Luigi's in Little Silver is a hidden gem. The square pie is good, but nothing hits like their round pie. We normally get a sausage and pepper pizza and a chicken parm sub to split which give the two of us a few extra meals. When we dined-in we would order the chicken parm entree and the portions were ridiculously big and delicious. Covid is the worst, but Luigi's delivers... not just good food, but the comfort we need during a time like this. You can also find comfort in the fact they adhere to covid protocols during in-store pickup. read more

If you're a Trump fan, you won't be welcomed. This review is solely based on the way the blonde female in her early 50's staff member reacted to a customer who was wearing a Trump related T-Shirt. The T-shirt was being worn by a retired gentleman, and it read: "Make Retirement Great Again". Offensive? She wanted to know what the name was on his order, then made an unnecessary comment. I don't care who anyone votes for, but businesses need to be careful when expressing their political opinions. They risk losing a portion of their business. read more

One of the best pizza places around now they're offering specials two slices with a soda for $5.99... My favorite is their big square pie. I usually get that to go home. I've also noticed that they opened their beautiful dining room again for dining and you can bring your own bottles in! read more

Luigi's Famous Pizza - The 599 special - Pizza Near Me - Little Silver, New Jersey

See all

Great customer service. Quick seating or dining in is available. Only had a plain slice but it was packed with the so much flavor and cooked to perfection. read more

Luigi's Famous Pizza - Plain slice - Pizza Near Me - Little Silver, New Jersey

I ordered a pizza for delivery and it was missing pepperoni, called and the owner instead of saying offering an apology he started arguing me saying he cut the pie and it had pepperoni. They just loss a customer read more

Luigi's Famous Pizza - Receipt - Pizza Near Me - Little Silver, New Jersey

See all

Ordered 2 eggplant parm dinners with delivery and they gave us 2 chicken parms instead. Tis place has slowly gotten worse over time, and this was the last time I'll ever order from here. read more

Luigi's is a great stop! The restaurant is a-little dated but the staff is very friendly. My favorite thing at Luigi's is their square pizza, it's very good, if you like your pizza crispy, make sure to tell them that. Ask for it well done! Definitely has a differant taste then the regular round pizzas! I've had several differant items off their menu and I have to say they are pretty consistent! If you like square pizza give it try, you won't be disappointed! read more

Luigi's Famous Pizza - Mussels Marinara - Pizza Near Me - Little Silver, New Jersey

See all

Ansolutly known for the "square" thin rolled crust thats actually a rectangle. Smaller sizes are square read more

See all

the food is top tier and the d was very fast! the delivery drivers are very nice and welcoming.

Have been going to Luigi's for over 15 years and never had a bad meal. Went this Saturday with family (total of 8 people). The place was packed and Patti the server was fantastic. The calamari and chicken caesar salad were great starters. We followed with an extra large pizza with half meatballs and a small Sicilian pie. Both outstanding! The atmosphere gave a family vibe and you can see that by the number of parties of 8 or more. On a side note, Luigi's has been our go to for catering in the area. read more

I grew up eating Luigi's and it was my go to spot. It used to so good but quality has fallen off. The pizza was soggy and way too floppy. It was literally falling apart. They don't seem to care anymore or changed management. read more

Great! Delivery was faster than promised. Wish the crust were a bit thinner, but I ordered a medium and I think you need an extra large for a thin crust pie. Still crunchy and big enough to save the other half for tomorrow. Will definitely order again soon. read more

Luigi's Famous Pizza - Medium, with three toppings. - Pizza Near Me - Little Silver, New Jersey

Best effing pizza around! I live in eatontown but will make the drive to little silver solely on their amazing crust! If you want a good slice or one of their amazing huge square pies go try them out!!! read more

Very good pizza. Delivery was made on time and with care. All food was very hot and fresh. Among the best pizza around these parts. Other items from the menu were just ok. read more

Luigi's Famous Pizza - X-large sausage and pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Little Silver, New Jersey

I wasn't upset that they had no servers to serve us dinner, I wasn't upset that I had to go to the counter to place our order along with our guests. But the quality of all of the dinner was terrible. Cavatelli was undercooked and over power with garlic. Chicken saltimbucca was tough, veal marsala did not look like marsala and both were swimming in broth. Eggplant parm was too much breading. I am so upset that I invite guest to go out and have a terrible meal. Should have gone with the pasta. Not sure what happened to the food prep and recipes but I think I will be scratching them off the list. Such a disappointment and embarrassment to me. read more

I ordered a pie and calzone. The food was good! I have been there before. I asked about the website prices which are about 20% below the actual. I mentioned this to the counter person. He lacked any level of customer service. I suggest to management that they train staff in how to speak to customers. Here is the site with the wrong prices: https://www.luigislittlesilver.com/pizza-calzones/1791567 The counter person response: " Do you want to fix this for us? " " It is very hard to update a website" He was combative, defensive, and rude. I was simply doing a courtesy and letting them know of the issue. read more

Great authentic pizza! Love the square pie. The eggplant sub was unreal! The place is quaint and simple but the food rocks. The vodka sauce here was so flavorful. I will def be back every time I am in town. read more

See all

what a joke this place is .... we ordered Margarita pizza and this was a Margarita pizza of its first kind, terrible. After calling them received no solution to a complaint just a hang up . So , i wouldn't order from this place if they paid me to do so ! read more

Cardboard pizza over priced it was burnt with no flavor l wish I took a pic that everybody would agree!

Haven't eaten here in a while. It used to be a regular for my family. So disappointing now. I don't know if there are new owners or if they changed the recipes but the pizzas were oily, burnt, and flavorless. My kids said it reminded them of what is served at school. So sad to see them change for the worse. Hopefully they will improve. read more

I used to get my pizzas here all the time the last two times we got it that was not the same.. must be new owners or they're using different ingredients. We were very disappointed.. no more for us!! read more

Consistently good food tucked away in a strip mall. I've sat down and had dinner and ordered take out as well. A friend even had a catered engagement party here, which was actually quite a good time. First things first is the food is good. Solid Italian good think pizza, cold & hot subs, and pasta plates. I generally get the chicken Parm sub or onion rings. Never been disappointed. 11 bucks gets you a whole sub and fountain soda, they are a Pepsi account if that matters to you. Staff is friendly and gracious, great for a low key meal or a longer hangout with friends. They are BYOB so it can be a cheap Italian meal. read more

It's a good pizza place, I am emotionally inclined to say it was the best place ever because of whom I was with but that would not be fair to Yelp community. Drink cups are out in open for public to touch... points off from me. Seasonings available with hand prints. Tables were greasy with crumbs. Floor is sticky in spots. Service was so/so. I was asked (twice) if I needed help on my way to the bathroom, as they stood in front of me blocking the walkway....a little intimidating. Pizza was served on the cold side. Also was charged for tap water (most places don't). "Marinara" sauce was good but more like tomato sauce for a pasta than true marinara sauce (This is my goto pizza request, I've had in so many places now). To leave off on a good note... the size of my slice was huge! The taste of it was delicious, stuffed with spinach, broccoli, eggplant, onion, maybe mushroom? And topped with cheese. Yes I would come back! read more

Luigi's Famous Pizza - The second half of my slice of stuffed veggie pizza. It was served cold/barely warm. At home I reheated it and it was delicious. - Pizza Near Me - Little Silver, New Jersey

We used to really like this place. Prices went up, quality is way down. Never againl read more

Luigi's Famous Pizza - We used to really like this place. Prices went up, quality is way down. Never againl This is a meatball sub. - Pizza Near Me - Little Silver, New Jersey

The best out there for your cravings. They got you everything. Wings, pizza, tenders, parmigiana, subs, wraps, salads. Get it delivered, take out, or eat there. And everything made fresh and hygienic always. I have been eating at Luigis for 8 years now, and it's like a fam for me. read more

There is no social distancing Have to pay at counter and go in to get your food with 8 other people inside small waiting area Door closed so everyone has to touch it coming and going Left did not pickup order based on poor operation during this time read more

I don't know why they put the pizza in a paper bag instead of an entire box. Maybe so you can rip it open like a birthday present. This is by far the most excellent pizza in the area. I've been eating it for over 15 years and it is the exact same classic Jersey pizza every time I order it. BRAVO! read more

Stuffed pizza? On the East Coast? That's usually a Chicago thing....but sure enough Luigi's does an interesting East Coast take on it. It's a fairly thin crust with toppings on the bottom under the cheese. We went with a Stuffed Combo Pizza, which is pepperoni, sausage, ricotta, onions, mozzarella, and romano cheese. Broccoli was supposed to come on it, but come on....broccoli on a pizza? I think not...Pass. We got a side of excellent red sauce to dip the pizza in, which was great, because I'm not sure there is tomato sauce actually on the pizza. If so, it was very little. With pepperoni and sausage, there is enough tasty oil coming from those meats, so wasn't dry without any sauce. I liked how each ingredient was thinly sliced so the pizza didn't get thicker than an inch. Thus it still is in the thin crust family and not deep dish. 5 stars https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/luigis-famous-pizza-little-silver-2?select=HP3WCaU4Tl5abOYclIUasA We also ordered a basic pizza half pepperoni and half sausage. Here the sausage was crumbled rather than sliced, but still was pretty tasty. They really have good pizza sauce here, and the mozzarella was golden brown. The crust for both of these pizzas are made with top notch dough. I'm sure you Jersey people take it for granted, but come out to Southern California and order some pizza, you'll be shocked for what passes as pizza dough out here. 4 stars https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/luigis-famous-pizza-little-silver-2?select=DYLHdSYWKzYLINEjTyNlZQ So my brother, having been here before, quickly ushers me off to the side to sit down at a table to order, hiding how they make their pizza. As we leave, he shows me the open kitchen. Expecting to see the traditional Steel Pizza Deck oven, I'm shocked. They are spitting these tasty pies out with a Conveyor belt pizza oven. The kind you would see at most fast food chains. If I had seen that on the way in, I might have left, assuming I wouldn't get a good pizza here. But once again this proves, it's always about the ingredients. Plenty of hot fresh bread was brought to the table while we waited. They don't mess around here with the quantity of bread, that's for sure. I'm guessing that sub sandwiches would be good here. We also did get to sample a very good Shrimp Scampi with a nice garlic sauce to dip the bread in. 4 stars. https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/luigis-famous-pizza-little-silver-2?select=s8HsCDeEVK75r-8rodaDOQ I'm going to round my 4.5 star review up to 5, just because the current 3.5 is too low. Luigi's is pretty darn good and very reasonably priced as well. read more

See all

I had the buffalo chicken pizza here. I was excited when they had specialty pizzas available. Most pizza places in the area have plain, pepperoni, and usually two other choices. However, that excitement was turned quickly into disappointment when I took my first bite. It was a pizza that's been sitting out for a while and it broke apart when I got about half way through. With only about 9 tables to sit and combined with a Boar's Head (really, a chain + another chain?), it suffers a serious case of an identity crisis. read more

Luigi's is my "go to" pizza joint in the Red Bank area. We order their take out on a regular basis. We usually will order their extra large pie -- which is a large rectangle with a thin-ner crust. They have a lot of options for toppings. We prefer a sausage peppers and onions, pepperoni, or meatball. If I have to complain, I'd say that since this pizza is so large, grease can pool up towards the center. After time, you may end up with some soggy square slices. Nonetheless, just grab a paper towel and mop it up if it bothers you that much! In addition to the pizza, we order hot and cold subs and the cold antepast. They make a real nice antepast filled with all sorts of quality ingredients. It is one of my favorites. I get their chicken parm and veal parm subs. They are pretty good, but not my favorites -- but still go to orders. My wife likes their peppers and eggs sub. We pick up and have it delivered. Their delivery service is very reliable -- but I believe they do charge a small delivery charge. Their Little Silver location has a small informal dining area, and an adjoining room. The second room can handle a small casual party or getogether. The smaller dining area is your basic pizzeria, with a few tables across from the counter. While I only gave Luigi's a 4 star rating, this has more to do with me being extremely picky with my 5's and less to do with Luigi's as an establishment! GO HERE! NOW! read more

Terrible pizza last night. Usually huge fan of their XL square pizza so ordered for delivery for first time in long time. Very disappointing pizza - the canned mushrooms they threw on there were gross, the green peppers on the sausage & peppers side were barely cooked, and the whole pizza was undercooked. Hopefully this was just an off night. We'll give Luigis one more chance before permanently crossing them off the list. read more

We usually order from guidos but I only like their Roni pie so we yelped and found luigis ! We got a whole chicken parm and a large half chicken vodka half four cheese and everything was delicious! We called an hour before they closed and asked for delivery..very nice very fast and very delicious!!!! We will be ordering again. Ordered again and got buffalo chicken pie , so spicey so good! Get ranch on the Side ...tortellini alfredo was good , meatball parm good as well! read more

Luigi's Famous Pizza - Buffalo chicken - Pizza Near Me - Little Silver, New Jersey

I call in large orders on a regular basis from Luigi's for our employees for team events. The pizza is excellent! A team favorite. Everyone always asks where the food is from as it's so delicious. It comes piping hot and always on time. I have ordered from the catering menu almost all the entrees and they are fantastic. The customer service I receive when I call is outstanding. Luigi's is my go to! read more

Very good square pies, fresh ingredients and cooked to near perfect. I prefer a bit more charring - like the old wood fired ovens but they're hard to find. We phoned in the order and it was right on time for the pick up. We're visiting from NC, but my mother-in-law here in Fair Haven along with her neighbors all say it's the best pizza in the area now. Got to go with the locals, I agree. Been coming up here since the 70s and it seems the old family pizza places have all sold out? read more

Came here twice while in the area. Had 3 peperroni slices and then a buffalo chicken and a plain. By far best pizza ive had in a long time. Crispy crust peperroni was crispy. Chicken was fresh. People i was with had chicken salads which looked great. Too bad its an hour away. I will go back one day read more

I wish I could give this place zero stars. I always feel sick after eating here and you could fill a whole cup with grease by lifting just one slice of pizza vertically. I have found hair and bugs in my food yet they've never done anything for me about it. I don't recommend this place to anybody they need to be shut down. Not to mention the workers there are all rude besides a very choice few. And the manager/owner whoever he is, is not only rude but very inappropriate. He made my friend feel very verbally violated after one specific visit. read more

They don't care about customers at all. Horrible service in the dining room when it was basically empty. I've gone several times where we've had to ask for our salads since it takes forever. The owners blamed it on having too many pizza delivery orders - not an excuse! The food was not good and they didn't seem to care. read more

Pizza used to be so good, but lately...meh. Last couple orders were rush jobs. It's like they don't care about the quality of their pizza anymore. It's a shame, used to be great read more

Came in for the first time this past Saturday. I was very disappointed. The food was good but the service in the dining room was shoddy. Our server a younger man with a beard was walking around with his phone blaring a sports event. He was very touchy feely with the girl who was working that night clearing tables. We waited a while for our appetizer (about 20 minutes) which was fried calamari, and it was delicious. The only one who seemed like they were intent on doing their job that night was the heavy set gentleman who introduced himself to us as the manager when he came to check on tables. He gave us ten percent off our bill and invited us back even promised to take care of us personally. Now that's service! But me and my wife are it sure we will be back as of now. read more

Our first time here . But definitely not our last . The food was outrageously good my wife had the baked ziti and loved it .I had the pasta Eduardo and it was so good lots of flavor and they don't skimp on the meat read more

Luigi's Famous Pizza - Stuffed combo pizza yum - Pizza Near Me - Little Silver, New Jersey