Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Libby's Oak Street Treasures

    5.0 (1 review)

    Libby's Oak Street Treasures Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Libby's Oak Street Treasures

    Recommended Reviews - Libby's Oak Street Treasures

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Ariel W.
    4034
    6131
    107572

    7 years ago

    Helpful 75
    Thanks 0
    Love this 62
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Libby's Oak Street Treasures

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Goodwill Superstore

    Goodwill Superstore

    2.5
    (6 reviews)
    30.6 mi
    $$

    Goodwill was found in 1902 by Boston Minister, Reverend Edgar J. Helms. He took donations from…read morewealthy Bostonians and hired people who were poor and who could fix the items. The items were then given to the people who worked on them or were resold. Goodwill's philosophy is "a hand up, not a hand out". Today Goodwill has become a $5 billion nonprofit organization that provides job training, employment, and community programs for people who have disabilities that might prevent them from getting a job on their own. I was in the area so I decided to check out this Goodwill in Sebring. It was completely different than any other Goodwill I have been to. They still had the same racks of clothes I am used to but they also carried a wide range of brand new household decor items including art, rugs, and decorations. One large part of the store was roped off and it contained hundreds of brand new Halloween costumes in bags. It was a far cry from the one rack of used mismatched costume pieces I have seen Goodwill stores carry in the fall. This store also carries brand new mattresses. This Goodwill resembled more of a Big Lots than the Goodwills I am used to. The prices were on par with those of discount retailer Big Lots as well. They even sell snacks up front. I inquired about what they sell and was told it was new and thrift items. The new items had been donated to them. I don't know if this store is unique or the way Goodwill wants to move in the future. Everything was clean and displayed nicely. I really wanted to find out more about this store but unfortunately they were getting ready to close for the night. If I lived in Sebring I would be a regular customer at this store.

    The employees seemed nice but it is definitely not your typical Goodwill. I am not sure why it is…read moreconsidered a superstore. Although very clean an organized the merchandise lacks a lot to be desired. It is nothing like the usual Goodwills. Most all items except the clothing is cheap made and new items priced much higher than the same items from a regular retail store. The furniture was extremely over priced. If you are a thrift person looking for items to refurbish or resale dont wast your time at this store. The clothing both new and used was lower quality. None of the special finds that make thrifting fun. I love shopping Goodwills and was a regular customer in Jacksonville. I have been in this store several times and have found absolutely nothing I would consider purchasing. I would rate it the lowest of all the Goodwills I have shopped at in my many many years of thrifting. I would give this store an a+ for cleanliness. The employees seemed friendly and knowledgeable. It is the merchandise that should be given a 1 star rating. It is not just that it is overpriced it is the quality and selections. I wish Goodwill would consider opening a store similar to the other Goodwills in Florida if not in Sebring then Lake Placid. This store is a total disappointment.

    Photos
    Love these!
    Love these!
    Goodwill Superstore
    Racks of brand new Halloween costumes ready to go. They probably have more than Spirit Halloween stores.

    See all

    Racks of brand new Halloween costumes ready to go. They probably have more than Spirit Halloween stores.
    Fleamasters Fleamarket

    Fleamasters Fleamarket

    3.7
    (140 reviews)
    39.8 mi
    $

    What an experience…read more.. I'm a self-proclaimed thrifting fanatic, and I grew up loving to go to flea markets and priced-per-pound places with my grandma. Maybe it was the heat, but this fleamarket just wasn't hitting when I visited. SETUP: You can really get your steps in here! Park and remember where you parked, then head in. Tons of shops to explore - like miles of it - and it's all covered. It's open air so no AC, but many shops have fans and some have AC running. They have each lane color coded on the floor, so you can remember you started in the red lane, then went to blue, etc. We still got lost haha. FOOD/DRINK: There are restaurants and bars here! Very fun to get a beer to drink while you walk. Most of the food was food truck style - pretty greasy and hot, which didn't appeal to us. SHOPS: This was the disappointing part for me. Maybe it's just not my style, but I was bummed to see it was mostly cheap bulk items and poorly made stuff at that. The t-shirt shops were selling cheap, misprinted Fort Myers stuff - but the prices weren't that crazy good? And they didn't have true tourist stores with souvenirs more than just t-shirts. Some of the shoe stores had some decent deals, a few record store scores, and I LOVED the few well-curated vintage shops inside. But otherwise, it was a lot of stuff I happily passed on. Some of the vendors were a bit pushy (the spa/skincare ones) but otherwise most left us be to browse. Even as a fan of thrifting, I found this to be overwhelming and underwhelming at the same time and likely won't be back.

    This place has everything! It is a maze so make sure you remember what color you enter from and…read morethen follow the other color lines to each end. You'll find things from trinkets to clothing to furniture and more. I personally love to thrift and this is like a mall for thrifters. They also had a bunch of food vendors (we did not partake) and a couple full bars (we did partake in that). Ton of fun to explore and came out with a couple goodies myself!

    Photos
    Fleamasters Fleamarket
    Fleamasters Fleamarket
    Fleamasters Fleamarket

    See all

    Libby's Oak Street Treasures - antiques - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...