Huge shout out to Rosarios Pizza in Leola. Hands down the best customer service!! They know me by…read morename and always get the same salad every Friday. Realized I received the wrong order once I got back to work. Figure oh well Im hungry Ill just eat it. Next thing I know they are delivering me the right salad. Hard to find honest service like that anymore. I cant be thankful enough.

We walked in an about an hour and half before they closed. No one greeted us and the sign said…read moreplease seat yourself. There were no other customers in there. I asked the waitress if we could sit in a certain area and she said with an attitude "we are closing soon and we prefer you to sit in this other area so we can clean this area." No other customers came in the whole time we were there. We felt like we were not welcomed. The ambiance was not welcoming. We ordered a veggie pizza and a meatball sub. The meatballs were so small. I have never seen a meatball sub with such tiny meatballs. The meatballs barely came up to half of the sub, the rest was bread. The veggie pizza was just ok. The food was served hot. The place seemed clean and looked nice. We tried this place since we were on vacation in the area and wanted pizza. Sadly, it was not a good choice. We will not be back and do not recommend this place.

Great costumer service! Wonderful family friendly atmosphere. Owner and wife kept coming over to…read moreask how the meal was and how they could serve us better. Food was amazing. My husband and I had the manicotti and the chicken ziti. Portion size is larger than I thought and the prices are reasonable. Our meals also included a house salad and garlic knots. Everything was made quick, fresh ,and tasted wonderful. Overall my husband and I walked out paying $26. You really can't beat the price. Highly recommend this restaurant if you are in the area.

We just happened by here one day on a visit to Lancaster, and we really liked it. If this…read morerestaurant were anywhere near the DC area, we would be regulars. There were nice toppings to choose from, and both pizzas were very tasty.

We arrived around 5:30pm a few nights before Valentine's Day. Even without reservations I was able…read moreto get a table for two, but I wouldn't guarantee that will always happen. When we finished our meal there were multiple people (probably at least 10) waiting to be seated. So I recommend dinner reservations. We enjoyed our chicken Parmesan. The bread they serve is wonderful. Our waitress was Stacy and she was friendly and helpful...10 out of 10.

We had the mozzarella fritta, arancine, Caesar salad, and carbonara pasta. Everything was solidly…read moreokay. It was very busy on the Friday night we went with friends, so reservations are a good idea. Getting seated was a bit chaotic, as the same area is used for both takeout and dine-in. The servers were clearly busy--managing multiple tables while also plating and serving desserts.

5/5 for Value…read moreCleanliness Service Options/Menu Perfect spot for a family or friends. They keep the customer top of mind.

This place is a little strange to navigate on the first visit…read more.. Tables no table service although someone brings you the food. My wife had the spaghetti with sausage and it was good I had the Italian Trio which was a disappointment. Nothing was hot and I was expecting more of a pounded chicken cutlet vs. a thick chicken breast. Actually tasted like it was bought that way...and dropped in the fryer. Either way not sure if we will return but at this point being new to the area will still be looking for that weeknight Italian BYOB.

We were looking for someplace to eat on Memorial day and a lot of places were closed. After calling…read morearound thankfully we found this place was open. We received a welcome greeting by a very friendly lady who gave us menus to look over. We got a really good feeling about who is running this spot. Ordering is at the counter and then you seat yourself. Drinks and table ware is self serve, but they do bring the food out to you. Everyone working there is very clearly out Italian so we expected very authentic authentic meals. The decor is nice, but the booth seating is fast food like. After a short wait the salads arrived, which were very good. I appreciated the sweet marinated peppers on mine. The dressing isn't homemade, but it is Ken's, which is close enough. We also received warm toasted garlic bread. We each ordered pasta. My spouse got the angel hair with marinara which she enjoyed. I had spaghetti with clams which were plentiful, although the whole thing was swimming in olive oil. Way to much for me. At the end of our meal a man brought over some complimentary fried dough balls rolled in sugar which was a nice touch. All in all a nice experience.

This place might not be known as the best pizza in Lancaster but if you are a New Yorker like me I…read morethink you will realize it is the best pizza anywhere near here. When I moved here to Lancaster in 2017 from Long Island I just assumed pizza was one of those things I would have to live without but the pizza here is as good or better than most places in NY. The owner did come from Long Island so it makes sense.

My family always loves anything we eat from Palermo's. Sometimes it is take out and other times we…read moresit down. Most of the time we get cheesesteaks there and they are always enough for 2 full meals! Our son either gets a personal pizza or a burger and always loves either! We have had pizza, stromboli, and other hot sandwiches. All are yummy and plenty of food!

It's a good neighborhood pizza place. Friendly staff, clean and plenty of parking. Out of the many…read morepizza places in that area, I would vote this one top. My only hesitation to a 5 star is their prices are a little higher and the menu in their website does not reflect their current pricing. A large cheesesteak was $7.50 and now it's $11 or $12. I know they can't control costs going up but it would be nice to have the accurate prices on the website for ordering purchases. I did take out so I can't comment on the experience of dinning in but they do have a good amount of seating and could shift things to accommodate a large group. Cheesesteak was perfect but the bread was a little soggy since it's not a hard roll. Tuna salad was one of the best I've had! Love how they make their recipe. My recommendation is that you ask for them to add more to your salad besides only lettuce and a tomato. Onions, pickles, sweet peppers, black olives, etc.

Pop up Pizza Pie, well yes, I will! The hot honey pepperoni…read morewas the perfect balance, the combo of honey and sriracha is surprisingly delicious. Tried the garden pizza and the regular cheese pizza, both also very good. Corey is very accommodating and personable, he will do any custom request made. Order through the website when he'll be in your area and it'll be fresh and hot when you arrive.

This is my second (updated) review for this restaurant. We are not local, and we stumbled upon it…read moreabout a year ago when we were in Lancaster. This time, while traveling, we drove out of our way just to pass through Lancaster and stay the night just so we could some genuine Brooklyn style pizza without having to go to the Big Apple. This time, like last time, it was some of the best pizzas I've had, and I'm sure it may be the best in Lancaster. It is true NY style (Brooklyn) pizza made by New Yorkers. The restaurantier is a NYC transplant, and he brought with him that NY pizza. Simply stated, it's awesome. All the staff is polite, cordial, and engaging. They don't waste any time in creating your meal and making you love every bite. They offer a rather extensive menu with good variety, but we have only tried the pizza, and we love it.

We wandered into Thoze guys pizzeria after a long exhausting day at Dutch Wonderland. Great…read moreatmosphere of a neighborhood pizza joint. Informal feeling, which was great when we were walking in with three kids. The staff was friendly and the food was amazing. Super authentic and hit the spot. The marinara sauce with the garlic knots was something I could drink out of a faucet. Also loved that they had individual slices available so we could try an assortment for the family.

We are in the area for the weekend and we just wanted a quick and easy pizza dinner while the snow…read morewas rolling in. I found this place on Google and it really impressed! The staff was very friendly upon picking up, chatted a bit while I packed everything up. The price was right and the food was incredible! Plain pizza so good my son house several slices and the Buffalo chicken pie and garlic parm wings were exactly what we needed after a long day of adventuring. The restaurant itself seemed very inviting. If I were back in the area I would absolutely get this pizza again!

Good pizza! Not too greasy, not too cheesy. Once you take that first bite, the dough had a nice…read morecrisp crust...not a soggy bottom. Pizza was the only thing we tried but there was plenty of options on the menu to choose from. There's tables and booths for seating. A bench for order out to have a seat and wait. Plenty of customers in and out while we dined in. Easy to access; right on route 322 before the 222 interchange. The only negative aspect was the untidiness. Most of the tables could have used a good wipe down but maybe there was a rush of customers before we arrived.