We got takeout of three large pizzas plus an order of breadsticks. The breadsticks were okay. But the pizza was quite nice. We got a cheese, a mushroom, and one with sausage, mushroom, and black olives. I am not sure which was my favorite! It was a very enjoyable and tasty meal. read more

I was completely dumb-founded by the lack of ingredients used for my food. Not only did my Italian sub lack the most important ingredients: lettuce and onion, but my pizza was low-balled on half of it, and didn't even have one of the simple ingredients I asked for: pepperoni. Not to mention, we were served only 4 out of 5 plates for my party, was not asked if we needed refills, napkins, OR Parmesan, and the straws offered were crinkled and weak. read more

Mario's Pizza - This is the weak Italian sub I was given. PSA.. I asked for no tomato. Guess what was on the sub more than the ingredients I wanted. - Pizza Near Me - Greenville, Illinois

The services was good but the food was excellent also came fast , was clean neat and staff was very friendly. Can't wait to go back.

My first time here but I will definitely come back. We had two different appetizers: the garlic cheese bread which was really good and the absolutely amazing Massimo stick bread. For dinner I had the calzone which was perfect. I tried the slice of an extra thin pizza (think sorta like imos thin) and it also had a really good flavor. They use a lot of oregano seasoning and I think that really makes their food standout. read more

Mario's Pizza - Massimo Stick appetizer (not on the regular menu) but oh so good. - Pizza Near Me - Greenville, Illinois

See all

Great as always. Called in for take out. Was just as good next morning for breakfast.

We did a large carry out and everyone enjoyed the food. It's thin style but very tasty. We recommend it. read more

Always pleasant and the best pizza ever. Never disappoints us Casual setting first rate ingredients read more

We went adventurous and tried the Olympian, which is a hummus based pizza. It's apparently divisive, but the hummus base, veggies, and banana peppers pulled together to be a great pizza! The only drawback was the crust--it was a little crispy to my taste, no tea softness, and there was no flavor in it at all. The crust needs to fermer for quite awhile longer to be really good. read more

The pizza is good the cheese is stretchy. The bread sticks came fast so did the food.the service is fast. The booth seat was ripped but everything else was nice. read more

Best pizza around, and the salads are equally fantastic! Loved the Mario Sticks as well. But that Divinci pizza is my favorite

My favorite and only place to get pizza in Greenville! Thick, delicious and filling pizza.

Excellent pizza- crispy crust and food didn't take long to come out. One of our pizzas could've used a bit more cheese & sauce otherwise great! Staff at the counter was really nice read more

Ordered 5 pizzas for the family when we rented a lake house. It was done when it was supposed to be and the pizza was very good. Crust and cheese was good and toppings were visible and tasted good. They were friendly on phone. I highly suggest them! read more

Best pizza in southern Illinois! A must eat for any authentic pizza lovers. Story of place is also very heartfelt, owners are Sicilian immigrants with a passion for good, high quality pizza. Ask for Chris, she's the best manager there-incredibly sweet and always ready to help! read more

Mario's Pizza - two slices of pizza painted on the side of a building - Pizza Near Me - Greenville, Illinois

Authentic college pizza place. Try the veggie or meat sticks. The salads are good. On some days they have funky lunch pizza specials. Give them a try. read more

Brought a group here on a weeknight and ordered 4 pizzas for 6:30 pm for dine-in. We were running a little late, and a manager called and wanted to make sure he kept the pizzas hot for us. Very nice gesture that I greatly appreciated. When we got to the restaurant, we were greeted promptly and pizza came to our table almost immediately. Very tasty- we all loved it!! We even had someone in our group who doesn't normally like pizza; she tried one of the pieces of pizza and loved it. Excellent job! read more

Still Awesome after 20+ years of eating here. Still a FIVE . Got takeout due to Covid restrictions. We live in CBus, Ohio and we eat here everytime we visit my brother. If Mario's was in CBus, it would be number one. We still love, love, love Mario's.!!!! read more

Mario's is a Greenville staple. Handmade from fresh ingredients using traditional recipes. The new takes on flavors and combinations are well crafted like the Wrangler using their house dressing as sauce. Good selection of salads and sides. It is a weekly tradition for a lot of people and the first stop for those returning to town. read more

Has the DaVinci it was great. Fresh ingredients. Prepared and presented tastefully. What was on the pie tin was incredible. I was surprised at the quality considering the exterior of the building. A gem. This pizza rivals any big city pizza anywhere! Definitely worth the stop if you are in town. read more

Mario's Pizza - Absolutely outstanding. Had the DaVinci. The homemade salad dressing is in a class of its own. Fresh ingredients and quality!! - Pizza Near Me - Greenville, Illinois

Always amazing! The house dressing is so versatile. We use it as dressing, we use it as a dip for the pizza, and we also use it in place of red sauce on our pizza. The Massimo sticks are amazing and their salads are always fresh and big enough to share. Whenever anyone comes to town we always take them to Marios because it's just that good read more

Best pizza ever!! Wrangler w feta and a Mario's Supreme both are awesome! Start w a BLT salad...order extra house dressing to dip crusts in...the best!! Still waiting to find out the secret ingredient(s) for the dressing. Drive from STL / Chicago / Memphis / Indy...nothing compares!! read more

Favorite Pizza Hands Down. Raised my daughter in Greenville and didn't realize how lucky I was to have Mario's in the same street as my house. I lived in Springfield, IL and now St. Louis..... We still cannot find a pizza that we all like as much as MARIO's!!! It is even nicer that when you walk in... it feels like Home and they are all like family!!! read more

Mario's Pizza is a long standing favorite of our family . You walk inside and the aroma awakens your tastebuds ! Their pizza -fresh out of the oven - is the BEST! The combo house salad with their house dressing is always fresh and delicious ! So grateful Mario's Pizza is in Greenville . We love it ! read more

I love Marios! Sweet sauce and so thin cracker crust is the best! I love sausage and onion and their muxed salad with ham and pepperoni. Delish! read more

Normally I would've had to have gone to Chicago to get pizza this good. Delicious, everything homemade and place was clean though service a little slow, but they were busy so that's not really a problem. It was so good we ate one pizza there and took another one home! Doesn't look like much from the outside but the inside smells like a pizzeria should, it's nice and clean and the food is absolutely fabulous! Even the iced tea was good. We will be going back regularly! read more

First time here. Good pizza. Their idea of crust is a little different than I'm used too. Thin,extra thin,and deep dish. Extra Thin I though would be a cracker crust but it wasn't and a deep dish defiantly wasn't Chicago style but non the less it was delicious. Sweet sauce. We will stop in here again. read more

See all

Wow...I love pizza and Mario's is fantastic! While visiting the alma mater of 3/4's of my family, we stopped here for dinner on the suggestion of the friends we were dining with. Let me be honest and say that from the looks of the outside, I wasn't sure how good it could be...but I knew it smelled wonderful from the time we walked in the door. Its a cute, family owned little space...with pizza and cheesecake as the top items on the menu (in my opinion). We tried the large Davinci deep dish...which is kind of like a regular thickness of pizza in the Chicago area and an extra think mushroom sausage. I really couldn't pick a favorite...both were delicious! If you are ever in Greenville, I would highly recommend a trip to Mario's....its meraviglioso!! read more

Mediocre pizza. The locals love it, but as a transplant to Greenville I can boldly say that this place is just okay. I've also heard they don't treat their employees well. read more

Fab! My friend and I got a new "vegetarian" pizza after stopping in to A) go to the bathroom and B) see if they had toasted raviolis....the girl working told us of her new creations and my friend liked the idea of the humus with feta/mozzarella and various vegetable pizza. I thought this can either be really bad or really good...it was great! I enjoyed the crust and cheese! we also tried the chummy rummy grapefruit soda, chummy rummy yummy! This restaurant is not anything to write home about as far as decor, so if your looking for charm this isn't it, but if your looking for a different pie experience give it a try! read more

I love Mario's Pizza. Lots of variety, great appetizers, and for a decent price as well. I have been there numerous times since being a student at Greenville College, and I have not once been disappointed with my visit. Do yourself a favor and go get yourself a pizza at Mario's. read more

The best pizza for miles around, salads are awesome too. Take out or dine in. Polite workers and you might even get to see Mario. Don't miss it. read more

Amazing little Italian restaurant. I have eaten here many, many times and have never been disappointed. Love that it's a family business with original owners straight from a Sicilian village. read more

My wife and I have been hearing just how great Mario's Pizza is and decided we would drive the 14 miles to Greenville for some shopping but especially to try Mario's. We were disappointed that their inside dining was closed due to covid and if we wanted to eat it would have to be take out. Not only that but their fountain service was not working so that if we wanted soft drinks we would have to go elsewhere to purchase them. In spite of these inconveniences we decided to place a order for a large pizza and bread sticks. We waited for about 15 minutes while several people came and picked up their orders. Finally a young man came to our car (not the one who took our order) and asked if we had placed an order. We told him we had and that we had been waiting at least 15 minutes. He told us that he would try to find out what the holdup was. 10 minutes go by and still no food until finally the young man comes to our car and says that they cannot find our order. He offers no apologies or offers to compensate us for our inconvenience. Disgusted we left, drove .5 miles away to Joe's Pizza where we were able to go into the dining room and in spite of the covid were able to order and eat our pizza there. While eating at Joe's, I called Mario's and asked for the manager. I relayed our unpleasant experience at Mario's and asked if he thought that was a good business practice. He assured me that it was not and took my name and phone number promising to call me on Tuesday to set up a times when we could come to Mario's for a dinner at no charge. Unfortunately several Tuesdays have come and gone and we are still waiting on that phone call! read more

Authentic local pizza institution with in house dining. Yummy fresh ingredients make this a can't miss stop when in town.

We've deliberately detoured to Mario's from St. Louis to Effingham for dinner several times and will do so again. Great pizza (and salads, too). read more

Marios is very authentic Italian pizza. The crust is phenomenal. Toppings very generous and fresh. I've eaten here monthly for the last three years and never let down. I would skip the calzones. To much dough and not enough fillings. The salads or very good. Great place worth the trip. read more

Best pizza around, by far. Good ingredients. Friendly staff that are committed to a good experience.

Not the place to go if you are driving through & starving. The service was poor & it took forever to get the food. The salad was gross & had a hair in it. The pizza was ok. NO ONE was using gloves to prepare food. How this place got 4.5 stars I have no clue. Bad experience altogether. read more

Oh, how I love Mario's Pizza. This place has fresh ingredients and a real Italian owner that can whip you up a feast. I get The House pizza "The Mario" along with the house salad. Their salad dressing is wonderful! Don't be fooled by crappy imitations once taking up residence in Vandalia, IL. This is the real deal people. read more

Takes hours to get food and when they "forget" to make your food they have the audacity to tell you are in the wrong place because they are too lazy to write down your order, phone number, or name. read more