Best NY style pizza in the Pinehurst area. The wait is worth it. There is a reason you have to…read morewait in line and then wait 15 - 20 minutes for your pie to come out. Ask for crispy if that is what you like. His red sauce is also very tasty and combined with his dough, he gets the #1 rating. I just moved here from NYC where I lived for 67 years so I think I am a good judge. His meatball parm hero is also excellent. Tasty meatballs with his spicy sauce combined with fresh mozzarella cheese and good bread combine for a treat. This is our go to place for pizza and meatball parm hero's. So far that is all we have tried so possibly more recommendations to come down the road.

Delicious gluten free! Their gluten free crust is bigger than average with great flavor! I've had…read moreit twice and it's one of my favorite crusts. The put a good amount of toppings on. They are easy to order from in person or over the phone.

Whispering Pies was a regular place to visit for the 2 years our daughter played volleyball for…read moreSandhills CC. It was a must when we were back in the area to see our daughter played volleyball against SCC in beach volleyball. It was WONDERFUL! A.J. Is always the sweetest and made another great recommendation. I had a fall special, Blushing Pig, and my husband had the Meat Lovers. There is a picture that describes the pizza I had. It was delicious. They have made some changes since our last visit. Loved the pizza boards the pies were brought out on. If you are in the area, this is a comfortable little place with wonderful staff and delicious food. They have great pies for those needing gluten free and/or vegan. My mother loves them. Meat Lovers is red sauce base, sausage, pepperoni, bacon and ham.

Not a fancy setting but a good setting to have a slice and sit at the bar and watch a game on TV…read more The pizza was ok for a NYC standard. For this area the crust was slightly better than average. Sauce was not spicy and did not have a lot of taste. I have high expectations coming from NYC so I would not go out of my way to go there. The crust was a tad like cardboard and is not good when reheated. Best to have it fresh while in the restaurant.

I tried them out on a Tuesday night with their $12 special on pizzas. Started with their Caprese…read moresalad Which was delicious. Then split a Snookies pizza which was a 5 out of 10. Crust edges were very good but canter was very soggy. Overall pretty greasy with the pepperoni. I had to look twice to see if there was any cheese on it. Next time I'll try a different pizza that might be a little more traditional. You order at the counter and get a number here. They bring your food to the table. They have no fountain drinks or draft beer. All bottles and cans. All food is on paper plates with plastic forks and knives. We ate at a table close to the windows. The dining room is painted black with zero atmosphere. Overall the staff were pleasant and helpful. Of course when you order they flip that screen around looking for a gratuity where there is very little service provided. This could be a great spot if they stepped it up a little bit. This is a place to eat and not a place to dine.

The place is nice, clean, and open. The pizza pies are very good I may say. Many varieties to…read morechoose from. We ordered the CARNIVORO Pepperoni/Italian sausage/san marzano tomato sauce /mortadella / soppressata /pecorino romano / fresh mozzarella / fresh basil. I called it a personal pizza but really, it will feed two love birds for sure. The crew are fantastic and friendly.

Marco's Pizza is Marco's Pizza. They taste very fresh in every ingredients you bite into. This is…read moremy go-to pizza joint when I crave for thin deluxe pizzas. Real great prices that no one can compare. DoorDash'd my ordered of deliciousness. Try them, you wil understand what I'm talking about. Thanks crew for delivering another tasty treats. Chocolate CinnaSquares is delightful for a simple treat.

Food, alright. Customer service could be better. It was a carry out order. Just wasn't a welcoming…read moreatmosphere.

The pizza was made for ME! and it was top notch! I am coming back November 1,2,3 2026 and will eat…read morehere at least two of these n nights. I lived in Pinebluff in 1964 Sam Morgan Tampa

Absolutely amazing pie! The philly steak is great too! Awesome little mom and pop shop!read more

Awesome food & service. Were super nice to my kids & gave them a toy after dinner. It's a cool…read morelittle spot with TVs playing golf in all the booths. 10/10 place!! Can't wait to come back next year.

Man this place has it all! Delicious pizza and the best wings I've had in the south, they do their…read morespiciest one in house, and it is fantastic. Kids have games to play, there's a putting green and a Poole table. The music and old school feel is pretty awesome too, definitely our new go to spot. The owner and service was great as well. Sunday's is $1 wings and $3 beers!! Can't beat it!

I always crave for some pizza every now and then. Marcos Pizza here at this side of Fayetteville…read moredon't play around. Order now, customer service is very knowledgeable and the place looks really like a real fastfood place but 5 stars quality for real . Highly recommended. Burgers and tacos gets old quick. Have some Marcos!

Went to the one on Ramsey st. Love this pizza. Customer service was very good. Pizza was hot &…read moreready when I picked it up. Small store but had some tables. Very clean.

This is the best NY style pizza my husband & I have ever had! I listened to everyone else's reviews…read moreon this place & I'm so glad I did! Give them a try, you won't regret it.

To start off the staff is nice so that's a plus Had 2…read moreslices and ordered a pie to go not our first visit here The slices were thin and cut uneven the sauce needs something it's devoid of a real taste and not enough cheese. My recommendation is thicker pie not too much but a touch more cheese and work on a new sauce. The choices are very limited here (being from New York ) where we have real pizza so I am a bit of a pizza snob sorry. Good working folks nice people Update the seating area it needs a redo inside