read more

Mcseagulls is my new favorite restaurant in the Harbor! Major upgrades have been done to the food, drink menu and interior recently and everything is spectacular! Lexi the host is so kind and gives the perfect first impression to the visit. Tyler behind the bar is so knowledgeable about everything food beverage and he really knows how to take the dining experience to the next level. The cheesesteak is one of the best I've ever had and the Tuna Crispy Rice is another major favorite. This restaurant is perfect for lunch or dinner because the menu has a perfect level of variety. Definitely recommend! 10/10 read more

See all

The service was great, we were seated right away and I love not having to wait. I ordered the seafood pasta. Yes the flavor was wonderful but as the dish cooled it "solidified" in a lump; That wasn't very appetizing. The atmosphere and service was wonderful though. read more

McSeagull's Restaurant - Menu - Seafood Near Me - Boothbay Harbor, Maine

We started our mid-afternoon snack with the Blood Orange Bellini and the Blueberry Mule. Both perfect to sip on the outside deck while watching the boats, birds, and other couples. The Scollop Ceviche was sublime. It's a small dish, even for one person, but I highly recommend it for a couple to share. The portion on each scallop shell is enough to tantalize the tastebuds. We split the Crab Cavatelli, which we discovered is a delicious pasta shape that pairs perfectly with the Romesco sauce, which we also learned is a smooth sauce made from red bell pepper with tomato. Now, add to this "crispy capers" and we were at a loss to in what this entree was taste like. Well, it's yet another culinary revelation from Chef Dushuttle that needs to be savored by the masses visiting Boothbay Harbor this summer. I loved not being completely familiar with the ingredients and these dishes did not disappoint. VERY HIGHLY RECOMMENDED read more

It was so good and we were staying so close we are there a couple of times. The fried scallops were the best I've ever had. They were very lightly breaded and flavorful. And their lobster bisque was hands down some of the best we had ever tasted. Don't miss the fried shrimp either. Great service even though they were extremely busy at times. read more

Had such an amazing experience with Ginger our server!!!!! She was a hoot!!!! Can't believe how well she managed the dinning room with so many tables! Food was amazing as always can't wait to come back next year one of our favorite spots. read more

Seated outside immediately on a Friday around 2 pm. Beautiful view. Service was attentive. Clam chowder, haddock bites, and bacon wrapped scallops appetizers were very delicious. Fish tacos were wonderful and filling. Seared scallops with risotto was a bit disappointing. The 5 scallops were delicious and cooked perfectly but the whole kernel corn was not a good texture in the risotto. It should have been puréed to complement the creamy texture of the risotto. Overall a good meal. read more

Easy going terrace lunch! Blackened fish Tacos and Maine Salad were perfect! Gosh they know how to cook fish here! Service easy going, attentive but unobtrusive Wine and beer lists well chosen! read more

Nice restaurant right on the water downtown boothbay. They allow dogs on the patio and the view is everything! The menu had a lot to offer for everyone. My family loved the mussels and smash burger. My husbands chicken sandwich was pretty dry but the fries were delicious. The Bloody Mary was absolutely delicious too. Staff was prompt and nice. Great place to stop for food and drinks and relaxation! read more

McSeagull's Restaurant - Bloody Mary - Seafood Near Me - Boothbay Harbor, Maine

After 3.5 weeks all up and down Midcoast Maine, this was The Best take on a fresh seafood menu I've had. Do not miss the blackened fish tacos and bacon wrapped sea scallops. The twice fried fries were an unexpected happiness! Seamless, friendly, unhurried service and the view from tables in the bar area just made for the beginning of a perfect day before hitting the Botanical Gardens! read more

This is a GREAT restaurant. I can say this was a great experience. The server was spot on. The atmosphere was welcoming and very inviting. My wife got a lobster roll and asparagus. I got a fish sandwich and fries. We both loved our food. If you are in the area, do yourself a favor and stop in. read more

See all

Decent food. The outside seating was full, so we sat inside. They had several televisions going, how to infomercial channels. I found that a bit odd. The menu is a bit small,... In hindsight, I would recommend going next-door to mine oyster. read more

Absolutely love the lobster bruschetta and of course they're always so sweet and nice when we bring our pup. The deck is perfect for a full family experience.! read more

McSeagull's Restaurant - Lobster bruschetta - Seafood Near Me - Boothbay Harbor, Maine

A reliable restaurant on the harbor. We came with family for a Sunday lunch. Some of the other spots had brunch-only menus and we were happy to have a regular menu. Our party got Fish Tacos, Haddock Bites, Blackened Haddock Sandwich, and Fried Whole Clams (all in photos below). Of the four entrees, by far the best (and the best value) was the Blackened Haddock Sandwich. It had a generous portion of fish and the seasoning brought out the best in the fish. The battered French fries were also a hit with our group... The service was exceptional. I was impressed with our server's ability to slip in and out unobtrusively and pick up on non-verbal communication. He was clearly a people person. read more

See all

First timer at Mcseagulls !! What a great place to stop into. We came in right as they opened and we're given a choice of where to sit. We choose the covered deck with a bit of sunshine coming down onto the table. Located right in boothbay harbor near pier 7, this place is really cool. A great location, and for where it's at, good prices. We started with an app of spin dip, that was huge and delicious. The breadcrumb too was toasted to perfection. The insides were juicy and melty, just perfect. The smash burgers were to die for. They had an amazingly crunchy toasted buttered bun. They had two slices of American cheese, bacon jam and onion crisps. I don't think I've ever had a better burger. The servers seemed to be hosts and bartenders as well. The greater customers at the door and then took order at tables and came to and fro with bar beverages. They were on top of it. The interior was very beautifully done in light oceans tones, and decor. This place is a must, even if you're not waited on by Paul Lepage!! read more

See all

We had a great experience at Mcseagulls. We looked at reviews and figured, it's just mediocre, but we are hungry so let's try it. We went in and were seated right away. We had a great view from the deck of the water. Server was very friendly and checked up on us often. When the food came out we were happily surprised. My chicken sandwich was very moist and delicious. A lot of places over cook the chicken so it's dried out. My husband said his haddock sandwich was delicious. It looks like they get all of their seafood as local as they can. This is not a fancy place, but if you are looking for a place to sit by the water and have good pub/bar and grill food. Try it out. read more

See all

We arrived late afternoon and after unpacking walked to this restaurant, I loved the outdoor patio. The portions are so big we spilt the haddock dinner and each tried a local beer. Delicious! We subbed onion rings and they were so good! read more

McSeagull's Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Boothbay Harbor, Maine

as always, the food was excellen! We came to Boothba, having made a reservation before knowing it was Windjammer Days, but we knew we were going to eat at McSeagulls! we were lucky, both nights, to have Ginger as our waitress. she remembered us from the night before and knew automatically that we share an entree. she brought out an extra plate even before our order was ready. she is very friendly and outgoing! we just want to thank you and Ginger for a great time! read more

We dined at McSeagull's three days in a row. It's not fancy but it's clean and neat and the location is great (within walking distance from our hotel)! *** Night #1: $100.44 + $8.00 tip (she's lucky she received a tip at all!) ***We chose to wait for a "direct waterfront" table instead of being seated elsewhere immediately. We were quoted a 30 minute wait and waited about 40 minutes. The host was warm and friendly and he made us feel welcome as we waited and were seated. The view was nice! **Our server, Cortney M., was a huge disappointment.** No smile, no friendliness, just a cold stare. We waited quite a while for her to even come to our table and bring water. We waited quite a while for our order to be taken (lobster roll, fisherman's platter (haddock, scallops, whole belly clams & shrimp), draft beer). My husband wanted another beer with his dinner (it was a hot night!) but Cortney never came back so he did not get one. I wanted more tartar sauce and napkins, but again she never came back so I didn't get any and finished my seafood without). My husband's lobster roll was good... served with hot butter and had a good amount of lobster. My fisherman's platter was a letdown... the haddock was amazing but the whole belly clam strips were so tough I could not chew them. There were only 4 tiny scallops and 12+ tiny, flavorless shrimp. Pretty bad considering my dinner cost over $42! We waited a long time for Cortney to return to clear away our plates & take a dessert order, but she never did. To our amazement Cortney returned, did not ask if we wanted dessert and just put the check down on the table! We felt so unwelcome! There was no excuse for this, it was almost 8pm, the "dinner crowd" had already died down & there were plenty of open tables. We told her we wanted to order dessert and could see her jaw tighten as she asked what we wanted. We ordered blueberry pie and she nodded curtly and walked away. We waited a long time for the pie to arrive... so long we wondered if Cortney forgot to put the order in. Eventually it arrived and it was nothing to write home about. We regretted wasting the time to order/receive it. Cortney needs to be retrained or not work in a customer-service related job. We said nothing but our tip reflected her poor service. Rude & inhospitable! *** Night #2 *** $90.72 + $15.00 tip Because the haddock in my seafood combo was so good, we decided to return to McSeagull's the following night. We asked for a table in the outside dining area where we had been seated the previous night and also asked not to have Cortney M. as our server. There was a man standing near the hostess who we later learned was the manager. Our hostess assured us that was Cortney M.'s night off and we were seated in a nice table, not direct waterfront, but still in the same room and we were greeted immediately by our server, David S. who was warm, welcoming and took great care of us the entire time. We both ordered fish n chips, 2 clam chowders, beer and water with lemon. Once again the fried haddock was amazing and the chowder was chock full of flavor... one of the best I've ever had! David and all the support staff were fun and engaging and we felt welcome and happy. *** On our way out, the man who had earlier been standing near the hostess asked us why we did not want Cortney M. as a server. I asked if he was the manager (he was) and my husband & I kindly explained how rude & awful Cortney M. was. He knew she was a problem, because he said "Yeah, she can be like that". He apologized but apparently he cared more about gathering info on his staff and not us. No offers of compensation were made, not even the next night when he saw that we had returned for a third night in a row, regardless of Cortney's horrible service! *** *** Night #3. *** $102.60 + $20.00 tip Returning to McSeagull's on day three was a testament to lobster roll my husband had on day one and the service we received on day two. It was our last night in Boothbay Harbor & we wanted good lobster rolls (even though they cost $36.00 each). The host, the same friendly gent that had been so kind on day one (sorry, didn't catch his name & it's not on the receipts, like the others) seated us in the outside dining area at a nice table. Our server, Ilinca P., was extremely attentive and very friendly! We ordered two lobster rolls with hot butter, clam chowder, beer and water with lemon. Once again the lobster rolls and chowder were quite good! We had a great dinner and left a commensurate tip for great service. SUMMARY: Some food is great, other food is not (it's hit or miss) and it's overpriced. The view is nice & the location is great if you're staying at Fisherman's Wharf Inn, as we were, BUT we will not be returning. We had comparable food and an excellent view, outdoors, at Kaler's & the manager needs to treat his customers better, especially when they RETURN after HORRIBLE SERVICE! read more

See all