John's pizza is always great! Unfortunately, there was an oopsy on tonight's order. When I got home with my pizza, I realized it was not exactly what I ordered. I let them know about it because I went back to get another pizza without the pepperoni that was mistakenly added to my original pizza. Not only did they replace the pizza for me but also refunded me for the first one. I didn't ask for that and certainly didn't expect that, but they are good people. Not only is the food excellent at John's, their dedication to taking care of their customers is amazing! read more

Every time is a great time here. Best pizza, garlic rolls, and the best baked ziti bimut you have to get it with Ricotta. John, the owner is a great guy and always a pleasure to talk to. Tiramisu is homeade daily and a staple from John's family. The only one I eat. My pictures are ongoing for the place because I'm always there. Take out always busy, restaurant is clean, and the staff is perfect in front of or behind the counter. Same guys in the back for years. New Deerfield location is pretty good but the staple is on Flamingo read more

See all

I've heard a lot about this place so I was very eager to try it out. I placed the order on the phone for pick up. I ordered the hot honey pizza, large Caesar salad, and the grilled chicken and broccoli which comes with garlic rolls and a choice of veggies, pasta, or mini salad as a side. I went with the pasta. These have been the best garlic rolls I have ever had and the rest of the food was just as good! There's plenty of parking and the inside was clean with plenty of seating. It also has an open kitchen so you're able to see the food and cooking preparation process. I'm not sure about the sit down service but the customer service over the phone was not very friendly. read more

See all

I have to reduce my rating here. I am tempted to reduce it to three stars. I am not because they retain their great value and nice employees. I have eaten here twice in the past week and was not too happy either time. The house salad was very fresh and I like the ingredient combination. I ordered garlic rolls but ended up with bread that had a very faint taste of garlic. I like the garlic and the oil. None were given to me. I realized when I came home and did not want to go back. I checked to make sure all items were included but didn't think I had to check for garlic on the rolls. The lasagna is a family recipe that is over 60 years old. I am not sure I'd someone else is in the kitchen or if they changed an ingredient. I can say that the lasagna is very heavy and well worth what I spent. I just didn't care for the taste like I used to. It is not the same. I might go back and try a chicken parm meal or a sub. read more

See all

John The Baker has the best Garlic Bread ! Smothered in garlic and butter and so soft melts in your mouth. The place is quite busy and there was only one waitress Alice. She told us today was her first time working by herself. She did fantastic and was very friendly and upbeat. We heard she also works a second job. Kudos to her for having such a great attitude and work ethic. We all ordered pepperoni personal pan pizza. Came out fast and hot. Thin crust perfect. They don't serve pizza by the slice but their personal pizza was perfect size. Their menu consist of all the classic italian dishes and their Baked Ziti seems to be a popular one. I'll try next time. read more

See all

A tribute to honest craft and true hospitality. You just don't describe food--you honor a person, a place, and the tradition behind them. You can taste the lessons from Italy--simple ingredients, patient dough, village ovens--in every bite. Start with the must-have: the garlic bread rolls--pillowy, deeply garlicky, perfectly brushed. Then go straight to the house specialty, the "John the Baker" pizza: sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers. Add anchovies upon request for a bright, briny lift. Delicious is truly an understatement. A must-have. Warm, home‑feel ambiance--perfect for get‑togethers, small or large. A truly wonderful place to always come to again and again. Being my first time..its warming reception made it a chance to book my flight to Italy indeed! So grab your passport and head over for the realistic food of Italy you'll mouth watering flavors will always remember.. read more

See all

This place is a VERY solid family pizza place that has been in business forever. The pizza is excellent New York style. But what makes this place is the garlic rolls. Simply one of the best garlic rolls, I've ever had. I normally just get pizza at a restaurant. But whenever, I come here, I always get the pizza rolls as well. As mentioned, the pizza is great, anything you want, they can make, ps get the hot honey pepperoni. But you can't go wrong with any of the pizzas here. And what makes this place great as mentioned that it's a family business, and they truly make you feel like a part of the family. Definitely pass by here when you are in the area, or craving pizza. It is worth it alone for the garlic rolls! read more

How do you leave the main ingredient, a protein, off of a pizza? I ordered a pepperoni pizza and I had to make notes to add mushrooms and onions because you can only pick one topping. What I mentioned to them I think every time I order. So, you have to scroll like 37 times to get down to the notes - which I have also mentioned to them many times - to add other ingredients. I do not understand why when you order a pie there's not whole pizza toppings click here to customize half pizza toppings click here to customize quarter pizza toppings click here to customize... Again something I have mentioned to them many times. So my pizza showed up with way too many onions I could see some mushrooms, but essentially I had an onion pie I tasted no tomatoes, I tasted no garlic, both are supposed to be included in the John sauce. Super disappointing and frustrating again. We have eaten here or ordered from here for probably 25 years and we love to support small businesses. I don't know if there's no training going on with new employees or no quality control like a manager hovering, watching and tasting and looking at orders before they leave, but this has gotten ridiculous. read more

I had food from here back I. High school like 20 years ago but we had not come back and man o man this place is just the perfect pizza place. The garlic rolls are huge and juicy and the pizza is full of flavor. Love that the portions are good and that we have left overs. The service is great from the door attending us quickly to the waiter being the most nicest and energetic. She refilled our drinks constantly and cleared things off the table with ease. I liked how she started a conversation with my son about monster jam how he was wearing a shirt. Glad we picked this place for lunch. I don't know if I have room for dessert but yeah thanks to the @CubanCulinaryJourney for reviewing this place and this place just being amazing. They play music and they clean up quick after each group to have a quick turn around. That's awesome. read more

See all

If you are looking for a solid Italian restaurant, this is the choice. Prices are reasonable, food is good, service is friendly and good, restaurant is clean. If you want to spend more just because of going downtown or the beach, go ahead, spend more, but you will not have made a better choice. read more

me and my husband live just around the corner from john the baker. the lunch is a little bit cheaper then the dinner. the galric rolls and the cheese bake ziti is the bomb. must get it with the ricotta cheese. so so filling. the staff is so amazing. so helpful. clean setting. but only down fall is at time it gets a little cold inside due to the oven of cooking i guess. read more

Baked ziti was bland, no ricotta cheese in it. Just cheese, a bland red sauce, and pasta. The inside is awesome! And the pizza looked good! Rolls did not have any garlic on them. read more

Garlic rolls are amazing, pink sauce pasta was great. Meat balls not good and pizza mediocre. Not going back. This was at the Deerfield beach location. Sorry owner but you need to do better. read more

I was in the mood for pasta and hadn't had in a while. I ordered for take out. Chicken parm with pasta as a side. It was good. I would have preferred more garlicky spice but it did the job. I was surprised that it was $19 and some change. It came with 3 garlic rolls. I will probably make it on my own next time. read more

John The Baker - Chicken parmigiana - Pizza Near Me - Pembroke Pines, Florida

I redownloaded yelp just to give this place 5 stars. Food was marvelous and prices were great. Would 100% come back here again. Every part of this experience went way more than well. read more

John The Baker - Leftovers - Pizza Near Me - Pembroke Pines, Florida

Amazing pizza!! Such a warm and lovely place. The rolls are amazing! I definitely recommend

I love John The Baker. I first came here due to an intense pizza craving and needed a place nearby to satisfy that craving stat! Uber Eats led me the John the Baker and baby let me tell you John and I have been besties ever since. I usually order to go but today was my first time dining in, so I can finally speak on the service. Service is also great! But let me tell you what really keeps me coming back...the rollsssssssss. The garlic rolls are hands down thee best I've ever had anywhere including NYC. Buttery, pillowy, soft, garlicky perfection. What I love most about them is they do not put chopped garlic on the rolls like many places do. They use a housemade garlic oil. So the bread is still intensely garlic tasting but not offensively so. Ladies this means you can still kiss your man even after eating a half dozen by yourself (don't ask me how I know, mind ya business). The pizza is also good. I don't love the pizza nearly as much as the rolls but it's still good pizza. And it's reasonably priced! I haven't yet tried their non-pizza dishes but I def have my eye on the baked ziti. I will be trying that on my next visit. read more

See all

John the Baker never disappoints. The service is consistently great, friendly, attentive, and fast without feeling rushed. The chicken parm is always on point, perfectly cooked with rich sauce and just the right amount of cheese. And the garlic rolls absolutely hit the spot every time. Warm, buttery, and impossible to stop eating. One of those places you keep coming back to because it's reliable and done right. read more

I've been coming here for years & the quality of their food has never changed. Whether it's a delicious pasta dish, a good ol' chicken parm sub or some mouth watering pizza, you can't go wrong. The ingredients they use are super fresh & if you're dining in or taking out the food is usually prepared within a reasonable time. They run a special on Tuesday's where you can get a large 16" for only $12.99. Considering prices have gone up everywhere, I really think it's reasonable for the quality you get. You won't find a better pie in the area. Service is always good. The employees are friendly & do a good job at managing the crowds. I haven't had many issues with the food, but the few times there were mishaps they've always done a great job at making sure I was satisfied in the end. Good customer service goes a long way & that's another reason why I'll keep coming back. If you have a delicious entrée you might as well end it with some dessert & I highly recommend the cannolis; they're some of the best I've ever had. The sweet ricotta that they're filled with is out of this world. The shells are always the perfect texture which really complete them. Be sure to grab 1... or 5. Life's too short to skip out on dessert! read more

John The Baker - Large Sausage/Mushroom Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pembroke Pines, Florida

If you're on the hunt for a place that feels like a comforting hug and dishes out flavor. John the Baker is our go-to for reliable, delicious Italian eats with a side of family warmth. Each dish tastes homemade. Dine-in, takeout, or delivery - they're all about making life easier, and tastier. Don't miss out on their Pasta e Fagioli soup - it's a delicious must-try! And, oh, the garlic rolls are absolutely yummy. On a recent visit, our Chicken Parm sub had a slight burn, but guess what? It was still bursting with flavor! A small glitch won't keep us from returning. John the Baker truly nails the blend of reliability and flavor. Highly recommended! read more

See all

We come here for the ROLLS!! This place makes amazing garlic rolls and they stay fresh into the next day. We have come here since my kids were young, the vibe of the restaurant is very old school pizzeria, it's always busy which is a great thing. Although they are busy the service is always good, we are greeted when we arrive, and acknowledge when we leave. 10/10. They have a variety of pizza options and Italian food but we always go for the Margherita. Prices depend on what size pie you want $11-21. Nothing we have had has been disappointing. Definitely a go to for good old Italian pizza. read more

Excellent New York style pizza. I've been coming here for 25 years. I am sure that I have written a review. Possibly it was written for a different location. John the Baker is located in the Fresh Market Plaza. It is a small location but they have plenty of seating. The staff are very proficient in dealing with large crowds. They move out the pizza and pasta dishes faster than any Italian place that I know. The food is always hot and the quality is consistent. Don't expect too much as far as decor. It is relatively simple but watching the show between the staff and the pizza makers makes up for any fancy decorations. The place is not quiet. Sometimes it can be hard to hold a descent conversation. Most important, the pizza is great, the meatballs are good and their cannoli are the best. I love that they fill the cannoli to order. Many people love their garlic rolls. While they are good, lately I like a small basket of crusty bread instead. Back when this was located in the Walmart plaza, I had a few of my children's birthday parties at John the Baker. Everyone left happy and they let us bring our own cake and party supplies. This is a family owned place that has a regular following. read more

Absolutely the best Italian food in South Florida. I highly recommend them. Great service too!!!

Come for the garlic rolls, stay for the incredible baked pastas. I didn't bury the lede here. Seriously, my parents come here just for the baked ziti and it's incredible. I branch out on occasion and recently got the chicken Parmesan (which is brave for me since I make a great one at home), and for a side of spaghetti. It was al dente which is unheard of at most places and made me so happy. My husband got a mushroom ravioli (also Al dente) and got it baked with mozzarella on top and devoured it. The youngest of the group subsisted off garlic rolls and a side order of meatballs. Service was super fast and cordial. Came here after a Canes game and all the tvs had other games on so I could catch up and I really appreciated that. Life hack: since you'll have enough for leftovers, bring home a garlic roll and put your chicken cutlet or meatball or sausage inside and eat like a slider. Freaking game changer! read more

Our server was very nice and was hustling around to all the tables. We got complimentary garlic rolls which came out warm and had lotsss of garlic. Food also came out quickly and was decent. The restaurant has a good amount of seating for eating in. But I saw a lot of people doing carry out as well. read more

John The Baker - Chicken parmesan - Pizza Near Me - Pembroke Pines, Florida

See all

Great food, staff are super nice. Large portions and the garlic rolls are to die for. Pizza is great, white heat is my favorite

food is great, staff is very nice, however it is the second time that my takeout order was missing an item, they are super nice about it, except that maybe they should figure out how to maybe use a food delivery service to bring the item out to the customer. I may give it one more try, not a good track record so far, however what we did receive was great. read more

John the Baker is a staple must have for my family and I when we visit South Florida. We are never disappointed and look forward to our next visit when we leave. read more

The garlic rolls were rather small, but the personal pizza was good. The service wasn't bad and they were nice.

I use to go to the various John the Baker for years before I moved out of area and since returned. Being from Both Boston and NJ I always craved for a real pie. This has always been the real deal. Thin crust, super crispy, incredible flavor and served piping hot. Had a salad and garlic roll which were extremely fresh, garlicky and not overly buttery. Great atmosphere and super friendly service not to mention meticulously clean. read more

Great food - Nasty servers. All the food here is good and the Garlic Rolls are the best anywhere. Good lunch specials, but the daytime servers are nasty people who think they are doing you a favor by serving you. Our little group has been going there for years. The older/experienced servers are fine. But they have some younger people and this is obviously their first job in the food service industry. They are just rude. If you want good food at fair prices and don't care about service, this is a great place for lunch. read more

I went to John The Baker not expecting much. I must say, I was surprised how satisfying it ended up being, but with a few bumps. First off, I loved the John's sauce plain cheese pizza. But, it had WAY too much cheese, albeit with the right snap and stretch. The pizza was saved by an incredibly good, crispy thin crust and a zesty tomato sauce. Good chew to the crust, too. I also got some garlic rolls with my order which were like crack; the more you ate them, the more you wanted them. Full-on garlic and dough nirvana. Those rolls alone will have me coming back. Finally, I had the veal parmigiana with ziti. Besides the 3 garlic rolls it came with, the rest of the entree was underwhelming and bordered on awful. The veal came as a whole cutlet filet, not cut up, which is a major plus. But, it was like shoe leather with a thick, mushy breading. The cheese & sauce were the best part...and the rolls! The ziti was overcooked and mushy. Next time, I'm sticking to pizza & those memorable garlic rolls read more

See all

Pizza was fantastic. 8.4 on the scale. Busy on the weekends but quick service anyways. Feels like a pizza shop through and through inside. Would and will be back. read more

John The Baker - Sausage and Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Pembroke Pines, Florida

The food was amazing, the employees were extremely helpful and were willing to cater to our class for free. The environment felt comfortable and overall delicious food!!- Mrs.Cabreras Class read more

The reviews did not lie. The garlic knots were buttery and full of flavor. The bacon cheese pizza was served crispy...as we ordered. We are from home of New Haven pizza and this was just as good! Daniel, our waiter, was very friendly and helpful. Head here for a true Italian experience read more

Best pizza in this area. I usually go to the LA Fitness nearby to workout and typically go over to Fresh Market and one day, while walking through, I noticed the longest line outside of this restaurant. I immediately looked for it in yelp and begged my boyfriend and brother to accompany for a large pie of cheese so we can try it. The large cheese pizza didn't last a second :( I was only able to have one slice and then when the panthers playoffs were going on we ordered a couple of pies for the family. Everyone has completely raved about this pizza and the delicious pizza that it is! Do not fall for false reviews or Debbie downers. If you like NY Style slices and enjoy a simple delicious slice, please come try this place. My grandfather is Sicilian and he grew up making pizza in New York. (So I may have some flavor credentials) Give it a try. read more

So many Bakers, so many claims, but let's make a distinction, this is the "One". The Italian food is family & homemade. I say even the pizza is good. The absolute star, is the over the top garlic rolls, start with them and enjoy all the rest of the menu. Waitress was super friendly and attentive. The location is clean & large, but popular and can get busy at dinner time. read more

I have been coming here for years with the family. It's abit of a drive from Miami but well worth it. John and Patty are here often watching over everything. They use top notch ingredients in everything they make and you can taste the difference from the first bite. Food-wise I'm going to mention a couple of items that I really like though I encourage you to to come and check out whatever you like. Salad - I like John's single salad with their house vinagrette. Very traditional Italian style. Garlic Rolls -- Get these with extra garlic. You must get them. You wll need them and don't forget to take some home. Pizza - We prefer John's sauce which is chunkier with more vibrant flavors and sometimes we get ours well-done. - OH HEAVEN! Ravioli - OMG, so good! And the tiramisu....so memorable! Try John the Baker once you will be hooked! read more

Best pizza in town. Just ordered two dozen of their famous garlic rolls with baked ziti, chicken and salad. All were hot and ready to eat. Easy restaurant location at Flamingo Rd and Sheridan St. They make togo orders very simple. Lots of locals eat here. Staff is very friendly and a clean place. read more

See all

First time having dinner here and we normally have a little Italian restaurant near our house. NO MORE since we dined at John the Baker. !!! A small salad was big enough for us to share, my baked ravioli filled with short rib meat was super. Never would have thought of that but way to John !! Garlic rolls were big as Cat Head Biscuits and the whole meal for the 2 of us was more than generous and enough for dinner tonight. JOHN THE BAKER is our new best Italian restaurant. Thank you read more