Cancel

Open app

Search

Maya’s Crab Shack

3.0 (4 reviews)
Open • 7:00 am - 8:00 pm

Maya’s Crab Shack Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Maya’s Crab Shack

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Amy S.
125
1
0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Maya’s Crab Shack

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

Cape Fear - Cabo Blackened Fish Tacos!

Cape Fear

4.4(293 reviews)
15.7 mi
•$$

We had a fantastic experience at Cape Fear Seafood! The food was fresh, flavorful, and cooked…read moreperfectly. I ordered the blackened catch of the day tacos, and they were delicious--the fish was seasoned just right, and the mango salsa gave them the perfect fresh, sweet kick. The side salad was crisp and fresh, and everything came out quickly. The service was friendly and attentive, and the atmosphere was relaxed and welcoming. It's easy to see why this place is so highly rated. We'll definitely be back the next time we're in the area. Highly recommend!

Heard this is the place for quality seafood in Leland. Finally went here with the family last week…read more The waitstaff is very friendly, so that was nice. The fried okra did not taste fresh at all, kind of mushy and didn't have parm on it, 4.5 out of 10. The mussels were a HIT!! Great flavor, lots of buttery sauce, 9.0 The roasted red pepper and crab bisque had a really nice flavor, but alas, there was about 2 teaspoons of crab in it. So sad, 7.0 The shrimp and grits tasted good, but that's a high bar, being you should be making a great shrimp & grits if you put it on your menu in this part of the country. It's not near as good as I've had around here, but still, 7.0 Both the girls had the salmon with risotto. Risotto was good, but both pieces of fish were overcooked. If your a seafood place, cooking the fish correctly is a must. Sorry, 5.0 My son had the flounder and, again, the crab tasted like it was canned and the fish was overcooked, 4.0 Since Yelp only has 5 stars instead of 10, I had to mark down so people wouldn't think it was a good meal. 3 out of 5 is just above average. Sorry Cape.

Photos
Cape Fear - Sitting down for Grandma's 92nd birthday!

Sitting down for Grandma's 92nd birthday!

Cape Fear - Blueberry cobbler

Blueberry cobbler

Cape Fear - Prickly pear margarita

See all

Prickly pear margarita

Cape Fear Seafood Company - Fish -n- Chips Platter

Cape Fear Seafood Company

4.4(866 reviews)
24.5 mi
•$$

We have been coming here a while now, and I will say this visit was the best one we had. Service…read morewas great, food was amazing, we had a reservation so we were seated right away, and we like the vibe here. Even though you are in a strip mall, this is a comfortable location. We started with an appetizer we have not had before and we really enjoyed it. Get the Crab dip. You get a hot, bubbly dish of the dip with some fried pita chips. Get some bread at the table too, so you can enjoy the dip if you run out of chips. My husband loved it so much he ate it plain. We got some excellent entrees this time. We had the Figure 8 stuffed flounder. Instead of the green beans and risotto, he got risotto cakes and sautéed spinach. Risotto cakes are really good. Nice and crispy and so tasty. We also had the lemon pepper scallops with risotto cakes and asparagus. We really enjoyed everything and our server was so nice. I didn't take a pic but I also had the handcrafted lemonade which is delicious. Unfortunately no room for dessert, but they have some yummy selections to try. We have enjoyed coming here repeatedly and do enjoy this place. We have had very few minor issues that were not deal breakers for coming in. As with any restaurant, they will have some minor flaws. Overall it is consistently good.

We used to love this place and to some degree I do because I order sandwiches with fries , and they…read morenever screw if up, but my wife orders the seafood dinners and the last 3 times we had to to return over done, underdone, or cold food and tonight was #4 and I know what happened they plated the soupy risotto, and the broccoli while the fish cooked so the sides got cold. They just have a miserable kitchen staff or lack of leadership at management level. It will be a very long time before we return, but Dan and Jason at the bar were amazing! It is a sad situation that the "seafood" meals are hosed up! 2 stars as my chicken sandwich was decent. So disappointing! Such a cute place

Photos
Cape Fear Seafood Company
Cape Fear Seafood Company - Surf & Turf Chimichurri $13.99 - perfectly seasoned n cooked steak

Surf & Turf Chimichurri $13.99 - perfectly seasoned n cooked steak

Cape Fear Seafood Company - Mixed Berry Mojito Mocktail

See all

Mixed Berry Mojito Mocktail

Fish Bites Seafood Restaurant - Oyster bites appetizer

Fish Bites Seafood Restaurant

4.4(975 reviews)
25.4 mi
•$$

This little out-of-the-way place gets my vote for the best seafood in Carolina Beach! Everything we…read morehad was fresh, flavorful, and delicious--and the best part was that it wasn't fried. They do have fried options on the menu, but we chose the fresh, lighter choices and were so glad we did. The homemade soups were fantastic. He tried both the lobster bisque and the New England clam chowder, and we also had the spinach salad with poppy seed dressing--absolutely delicious! Then we tried the daily special: a blackened shrimp wrap with a side of garlic mashed potatoes. You could tell the potatoes were homemade, and everything tasted fresh and made with care. I honestly can't say enough good things about this place. I wish we had discovered it years ago! Hands down, one of the best places I've eaten in Carolina Beach in many years. We will definitely be back as soon as possible!

Service was great, friendly and prompt. Food was incredible and came out fast and fresh. We had…read moresome raw oysters and lobster bisque. The catch of the day was blackened swordfish and it was fantastic. My wife had the crab cake sandwich and it was amazing. But the part that I loved the most was my son's fish sticks. I half expected Gorton's for a kid but they came out, fresh fried fish and it was delicious. I ended up eating the rest of what he couldn't finish. This wasn't my first visit but it's been years since I was here. Glad to see it's still going strong. It stays as my top recommendation for folks coming to Carolina Beach

Photos
Fish Bites Seafood Restaurant - Dining area

Dining area

Fish Bites Seafood Restaurant
Fish Bites Seafood Restaurant - Back bar

See all

Back bar

Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar - 1/2 lb crab legs

Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar

4.1(783 reviews)
29.7 mi
•$$

Awesome spot for some great seafood. This is chain, but don't feel like it at all. When we were…read moretold it was a chain, we were shocked. Doesn't give that feel at all. It's a small place with a long bar and some high tops. It was very busy the entire time we were there with people even posting outside for a table. We sat at the bar. The service here is fantastic. Super friendly and constantly checking in on you. They work as a team. They add to the vibe for sure. Ordered the Michaelada and a margarita. These were both delicious. The beer based drink comes with an oyster. Added hot sauce to it to make it extra spicy. The margarita was tasty. We didn't order apps as we opted for a boil bucket - don't remember the name. It came with oysters, clams, streamed shrimp, corn, and crab legs. It was $75 and was plenty for two people. There was an additional $2 or $3 charge for steaming the oysters. Didn't get a pic as we tore into the bucket. All was delicious. Would come again!!!

If you are looking for a good place to sit I would keep walking. It's Literally in the restaurant…read morename "Shack". It's small and Crowded. Friday night so it's expected. But hardly any standing room - it's cramped! We had to sit at a "community table." They said for 8 but more like 4 comfortably and 6 MAX. Lobster roll was not good. The bread was in what tasted like when you eat something fried in old oil. The lobster meat was ok. The mahi fish basket and wings were good. The waitress seemed like she didn't want to be there. So overall bad experience with ok food.

Photos
Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar - Total dining room

Total dining room

Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar - Crab legs, appetizer sampler

Crab legs, appetizer sampler

Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar - Marg

See all

Marg

Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar

Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar

4.3(518 reviews)
39.2 mi
•$$

We've lived in the area for about 6 years. Eat out fairly often. This restaurant by far has been…read morethe most consistent in the quality of the food, which is the best of all the restaurants in the topsail area. It is not fine dining and has the sports bar vibe. It is a relatively small place and I recommend going on non peak hours in season. If you are into oysters, they have a great selection of both local and regional on the half shell. If you prefer cooked, chargrilled or steamed is a good choice. While the menu has a great selection of seafood, the chalkboard specials features extremely fresh local catches which change daily. While there are several restaurants in and around the topsail area this is the only one where I have never been disappointed. If you go at peak hours during the vacation season expect to wait but it is worth it. You can't miss with any of the steamed shellfish offerings and if you prefer fried there batter is light and not overpowering. As a sports bar, they have a large selection of tap and bottled beers and a good mixology of liquor options which is only outdone in my opinion by Rick's in Sneads Ferry

Great place for oysters. You can buy them individually which is great if you eat more than a dozen…read more I normally get 15-18 oysters when I go. They are delicious and the service is top notch. It' is a little hot in there, so dress cool. I go weekly to this restaurant and highly recommend.

Photos
Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar
Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar
Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar

See all

Splash by the Sea - Sliders with Waffle Fries

Splash by the Sea

4.3(403 reviews)
49.0 mi
•$$

Food and atmosphere were good. We had a party of 10. Got seated in around 20 minutes at peak dinner…read morehours. The waitress was supper friendly and helpful explaining everything. I ordered the seared tuna and wasabi mashed potatoes. I would eat them again. They were very good. My dad ordered the shrimp platter and that looked like something I would like to try also. My daughter got a pound of crab legs and a side of waffle fries. She said how good the fries were several times. Someone at the far end of our table ordered a pizza. And they said it was excellent. The place isn't overly expensive but also not cheap. But the food and staff made it a place to consider going back for sure.

My wife and I both ordered the tuna with wasabi mashed potatoes. We enjoyed it, and the…read morepresentation was nice, but it didn't wow us. I think the poppy and sesame seeds threw off the flavor a bit. My wife says the tuna steak at Ribeyes in Swansboro is better, and I'm staying out of that argument. The crab dip was also good, though it didn't change our lives. Our server was great, and the food came out so quickly I barely had time to pretend I was still reading the menu. We'd heard about the view, but the swimming pool takes up most of it. You can see the ocean in the distance if you know where to look. For the view, we'd pick Mac Daddy's. Overall: 4/5. Good food and great service. We might come back once more to see if the tuna and the view make a stronger second impression.

Photos
Splash by the Sea
Splash by the Sea - Ahi tuna tacos with their waffle fries and tuna steak dinner

Ahi tuna tacos with their waffle fries and tuna steak dinner

Splash by the Sea - Diet Coke by the pool

See all

Diet Coke by the pool

Michael's Seafood Restaurant - Snow Crab and Ribe eye

Michael's Seafood Restaurant

4.0(1.1k reviews)
28.8 mi
•$$

Our first time dining at Michael's Seafood Restaurant. Only our second time to Carolina Beach. The…read morewait wasn't too bad, about 30 - 40 minutes. Once seated though things moved pretty fast. Our waiter Noah T was very attentive, answered our questions and we were off and running. We chose a couple of appetizers; a bowl of Chowder (only because of the raves from fellow Yelpers) and the Athenian Bruschetta. Both were very good but my expectant bubble was burst as it wasn't "the best I have had" as many of the Yelpers had described it. The Athenian Bruschetta though was A-amazing. For Entree I had the stuffed Flounder and Norma had Shrimp and Scallop Scampi. Both were very delicious. Atmosphere was nice, a bit crowded, as you would expect where the food is really good. Tables were tight. Hard to navigate with Norma's wheelchair, but we made it through. Large helpings, took tomorrow's lunch back to the hotel. A definite come back to place.

I've been visiting Carolina Beach for years (since 2013?), and Michael's Seafood has been one of…read morethe restaurants that has seemed to be a constant throughout my years of visits. That said, despite the place seeming to be very popular, I'd never actually visited for a meal - until my most recent visit, that is. I was visiting my grandmother and we finished a nearby game of miniature golf around 4:15pm, so we decided to head over to Michael's for an early dinner (I was going to bed early that night anyway, since I had to drive to Raleigh the next day for my flight out of RDU). She'd been raving about the dressing available at this place (they're known for a champagne vinaigrette, apparently?). I'd been eating light in Carolina Beach (having come from Houston, which made me feel like I was 95% brisket by the time I left), so I was looking forward to the roasted beet salad that she told me was on the menu of this place. We got to the restaurant and were seated right away (perfect timing, honestly, since the place started to fill up not that long after we arrived). I ordered the strawberry lemonade to drink, a cup of the seafood chowder, and the roasted beet salad (minus bleu cheese). It wasn't long before our order arrived at the table. The seafood chowder was decent, though nothing I would particularly order again or think especially notable. The beet salad was the same. I was actually expecting a different texture from the beets... they seemed more mushy than anything, and didn't have that "roasted" flavor I was expecting. The salad dressing that my grandmother had been raving about didn't really hit the mark for me either. It lacked flavor, and almost seemed overly diluted. Ultimately, I'm giving Michael's a 3/5 because our server was attentive and I enjoyed the general vibe of the place. I can understand why it's an easy place to grab a bit on Carolina Beach; that said, would I bother visiting Michael's Seafood again on a follow-up trip to CB? No, there are plenty of other options.

Photos
Michael's Seafood Restaurant - Bar

Bar

Michael's Seafood Restaurant - Santa's Night Cap, Smoked

Santa's Night Cap, Smoked

Michael's Seafood Restaurant - Patio

See all

Patio

Maya’s Crab Shack - seafood - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...