Always our go to spot for donuts. We have enjoyed them…read moresince we were little kids. Our favorite is the Maple cream filled. But honestly, they are all delicious!!

Delicious, they are the only to eat in New Castle. The glazed twists bring me back to the 1970sread more

Bills Bake Shoppe is owned by Bill Cast. He has been baking since he was 8 years old in his…read morefather's bakery, he is now in his 70's. If you want Authentic Italian Pastries look no further. Come to Mahoningtown... It's worth the trip! Tell Bill Kenny sent you.

This is where we stop every time we drive in from Pittsburgh to visit old friends. I have long gone…read morerelatives from this area and grew up in New Castle. You won't find many bakeries left like this. I've never had anything bad from here!!! We're on way next week! love talking to whomever is working. Great service!

They catered for my family lunch one Sunday and the food was phenomenal!!!!! new, tasty, and create…read moreservice

4.5 stars. Mainstreet Bake Shop sells baked goods such as pies, cookies, breads, cheesecake, cakes,…read moreturnovers, danishes, scones, brownies, fruit bars, dolce cakes, cupcakes, donuts, pop-tarts, etcetera. It also sells other foods such as breakfast sandwiches, coffees, and dog cookies. My husband and I shopped in this bakery one time. An employee immediately and kindly greeted us. It was a late morning on a Saturday, and the display cases were mostly stocked with baked goods. Unfortunately, the display cases had no signs to indicate what the baked goods were, so I felt unsure of what some of them were. I recommend that the bakery add signs with the names of the baked goods. I chose a cookie (5 stars) and a bear claw (4.5 stars). The total price was a few dollars including a tip. I have no idea what exact flavors they were! Perhaps I should have asked the employee. But they tasted great! If you want to eat here, some indoor tables and chairs were available.

I am fucking speechless. It's rare we go to a spot and there's nothing we wouldn't recommend…read more ESPECIALLY a bakery. We had almost every item in there and not a single fucking thing missed. Not even missed, it was all elite Inside is adorable. It's exactly what you would expect inside a local town bakery. It's cottagey if you will. The owner Megan is one of the greatest humans I have ever met and has something special in that bakery Manager J also a super nice dude and if you bring your dog he'll give it The breakfast sandwiches. Their homemade pretzels bread is out of this world. Exterior texture doesn't need a pull like pretzel, has the taste of one of the best orals ever and soft in the middle. The meat is also from the local butcher. No store no bought shit. Call ahead for these. They sell out FAST The donuts were all amazing. When you have aesthetic, crazy ones like this they tend to lose a flavor profile and just become overbearingly sweet. None of that happened here. We had the creme brulee, cookie dough, peanut butter cup and maple bacon. I hate maple bacon, that one was the best I've ever had and HOT HONEY on top. Brilliant The street tarts. I have been talking to Megan for about 2 months with these and she has made endless flavors. We had the brookie, carrot cake and biscoff cookie. She's made cosmic brownie, s'mores, cherry cheesecake, blueberry, apple pie etc. Just go and get whatever they have. It's going to rock your world Pumpkin cinnamon roll, insane. Not overpowering pumpkin, super moist middle and not hiding a shitty roll with an unnecessary amount of icing Just the chocolate cookies are even amazing. I don't even like them like that but would destroy a box of these If had to pick a favo it was the last thing I'd guess. The pretzel maple rod. I bit into it and was baffled. Never would I imagine that tasting the way it did. The perfect consistency of pretzel, just enough flavor to know it was that and not overbearing sweet maple I drove 40 min for this and would every single day. Put this at the top of your list now

Such a cute shop! They have games to play while enjoying ice cream with friends or family. Artwork…read morefrom the local elementary school is on the walls and the staff is very friendly. When you think small town, you think of places like this!

Really cute little shop with really good ice cream and friendly staff! Certainly one of the best…read moreoptions around the area!

Not from the area, but I stopped in and had the best chocolate raisins I've ever had. Excellent…read moreselection and prices, will definitely be back.

I was in there area and had dropped my car off for checkup and decided to walk around the local…read morestores. Grandma Ann's Nutbread was close and decided to check them out. the nut bread seemed ok looking and i sore some almond biscotti. I asked the woman behind the counter about the product and she said basically she knew nothing about them and that they did not make them they just sell them. HUH???????? I cannot believe this place makes all there own nut bread but they sell something that they do not make. And to make it worse they sell something there people no nothing about. You can be sure I will not go back again.

The best that I have ever had. So filling. And price was…read morereasonable. A lot of different fillings. Nut and apricot are my favorites.

Kimmel's is a hidden gem. Known for decades for their amazing donuts, they also offer many other…read morebaked items. Located on a side street in a residential area of a small town, they are worth searching for. Ordered a birthday cake for the first time yesterday. Man, was that a mistake. I am now incredibly upset that I missed out on decades of the best cake ever! Ordering was easy with a quick phone call. Not sure what I wanted so the gentleman made several suggestions that helped greatly. The cake was a fluffy, moist white cake with a silky buttercream of the right sweetness. Not cloying at all like some buttercreams. Decorations were beautifully piped. Had a little family tiff over who got the flowers. We all wanted them because the icing was so good. It was a huge hit! Might have been my first cake from them but will not be my last. Also got a dozen donuts for the party which we devoured quickly. The owners are absolute sweethearts. We had a nice chat about being business owners in a small town. Kind of people you just want to have a cup of coffee with while enjoying one of the their filled long John donuts (I recommend the custard filled with maple icing).

Awesome donuts this place has been here for long time and they are great!! It is a small venue but…read morebig enough to service good demand