We just left Lost Pizza and it was terrible. The pizza was overcooked. Crust so hard I couldn't bite it. Customer service was as expected.

Stopped by again as I was traveling through Still great Really good thin crust Can't go wrong with the Otis House salad is a really nice addition Great friendly staff read more

The pizza was a 4, but horrible service. No one welcomed or said anything as we left. No one smiled. No one came to check on us or make sure anything was good. We ordered a pizza with pepperoni and they brought us pineapple. We ordered garlic ranch and when they didn't bring it up, I went to ask for it. The waitress took the time to look up our order and she said it didn't ring up, admitting her mistake. She said, "it'll be 55 cents." We will not be back. Horrible customer service. read more

Wonderful very flavorful pizza. Great Service! I now been there twice and ordered takeout a couple of times. Same great experience every time. Highly recommend! read more

Even on a busy Sunday, we were able to place an order pretty easily and find seating. Love that they offer local beers! There's a nice variety of pizza choices, too. The one I chose was a bbq situation while my kids got plain cheese. I love a thin crust pizza but my partner doesn't. Luckily their thin isn't a crispy-cracker thin so we both enjoyed it! read more

Horrible experience. First of all you have to stand there to read the menu. Might as well have to a fast food restaurant. Could find a pizza I wanted, so was trying to build a pizza. Several more customers came in and were getting impatient because we were holding up the line. Funnily I got disgusted and ordered the BBQ nachos, wife ordered a salad. So you pay when you order, and at that point they are expecting a tip. How in the hell am I supposed to know how the food a service are? So then it's self serve drinks. Got drinks and sat down and they immediately brought out wife's salad. My nachos didn't show up for another 10 minutes. Who in the hell a 2 top separate? That's dumb. My food shows up. Looked rather disgusting and didn't taste much better. Every chip except two were soggy. Someone had poured some liquid cheese on them, the only flavor the meat had was the bbq sauce which was way too sweet. Apparently they have no waitstaff, just food runners. No one ever came back to the table to check on us. So now I'm sitting here the next reflecting on the experience and wondering what exactly did I tip for. Certainly wasn't the service or the meal. Oh and let's not forget about the ceiling literally has cob webs all over it. Clean the damn place up. read more

The food was good but tell me how I found not 1 but 2 hairs in my food! A long hair in my pizza and what looked like an eyelash in my salad they need to get some hair nets or something in their kitchen read more

Our family orders from Lost Pizza almost every week, and it never disappoints. We especially love the Hot Chick and the BYOP with pepperoni and mushrooms. Both the thick and thin crusts are consistently excellent. Great food and reliable quality every time! read more

Horrible! For some reason Yelp cancelled our order but failed to tell us until 20 minutes past the supposed delivery time. No fault of the Pizza Co. they were as confused as we were. I would have loved yo try the Pizza Co read more

This is the best pizza around... I look forward to traveling towards Little Rock so I can stop here for lunch. Conveniently located close to I-30, they always have good music and their decor is definitely 70's Rock n Roll... 5 stars all the way! read more

Lost Pizza - Business - Pizza Near Me - Benton, Arkansas

See all

Searched Yelp for a place to stop for lunch on the way home from a trip. Lots of different places came up but decided to give this one a try...so glad we did! Clearly a local favorite as there were alot of big groups and lots of cars in parking lot. We expected a long wait but were met with plenty of seating and very friendly staff despite all the people! Clean restaurant and restrooms. Fun decor. Excellent food! Pizza sauce "just right" not too spicy or sweet. Food served quickly and hot! No complaints whatsoever! read more

See all

Everything was great! Their pizza is delicious and like nothing else around here. Super fresh ingredients and very good.

Good pizza from a smaller chain. Had an Otis and an Alfredo pizza. Employee taking the order was very nice and attentive.

I was 3 bites in when I wholeheartedly told my husband "I'm going to go out on a limb and say it ... this is the best pizza I've EVER had". We ordered the Lucille. Not expecting a lot because until then, everyone here told us Hideaway Pizza was the best and we just were enthused. So we sat down, waited just a short bit for our pizza and we were literally sitting at our table exclaiming to each other how good every single bite was. Every bite was a flavor explosion and the crust was like eating a garlic twist at the end. From the first bite to the last, HEAVEN!!! read more

Lost Pizza - The Lucille - Pizza Near Me - Benton, Arkansas

This pizza joint has been around for a few years now and I am surprised this is the first review. The pizza is really good and they have plenty of other options for the kids not interested in pizza. Mine love their ravioli. They also have the best ice! Seating can be a bit challenging If you have a large group but parties of 6-8 should not be an issue. Easy access off of highway 5. The restaurant and restrooms were both very clean. Definitely a hidden gem! read more

See all

Got to say, pizza was good, service fast and friendly. Prices reasonable. Salads looked good, will try next time. Parking just to pick up is a bit of a hassle. I like it. read more

I first tried this pizza place in Mobile, AL. Much to my surprise, it was a chain and we had one in my neighboring town!! Their salads are huge and tasty, seems like almost full head of lettuce. Pizza was good as well! The atmosphere is open and they have a little arcade for the kids while you wait for pizza to cook. Definitely recommend! read more

This was my first time eating here and the pizza was amazing. I ordered the Otis and a 6 piece mild buffalo wings. Food was delicious and hot. Even the ranch dipping sauce was good. Will be coming back here for sure in the future. read more

Lost Pizza - The Otis pizza - Pizza Near Me - Benton, Arkansas

Pizza is so good!! This place is a must try we drive from arkadephia to eat here. Sandwiches are fantastic also!

We really enjoyed this place. The atmosphere is nice and we love the deck and tv. The pizza was really good! The waitress and staff seem really nice. One time we had to look for our waitress but we weren't upset by it. Will definitely be back. read more

This is my second review for Lost Pizza as my first review a few years ago was not too encouraging. I had just ordered the wrong thing! Lost Pizza redeemed itself as we now order from there regularly! Our favorite is the El Diablo which is so scrum! The barbecue swirl on top adds just enough of a different flavor to the whole get-up. And it's wonderful dipped in their homemade ranch. I also love their Greek salad as it has so many different vegetables and flavors! Pairs perfectly with their Greek dressing. Lost pizza has become our favorite pizza in Saline county. read more

Love their Pizza, I got the Beef, Black and Green olive with Bacon. Olive oil and garlic on thin crust, sooooo good

Awesome place! Hands down, a must visit, again and again. The pizza's great and the Italian dishes compare to any reputable Italian restaurant in a 20-mile radius. Yes, as good as Luigi's! The atmosphere is relaxing and fun for all ages. The service is extremely accommodating. I have three little girls and they loved the food and the staff treated them great! The manager, possibly owner, greeted my family upon walking in and visited our table, thanked us for our business and ensured we were enjoying ourselves and food. Much appreciated, and all my pleasure! Nothing like some appreciation these days. I've attached a picture of my pizza and a view from the back area of resutarant. read more

See all

Iconic local location that serves great pizza with a large ding area. The ambiance is genuine rural.

The Otis is the best. Staff is very friendly and helpful. The sweet tea is awesome . The service is speedy.

Just in town for 2 days and found THE best pizza in town. Place is clean and the service was great. Pizza was great!!! Highly recommend.

Kujo was great. Pizza came out quick. It was hot, fresh, and had a perfect thin crispy delicious crust. Service was top notch!

Pizza was overcooked and the quality and amount of toppings on one of their signature sandwiches looked as if it was a kid's sandwich. I think I paid $15ish for it. Very disappointing. read more

Could not recommend Lost Pizza enough! Great staff & great food! Stellar atmosphere & very family friendly!

Amazing pizza. I'm from New Orleans and we have some good spots but this place is spectacular. Made the move to the area worth it.

Good pizza and the environment was good, friendly staff. Bathrooms are clean somewhat fair price unless you have a large party. Guess the locals had no choice given the location. I would go again a order different read more

First and last time ordering a chicken Alfredo from this place. After picking up my order & opening them at home, I could not be more disappointed. The spaghettis were very thin and so clumped up together. There was sauce on one side of the pasta and not the other as if it wasn't mixed. Highly dissatisfied, what you see in the picture is all the food I did not eat because my stomach began to hurt. read more

See all

Amazing pizza!! Loved it all! We tried the Hectors taco pie , the cheese stick was some of the best we ever had. The Otis was absolutely amazing! The wife loves the spicy food and couldn't get enough of the El Diablo! read more

Fantastic place, friendly people, great pizza and wings. Appetizers and all Pizzas are great. You have to try the Otis!

This place was incredible! The Tamales were delicious, especially with a little of their hot sauce on them (I bought a bottle). The Pizza was amazing!!!! The service was excellent!!! Definitely 5 Star!!!! read more

Fantastic pizza and service! Very nice little restaurant. We eat here several times a month.

I visit here about 2-3 times a month. I don't think I have ever gotten anything bad from here and the service especially at lunch time is always good. The Otis is always my go to for pizza. read more

This restaurant has been so many different things. Glad to see that it's (hopefully) settled as this local pizza joint. It's been voted "Best Pizza in Saline County," so I had to check it out. * The interior is a funky retro-style place. It has lots of colorful lights and is well-lit. The only issue with the many lights is that their menu (which is mounted on the wall) gets a little bit of a glare and thus makes it a little hard to read. The prices are a little high for pizza in my opinion. There's a game area in the back of the restaurant, which closely reminds me of Larry's Pizza but on a much smaller scale. * The wait time was quick, probably about 10-15 minutes. I ordered the massive custom pizza (definitely not eating it by myself, haha), with cheese, sauce, and meatballs (specialty topping, $3.00) on thin crust. When the pizza arrived, however, it turns out my thin crust became thick crust. Not a terrible thing, but was hoping to save a few carbs with the thin crust. The waitress offered to fix it but it wasn't a big deal so I kept it. * The pizza itself was cut very quickly and not throughly so I had to use the fork to cut the slices off of each other. The pizza itself is decent and I can definitely tell it was handmade. The dough is light and cooked good with a little crunch and a little crisp. The meatball had a good subtle flavor. Overall, a good pizza but I'm missing where the "Best in Saline County" is. * Last note, the staff are very friendly aside from the man I presumed to be the owner -- I asked for marinara sauce and he never said a word to me. Note a big deal except I assumed he was the owner and expected a better impression. * I recommend this place -- great for groups and kid-friendly. read more

See all

Best pizza in Saline county. We leave close so we have it often. Never had a complaint

Really great pizza. I had the cauliflower pizza and my husband/daughter had thick crust. Their sauce is so good! Great atmosphere! Highly recommend read more