We have always gotten great food here. Salads, cheesesteak wraps, lasagna, pizza. There are several pizza shops in the area, but this is our go to. Service is timely as well. read more

Cheesesteak and the bread they use for it is the best in the area. It has always been consistent, service is good and price is great as well. read more

Every single time I order from Mammas they tell me 30 minutes today he said 35 minutes got there and it was another 30 wait as my ice cream melted in the heat. I'm already mad get home, I ordered veal parm dinner guess what no pasta in my dinner what a disappointment. Everytime it's almost like they don't start your meal until you get there. I'm done. I will never go to Mamas again and will make sure my friends and family do not go there as well. I have given them chance after chance after chance. This was the last chance! read more

Ordered a tuna hoagie off their menu and states what came on tuna hoagie, which said lettuce top with tuna salad, tomatoes, sweet peppers, mushrooms and pickles. No sweet peppers no pickles n no mushrooms. Also ordered 6 hot wings double fried, however wings were slimy and I didn't get my ranch and celery. We also asked for salt n pepper on wings. They also charged me extra for the ranch and celery. Driver said he can bring it to us tomorrow. Called them and they hung up on us three times read more

We order subs from Mamma's almost weekly and for the most part, it's good. However, we ALWAYS order a sub with no mayonnaise, and without fail, 4 out of 5 times it has half a jar of mayonnaise soaking up the bread and slopping everywhere. I want to love this place, but they simply do not pay attention to details. I'll give them one more chance, but if they don't start reading the orders more closely, we will stop buying there. Please please no mayonnaise! We want to love your place. read more

The food here is consistently good. Pizza and subs are very good and they have a nice selection of things on the menu. The service, however is not very good. Delivery is often slow and many times the orders are wrong. Pick up is your best option and be sure to check your order. read more

II placed an order, picked it up and went to my sons house. Upon opening the pizza box, I received the wrong pizza. I called the business and the person who took my order began to argue with me. Told me to come back and he would remake it and charge me the difference. I was willing so drive back, bring the now contaminated pizza with to but do not feel I should be charged the difference. I took the pizza back and they didn't even start to make the correct pizza. He looked inside the box, folded the box back down and set it over like they where going to resell the pizza. I asked for my money back the lady rudely handed me a $20 (12-cents short. I then witnessed the person who took my order start to make food without washing his hands I advised him that he should wear gloves. He became combative. I took my partial refund and left. I only gave them a 1-star review because it would not allow me submit with a zero star review read more

Yeah, this place was somewhere I wanna wanted to go. I like experimenting new pizza places and this one was on my list. A total disappointment. My boyfriend and I walked in, looked at the menu for a few minutes. We asked for the combo #1. The staff told me that they don't make slices. Like huh? Aren't you a pizza shop. So anyways they don't make slices, we had to either order a small or medium pizza so we get a medium. Then, I ask for 2 large drinks. I get charged 1.99 per drink and she hands me a small cup. I told her I asked for a large she then tells me they only have one size. So I was charged a made up price. The staff members were not pleasant, they made me feel like they were annoyed that we came in, and how dare we ask for pizza. The taste of the pizza was. 5/10. It wasn't anything special. Bottom line, never again. read more

I've eaten here many times. Service and food has gone way down. I just spent $44.00 on crap. The chicken Alfredo was undercooked. The lasagna was burnt. I accidentally spilled my drink on the table and they gave me a dirty rag and walked away. The silverware is in a community drawer for everyone to handle. I saw a jar of Barilla pasta sauce being warmed on a pan, in the jar. I've worked in restaurants and understand shortcuts, but this whole experience was ridiculous. I'm done with this place. read more

Really gross. There was MOLD all around the edges of the meat on my Italian sub. They also said they had no oil for fries and gave us bags of chips instead, which were coated in a layer of dust. It was once a good place, but now the place is falling apart. An open bucket of bleach water was on the counter. Tiles coming off wall. Open wiring sticking out of the ceiling. Placed me on hold for about 10 minutes when I called to complain about the moldy sandwich that I picked up. They asked if I wanted them to make me a new one. I told them I wanted my money back instead. read more

Mamma's Pizza & Subs - Mold shown on edge of salami was all along edges of multiple pieces. - Pizza Near Me - Etters, Pennsylvania

Got a sub from here today and when I opened it up had a big pice of plastic rap in it I called them they didn't even apologize they said they would send a new 1 out to me and I threw that 1 in the trash with out looking at it read more

Mamma's Pizza & Subs - Sub from mommas pizza on fishing creek - Pizza Near Me - Etters, Pennsylvania

WOW!! Mamma's Pizza & Subs is our new favorite for delicious pizza at a great price!! The crust has a nice flavor & texture (New York style); even the pickiest in our group left only crumbs on their plate. The sauce was good, not overpowered by spices; a little skimpy though. There was just the right amount of cheese, not too stringy or chewy & not too little. The toppings were generous. Last, but not least, the price for an x-large 'Mamma's Special' (think everything but the kitchen sink) was $18 w/o tax!! We ordered our pizza to go, so I can't comment on the service for Dine-In. We walked in at one of their busiest times on a Friday evening and the service was prompt & friendly. The only disappointment I experienced as a first-time patron was not being able to get their menu online. Three stars for now; watch for updated reviews because we are definitely going back! read more

Mamma's Pizza & Subs - X-Large Mamma's Special: Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, mushrooms, green peppers & onion; $17.99! - Pizza Near Me - Etters, Pennsylvania

I just moved to a new house about 1.5 miles away. I order pizza 1-2 times a week as I hate to cook. I Ordered pizza at 5:15pm. Called at 6:15pm and was told driver just left. called at 6:45 pm and was told driver just left. called at 7:10 pm and was told driver just left. (Left for where? Tahiti??). Called at 7:30 and was told driver was enroute. Driver arrived 7:47pm -- that's right --- 2 hours, 30 minutes after ordering. Reading the reviews, apparently this is standard practice. Driver said the owner will only cook delivery orders if there is no other people in the store. The owner cooked all other orders that walked in AFTER I called, for over 2 hours!!! and finally when the dinner rush was over & the store had no one left, he then made & cooked my pizza. Driver said people complain all the time about the 2+ hour wait time but the pizza is good, so people just keep buying. Obviously, my pizza was cold. Good, but cold and 2.5 hours is way too long to wait. Should have read all the Yelp reviews first and gone elsewhere . Can't imagine how much $$$ this owner loses every year by poor time management & processing issues & poor reviews. Guess he thinks there's no other options , but surprise! other pizza places deliver too! (and with a $5 tip to the driver, I now have a nice little list of places with faster delivery). read more

The pizza is average. The "personal" size is big enough to share if you aren't starving and don't want leftovers. Would be three stars, but I took one off for having the heat too high and the TV on at a pretty high volume playing some obnoxious sitcom. read more

We order from Mamma's on a regular basis. The food is great, service is fast and friendly. Sometimes they get super busy, and slow, but I see that as a good sign. read more

First of all; the other review that gave a one star was being irresponsible. There is no possible way a reasonable person can leave a one star unless this was an entirely different establishment a year ago.....and maybe it was for all I know. But this place was not dirty in any way. In fact, I had just noted how clean the restroom was before I read that review while waiting for our food to be cooked. The food exceeded our expectations. The pizza was above average and so were the wings. The chicken parm sub was superior. They had some original items such as the "Hawaiian cheeseburger". The staff was very pleasant. The decor was retro feeling (which we like very much). It is not fancy and it's not some corporation. It's local and divey (and to me "divey" is a compliment). If you want a brand new restaurant with no personality, that's not this place. This is simple and old fashioned and local. The prices were normal and perhaps a little lower than I am used to. It was definitely clean to my standards. It doesn't look like much from the outside and is very easy to overlook. I'm glad that didn't stop us from going in. I find it sad that someone left the absolute lowest rating one can leave just because they may or may not have seen one dead bug under a table, and then SPECULATED, with no tangible information, that the kitchen was probably dirty. My son and I very nearly didn't come here simply because the only review was a one star. But we were in a silly mood and I said "do you want pizza or GOOD pizza" and he replied "whatever is closest". This was simply the closest place to us at the time. But we VERY much enjoyed our visit and even though it's not local for us, we will come back if we can. It is a shame that someone didn't think it through as to the damage they could do to someone's reputation by giving the lowest star rating they could, based on shaking information. They even agreed that the food was at least "OK" in their opinion. By their description it sounded more like a 3-star review. My son and I are two people that are giving it 5-stars. --Food: 5-star --Staff: 5-star (the one lady from the kitchen came out to our table and asked about one specific item, the Hawaiian cheeseburger (maybe because she personally made it and had pride?)....even though she didn't speak great English. How often does that happen at a small local pizza shop?) --Cleanliness: 5-star --Prices: 5-star --The outside appearance: 2-star....but how important is that anyway? read more

Horrible customer service,they never want to accept any accountability when screwing up orders.

We originally ordered from Mamma's pizza because they're the only place that would deliver, but it's quickly becoming my favorite pizza joint! They don't always answer on the first call and sometimes the delivery takes a bit longer than expected( I just assume they're busy). The Food is worth the wait! There Chicken Ranch pizza is absolutely AMAZING they definitely don't skimp on toppings loads of chicken and bacon in every bite!!!! read more

We called and placed an order for delivery a hour and a half passed still no delivery we call and they hadn't even cooked the food the man said no ticket printed when we placed the order they asked for a phone number someone couldn't call back? Very poor customer service! read more

We ordered delivery from here tonight, they told us 45 minutes, we called them when it was 15 minutes late and they said that the driver left 5 minutes ago and should be there any minute, 15 minutes later he finally showed up, our subs were like warm, our fries we soggy, never again will I order delivery from them! read more

This place has really good food I'd give five stars if the waitress hadn't dropped most of our fries and only gave us what was left in the plates or if they didn't take 30 minutes to make anything u can order from the menu. read more

Food was great, quick delivery however, make sure you have exact change for the delivery guy because he doesn't carry change, also remember the tip read more

Best pizza around! Treat us like family and I'm never disappointed in the pizzas, subs etc and the staff members are absolutely amazing! Ever since we tried this pizza many many years ago, we won't go anywhere else! read more

Prices aren't bad. The food is pretty much all "decent". They tend to slightly burn the crust on the bottom of the pizza. Makes it really tough to chew. We go there in a pinch sometimes, but there's better places for pizza/wings/subs in the area. read more

The last time I ordered for pick up they forgot to put it in. When I got there they apologized and told me they would put it in right away. I waited and 15 minutes later after watching multiple people walk in and out with pizza's I again went to the register. Believe it or not , they did not put my order in again. I asked for my money back which they did. Terrible service at this place. read more

The cheeseburger subs are the best I've ever tasted. Don't forget the banana peppers!

I went here on my break one day. There were 3 people cleaning behind the register and I had to wait a full 2 minutes before one of them acknowledged that I was there. I didn't have allot of time so I asked for one slice of cold pizza. The guy who took the order clearly did not speak good English. I watched him open the oven door, then TAKE A GROSS STAINED RAG off the ground and wipe down the inside of the oven. Then without washing his hands he touched the slice I had ordered and put it in the oven. I told him I wasn't going to eat that and he said. "oh, no, is okay, I wash" and then pointed to the back room where I assume the sink was. I just left without pizza and without paying. read more

Pizza ok. Delivery is very slow/late. Usually more than an hour so don't call for it if you are hungry. I was told 45 mins, called back after an hour, was told on the way. Then 20 mins later called back and they said it was in the way. 1 hour and 25 mins later one pizza came from less than a mile away. I know I should have just walked to get it myself. read more

A couple of weeks ago we ordered 2 large pizzas and a dozen wings. Was told would be delivered in 45 minutes. An hour and a half later, I called, was told that he had left half an hour ago he should be there any minute. 30 minutes later the food showed up (so it took 2 hours to be delivered). The pizza was the most awful pizza we have ever had, it literally tasted like we were biting into a mouthful of salt. Called to complain.....was told the owner was not in and gave my number for him to call. She also said i was the 4th person to complain about the pizza that day, they had tried a new supplier. The next day, no call, I called and told he was not in and again gave my name and number. Following day still no call, called again, and was told he was not in. I am not a complainer by any means, but this was extreme. We paid $35 (including tip) for two pizzas and wings that was delivered an hour and 15 minutes late and was so awful even the dog wouldn't eat it. Then the "owner" couldn't even return my call. I PROMISE I will NEVER be ordering from this establishment again!!!! read more