good food, great views on the water, friendly efficient staff difficult to get a seat in season,…read moretiki bar has live music. Wife and I try to go once a week Richard B

Ok this place is a total dive. It was recommended to me by a local bartender who seems to know her…read morestuff. I came here after a round of golf. Everyone loved my golf hat- "play bad fast". I looked at the outdoor bar but every single seat was taken. All the outdoor tables were booked. So I went inside and saw the inside bar was also full. A table for ten and a table for 6 had departed and needed to be bussed, but both were too much for just one person. So I checked in w the hostess and she asked - booth or table. I wanted table. I got a nice table by the river! Lovely views. Exactly what I wanted. Menus were dropped and soon, Sam was checking in on me. I was so hungry, I had looked at the menu and pics on my way there. I went for the crab cake appetizer and the Gold Wave cocktail. For my entree, I was torn between the Grouper Reuben and the Sea Dog (fried grouper on a long roll, topped with all sorts of goodness). Sam said grouper Reuben was his choice. He asked if I wanted grilled, blackened or fried. I told him to surprise me. For my side, I had the choice of (more) coleslaw (it has coleslaw instead of sauerkraut), fries, sweet potato fries, or a side house or Cesar salad for $4 more. I went w the house salad and their standard citrus vinaigrette. Salad and crab cake came out first. Salad was a huge portion- romaine (some pieces needed better washing), red onion galore, halved cherry tomatoes and cucumber slices. It was great, but needed croutons. The crab cake was the perfect size for one person. It had a whole grain mustard remoulade sauce. Yum! It had some filler but also had a lot of crab. I enjoyed it. The grouper Rueben came out hot!!!! Served with a side of coleslaw and a pickle. I added some needed salt. Boy that fish filet was huge. Sam had put it in grilled for me. Healthy. Nice. I ate half and then I was stuffed. I filled up on the salad and crabcake apparently. I enjoyed the views of boaters going by. It started to rain hard and the folks outside just stayed there. The overhang must've been protecting them well. My server, Sam, was around often to answer my questions. Apparently the grouper Reuben market price is only $21. And if you want redfish or mahi, the price is the same- $21! That's crazy. What a deal. The gold wave is made with Elijah Craig; Good ol Kentucky bourbon. And for dessert, they have cheesecake, peanut butter pie, mud pie, key lime pie, coconut sorbet and orange cake (which he says is a local favorite). I was too stuffed to buy but happy to hear the list. Overall I had a wonderful meal and service was really good. I would recommend adding croutons to the salad, and cleaning up the bathrooms regularly. This place ain't fancy. It's a dirt parking lot. The tables are naked. Folks come casual. However, the prices are great and the food does the talking. Come check them out.

First timer here. Bloody Marys after breakfast next door at the Trading Post. Sat at the bar. Good…read moreview of the servers poring soft drinks. Servers seemed a bit stressed...well, only the male server. He was sweating, stressing, and just overall really not doing well. He's pouring ice from a cup into what looked to be iced tea all while holding the cup over the entire tub of ice as tea spilled into the ice. Smh. Did not order food or even look at the menu but I've had some friends that really like it here. Drinks were ok. Nothing fabulous. A little weak. Meh.

Joe and I have been staying at Burnt Store Marina since Sept 26th. Cass Cay is a 4 minute golf…read morecart ride since it's on the grounds of the community. Absolutely love this fun casual bar restaurant. Every night they have something going on. Usually live music on Saturday and Sunday without a cover charge. Tipping is welcomed and we'll deserved. The best performances so far have been from solo artist Jaid Joice and very talented group called The kollections. Wow! Joe and I have been beyond impressed with their talent!! On Monday evenings the older folks (mostly) get together for Bar Bingo. Check their website for trivia, karaoke, the Gatlin Show. Basically every night there is something going on that satisfies someone's fancy. Oh my age is showing! Lol This establishment is very active with charity events, especially for the Veterans and their families. We have attended several charity events since we've been here. What a great feeling to be involved and spread the love and appreciation! Cass Cay has a simple menu with a wonderful variety of options. From snacks, salads, sandwiches, soup to hot dinner meals, everything is delicious! To date everything has been delivered to us with complete satisfaction. Located on the Burnt Store Marina with an unbelievable views. Paradise!! The staff is amazing! Very hard working, pleasant and patient folks. Joe and I appreciate all of you for your hard work, we see that you never stop moving and always serve with a smile. A big thank you shout out to bartender Caitlin, you know we love you NY girl! And Michael also from NY, you bust your butt man and craft an excellent LI Ice Tea! Thank you bro!!. Over the last 2 months Joe and I had the pleasure to meet hard working Maddy, Brad, Mike, Emma, Cody Jess, Sheri, Donna and the amazing buss staff. You are all such an asset to this establishment and very much appreciated! See ya soon!!!!

Our group had been boating for a few hours and were able to pull up at the dock around 3pm. There…read morewere plenty of spots. The dock was well maintained and the restaurant/bar has a decent feel with sand all around. It was a super hot day so we made our way inside and snagged one of the few tables that was in there. My brother and I made our way to the bar outside to order drinks for our group. We ordered 2 watermelon mojitos, a margarita, and a strawberry lemonade. The drinks were all served in regular plastic solo cup size cups. I paid $80. This is astronomical especially for what we received. I'm not new to the island hopping life but this was way overpriced. The Watermelon mojito had a sort of phoney taste to it. Maybe it was not fresh juice used. I was told the margarita was just mehhh. But that price for 3 alcoholic drinks and 1 plain lemonade still gets me. This is definitely not the spot to stay for a long time and enjoy many drinks over an afternoon.

BEWARE! SHADY 20% tip automatically added to bill labeled as "OPERATIONS CHARGE" (or similar name…read moreif i remember correctly) so that maybe you don't notice and still tip additional. Also, the bartenders lie about the prices to intentionally mislead customers. Extremely OVERPRICED drinks! I'm debating alerting the BBB about my experience. Mainstay offers a 16oz glass or a 20oz 'bucket' mixed drink choice. When ordering, I asked the male bartender on 3/17 (St Paddy's) the difference in prices and was told that "The bucket is a better deal if you plan to order two or more drinks since it's only $2 more and you only pay the extra charge for the bucket on the first drink". Great - i planned to order 2-3 drinks so it made sense for me to pay extra for the 20oz 'bucket' drink. When I went up to order my 2nd drink it was a female bartender who took my order this time. I held my empty 'bucket' up to show her I had already purchased it and ordered the Mai Tai in a bucket. I asked if I need to give her my bucket to refill and she said 'no, hold on to it we'll give you a new one'. Well, she did give me a new one but she also charged me $13 AGAIN for the 'bucket' charge. So I paid $20 for the drink + $13 for the bucket. $33 for the drink. The 16oz drink is $18. Bartenders intentionally mislead customers. BEWARE OF THIS PLACE.

The food and service defines the experience. Blue dog never changes. Daily printed menus of fresh…read moreofferings, friendly familiar faces of staff and customers every day, the only downside is trying to find parking during peak times. This place thrives on volume and pure mayhem. But quality never suffers. The food is always amazing. I wish they had liquor, be aware all alcoholic drinks are beer based. A minor complaint which doesnt even effect my five star rating. The food speaks for itsself.

Blue Dog Bar & Grill is another local "must do"! Daily specials based on what is fresh, Friday…read morenight Prime Rib, and a fantastic everyday menu. The food is always super fresh, hot and delicious! Any choice from the "Fish of the Moment" is guaranteed to be amazing and I LOVE their Prime Rib! Staff is always friendly and quick but can become overwhelmed at peak hours. We tend to "stagger" our orders to prevent our entrees arriving while we are still eating our appetizers. Matlacha charm and Island Time feel will melt your day away, especially with a frosty Blue Dog lager in hand. Grab a seat at the bar if possible. Parking can be crazy during season. Cheers!

Enjoyed a great early evening lunch/dinner. The staff was amazing and very attentive. Food just…read moreas wonderful. More than amazing was the bar back. He made sure he took care of the bar and was super pleasant to the customers. The day is 8/22and the time was 3:30 pm. Good job everyone!!

It was my first time there. Went with a date. I live 45 min away and have been to a few tiki bar…read morerestaurants in my area in SW Florida, and this one was the best. Love this place. We sat on the swings at the bar which were fun. Next time we will try the patio in the evening for a romantic dinner. They have a small gift shop. Bought one of those glasses and a coffee mug with their cool pic on it. They have free Valet parking. Please tip the guy. They also had music bingo when we were there on a Monday for lunch. I think they do it twice a week. I wish the place would be closer to my house. I would be there all the time. They have a very large bar. I would like to see more familiar items on the menu. You have to go there. It's on the water. Several small buildings with gift shops on the same street, we didn't have time to stop in there. We'll do it next time. Can't wait to go back for dinner

My first visit to Tamiami Tavern, but absolutely will not be my last…read more I had read online they served a good beef on weck. Well, that's a local specialty in my home state so I had to find out. The plate was golden, I was very surprised. The beef was very plentiful and top quality (sliced correct thickness and piled HIGH). The kimmelweck roll was hardy enough to hold up, but didn't overpower the beef. It had the perfect ratio of caraway seed and salt. A generous side of au jus, and horseradish, completed the sandwich. I chose coleslaw as the side dish, and it was also very good. The service was tops, the environment was very friendly and inviting. This will be top of my list to visit, and recommend to others when they request a good place to dine out.

My husband and I stopped by Tamiami Tavern for the first time for a quick dinner. The atmosphere…read morehas an Irish pub feel, and the décor is sparse. Both the hostess and our waitress were very friendly and welcoming. Our drinks were brought out quickly after we were seated. The Mountain Dew tasted almost like pure syrup, which made it difficult to enjoy. We ordered the Tavern Steak Hoagie with French fries, and I also had a bowl of lobster bisque. Unfortunately, the food didn't quite meet our expectations. The lobster bisque was extremely salty. The steak hoagie was small and wasn't what we expected for $24. We've enjoyed many steak and cheese hoagies over the years, and this one left us disappointed. Overall, the service and atmosphere were the highlights of our visit. While the food wasn't a hit for us this time, the staff was pleasant and the restaurant itself is clean.

Tarpon Lodge & Restaurant is our date night location. So much charm! Indoor / outdoor dining in a…read morebuilding dating back to 1926, screen door out to the beautiful grounds, amazing food and wine menus and finally the SUNSETS! The menu focuses on locally sourced ingredients, served with Pine Island flare. The service staff is knowledgeable, attentive without being intrusive and always smiling. They really make you feel welcome and part of the family. Plenty of on-site, free parking. Make sure to plan your visit to walk the grounds and take in a sunset. Regardless of where you are in the cape or surrounding area, Tarpon Lodge restaurant is worth the drive. Cheers!

Unbelievable to witness this place rebound time and again, storm after storm, flood after flood…read more Not to mention the incredible amount of responsibility placed upon this family run hospitality business. Anyone looking to support a quiet waterfront community should certainly consider this gem. Parking in navigation can sometimes be tricky. So consider utilizing the paid parking and security offered by the Pineland Marina Safe Harbor next-door. The twisty windy Road past the historic post office, the Randall research center, and all the grounds of this archaeological treasure trove is worth the drive. But I would not encourage anybody to bike or walk due to limited unsafe pathways and frequent flooding. But once you find your sweet parking spot and don't have to worry about anything. Have lunch at the tarpon Lodge and then walk all through the community of pineland and gaze upon this country club-esque neighborhood that is anchored by an abandoned golf course. Local wildlife is rebounding in this potential preserve. Bird watches especially have opportunities to check rare sightings off of their ornithology list. Including spring time elusives like the Chuck Wills Widow nightjar, white pelicans, juvenile bald eagles looking for their life mates, pileated woodpeckers and so much more. And if you're lucky and you play your cards right, a local might give you a couple fishing tips and some secret spots. So always have a fishing pole and bait ready.

Just had awesome fish tacos (cobia) at the Pink Elephant. Always in search of better than average…read morefish tacos and they did not disappoint. Plenty of meaty fish similar to mahi. Delicious topping & sauce. Highly recommend. They come 2 per order and they split them on plates for us since we just wanted a snack (only went in for a drink). The onion rings were also way above average, crunchy and delicious! Austin the bartender is really sweet and keeps the customers happy. Enjoyed sitting at the bar so he could serve us again. Don't recommend going on a holiday weekend though. What were we thinking? Well the beach had no parking and the streets were very busy. Glad we found a place to park at the pink elephant. We just wanted a little beach outing for vow-renewal "anniversary." Wink. Probably going again soon on our engagement anniversary!

Hostess was great, food was good, but the service was poor. After we received our entrees, no one…read moreever came back to check to see how it was or if we needed anything. Our table was cleaned and the waitress came back and asked if we wanted another round of drinks, we said no thank you, she said "okay your dinner will be out shortly". We already ate !!!! We are drinking coffee and waiting for our dessert and they brought us out more bread The atmosphere was very nice. I think they gave the waitress too many tables.

Menu is 5-6 pages Food portions are huge…read moreFast friendly service Great decor & music Guacamole table side is good

September 2025 First time trying this restaurant.. and we…read moreloved it. The food was great, we started with table-side guacamole, awesome. We ordered the Tacos Los Mariachis & Chimichangas both dishes were delicious and great portions! We also had skinny margaritas, yum!