The best Italian food I've had outside Italy, and better than some I've had in it. I asked "what are your favorites?", and got answered "it's not on the menu if it's not a favorite". I absolutely believe it! Ended up with heirloom tomatoes with mozzarella, Radiatori Pork pasta, and a salami and bacon pizza. Even the wine, incredible. read more

After living in Sydney close to 5 years, i think i have finally found my favourite pizza joint! Personally i dont like thin crust pizzas because they tend to be soggy if there is too much ingredients on the dough or if you dont eat it quick enough. But love surpreme pizzas prove me wrong ! love the crunchy thin crust with heaps of fresh ingredients .... just so good ! i love the pablo pizza as the ppork sausage is so good, packed with herbs and deliciousness ! cant wait to be back to try the others ! read more

See all

Great spot and one of few places open late to eat in Paddington! We came here a few times during our stay and loved the pizza and pasta! I wasn't a fan of the cabbage salad...maybe it was the american me that wasn't expecting a wet soft cabbage salad. But the lamb ragu is soooo good. The pizzas are all so yummy as well. Friendly staff and cute place. read more

I'm shocked by the negative reviews. This is my favourite pizza joint in Sydney, it never, ever disappoints. I was recently there with mates from NYC. They loved it. So did I. Please go read more

Love Supreme - Pizza Near Me - Paddington, NSW

It's time to fall in love with Love Supreme. Don't even try to fight it. This Oxford Street staple might be nestled amongst the La Di Dah boutiques, but this restaurant is definitely one-sized-fits-all deliciousness. The pizzas hail from organic and biodynamic origins, and they're ridiculously tasty. Names like Lola, Pele and Smiley are sure to get you, well, smiling, but if you're feeling game, go for the Surprise. The waiter will ask a couple of questions to gauge your tastes, then you can wait and see what the chefs concoct! If you're catching a movie at the Chauvel or Verona, you should definitely stroll over to Love Supreme for a pre or post-cinema snack. Don't could on strolling in without a reservation though - there are lot of Sydneysiders already head over heels for these pizzas. read more

Love Supreme - Pizza Near Me - Paddington, NSW

There is certain type of dining that is not very costly, yet is an indelibly priceless, experience. Love Supreme, is that type of experience, one that leaves your spirits elevated by the warmth of its owners, the delectably fresh, endlessly aromatic offerings & the euphoric atmosphere! From its clean tastes, it's crispy fine crusted pizza, it's light & airy gnocchi's to its homey ragu, this restaurant, is reminiscent of glorious summer's spent in the Balkans. It is a place that rings with laughter and where children are celebrated. To top off a perfect meal, the freshly made chocolate gelato and side order of oven toasted hazelnuts, left me swooning. This, is fast becoming a consistently good haunt of mine, when in Sydney, a place for family & friends to feel at home. read more

Love Supreme - Pizza Near Me - Paddington, NSW

See all

omfg. THIS is why I yelp!!! Can you believe I was about to scarf a pie at Pieface and suddenly thought, hmmm I wonder what yelp would have to say about that? So I searched pizza in my area and now I want to have Love Supreme's babies. I don't even care that the beer in my beer-pizza happy hour deal ($19.90) was babycinno sized... Gorgonzola and super-finely sliced spuds on a crispy, bubbly base with flat parsley to top it off? Back off, it's all mine. read more

The worst! We booked a table and arrived at the time of the booking, no one approached us and we were waiting almost half an hour to be seated. The staff were SO rude. When we were approached it was as if we were a massive inconvenience. I understand they were busy but there was no need to be rude and also forgot we even existed. Also it's not BYO if you book but if you walk in its fine.... Makes zero sense to me. The pizza was soggy and we waited so long for it to arrive. The ragu wasn't anything special at all. Safe to say I won't be returning. read more

Delicious pizza. The lamb ragu was amazing too. Beautiful vibe in the place, great place for a special, romantic dinner. My partner and I ordered a glass of wine each and one glass had 'love' written across it and the other had 'supreme'. A lovely touch. read more

Love Supreme - Perfect place for a 2 year anniversary dinner! - Pizza Near Me - Paddington, NSW

Pizza here is great. 4 pizza for 7 people. Love the mushroom one. Many special kind of pizza here . don't really like the chairs here. read more

Love Supreme - Mushroom pizza is finished by half in 1 min - Pizza Near Me - Paddington, NSW

Strolled past Love Supreme Monday evening and could not help but poke my head in to see what was going on beyond the giant stack of pizza boxes and the underwhelming shop front. Curiosity may have killed the cat but on a good day it will leave you pleasantly surprised. On entry we were warmly greeted y the chef and the wait staff, the dimly lit room is quite romantic on a Monday, I imagine the feel would be quite different on a weekend. We shared fig with goats cheese; served on a bed of rocket, the spring bay mussels in tomato sauce (delicious) and the salami, red capsicum and jalapeno pizza called 'yes we can'. Was very tempted to try the 'Surprise ????' pizza but my company wasn't game. With any luck it will be my order next time. read more

No stars. One star because i have to. This place is ordinary and pretentious. Only $5 organic soft drinks that taste rank are available. They forgot about our order, no apology when it did arrive after my asking twice and then the pizza was luke warm. Only came here because Arthur's was closed. We will not be back read more

Excellent Italian cuisine (although my neighbors whispered the owners are Croatian). I had a cotechina sausage (never heard of, but made inhouse and quite good) in green lentils with spinach stew, followed by one of the best pannacotta's I ever had: pannacotta seems easy but to get it really right takes the hand of a master (and a lot of time: it took a while to come): it was surrounded by a sort of caramelized crumble which was superb. Even the housewine was worth the visit. The owner - or who is this hand clapping madman who wishes everyone a good week - certainly helps the atmosphere, as did the music from Marisa Monte and European jazz. I will go back. Interesting brownish interior and a lot of organic ingredients. read more

From a very inconspicuous shop front we had quite a surprisingly good meal. The pizza was right up there. I wished I'd ordered a large one.. Get in early for the pizza & beer special. read more

When Love Supreme on Oxford Street first opened it didn't have any signage out the front and I became a bit obsessed at what this place was, why it always had people in it and what was the point of having a lot of empty boxes that looked like pizza boxes out the front! Well I finally made the journey in for a bite and that first time certainly wasn't the last. It's a great place with more than just pizza. I love the entrees/antipasti like the arancini balls, zucchini flowers and artichokes and the list of pasta, risotto and pizza's I like or want to try is too long to mention. In fact it's pretty much the whole menu and I've never had the room to sample the dessert yet. What ever you do decide to eat, I assume there is always room for a beer or glass of wine although if that's not enough, grab a cocktail! I love the dimly lit atmosphere and feel of this place although if you can't make it for whatever reason they do delivery and take-away so there really is no excuse not to try it. And there is a sign out the front so you can't miss it! read more

Love Supreme - Pizza Near Me - Paddington, NSW

O no - what was once one of the best places for pizza has sadly gone mainstream - very disappointed by what was once my favorite. The reduced size of the pizza to 'happy meal' and the lack of flavour has turned away a very regular customer. RIP read more

Love supreme have some great ingredients but when it all comes together, it falls a bit short for me. I may be attacked for saying so, but I think there is better pizza in Sydney. Even the simple christos in paddington five ways I think has some great pizza, without any of the elitism that you can get for free at love supreme. read more

It's an Australian pizza pie for sure, but it's one of the best. Everything is fresh and delicious. The ricotta is some of the best I've ever had. Was worried the tiramisu would be pre-made. Yeah, no, it came out in a single serving jar (very cute) and was damn good. I usually don't care about atmosphere, but it's near perfect here. Rarely do I stick around much longer after my last bite of food. Here, they almost had to drag me out. read more

A meal here and you'll be declaring your love from the rooftops. This place is one of my favourite Italian restaurants in Sydney (it's a close tie with Il Baretto in Surry Hills) and they're now taking group bookings. The dimly lit dining room is the perfect setting for a dinner date or catch-up with friends. Open for lunch from midday on weekends, and dinner seven nights a week (with delivery from 5pm), if you pop in for a quick bite between 5pm and 7pm Monday to Friday, you can enjoy a single pizza and a glass of wine or beer for $19.90. Good luck choosing between the signature pizza with artichoke hearts, anchovies, buffalo mozzarella and gremolata or the Leona - lamb sausage, silver beet, provolone cheese and harissa. The guys in the kitchen use organic/biodynamic produce as much as possible, including 100% stone-ground organic flour, organic eggs and Paris Creek organic dairy products. That's a whole lotta love. read more

Love Supreme - Pizza Near Me - Paddington, NSW

Warm, friendly and attentive service. The pizzas are excellent and prices quite reasonable for the area. Interesting design and a nice buzz - a place to visit regularly. read more

Love this place. There are some pretty ordinary pizza joints in the area. Love Supreme shines. Bosco try's his guts out to ensure you have a great time and served fabulous organic produce. The best ricotta in town and great desserts just adds to the experience. read more

Great pizza, pasta is not spectacular

I knew going here yesterday evening for early dinner (5:30pm) Saturday that there were mixed reviews. However, you can really just report on your own experience - I'm giving Love Supreme the big thumbs up. I thought it was great! Found the staff very attentive & friendly. Superb pizzas! I took a bit of a gamble and selected the "Surprise Pizza" which literally is whatever the Chef feels like dishing up. Great pizza - but I did let the waiter know I was a meat lover. Found it was quite reasonably priced. Best of all for this Saturday evening we were going to the super rugby at Allianz Stadium. Stadium was a 10 minute walk away. Great evening all round. read more

pizza dough should be thin and thats why i love their pizza, not only the toppings are palatable but as well as their dough,