Our journey from New Mexico to Indiana yielded a truly exceptional discovery in Alfonzo's. While the cuisine was thoroughly delightful, it was the caliber of service that elevated our visit into a memorable highlight of our travels. Joe greeted us with a genuine warmth and an infectious enthusiasm that immediately transformed a standard dining stop into an outstanding hospitality experience. In an era where true customer care is a rare commodity, He is an absolute asset to the establishment. read more

First time ordering pick up from here and it was great! The pizza is pretty unique and the crust is so buttery. The Greek salad was 10/10! Best Greek salad I've had in forever. We also ordered the fonzo bits a they were good but should have ordered them with garlic butter. Overall good takeout and quick! Would eat inside for sure next time! read more

A nice family owned business with a friendly owner and great wait staff. Despite the crowd inside, the staff was attentive and friendly and food came out fast. Started out with the antipasto salad and it was delicious. Ordered a side of wings and they were hot and crispy, but a little on the small side. We ordered a giant pizza as that's the only way to describe it and it was an average pizza. I liked the edge pieces more because they were crispier than the middle pieces. The middle pieces were just floppy and a little soggy and floppy. But the flavor was there though. I give it an average rating but it's worth it to try. read more

Alfonzo's Pizzeria - Antipasto salad - Pizza Near Me - Troy, Illinois

See all

Hubs & I stopped off one night after a school meeting. It was close to closing time, but our server was AWESOME!! We didn't feel rushed. Great salad, great pizza & yummy wings! We ordered the Large Avalanche pizza. DAMN, IT WAS LARGE!!!! We took home more than we ate. FYI: Leftovers were great toasted in the air fryer. My Greek salad was delish & hubs house salad looked good too (he does not like to share LOL!). It was "Wine Wednesday" & the wine was lovely... Restaurant & bathrooms were clean (even right before closing). Thanks Alfonso's I'll be back!! read more

Food-absolutely loved it. The roast beef sandwich and the meat sauce was amazing. Our server was very nice. The atmosphere was not to loud and the lighting was perfect. Last thing, the tiramisu was amazing. In my opinion, if you like Italian, this is a go-to restaurant. (Written by my 9-year old son) read more

I grew up with Alfonzo's and let me tell you, nothing compares! It's amazing! Best local pizza in the Collinsville, Troy, Edwardsville area! I'm so thankful they made it through the C***d stuff cuz they are spectacular! If you're ever in the southern Illinois area, visit Troy IL and it's located on HWY 162! read more

Alfonzo's Pizzeria - Front door to the greatest pizza joint in southern Illinois! - Pizza Near Me - Troy, Illinois

Good service and family owned. Italian food and pizzas. You can buy whole, half or just a slice. Prices are fair and atmosphere is comfortable. While we were there after 16:00 on a Thursday, there were about 20 people and was quiet with music playing from the 70s. I had the baked cod fish and get it almost every time I come in. Recommend!!! read more

Ok. I live close and there are always a lot of cars here. I ordered a large pizza extra sauce,extra cheese one topping and 5 wings. Seemed high $46.00. Pizza was huge lots of cheese hardly any sauce. To be fair extra sauce wasn't listed but I ordered it. Crust was done but soft and doughy but not real thick but not real thin. Not my jam but chewy not tough. Sauce I had was just ok cheese acceptable. Wings were tasty but pretty dried up. I got it to go and served taking my order was a bit rude so no tip. I would say if you want an extra large pizza and aren't picky I'd try this place. read more

Alfonzo's Pizzeria - 5 wings $7.99 - Pizza Near Me - Troy, Illinois

We always love the pizza and the holiday cocktails on the menu were great. The owner and his family are so friendly and always check in at your table to make sure the customers are happy. We will be back soon! read more

Last Wednesday was my first time at Alfonzo's Pizzeria and I Love it the food was so good I got the manicotti.And also their salad I really love this restaurant and definitely will be going back. read more

Friendly staff and great service. Our slice of pizza was huge and very delicious! Antipasta salad was very good. I would eat here again when in the area. read more

I have never been so embarrassed ...my brother visiting from out of town...loves Alfonso's....ordered half size...was a quarter of the size it use to be.... 4 sm dinner salads ...8 ravs....almost $80....sorry Alfonso's... I just don't know what to say...but probably won't be ordering anymore read more

I have been coming here for years and I always have a great experience. The servers are incredibly friendly! It's a family owned business and the owners really care about their customers. Food is amazing every time too! The pizza recipe is so different from other places and truly my favorite. I always recommend the Alfonzo bites as an appetizer also! Parking is easy with a huge lot. They are usually pretty busy but service is quick! They also offer a room for parties/events. read more

See all

Our family had dinner here for the first time tonight and this place did not disappoint! The service was impecable right from the start when we got inside to the very end. The employees went above and beyond and catered to everything we wanted/needed. Our server, Ben, was exceptionally great and a great conversationalist. Food was great too! We ordered the chicken wings, garlic bread with cheese, and toasted ravs for appetizers for all of us to share and we all loved each of them. I personally had their fettucine with chicken that came with salad and garlic bread and it was good. Everyone else also loved what they ordered. Even my daughter loved their kids meal spaghetti! Will definitely come back to try out their other dishes. read more

Alfonzo's Pizzeria - Fettucine with chicken + garlic bread - Pizza Near Me - Troy, Illinois

Ummm well my family and my wife all went there (total 5 people) well 4 of us got a slice of pizza each and my dad go some pasta (I believe it was lasagna) and all of us got SMALL side salads, and dad got cannoli for his dessert. Well long story short, AND A $120 LATER. We still can't figure out how it got that high. The food was just ok, definitely not worth a $120 dollars. More than likely will not be back for a VERY long time read more

Aug 17, 2022 Dinner for 6 @ 6:00 Toasted Ravioli - good size serving, good tasting but sort of dry, sauce good but thin. I probably will not order again. Boneless chicken wings spiced hot very good. 18" pizza with meat - very good but not excellent. Needed more cheese. Vegetarian pizza - good but light on the vegetables. Room for improvement. House salads - very good Noisy. Good parking. read more

The pizza was mediocre at best and was WAY over priced. Most chains have better tasting pizza for much less.

Food was delicious. Waitress was very polite and checked on us a couple of times to make sure we were doing good. Atmosphere was good as well. read more

Would give 10/5 if I could. Joe was the best waiter I've ever had. He had rapid pace, high energy, and even competitive greatness. I would eat here every day for the rest of my life if I could. Great atmosphere too. read more

Great for a family pizza night! Food was good and timely. Service was friendly and accurate. Owner stopped by to check on our experience and was charming without being intrusive. Thank you for your service Mike! read more

The atmosphere and food here are both so great. The owner (Mike) keeps the food very authentic to the Italian cuisine. It is a family owned business that I have been going to for over 20 years. I love their hot wings. They also have really good cod for a nice, light option. Their house salad is incredible and their house dressing is to die for. I always get it any chance I get. Their pizza is super great. Not too thick, but not too thin. I love getting it with cherry peppers on it! The pizza is not only good that day, but it is also excellent when you heat it up the next day. They have great drinks to go along with their food. The service is so great and you can really tell it is family owned because they care so much. There is plenty of parking. If you are stopping through Troy, I highly recommend this authentic Italian pizzeria. Hands down the best restaurant in Troy. read more

I used to love eating at Alfonzo's. But the last two times that I was there, they included a black hair on my food. I'm done. Won't be back. read more

The restaurant atmosphere and waitress was top notch. This was our first time and we enjoyed the pizza and salad. It was really good! We live an hour away, but we will be back. read more

Great atmosphere, always busy, service was pretty good and most importantly the pizza was great. Also try the Spumoni! read more

Alfonzo's Pizzeria - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Troy, Illinois

Wow!! Everything was delicious!! We are from St. Louis and this was worth the trip. If you're in the area, definitely a must visit!! read more

Alfonzo's Pizzeria - a table full of pizzas - Pizza Near Me - Troy, Illinois

Best pizza ever! I used to work here and moved out of the area but still come back on occasion for the food. High recommend garlic butter bits as an app and the pizza of course! Avalanche is good if you like a lot of toppings or if you're like me just plain pepperoni is amazing as well. Enjoy!! read more

Alfonzo's pizza is a childhood fav of mine it's very very good and I recommend. Get a jumbo and enjoy

Some of the best pizza out there. When my dad's family lived in Maryville we would get Alfonzo's while visiting. The pizza crust is very unique and I can't seem to find it anywhere else. Highly recc the wings and pizza. Give Alfonzo's a shot, you won't be disappointed! read more

Yum yum in my tum tum. Great fettuccine Alfredo with chicken yum yum yum yum so yum yum yum

Great service. When the owner comes and checks on your table and asks you how the service is, that's quality. Wings, ravioli and Alfanzo's bites are a must for appetizer. Pizza is great & spaghetti - have to get with the meatballs. Inside is nice and clean. read more

Great Pizza, however they close at times when people want to eat. Sorry for your loss, many other places to get good pizza.

Horrible in every single way . I am never coming back. The staff was rude and it was overpriced

Absolutely great place to go for dinner! Food, staff, owner and his family are all great! Pizza, pasta, salads and everything else is awesome read more

We used to love Alfonzo's and have been patronizing this business since the 1980's when they were in Maryville, IL. However, the last 2 times we ordered carry-out, there was a hair in our food. Yuck! I cannot get myself to go back. read more

I'd really like to give Alfonzo's a higher rating, but I got to be fair. Let's just start with what they are obviously famous for: the pizza. The pizza is great. I like most kinds of pizza, and theirs is a bit hard to describe. To sum it up, its pizza you would sit and eat endlessly because its that good. I would put their crust very soft with a little burnt, crispy edge here and there. Then you have the cheese and the sauce which is hard to taste at most times. The only thing I don't like about the pizza is they only give you three options on size. You can have it big, mega-huge and just one big slice. In other words, there is no middle ground. Big and small are the only options available. That doesn't sit well with people like me. Their salad is decent, no complaining there. Alfonzo's likes to advertise itself as 'the best margarita in town', and theirs was good. Now onto other menu items: their wings, which they are also famous for. I had the hot boneless wings, and I was extremely disappointed. They are no different than the Tyson boneless wings found in the frozen foods section in the supermarket. Maybe I should have splurged and got their more "advanced" wings like the salt/pepper rub (I believe that's what it was?...) ones. I also had their "Loaded" Fries, which had cheese sauce, cut bacon and jalapenos. Sound good, right? That was another disappointment for me, as the fries tasted like the microwavable kind you get at Dollar General (which is not far from Alfonzo's). I just thought I would try something different on this visit, so that's what I get I guess. My server, Bailey, was very nice and I told her my concerns about the food and she offered to replace them but I rejected. Alfonzo's is a place I've had many memories, mostly during their days as part of Family Fun Time in Maryville. I've also had Alfonzo's on different occasions like kids birthday parties. Like other reviewers pointed out, they have indeed stepped up their game with a nicer place - although I didn't care for the bathrooms. They also have a kid-friendly game room, and a nice private room for parties. Alfonzo's has been a staple for many years, for as long as I've been alive. Check it out, but go straight for the pizza. read more

Alfonzo's Pizzeria - Hot boneless wings and loaded fries - Pizza Near Me - Troy, Illinois

I've never really been a fan since they were in Maryville. Their pizza was greasy. Their pasta was bland. There is too much sugar in their sauce. I only went this time because I thought it might have improved in the last ten years. Nope. Maybe a tad worse. read more

Ask for Joe he's fricking awesome. In eed 85 characters so I'm going to tell you that the pizza was OK

Eh it's adequate at best. Every time I've eaten here the food quality and the service seems to have gotten worse. Not sure if it's the lack of staffing or what, but I'd spend my money elsewhere. read more

Look out the online menu isn't anywhere close to the actual prices. Ordered a pick up for $27 and got there and it was $39. The foods not that great to be charging $39 for three orders of wings. Never again one time order bye-bye read more

ALFONZOS IS BY FAR MY FAVORITE pizza place ,been going since I was knee high to a grasshopper and I will gladly make the trip to Troy for a.delicious pizza ,and the famous fonzo bites read more