Consistently great ice cream and even better service! My go to is the medium fruity pebble udder,…read morewhich is like a large. Very generous portions. They use to be cash only but they now accept cards. You can also get pints to go! It's usually a long wait but it's worth it.

Always been a returning customer, really good ice cream. Only downside is if you don't beat the…read moreline that forms after a few minutes. Has a nice outdoor seating area, I mostly use the drive thru. Would 100% recommend

Absolutely delicious. This was my second visit. Both times I got a Twister in a small. Neither time…read morecould I finish the whole thing but gave it a good try. The quality of the ice cream and the toppings is great. The staff are friendly and patient as you try to choose from all the varieties. The cute patio is perfect for a summer evening. I can't wait to go and try more.

Sometimes I struggle with my reviews between giving a place a 4 or a 5 star rating but that is not…read morethe case here. This place is AWESOME! The quality ingredients and amazing flavor combinations will keep us coming back again and again. I wouldn't change a thing about this place.

Friendly staff! A friend recommended the pie freezer so we…read morewent with peach pie. Split it with my husband and we both enjoyed it!!! We were traveling from out of town so won't be frequenting but glad we were able to try it!!!

I ordered a blue raspberry and grape slushy with some chips. The people here are very nice and…read morehelpful. They have a large selection on the menu from pies, ice cream and some BBQ sandwiches. The wait was not long at all and overall service was great with no complaints at all.

Try the Black Raspberry ice cream, it's the best flavor! The staff are friendly. The store is a…read morenice, small, quiet place to take a break.

Definitely call ahead!! We were the only ones who showed up to place an order…read more Place was busy, but they seemed to be working hard to fill everyone's order as fast as they could. They have 6 - 8 booths inside and a picnic table outside for eating. Not sure of their history and how long they've been around, but this place looks and feels like it's an institution. We ordered 2 cheeseburgers and 2 small shakes for $21.00. The burgers and shakes were a good size and a good value for the price.

It was amazing!! The person who was there when my friend and I went was so kind and friendly!!…read moreDefinitely had lots of patience. I definitely will be coming back here whilst in college.

What a fun place on a small town square. With all the feel of days past, they serve up a great cup…read moreof coffee and have the option to get lots of treats! Syrup soda and ice cream goodies are all there for the enjoyment! The staff was super friendly and attentive, even when busy! I'll be back for sure! Recommended!

My grandparents live in Pleasantville, so we visit them often. We always make a stop at either…read moreCheckerboard or Dairy Shoppe, and today we chose Dairy Shoppe. The food is always delicious, and the staff is very friendly. The cozy and quaint atmosphere inside is a plus. Keep up the great work, Dairy Shoppe!

The most pleasant thing in Pleasantville is when the Dairy Shoppe opens…read more This place has the most magnificent tenderloin, they use Northcote Meats. This is perfectly breaded with a a perfect crunch. Plenty of meat that is a real tenderloin and not the ground up mystery meat pressed into a tenderloin kind. The best tenderloin in town. I also got a chocolate marshmallow shake which was super, the perfect balance of marshmallow and chocolate. Will definitely be back to the Dairy Shoppe!

We always enjoy a stop at Captain's Landing during our trips to the lake. Yummy food and delicious…read moreice cream!

I don't know if it's just the beginning of a new season or just the attitude of the teens working…read morehere. First I stood at the counter while all the workers walked away. Then one finally came back after 3 or 4 minutes and asked if I had been helped yet. The food came out fairly quickly but when you have to send back a simple sandwich twice to get the correct components it's frustrating. The sandwich was good and the fries a bit cold. Being it's the only game close, maybe they are just forgetting customer service? It could be that the very young staff just needs some experience. I would have appreciated a manager speaking to me after the 2nd time I had to send food back. I'm not sure who the manager is. They are all teenaged girls, dressed the same. I hung around writing this review and still no manager.

All the flavors were delicious, so I got them all! Haha…read more This is a great place to take the fam, the service is excellent and the establishment is clean and kid friendly. 10/10 will recommend and return again.

Can't go wrong with fro yo! Got really good flavors although it's not the biggest selection. It's a…read morelittle dark inside and kinda smells like an antique shop but don't let that deter you from getting a cup! Eat it quick though cuz it melts fast!

Looks like as of 03/04/2026 they are open for spring through fall of 2026…read moreI will update this with new menu pix and pricing soon

Great daily specials. Great malts Love their pizza burgers…read moretoo. Always a pleasant experience

Got a couple burgers, chili dog and cheese curds. Burgers were not great, chili dog was not great…read morebut the cheese curds were surprisingly good. Ice cream was standard.

Very slow service ,when you finally get you order the ice cream is melted and your hot food is…read morecold. Won't be returning to this DQ.