Walking into La Michoacana Artisan, it seemed like half the hikers in the area convened on this one spot for their after-hike refreshments with the promise of homemade ice cream. A long line snaked out of the shop as everyone sought to replenish the calories they had burned through the day and the outside benches were full of people enjoying ice cream and various treats. Still, the line moved pretty quickly and soon we had our order:
Medium ($7.29) - This comes with three scoops (not the most generous of sizes), of which we went with the Matcha Pistachio Cheesecake (MPC), Gansito, and Horchata.
The MPC does have a bit of matcha earthiness, pistachio nuttiness, and has small cubes of cheesecake mixed into. It has a major issue though - it isn't completely frozen into ice cream. It's like it just came out from the ice cream mixer, not completely solidified and more like a light custard in texture. I saw that some of the ice cream tubs that were filled over capacity seemed to be on the melty side, but I didn't expect it to actually be melted going in!
I have never had the gansito snack cake before, but this ice cream tastes exactly like the description of this dessert. It's mostly earthy/grainy, kind of like biscoff, with a bit of a strawberry swirl, and a small amount of cream and chocolate. It has a bit of that kind of snack-cakey preservative taste, like taking a Little Debbie cake and making it into an ice cream.
The horchata tastes nicely of cream, heavy cinnamon, and rice. Flavor-wise pretty good. Unlike the MPC, the horchata ice cream level was all the way to the bottom of the tub, making it the most solid of the bunch. Unfortunately, this results in quite a bit of ice crystals embedded inside.
Overall, the ice cream is reasonably thick - not as low overrun as a typical super premium, but much better than any grocery store ice cream. There's a bit of a light stretchiness, indicating the possible use of some stabilizers.
I hate to give this business only a 3 star rating, but they have some major issues that should not exist in a properly run ice cream shop: the tubs that are overfilled are melted while the tubs that don't have much left are icy. I went in expecting to visit this shop multiple times, and came out not wanting to go again.
As a side note: As one of the employees was scooping more ice cream onto the ice cream nachos for another customer, I saw her bangs getting into the ice cream. Seems like a safety/sanitary concern.
Bathrooms - None that I could see
Edit: After seeing the owner's response, I think I might have been a little too harsh on La Michoacana Artisan. The fact is, it's homemade ice cream in a small tourist town. Yes, there are problems, but comparing against standards for an artisan ice cream in larger cities isn't really a fair comparison. Considering most other options in the area serve commercial ice cream, it's definitely a business worth supporting, even if it's not up my alley. read more