Delish pizza - had the opportunity to try the Butter Chicken pizza! And the crust, one can tell that it's homemade! Service was great, as it was not too busy - which was sad as this space is amazing. read more

Low quality pizza. One other group was there and they were not getting pizza. They'll be ok being the only thing in town but I wouldn't pull off the highway for them. "Kourtney" left. read more

Our family loves this friendly little place. Have had a few small parties there. Owners are very nice. Food is good!

Pizza is decent. Good luck ordering anything but a one-topping pizza, though. No one here has bothered to learn any English, so an order of 2+ toppings on a pizza and they get confused and just give you whatever they want. Oh, and then the lady gets mad at YOU for THEIR mistake. If you decide to give it a try this summer, order to go. they either don't have AC or don't want to use it. read more

Ordered 30 mins before I got there. Said 5 more mins when I got there waited another 25. No one was there mind you. Horrible customer service. Got a beer while I waited was completely flat. Never again, going to mountain mikes from now on! read more

This place is delicious. Really solid pizza good service and decent prices, went here for the first time with my daughter and I was blown away. read more

Language is a problem here, made an order to go, they made it for dine in, ordered a plain cheeseburger with catchup and mayo only, get the order then went back to the house, the plain cheeseburger was cheese on a bun, I took it back and they couldn't get it right, had to explain 7 times, they still wanted to screw it up, now I know why there was not one soul in the place, will not be back even if it was the last place on earth! One pissed customer!!' When I returned to the house we started eating the burgers, we took one bite and spit it out, don't think it was even beef, looked like a phony burger, pure trash! If you are going to have hamburgers on your menu, you better know how to cook them and you should sell beef hamburgers, if it is something else like at this place you should let people know that it's NOT BEEF, they wouldn't even refund me, almost $40.00 for food thrown out! Oh do the fries look raw, they were! read more

Kourtney Kay's Sutter Cut Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Sutter, California

Fast service.ordered over the phone pizza was ready when I got there. Fair prices for really good food. Hidden gem in a small town. Go support them read more

Meh! Quality of ingredients and pizza went way down with latest owner. After several attempts to "give them a chance" fell out because of price and quality of their food is now a "no go" for us. read more

Love this pizza! Very friendly people and excellent food! We have had all of the pizzas and never disappointed. The brownie dessert pizza is a must! read more

We attending a baby shower in the "special event hall" at this Pizzeria. The Pizzeria provided several pizzas for the shower, and they were absolutely delicious. The combination pizza had plentifuly fresh toppings and the cheese they use has great flavor. I wish we lived close to this restaurant. I would definetely order from them again. read more

Appreciate the hospitality and the willing to go above and beyond for their customers. They were closed and I did not know. Luckily they were able to bake a pizza for my family after closing hours. Aside from being very hospitable, the pizza was delicious. Fresh ingredients and perfect, perfect crust. Definitely a staple of Sutter hospitality. read more

Quality ingredients, fantastic flavor, and the customer service was great! Everyone was friendly when we walked in to pick up our to go order. Also, their red sauce is delicious and I really liked their ranch! My favorite overall was the bbq chicken pizza. I'll crave this flavor. We will be back to support this small business! read more

See all

The food was not so good the last time I went in there there was barely any toppings and the customer service was terrible the pizza was under cooked and the cheese and toppings just slid right off. I don't think I'll be coming back to this pizzeria. read more

The food is wonderful and the service was great. If you want it customized, no problem.

Very tasty pizza - and so happy to have the quick, friendly service when visiting family in Sutter!

We have tried this pizza place several times and the pizza is not to our liking. The bottom is always too burned for us.

Out in the middle of no where in little Sutter. Found this while taking a little drive. Located just past dollar general. The best Italian pizza and excellent quality ingredients, that I have found in the area!!! A must try. Other pizza can fall short with their ingredients! Not here. The dough, ingredients, sauce and cheese are delicious! And full of flavor. Ordered the all meat pizza, with white sauce. read more

Prior to and during the Covid crisis my family has been eating here. The Calzones are our absolute favorite. Two calzones is enough to feed our family (2 adults and 3 children) and have some left over (unless we are little piggies and overindulge). ;) The flavors are fantastic and everything always seems fresh. I avoid dairy, but if I'm going to splurge and eat it, I am willing to suffer the consequences on this pizza....and that's saying something. yum! read more

Took a long walk on the bike trail in the rain and was thinking of pepperoni pizza. Where else do you go but the little town of Suttter's pizza place, Kourtney Kay's! If you haven't been, you need to go and during these crazy times they are still open making the most delicious pizzas. I am thrilled they choose Sutter to open their pizza place. read more

Kourtney Kay's Sutter Cut Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Sutter, California

We were headed to dawg house from Marysville only to find it was closed, we ended up at Kourtney Kay's for lunch with our pups. Pizza was great, staff was friendly and it was a nice change in pace from the typical pizza spots around us. Will be back for sure!! read more

Kourtney Kay's Sutter Cut Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Sutter, California

Great food and service. We got the Sutter cut pizza and it was great and so was the hot dog that we ordered. The hotdog was worth the price -- it had a nice bite in the casing and came with a spicy mayo and onions. They also have a nice variety of beers on tap such as Track 7 Panic IPA that they offer in pints or pitchers. Also it appears to be a family run business and it was heartwarming to see all hands on deck on a busy Saturday. I would eat here again next time I visit this area. read more

Garbage service and the people are rude as hell the only nice girl there they got rid of also way overpriced

It was a very sad night. We really try to support local businesses but we no longer will eat here. The people working were nice. Pizza was just ok. The top was not cooked long enough and was doughy. All your toppings fall right off. The kicker was the pricing. "The Facebook page is out dated". The menu on the wall was even wrong. Was told if we want accurate prices to call in. They no longer do all you can eat salad bar because of Covid. Apparently Covid doesn't stick to the serving spoons that everyone shares. Why not give a clean plate each trip. Charged 9.90 for a large salad (menu shows 8.99) that was a one trip only. Wish we would have known that. Seems pretty weird not to post and advertise your pricing. It's hot outside, I get it. It was 87 degrees inside with no lights on at 7. Trying to save money? I'm really trying to give them the benefit of the doubt and realize they just took over as new owners. My suggestion would be 1) cook your pizza thoroughly 2) Advertise your prices correctly 3) turn your ac on 4) Allow the all you can eat salad bar with clean plates each trip or just take it away and make the salad for people 5) don't be afraid to turn your lights on when customers are in the building. Best of luck. read more

Awesome pies! We had the Hawaiian, Pepperoni, and of course the Sutter Cut! The entire family said "best pizza ever"!!! Even better than Slyvios in Yuba City and we Slyvios!!! read more

The pizza here was delicious! They do not skimp on the cheese. The Sutter Cut is my fav!

This is now the second Owner of the Pizza Place. Neither one of them felt the need to take down the hanging baskets of dirt! Hanging outside. They have been there for years. If you are going to run a Business or especially a Restaurant you should at least clean up the front of your Restaurant. It is the first Impression that every single customer sees. If they don't pay attention to that. What else are they Ignoring. The girl taking my order was very rude. I questioned the price of my order. She told me the menus were wrong. That what she charged was the correct price. I don't mind paying for quality. I feel they have cheep ingredients on their Pizza and the items on the Salad Bar were old. I will not go back. read more

The owner does not care for the customers and has minimal standards for the food she and her family serves. The older employees that worked for the previous owner make great pizzas I have to judge this based on how the owner runs and cares for the business but the food made from the other employees are 5 star read more

The pizza is good... The fried ravioli is low quality. Good ranch dressing and salad bar, though. I really wish they would open up the bar, though. The owner told me they were not sure if it would be worth the expense for the liquor license and to "deck out" the bar. I'm not sure what "decking it out" means to him. I think, as someone who lives in sutter, a more country "dive bar" feel would draw more customers than a "sports bar" feel. A great way to test this would be to start a Happy Hour, right now, with just the beer on tap. See what kind of crowd it draws. The owner could get a better idea of their potential customer base. I suspect a bar would be a gold mine in this bored little town. I suspect a stocked bar, a classic style juke box with mostly older country and rock, a comfortable outdoor smoking section and a good happy hour would be exactly what this community needs. A karaoke night, or two would do great also. It would definately draw more customers. It would draw me and my husband and I'd likely invite my cousin and her husband from Live Oak. Also, a slow economy is great for small town bars. People need social interaction more than anything in times like that... Plus, we just came out of covid social distancing. I'm telling you, as a bar tender for many years, that place is a gold mine... Especially right now! read more