Great local shop that we trust to bring our cars to. We know they are honest with estimates and…read morethe work they do. Best to plan ahead on when maintenance is needed so they can fit us in for appts. There is a reason they are so booked up - they are the best!

Went today to figure out best approach to shield on bottom of car coming loose. Initially offered…read moreto take it off for free before realizing there were more problems, ended up only costing $15 for cost of materials. Interacted with Tyler, very nice very helpful - explained everything he was doing and why and didn't overcharge- if I have another problem I'd come back here!

Don't let the other reviews fool you. Based on my experience, I would not recommend this shop or…read moreits staff. I brought my car in on August 10th for an oil change, tire rotation, and to check a service light on the dash. About an hour later I got a call about it, and was given an outrageous quote to repair the root cause of the light, which turned out to be my alternator. On that call I wasn't given any real explanation or even a breakdown of the cost. That's also where I learned about a diagnostic fee I would be charged even if I went ahead with the repair, something I was never told about upfront. I declined the repair. After that call, I got quotes from a dealership and two other local shops for the same alternator repair. DiMaggio was going to charge me roughly 30 percent more than the dealership and nearly 70 percent more than the other local shops. Nobody called to let me know my car was ready, so I showed up assuming it was done. At pickup, I was charged for services I never approved, with no explanation until I pushed for one. My invoice said I had been given a courtesy vehicle inspection, but I didn't actually receive the results until after I had already complained. When I asked for the manager's contact information in person, I was handed a business card with an incorrect email address on it. I had to track down his correct email myself just to reach him. He did call the following day, and I'm giving 2 stars instead of 1 only because of that call, but the conversation mostly defended his team's handling of things rather than offering any real path to fixing it. Because of that, I ended up taking my car to another shop instead. This experience was more than terrible. It didn't make sense on paper or even in person. Avoid this shop if you can.

It's been a while since I had my car serviced there. At that time when I did go to DiMaggio's the…read morefront desk was VERY Nice and was informative! I didn't have to wait long and they did do a good job with my car. I would recommend this business to anyone.

Brought my '07 mustang in for a new wheel and tire installation! They were quick to work on it and…read morethe tires look beautiful! Really happy with my service and would be happy to return. Very reasonable pricing and flexible for pick up times.

Ive had 2 visits with the center. James has been awesome. Takes time to listen, is responsive and…read morekind. Theyve done an oil change and a once over on my car-not as invasive as I feel was needed. Ive broken down twice needing a tow since. Thats not what I came here to talk about though. They certainly had not caused those issues, but it would have been helpull to know. They cost me time from work and money besides. My issue is with how the owner not only answered the phone but continued to speak to me when I was telling him my new dilemma (Im in bankruptcy and have struggled keeping a running vehicle. Ive learned a lot and can do much of the work myself). I have learned enough to know what I don't want to do myself. Mainly because it is now winter in freezing outside and Im without a garage. He never let me finish a sentence and was frustrated when he couldnt get the story straight. Every question he asked was biting and condescending, where if he let me finish and listened he would have had the answers. When he finally got a better picture of the issue he responded with 'I have a hard time believing that.' He went from 'thats not possible' to 'if we had done that' to 'this is what we do when that happens'. It turned into one of the situations where he said too much because he thought I didn't understand what he was saying. Looking at Google and the description-its an absolute lie. All of the part stores in the area know me. By name. And Ive taught the young bucks behind the counter a thing or two. I am smart enough to ask about the things that I don't know and I know how to ask nicely. He'd begrudgingly told me to make it in by 7:15 am to fit me in. Didnt offer the work for free (removing the leaking oil drain plug that they didnt use a crush washer with and is not coming out), didnt go into what could may be done to fix it and what they can offer for any price. I know how to fix it, his customer services was the worst Ive experienced in a long time.

I've had my car to Conant a handful of times now. They are honest, to the point, and don't charge…read morean arm and a leg. Unlike other places, they don't try to push every service under the sun on you. They tell you what's wrong, how to fix it, and what it's going to cost. There is no run around with them. I've been so happy with their work and completely trust them with my vehicle. Additionally, they are amazing members of the community. As someone who lives in Stoughton, I can appreciate the investment they put back into their city. They are sponsors of so many amazing organizations, charities, and events. Highly recommend!

After 27-years of going to Conant, they are no longer reliable. They don't do the work I ask…read morebecause they never have time to finish or can't get a part or some odd excuse. They are now employee oriented at the expense of the customer. They fixed a flat tire for me, it leaked so I had to go back. I don't have a spare tire so they had to give me a loaner car. Three days to fix a tire. Couldn't fix my gas cap, couldn't align my front end, I asked to have tires rotated, they didn't but charged me. All they did was check my brakes, change my oil and didn't have time to do the other things I asked them to do. THATS WHY WE MAKE APPOINTMENTS. I end up going to Stoughton Tire to get the other things done. Long gone are the days of Joe. So we are taking our three cars somewhere else. Service just sucks now.

Fixed coolant leak, get it home, still leaking coolant. Shop claims system was pressure tested and…read morepassed. Get it back into the shop; fix second leak with additional parts and labor costs. Claims pressure tested system and passed for the second time. Currently no leak. Took two trips, two bills, and didn't have my car for little under two weeks. You decide if this is the experience you want.

Branden and the team are amazing! Great experience all around. Excellent customer service that made…read moresuch a different and solid work!

Was so impressed w/professionalism! Handels automotive gave…read moreme peace of mind as they went through several problems at another mechanic created Darrel reassured me, after review, diagnostics. The codes warning best take car to Ford Motor? Who does this?? After 2 mechanics, broke bolts & lost bolts in engine, 1st JABS replace water pump, then broke protective cover over Timing & ripped new timing belt! Required tow, same thing Quality auto quote 1.5 hr, kept 5 hr, said "maybe 1-2 days"!! Had to drive away, these ppl not qualified mechanics. Darrel started me straight to Kayser Ford, both documented all "mess ups"! Towed again to Kaysers Ford! Darrel so grateful as it's unusual to see such professional! Ford said "This decision saved my '18 Ford engine"! Had I drove car diff would been $10,000 not $3000!! Monona has some very fine Business owners Handel Auto very grateful

Darryl and team were very kind and efficient. They were able to fix my car within 24 hours and it…read morehad multiple problems. They were extremely fair in pricing and kind while explaining what was wrong with my car. I'll be coming back!

Being new to town I needed to find a mechanic to work on my 15 year old SUV that in my previous…read moretown I only took to the dealer (too lazy to find someone else so I paid the high prices). After asking friends and neighbors with no luck I turned to Yelp and saw the great reviews for Monona Motors. I had seen this place dozens of times on walks and bike rides - it is just a mile away so I thought I would give them a try. It is a tiny place so it is hard to get into but I was not in a rush - two weeks out was OK. Greg and the guys were really friendly and straightforward in helping to figure out what was wrong. They only fixed what was wrong and did so in a cost effective way. They also discovered a very rusted out part that needed replacing in order to replace a rocker arm (I saw the old one - wow I am lucky it didn't fall apart). They tried getting the part from Nissan but due to pandemic supply chain issues it was not available but they found one from the South on Ebay for a quarter of the price of new. It was in great shape (no salt used down there). I like their initiative in trying Ebay for the part. I brought the car back for this additional work. It was done quickly and for the price quoted. So far so good with both the brake job and the front end work - and I am sure I saved a ton of $ going to these guys. I am glad I found them on Yelp!

I've been going to Monona Motors for over 30 years and trust them completely to do quality work…read morewith repairs and maintenance including the Honda and Subaru vehicles I currently drive.

RESPECT AND INTEGRITY!!!! If you are looking for frills like…read morelittle snacks and a free car wash, keep moving. But, if you're looking for a car repair shop that treats you with RESPECT and INTEGRITY, you've come to the right place! Marcus takes however much time is needed. He lays out all options, doesn't mince words and is so obviously passionate about his work, your car, and making sure, you will be as safe as possible on the road! I no longer dread bringing my car in for service! Just bring your own pretzels and soda. You won't regret it!

Super helpful, fast, and friendly service. Glad I found this place! They seem very trustworthy.read more