The TLDR of this somewhat lengthy review: Great experience until the contract is signed, then it started to go decline. Mack & Sons have not stood behind quality finish-work, nor followed up on correction commitments. By all accounts they simply don't seem to care, will say what you want to hear to your face then vanish. A lot of talk with little-to-no follow through. I would not recommend this company to anyone - smaller or larger projects.
This review is a long-time coming but is based purely on our experience. The quote process was quick and easy, contract sent through no issues. Communication was great and we were excited for the project! Unfortunately, once the contract was signed the proactive communication was gone and I prompted updates on delays or the overall project from thereon out. Between weather, concrete shortages and contractor vacations we encountered delays so the whole project did take longer than expected.
A larger job - we had 4 pads and 100ft+ of pathways poured. We provided the design, to scale, with conduit placement needs for our future landscaping. The contract was for the prep, pour, finish, sealing and cleanup. Originally, we'd requested stamped finish, it was recommended we stamp the pads only to break it up and broom finish the pathways, we went with their recommendation - they're the professionals after all. (We knew nothing about the process, as we'd advised) Fast forward to completion, we paid the final payment as soon as work was completed. I will note that both payments we made were in cash and a hand-written receipt written on the back of scrap paper.
Since completion of the job, we had a couple of issues resolved, but Mack & Sons failed to execute the many of the corrections they'd committed to - despite follow-ups. Some of the issues we had at completion included visible filler on the side of pad pours, chunks out of the concrete when forms were removed, no finish-work of the pathway edging, no sealant on pathways, some conduits were not put in as requested - which cost us more money with the landscaper - concrete splatters on the side of our house and decking, a milky finish on pathways cracks on most pads, etc. The final, but biggest issue that came up prior to the end of the warranty period was the pitting of all pathways. As soon as we saw this, we contacted them, they came over and said they'd make it right. I followed up after hearing nothing to be told it was the weather that caused it. No response was received after this, and the work agreed upon and committed to from the original pour has still not been completed. We've since been advised by more than one professional the pitting/erosion would have been avoided if they'd have sealed as contractually agreed upon.
Mack & Sons is a licensed and bonded business; however, I believe their bond is only $6k. If my understanding is correct, it costs $3k to file with the appropriate court system to claim - so bare this in mind. Our issues exceed the total bond, so we are pursuing small claims court which goes up to $10k. I sent a letter of intent per contractual obligation, which was met with a response from their attorney suggesting the blame be ours and we were out of warranty - which was not the case on either front. A few back-and-forth emails with their legal representative proved we were clearly at an impasse - the only attempt to resolve without court interference was a "gracious" offer of a reduced fee to correct - over $7k. We declined this instantly as we do not believe we should be paying for corrections they should be accountable for - both legally and morally. We've not yelled, gotten emotional or had any unrealistic expectations at any point of the process, requested no "extras" or "discount", all we have ever sought is the quality finished product expected.
It's around the two-year mark from when we got the first bid from Mack & Sons. We wanted this to have a happy ending, but I guess that is not to be! A final point to note - They claim to support veterans, it made no difference in our household whatsoever.
NB: Pics to follow read more