Absolute roller coaster of a review coming in…read more Ok my girlfriend and I walked into this place last night- decided to sit on the patio. They were out of Birra Moretti which was disappointing. Its difficult to find that beer on menus and ended up having a Peroni instead. Got the Calamari appetizer. The Calamari was perfectly fried and was absolutely delicious. HOWEVER, the dipping sauce it was served with was terrible. It tasted like a Pina Colada...so much coconut. I dont know why anyone would serve that dipping sauce with calamari. It was disgusting. But even without the dipping sauce the calamari was still really good. We then shared the Italian Pizza. Man...I've eaten a lot of pizza in my days. This may be top 5 all time. The crust was so crunchy, thin, and perfect. The sausage on top was amazing- as were all the other toppings. Its difficult to describe how perfect this pizza was. I will legitimately dream about it. It is the pizza all other pizzas strive to be. Straight up- I dont care how far you live. Just come and get a pizza- do not hesitate. But why 3 stars? For one, the service was just ok. Our waiter was very friendly but he didn't come out to ask us how the food was and after we were finished he never came out to clean the table or ask if we needed anything else. I ended up having to walk in to pay for the meal. And also, this place is way too expensive. For one beer, one appetizer, and one pizza it was $56 before tip. I'm tempted to give this 4 stars, but for a dine-in experience its only 3. But still, go try their pizza. Its insane

Ordered pizza Margherita, not a good pizza, the dough didn't raise much at the edge of the pizza,…read morethe textual of the pizza dough was hard and too dense for a fresh made dough. This could be from frozen. The ingredient says fresh mozzarella cheese, it doesn't taste like the "fresh" fresh cheese I used to have, taste more like regular shred cheese. Not sure why there are additional diced tomatoes, onion and green onion there, I like the simple version that only come with basil, San Marzano tomato sauce and mozzarella.

It was our first time here at this restaurant. Place is really nice and spacious. We asked our…read moreserver what she'd recommend and everything she said were all awesome. We ordered Penne Alla Vodka, Linguini Pescatore, Fettuccine Al Funghi and Bistecca Al Ferri... did not disappoint that we had to share just to enjoy each other's food. Quite filling as well. And you also have to try their Tiramisu! I think that's the only dessert they make in-house. Thank you for a really pleasant dinner! Grazie!!!

My family has been going here for years. The food is excellent. The service is amazing. If you are…read morelucky the chef will come out and visit your table. Nice family restaurant.

A beautiful, longstanding restaurant that has been a pillar of the Caledon community. That being…read moresaid, Terra Cotta Inn is competing with newer restaurants closing in, and some may find the menu offerings rather old fashioned or dated. It does cater mostly to an older crowd. Would do well with some updates and elevations to bring a sense of modernity to the table. The building is lovely, however, and I can appreciate the antique design that captures the old-time charm of the restaurant. Fitting for a casual lunch or a more formal dinner. Mealwise, our dishes were tasty-- including the bread that comes with the meal!

We enjoyed a very delicious dinner on Sunday by the river in Terra Cotta. A 10 out of 10 for taste…read moreand presentation. We enjoyed the Burrata salad (my favourite), Penne Rigate alla Diavola, Fettuccine con Funghi Freschi & Tiramisu for dessert. We will definitely be back with family and friends. Service was excellent: 10/10. The ambience inside the restaurant was comfortable, looks and feels like you are in Italy, very friendly and inviting. This is a popular restaurant for many food lovers; it gets very busy on the weekends so be sure to reserve a table! One of the best dinners we've had.

A cute little place where you'd least expect to find one !!!…read moreGood Italian fare and cosy, family like atmosphere. I'll go back

We tried this restaurant for the first time today. We had take-out of Spaghetti with Tomato Sauce,…read moreand Gnocchi with Rose Sauce. Both dishes were awesome! All of the pasta noodles are home-made, and so are the sauces. The elderly gentleman prepared the dishes after we ordered, and was very friendly and courteous, and treated us like family. The restaurant is very popular in the area (there were many take-out customers while we were there). Great food at very affordable prices. We'll be doing take-out from this place very frequently now. Highly recommend!

A very quaint Italian restaurant with delicious food. We enjoyed the fried calamari, Cesar salad,…read morechicken Parmesan and the seafood spaghetti. Everything was very good, and the two mains were very generous portions. The server was very attentive to us. The only downside was how many tables they had. We were sat against the bar and on one occasion one of the staff reached over our table to grab something... All in all this was a great find and we will be back! There looks to be space for outdoor seating in the summer so we'll look forward to that!

If you are looking for authentic Italian food, this is the place you want to be…read more The place is small, but it is worth coming

Great traditional Italian food. Lots of variety. Very welcoming family run. Our favorite go to in…read moreMilton!

Great Italian food that's apparently cooked up by the Italian couple who runs the spot! Super…read morefriendly and accommodating waiters too. Love the small but cozy dining room. BONUS points for having a in-house accordion player who sings old Italian classics on select weekends! I've been a couple times already and it's our go-to dine-out dinner spot in Fergus at the moment! We're tried their dinner and appetizer specials - pork always done to perfection and generous portions. On their regular menu, we had their calamari which was a bit generic and lack lustre. Their mushroom and pear pizza was ok as well. I'd honestly stick to their pastas and dinner specials!

Had a great experience here. Very nice small restaurant. We started with the Brie wedges that were…read moregreat. Then got the meat lovers pizza

I came here just for dessert. Service was quick and friendly. The portions are very generous. I'm…read moredefinitely coming back for the main course!

All I have to say is Oh My Gaaaad..... Talk about Iron Chef…read moreQuality ! We had our daughters reception there last night, the staff paid attention to Every detail. The starters just kept coming, one better than the last. By the time dinner came, I was pretty full but the main course came and it was magnificent. We ordered the lobster pasta which was cooked to perfection, the grooms father ordered the Fillet Mignon, it was as big as a Softball and he could cut it with a fork, I was wishing I ordered That but managed to eat every bit of mine. I would just like to thank LA Cucina for an absolutely perfect night. There were 25 of us and every person was made to feel like they were the only one. Sorry I have no pictures but I couldn't put my fork down. I would Highly recommend this restaurant and I will Definitely be back!

One of the best Naples-style pizzas I've ever had (reviews mentioning "burnt" crust may not have…read morehad this style before, but it's authentic and correctly done) - the flavors of the Hot n Honey were exquisite. One of the most unique bruschetta presentation I've seen - chewy focaccia with whole roasted tomatoes, artichokes and basil - delicious. Pesto pasta was good and would be a star anywhere else but compared to the pizza and bruschetta came in third. The coconut cheesecake was incredible. Tangy with the right sweet balance. Michelle was a lovely server. Highly recommend.

The board in front of the restaurant says "Biggest waterfront patio in Elora" which is correct…read more They have a 2-storey patio and also more tables in the garden area. The serving lady was very nice and helpful. I was so disappointed to hear that most of the menu items weren't available, but I was so excited to try homemade pizza and past in an Italian restaurant. We ordered "Sausage & Peppers Pasta", "Bucatini Bison Bolognese pasta", "Classic Canadian Pizza" and "Confit Garlic & Onion Pizza". Pizza dough tasted really good, but my pizza was burned and it was served with no explanations or apologies, which was a put off. Pastas tasted ok but nothing special. To be honest, I expected more of this place based on the marketing and reviews I read on Yelp.