As advertised, they were "freaky fast,"super friendly and polite and the food was great. I ordered an extra large sandwich so I could have it across two meals while traveling, and it worked out perfectly. Certainly not the fault of the local establishment, but I wish that Jimmy John's still had their spicy brown "Jimmy mustard." read more

Good subs. Poor service. I guess Saturday is teenagers running the show? They just wanted to fool around on their phones and talk to their friends who came in. Couldn't be bothered to make our food properly - uncooked bacon on the sandwiches, none of the extra toppings that were requested. The young boy was handling the computer with the same gloves he turned and made food with. Not impressed. Guess I'll have to check who is working before ordering in the future. read more

I like their sandwiches and visit every week with coworkwrs. I haven't reviewed this establishment until now. I like their quick service and fresh food. read more

Without a doubt the worst Jimmy John's I've ever had the displeasure of visiting. 0 stars if I could. JJ's is known for fast. Not here folks. On a Saturday at 3p with no one in front of you, you'd think 2 girls could make one sandwich in under 10 minutes, but boy was I wrong. They were too busy chatting it up with personal BS. Kudos to the one who said "hurry up and finish that sandwich" to Blondie. That's not it, I ordered a Vito with no onions, pretty simple right? Wrong again. She made sure to put onions on there, way too much fatty pork, and MAYO?! It's supposed to be "hand-sliced salami, capocollo, & provolone cheese on French bread, topped with fresh-sliced lettuce, tomato, oil & vinegar and oregano-basil (hold the onions)." I don't normally complain about getting too much, but why was this sandwich 8 pounds? Overboard on the meat train. Onions I can take off, but MAYO?! This is a hate crime on a Vito. I still have PTSD and feel nauseas just thinking ablegh *vomit* These people should be fired, or at least be sent back to sandwich school, Blondie clearly didn't graduate and has no business "working" here. Thanks for wasting my $10. read more

last two times we ordered two sandwiches it's taken of 45 min. new management need badly

37 mins for 2 sandwiches Freaky slow!!!! Do not come here on your lunch break. Go to the next location Go anywhere else read more

Walked in and was told it would be 20-30 minutes for a SANDWICH!!!! I asked why and he said they had a lot of online orders. Last I checked you should serve customers in store first! This covid has people delivering awful service!! read more

This is the worst JJ I've ever been in. They ran out of bread!!!!. I waited in there 1/2 hr and still no bread. Another customer in there said this is the 2nd time thats happened there. Save yourself a headache and go elsewhere. read more

This is the most chaotic sub place I've been in. The manager is screaming and yelling down the line with multiple customers in store. Subs are being left at the pickup they all seem very confused and disorganized. I've been waiting for the last 20 minuets for a sub, this place is an absolute mess. read more

After a disappointing experience at Just LeDoux It, we left there without eating and were terribly hangry. In search of fast food @8:30 pm on Fri night and found Jimmy John's lights on. Hooray! Our sandwiches were prepared quickly and as ordered. This place saved us and "Undouxed" a bit of our bad dining experience earlier. JJ earned our patronage. read more

Freaky Fast delivery is definitely not this stores motto... over an hour wait, and they didn't get the order right. Extremely disappointed by our experience. Should have taken our business elsewhere. read more

Can we get a "NO Star" rating option? Sad example of Jimmy Johns. Skip the rude little snots and go somewhere else in Sheridan. Placed my order for 2 sandwiches to go, one with the oil and vinegar on the side. Told they couldn't do that and had no containers. When I pointed out the sleeve of to go containers for the sauces for other things, they gave in. When they gave me my order, they just dropped the sandwiches in the counter. No bag, no napkins, no thank you. Asked for a bag which the little snot just tossed the bag toward me. Sandwiches were supposed to have extra hot peppers, actually located 3 rings on one and 4 on the other. Meat seemed much smaller portions than other JJs. Do not waste your time and money here. There are many places in Sheridan that are better by far. read more

The food was good and as aspected, but the service was really struggling. Lots of unprofessional goofing off, and the girl taking our order was really distracted, didn't greet us upon entering, and even turned to talk to another employee while I was mid-order. The space looked really clean however! The service could definitely use some professionalism. read more

This is like a Subway but with good quality products and good service, but it can NOT be compared to a PICKLE BARREL in any way! The sandwich is almost the same size but the portions are ALOT less at about 25% of what a Pickle barrel is! Once you've had a pickle barrel EVERYTHING else isnt even close! read more

Jimmy John's - Alot less than what I'm use too! - Sandwiches Near Me - Sheridan, Wyoming

I am shocked this place has such a low rating. I pretty much have quit going to Subway even though they have more variety for 2 reasons. First, their ingredients are consistently better. Second, you can get a sandwich almost instantly, whereas going the line in Subway takes at least 3 times as long and often more. You can't make up your own sandwich like you can here, but you will have a sandwich in hand in 1-2 minutes, and they ingredients will be top notch. Staff appear to mostly be friendly college age students, who are nice enough. For the person who wrote a bad review, get real, these kids are working fast food. The person who disappointed you likely worked there for a few months and either went back to school or got a different job. Fast food workers come and go and if you want fancy service, look for a place with a white table cloth... read more

Rude and loud employees. Ordered sprout- had to go ask for them even though they were on the ticket and found two long black hairs on my sandwich. Overall horrible experience. read more

Great tasting sandwiches friendly staff clean and quick service best subs and clubs i have had will definitely go back

My motel is 3 miles away from here and it's "too far of a drive for delivery, that's all the way across town." Like Sheridan is a big city. Boooooo. read more

I ordered an 8 inch tuna sub at 12:06 pm. The girl I spoke too on the phone said the were busy and it would be about 20 minutes if that was okay. I told her I got an hour so 20 minutes wasn't that big of a deal. At 11:01 I finally got my sandwich. The driver apologized for being almost an hour late. I went against my good judgement and accepted the sandwich, mainly because I hadn't had breakfast. He didn't offer to drop the $2.50 delivery charge. I am only at the most 2 minutes away. I took the3 sandwich to the break room and to my surprise, it was not freakishly fresh but was horribly stale and it was hard to even choke down. After three bites, I called the store back and they gave me to a manger who tried to argue with me about the time even thought it was on the receipt and said he was there when I spoke to the male employee who said would be at least twenty minutes. (I spoke to a young girl) Then sarcastically he asked, "What do you want me to do about it?" I was hesitant to call them to begin with because I think there delivery charge is a joke, however I can say for certain I wont be calling them anymore. read more

This was my first visit to a Jimmy John's. Pennsylvanian passing thru Wyoming. I liked it- tried a #1 with sprouts. I liked their bread better than Subway's bread and I'm a Subway fan and regular customer. But, like a previous review stated, it's a sandwich shop like Subways. Has cute sayings on the wall to read as you eat. Some Do's and Dont's and the one I liked was...If you Do what you did, you get what you got ! read more

I can't really complain about this place. The food is good, reasonable price for the food, and the workers are very professional about what they do. I get food from there all the time, and I have enjoyed it every time. I just wish the delivery distance was bigger. read more

I am not sure how Jimmy Johns could have gotten as little tuna on the sandwich. Instead of calling it a tuna sandwich, they should all it a tuna "smear". Plenty of profit in that sandwich...all cheap lettuce, a Super thin strip of tomato, and a very thin strip of cucumber...all lettuce and bread. $24 for a lettuce sandwich, one very skimpy Vito, 3 bags of chips and 3 regular cokes...not good value for the $$$. read more