Order Manhattan Pie Takeout or Delivery
Manhattan Pie Photos
Business Info
Manhattan Pie Popular Dishes
MANHATTAN PIE ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
More like Manhattan Pie
Recommended Reviews - Manhattan Pie
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
Manhattan Pie was a cool little pizza place, and as somebody who's been to New York City a couple of times, the pizza did seem to be pretty authentic. The way the restaurant's set up, you can either walk in and place a to-go order, or sit down and be served like a regular customer, which is kind of a novel concept (at least for the area). There were several "we're hiring" signs outside of the joint, and I got the impression that they might be short-staffed, as they only had one lady working as a waitress, and servicing all of the tables. She did a fantastic job, but there's only so much that one (1) person can do. I got a slice of pepperoni pizza, mozzarella sticks, and a drink, which were pretty good, but nothing mind-blowing. I was also a little taken aback that this relatively small meal came out to about $20 after tipping my server, as it felt like a small meal, not something that was extremely filling. As for the ambiance, I did really like the artwork on the walls, in particular the large homage to the Manhattan skyline on one of them. All-in-all, Manhattan Pie was alright, but if I were to go again, I'd probably stop in, grab a slice, and go, rather than choosing the sit-down option. I will come back in the future to see if they've worked out some of the kinks, however!
Great option for by-the-slice NY style pizza in Columbia. (They also have whole pizzas and lots of other options.) It appears to be family owned and operated, and they're very friendly and customer oriented. Got two slices of pizza for a quick lunch on a Sunday and the price was great: $13.43, before tip. I like that is a very casual, laid back place. Pizza was tasty, and I liked there were so many by the slice options. I will be back!
My son found this place for us. Being from CA we were missing finding an authentic NY pizza shop. This place was amazing. Snall spot downtown, of course you pay for parking. Food came out fast. It was authentic and crust held up with the cheese. I have zero complaints. Service was alright, servers seemed young. Place gave like a bar kinda place. The art on the wall was nice.
Customer service is great, family friendly with Delicious menu for kids as well. Slice of the BBQ Chicken, Bacon, Pepper is Sweet savory and the crust was crispy and delicious. Nothing running, cheesy good...!!! Must have ..! Great back ground music, peaceful outing to enjoy family and friends
Manhattan pie has been on my radar for a bit and I found the perfect opportunity to have a mommy and son lunch date here. Service was great and we were able to seat ourselves, menus came out shortly after. Being it was a lunch date I let my son figure out what we should order. We started with a basket of mozzarella sticks and then did a pepperoni pizza. The pizza was perfection- thin crust with a crunch but also still soft and chewy. Amazing pizza and staff, will def be back to try more.
Parking is beyond crazy. It is located on a super busy street. That is the ONLY reason why I am not giving it 5 stars. Now to the food. I had the stuffed all-meat pizza. Now, when I went into the restaurant, the garlic knots were staring at me, so I ended up grabbing an order of those as well. Normally, I pride myself on eating like 2-3 slices of pizza in one sitting. I was barely able to finish one. The toppings were amazing, the gnotts were divine, and I will 100% come back here again.
We ordered the 12 inch supreme, as well as the meat lovers and they were absolutely amazing in the picture that I posted that was the aftermath of the meat lovers and it was completely eaten. The owner of the place came up to us and asked how we were enjoying our meal and asked how we learned about this place and was very kind man. The overall vibe is nice good music playing the whole time as well as good paintings on the walls to look at while you eat.
This is a new spot in downtown Columbia that my NY born and raised coworker insisted we try for lunch. They are currently still on a soft opening so the entire menu isn't yet available, but we went for pizza and they had plenty of options on hand. My coworker was impressed with her pizza and was thrilled to see they also offered Zeppoles, which she ordered online as we sat in the restaurant and ate. This place is already very popular, as evidenced by the long line of patrons that came in during our time there. The pizza slices are definitely large and are of NY quality. Very delicious, and very meaty, were my meatlovers slices. The staff is still relatively new, so the lines move a bit slow, but it is definitely worth thae short wait. Highly recommend this spot for NY pizza lovers.
My experience was great getting some gourmet slices the other day. The slice it had were very flavorful and fresh tasting. Can't wait to try other traditional pizzas like the Sicilian soon !
Heard great things about this place and have been wanting to give it a try for a while because good pizza by the slice is hard to find in Columbia. Did not disappoint and I didn't even get the slices. My husband had a calzone, which is his go-to every time we head out for pizza. It came out much faster than they usually do and he said it was one of the best he's ever had. The vibe was great, didn't feel like a dive bar like some other pizza places in town do, and the service was friendly and very attentive. We will definitely be back.
2 months ago
2 months ago
My husband and I were craving authentic NY pizza and Manhattan Pie did not disappoint! The special supreme was excellent, just the right amount of crisp to the crust, very flavorful sauce and generous with the toppings! We learned that everything is made in house and ingredients are locally sourced. We had an opportunity to visit with Madhu, the owner. Madhu was quite charming and very hospitable. Don't skip dessert! The tiramisu was off the chain good! The restaurant is quaint and has murals painted by a COLA artist which adds a touch of local flair. We will absolutely be back and look forward to working our way through the menu. read more
2 months ago
Manhattan Pie was a cool little pizza place, and as somebody who's been to New York City a couple of times, the pizza did seem to be pretty authentic. The way the restaurant's set up, you can either walk in and place a to-go order, or sit down and be served like a regular customer, which is kind of a novel concept (at least for the area). There were several "we're hiring" signs outside of the joint, and I got the impression that they might be short-staffed, as they only had one lady working as a waitress, and servicing all of the tables. She did a fantastic job, but there's only so much that one (1) person can do. I got a slice of pepperoni pizza, mozzarella sticks, and a drink, which were pretty good, but nothing mind-blowing. I was also a little taken aback that this relatively small meal came out to about $20 after tipping my server, as it felt like a small meal, not something that was extremely filling. As for the ambiance, I did really like the artwork on the walls, in particular the large homage to the Manhattan skyline on one of them. All-in-all, Manhattan Pie was alright, but if I were to go again, I'd probably stop in, grab a slice, and go, rather than choosing the sit-down option. I will come back in the future to see if they've worked out some of the kinks, however! read more
3 months ago
Great option for by-the-slice NY style pizza in Columbia. (They also have whole pizzas and lots of other options.) It appears to be family owned and operated, and they're very friendly and customer oriented. Got two slices of pizza for a quick lunch on a Sunday and the price was great: $13.43, before tip. I like that is a very casual, laid back place. Pizza was tasty, and I liked there were so many by the slice options. I will be back! read more
3 days ago
1 month ago
My son found this place for us. Being from CA we were missing finding an authentic NY pizza shop. This place was amazing. Snall spot downtown, of course you pay for parking. Food came out fast. It was authentic and crust held up with the cheese. I have zero complaints. Service was alright, servers seemed young. Place gave like a bar kinda place. The art on the wall was nice. read more
3 months ago
Customer service is great, family friendly with Delicious menu for kids as well. Slice of the BBQ Chicken, Bacon, Pepper is Sweet savory and the crust was crispy and delicious. Nothing running, cheesy good...!!! Must have ..! Great back ground music, peaceful outing to enjoy family and friends read more
23 days ago
Manhattan pie has been on my radar for a bit and I found the perfect opportunity to have a mommy and son lunch date here. Service was great and we were able to seat ourselves, menus came out shortly after. Being it was a lunch date I let my son figure out what we should order. We started with a basket of mozzarella sticks and then did a pepperoni pizza. The pizza was perfection- thin crust with a crunch but also still soft and chewy. Amazing pizza and staff, will def be back to try more. read more
Parking is beyond crazy. It is located on a super busy street. That is the ONLY reason why I am not giving it 5 stars. Now to the food. I had the stuffed all-meat pizza. Now, when I went into the restaurant, the garlic knots were staring at me, so I ended up grabbing an order of those as well. Normally, I pride myself on eating like 2-3 slices of pizza in one sitting. I was barely able to finish one. The toppings were amazing, the gnotts were divine, and I will 100% come back here again. read more
2 months ago
We ordered the 12 inch supreme, as well as the meat lovers and they were absolutely amazing in the picture that I posted that was the aftermath of the meat lovers and it was completely eaten. The owner of the place came up to us and asked how we were enjoying our meal and asked how we learned about this place and was very kind man. The overall vibe is nice good music playing the whole time as well as good paintings on the walls to look at while you eat. read more
3 months ago
3 months ago
Pretty disappointed. Ordered the buffalo chicken pizza.... Wondering where the buffalo sauce is. It's just oily cheese with some chunks of chicken and the faintest essence of buffalo sauce on the crust..... Like the La Croix of Buffalo sauce. read more
This is a new spot in downtown Columbia that my NY born and raised coworker insisted we try for lunch. They are currently still on a soft opening so the entire menu isn't yet available, but we went for pizza and they had plenty of options on hand. My coworker was impressed with her pizza and was thrilled to see they also offered Zeppoles, which she ordered online as we sat in the restaurant and ate. This place is already very popular, as evidenced by the long line of patrons that came in during our time there. The pizza slices are definitely large and are of NY quality. Very delicious, and very meaty, were my meatlovers slices. The staff is still relatively new, so the lines move a bit slow, but it is definitely worth thae short wait. Highly recommend this spot for NY pizza lovers. read more
5 months ago
5 months ago
Heard great things about this place and have been wanting to give it a try for a while because good pizza by the slice is hard to find in Columbia. Did not disappoint and I didn't even get the slices. My husband had a calzone, which is his go-to every time we head out for pizza. It came out much faster than they usually do and he said it was one of the best he's ever had. The vibe was great, didn't feel like a dive bar like some other pizza places in town do, and the service was friendly and very attentive. We will definitely be back. read more
Manhattan Pie just opened last week and our ROMEO group of 8 have been wanting to try some NY Pizza for some time. We were here today and arrived about 11:20. They had one waitress, the owner/manager, and I think two other workers in the back. They have tables and chairs set up around the walls and have a long counter where you can sit and eat. In the rear they have a counter for taking orders. The soft drinks are coke/diet coke and canned soda. They have only sweet or unsweetened tea and do not have half-and-half tea. The menu for pizza is quite a variety and they also have some sides and pasta dishes along with salads. The eight of us ordered a whole variety of pizzas. From basic cheese, margherita, and build your own. We mostly ordered small pizzas with a couple of medium. Our waitress had a tough time getting our 8 orders straight and went around the table several times checking to make sure she had it right. It was only her second day working there and I could see how our group with all of the different types and sizes would be an issue for her. I ordered small cheese, onion, sausage and pepperoni pizza plus I asked for a medium cheese, onion, mushroom and pepperoni pizza to be made for me to take home. My wife and I were planning on having that for dinner the following night. It took a while to make the pizzas but the owner brought out the first two. We all were totally surprised at the size of the pizzas. They told us they were small (12") but they looked more like a medium to us. When the mediums came out they almost looked like a large. All eight of us were surprised at how large the pizzas looked. Our problem started when the owner brought out the first two pizzas. The Margherita pizza was basically just a cheese pizza. Apparently they didn't have any basil. Then he brought out a couple of plain cheese pizzas. One of our members had left the table and he brought out a pizza that none of us ordered and he said "I'm sure it was for the guy that went to the restroom" and left it in front of him. I had ordered a small pizza and they brought out a medium pizza...with toppings I didn't order. I could go on and on but the bottom line is there was so much confusion with who got what that half of us were waiting or trying to tell them what we'd ordered. The waitress surely had it written down when she took the order...but somewhere between her, the cook and the manager things got screwed up. One guy orderded Ziti with Garlic knots. The ziti had very little sauce and he didn't care for it....had lots of cheese. The garlic knots were excellent. The pizza was good. Several of us liked it...good cheese, crust was lightly browned and crispy enough to eat "New Your Style" like a pie. Some didn't care much for the sauce, but the cheese was good. I was hesitant to go to this restaurant because they really haven't had much time to get things running smoothly. I don't think they had any salads, or at least the anti pasta salad. Food was good, just a bad day for them on the service end (not the waitress fault), but management. I must say they did correct every thing that went wrong. They even had a medium cheese only pizza that they brought out for us that nobody ordered. Hopefully in a month or so they can get it together. We'll probably go back later on in the year and see if they've improved. Our group rating for Manhattan Pie was a 3.3. read more
2 months ago
2 months ago
9 months ago
I've been here twice. The first time, I ordered a large NY cheese pizza with a side of wings. Absolutely amazing. Today, I picked up a large white pizza, at the recommendation of the staff. It's delicious. Highly recommend this place. read more
10 months ago
The food here is truly of quality! The slices and garlic knots were delicious! In some ways you can tell that this is just the beginning of the resturant, but overall will be returning and cannot wait to see this place come together! Service was a little slow but there was only one waiter working during the entire lunchtime! We tried the garlic knots ($4.95 for 6) and they were delicious! We also tried 4 different pizzas by the slice, buffalo chicken (10/10), chicken bacon ranch (9/10), pepperoni (8/10) and chicken parm (6/10 could have used more sauce)! For someone originally from New Jersey, this is pretty comparable and i'm so excited Columbia has a New York Style pizza spot now! read more
2 months ago
The service was friendly, and the owner/manager came to see how we were doing. We had a stuffed meat pizza and New York style cheese. Both were wonderful. The sausage was flavorful, not too spicy and not ground which we like. The cheese was plentiful and it was all wonderful. The dining area was very spacious too, not crammed in like sardines. Will definitely be regular customers here. read more
7 months ago
4 months ago
6 months ago
Service and food was beyond amazing! This is the real deal. Bruschetta was insane in the best possible way. Pizza is a NY lovers pizza dream. We also had cheese raviolis in vodka sauce. First time we came here and will not be the last! read more
4 months ago
We got the Manhattan calzone and the grilled chicken hot sub. Huge portions and amazing flavor. The ingredients are fresh and you tell the difference. The crust is perfect. This will definitely be the new go to for pizza. Also the tiramisu is heavenly!!!! read more
9 months ago
The white pizza was fantastic! Great for garlic lovers. I plan to become a regular there. Pizza is available by the slice and they are large slices. Reasonably priced. Nice interior, too. read more
Ok...this place does not have legs yet since its so new. It doesn't help that the staff is not trained well either. There needs to be more management oversight for this place to work well. That said, I have to admit that while I. A pizza snob and southern pizza skeptic, this place did produce a pretty good Grandma Pie. A grandma pie is square with usually pan fried crust and although this was not quite pan fried, it was still pretty decent. Also, the pizza re-heated well the next day and was even tastier. I gave them 4 stars because it appears that they are using good ingredients and are not skimping and buying bad tomatoes and garbage mozzarella. The tomato sauce on the grandma was excellent and that only comes from using a good quality tomato. I think the place has potential and I LOVE having a decent pie take out in the Vista area. If they can iron out the kinks...we may have a winner here. There is pretty ample seating for dining in as well. I haven't tasted the regular pizzas yet but plan on doing that soon. read more
10 months ago
You feel the NYC vibes the second you walk in! Great lunch special that includes two slices of cheese pizza and a can of soda for $7.07 with tax. Looking forward to seeing this place grow! The owner was nice and welcoming. read more
8 months ago
From upstate NY been here for about a year and half and have been looking for a good pizza spot and my mother and i believe we have found it with this place! Service is amazing! And atmosphere is great very New York hole in the wall! read more
Online ordering doesn't let you remove pizza toppings . Asked for supreme pizza no green peppers and it came with both green and red peppers. Ordered meatball roll and got chicken instead. Staff was rude. Food was below average read more
4 months ago
4 months ago
4 months ago
Finally..... REAL New York style pizza in Columbia South Carolina. I tried the bacon ranch pizza and the white sauce pizza and both were absolutely incredible. This is the closest thing to authentic New York pizza I've had outside of NYC. The crust was perfectly crispy, the cheese was rich and flavorful, and every bite tasted fresh and homemade. The bacon ranch pizza was loaded with flavor, and the white sauce pizza was smooth, cheesy, and unforgettable. Hands down the best pizza I've had in all of South Carolina. Columbia struck gold with this place!!! 5/5 Also the staff was incredible and so welcoming and genuine and the atmosphere was great! read more
2 months ago
5 months ago
Page 1 of 2
More info about Manhattan Pie
Ask the Community - Manhattan Pie
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
2 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
2 months ago
1 month ago
