I had some time to kill so I figured a late lunch/early dinner wouldn't hurt. I placed my order via the app and it was ready before the pickup time. Always a plus! Due to it being ready early, I was able to eat in. I ordered a #7 in a bowl with mikes way, no onion and extra pickle with bacon. It was made perfectly. It was clean inside. The bathroom was also clean, however it had a terrible odor. Staff were also friendly. I'd return to this location again. As I was eating my lunch a rush of people came in and the staff took care of everyone efficiently and quickly. read more

Ordered lunch for my family. 3 sandwiches and one for a very picky eater who HATES mayonnaise. I ordered via the app and everything was done quickly. However when we got home we saw that THE one sandwich had mayo all over it. All the other sandwiches were fine. I called and a very respectful employee named Jon answered the phone. He took accountability and immediately asked to rectify the situation. In this world that is rare and very appreciated. Jon is a great employee, he was expeditious, courteous and exemplified great customer service skills, especially for the food industry. The food here is always fresh and tastes great. Jons handling of the error ensures we would continue to come back. read more

Food is always good and service usually is, except tonight! Ordered three heros each with specific items, each employee apparently has a specific job first hero, meat&cheese, next the toppings and last is cashier. Cashier was asking for money before i was even done with my order, felt hurried, had to ask what total was, since paid with $100 but told me my change and didn't even give me my receipt, which I believe he short changed me if what total he did say, eventually . Usually tip but, smh. Oh and miss labeled the bags and someone else took a bite out of my sandwich. Id like to return, but guys let's not rush people all which could have been avoided if stuck to the process! read more

Another quick and filling meal for my family in the burbs. Good choice for a nice easy lunch. Combo meal comes with a drink and small bag of chips. Service was good and they made all of our subs as ordered with specific toppings on each. As far as fast food goes this is also a healthier option. read more

Big selection food was real good. Fresh and cooked to my liking. Cold cuts are fresh and hot sandwiches are also very good. Plenty of sizes to pick from read more

It boggles my mind how Jersey Mike's has such mediocre reviews!!! My go-to are the #10 tuna sub and the #5 super sub. Both are always amazing and I tend to get the "giant" so they last me for a few meals. I usually get the tuna with extra mayo because I found it can tend to be a little dry otherwise. I can't believe giving them less than a 4 star rating! read more

Place is garbage! Ran by idiots who cant get an order correct at all! When I complained they are rude and tried blaming me! LOL Not my problem you couldn't finish high school, moron! read more

Did a mobile order in for my Collegiate Bowling team so I could pick up on way to airport. Said would be ready at 2:05 pm and didn't leave store until 2:40. We get to airport and go to hand out food and we were missing sandwiches. Very disappointing because I have always had great experiences at other stores around the country. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - We were missing the number 13's - Fast Food Near Me - Selden, New York

Going to start off this review by saying I am skeptical of most cookie cutter sandwich chains, but I have to be honest here, this location is really good. My family and I have become huge fans of Jersey Mike's. We have had hot and cold subs and each and every time they've been delicious and made to perfection. We always place our order in advance and it is always freshly made and ready when we arrived. We used to only go to homerun heroes, but now jersey mikes is our go to for all things subs. read more

They got my whole order completely wrong it's a bunch of kids working in there they were clueless

After a visit to the Selden location today, all I can say is think twice before coming to this location. When asked a simple question the server behind the counter answered rudely and rolled her eyes as if she could not be bothered to attend to a paying customer. When I asked a follow-up question she again rolled her eyes and refused to answer me. When I asked for her name, she refused to answer me. The manager, Brandon, came out to assist. Upon trying to speak to him, he also refused to give me her name and his as well. I asked for their names because I wanted to make a formal complaint to the company. Then, he threw my sandwich against the wall and said you are not getting anything here and told me to get out. Then they called the police because I would not leave without their names. I did receive a call from the owner the same day, which was professional and she apologized for the way my son and I were treated. Unfortunately, this was an upsetting experience today.​ read more

Ordered sandwiches online and got notification they were ready. Go to the store and was told they are not ready and I had to wait another 5-7 minutes. After 15 minutes they asked me if I was there to pick up another order. So I waited 25 minutes to pick up an online order. Then I get home and they forget cheese on one of my sandwiches. Terrible service. read more

Took my 91 year old mother here for lunch April 11, 2024. The sandwiches were great but the kind hearts and kind words of the staff were the highlight of our of our visit, they made my Mom's day and put a smile on her face. Thank you! read more

Though the food is good the service at this location is always not very good! The staff seems to be all teenagers with no management on site ever! read more

Unsatisfactory does not begin to define the experience we had with Jersey Mike's Selden location. On Father's Day we ordered 5 sandwiches via the delivery option on the Jersey Mike's app. We only received 4 of the sandwiches we ordered and paid for, and immediately called the Selden location. The individual who identified themselves as the shift manager refused to deliver the sandwich that they had forgotten claiming, "it's out of our hands." No satisfactory alternatives were offered by the Jersey Mike's shift manager. One hundred percent do not recommend. read more

Ordered a #26 and a #17, 26 was requested with no tomato and the 17 was requested without peppers and onions (due to a health issue). The 26 was made correctly while the 17 was filled with peppers and onions. read more

Over priced . $17. For a tuna sub !!! It's not lobster, its plain tuna out if the can with no toppings . Next time I feel like burning money I won't go to Jake's casino I'll just waste it on jerseys Mike's sub. At least the bread was soft. read more

Excellent costumer service . A bit crowded but loved the Philly cheese steak . Will definitely be back . The staff here is awesome !!!

Came and ordered Italian hero and then the guy asked the man behind me what he was getting to eat he was getting 2 heroes with none of the meat that I was getting at all. The guy proceeded to make this man's two sandwiches ask him what he wanted on the sandwiches and then rang the man up. Then came to me and asked me what I wanted on my sandwich. How can I order before this guy and the guy make the other person's food before me. It should be first come first serve as every place does. Shouldn't of paid a dollar for my sandwich after that. read more

Do not go this store by 8:30pm when closing is 9:00pm. Staff is shutting everything down, cannot sit down and eat or use the restroom. Pathetic!! You can order but don't get there when you see the tables and chairs moved to one side of the store. That's a wrap!! I will never ever visit this store again!! read more

One of the girls made my sandwich then passed down the line the young guy at the registered just finished giving someone there change back then used the same glove to package my sandwich up I told that wasn't cool his response SUFFOLK county bird health allows it, my response was even if they allow its not cool your gloves are now dirty and you used the same dirty gloves to touch my food read more

Piece of garbage place. Order 3 sandwiches tonight and one was missing when we got home. Called the store for over 30 minutes until some incompetent person answered. They stated the sandwich never was put in the bag. No explanation no nothing. read more

Not the best cheesesteak sandwich, but not the worst either. The meat did not look like steak...it looked like ground beef. The hero roll was fresh and soft. The peppers tasted fresh also, with a nice slight tenderness...not too mushy and not too raw. The cheese sauce was very salty...and I usually like salt, but this was too much. I will stick with Firehouse Subs in Centereach. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Cheesesteak...looks like ground beef, not steak. - Fast Food Near Me - Selden, New York

Needs more choices of vegetables, was very limited, yet the guys made a decent sandwich

Food is always fine there but very unorganized. I ordered a large hero (box) and an individual small hero a few days before a party with a set time to pick it up. When my son when to pick it up, they had no clue about it and had to use my paid receipt to make the sandwiches right then. It took them 30 mins and they only gave me the 1 box with the smaller sandwich mixed in the same box - unlabeled. So we had to open each sandwich to search for the one different sandwich and we were shorted 1 hero. I went back 2 days later to talk to a manager who was not available. They took down my number to have them call me and I never heard from them. They still owe me a sandwich, but I will not be going there again. read more

Came here today and got a Meatball sub regular size with a bag of Miss Vickie's Smokehouse BBQ chips and a fountain soda, of which I chose their special root beer. The sub was good, with a good amount of meat and cheese on it, and was a fairly big size. The chips and drink were downright amazing! They have a great selection of chips here. Would come again, thanks. read more

I have been the biggest fan of Jersey Mike's subs since 2018, that's when I first got introduced to this place by a friend. However, it was a different location. fast forward a few years and I've been venturing to this location for about two years now. For the last year coming here has been a nightmare. Several times they've gotten my order incorrect or were lacking a product and did not communicate it until I said something. Most recently when I complained about my order being incorrect, there was such a nonchalant attitude about it. They were unapologetic and even left to the back without a single word. I'm not a loud person or rude and it takes a lot for me to even speak up, so it was disturbing how quick they were to ignore me and there were about 4 employees available and none cared. Following the last visit, I wrote a comment to Jersey Mike's through there App, where it indicated that they would reach out to the store and someone would reach out to me, but I haven't heard anything back since. It's clear that management or the person that oversees this store does not care. I don't experience this at any other location. It's truly sad because this is the most convenient location to visit. I would wholehearted avoid this location, it was not a one time issues, but several over a set period of time. Hopefully they get better, but in the meantime I don't recommend going here.. I know I will not be venturing to this location any time soon. read more

I ordered the BLT medium hero with extra bacon for an additional $2.75. I received the BLT with four slices of bacon so thinly cut where is the extra bacon . I tried to call and it's a non working number (631 538-1983 ) in total the sandwich cost me $14.00 had I known they where going to play me I would have purchased the grocery to make a BLT myself. This was my first time I trying Jersey Mike' s and this will be the last time . It's a shame how these restaurants rip people off with poor quality. I'm going to start meal prepping to save some money and eating healthier. It's so disappointing when you're wasting money . read more

Food poisoning after having #13 don't go there obviously not keeping the food up to temp disgusting

As I was walking into this location to order I witnessed a female staff member reach into the back of her pants, adjust her underwear (I suppose) and walk behind the counter. Disgusting! I walked back to my car and proceeded to the Port Jeff location. Not something you ever wanna see, especially from someone preparing your food. read more

The last time I was at a location was over 20 years ago as a member of the Air Force reserves. If I remember correctly, I think it was on the jersey turnpike. The place has a nice vibe and the workers asking trivia questions for free cookies is fun. The subs come in 3 sizes: mini (which is probably 3-4 inches), regular (somewhere around 8-9 inches), and a giant(around 15"). I had the cheesesteak. When I saw the size of the regular I had to unfortunately go up to the giant and try to stomach the fact of paying $14-15 for one hero. The taste was very good but the pricing is completely out of whack in today's economy. The regular was around $8.50 but a little too small for probably most with an adult appetite. If this was a footlong like Subway, this would easily be a 4.5 but for the price, it's a 3. read more

After all the hullabaloo about this place I decided to try it. Needless to say, the sandwiches were all overpriced and nowhere in comparison to what the photos showed of what you were suppose to be getting. I purchased the giant italian sub for my husband as the regular was too small for what would be considered a full size hero. The giant ended up being 2/3 shredded lettuce and barely any meat and cheese for over $14.00!!! They should be ashamed of themselves for making a product so inferior. I will continue to go to the best place for a hero sandwich that gives you 4 times the amount of meat & cheese for $8-9.00 for a footlong sub. And that place is Campus Heroes in Rocky Point on 25A, just east of Broadway. Hands down for the money, taste and value, you won't find a better hero. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Now THIS is what a sub should look like....notice the meat to lettuce ratio.....this NOT a Jersey Mike's hero. - Fast Food Near Me - Selden, New York

Defiantly not subway, just anotherJersey Mike with sandwich's at Jersey Mike prices. I'm so glad this place finally opened! There hasn't been another good hero place in the area since Corner Hero's closed down. Also, for a new place they really outdid themselves for service, unlike cough* cough* corner hero's replacement...(pst* the service there is slow). read more

We actually order from Jersey Mike's pretty frequently in my house and we use this location. I'm always very pleased with how our sandwiches are made and that they're always made on time when I order from the app (and I order this way a lot). Your order can become pricey (depending on the size of the sandwich and any add ons you might include), but I'm alright with paying a little bit more because their sandwiches are delicious. The staff are always smiling and courteous. I'm very pleased. read more

Horrible. Worst food and service I have ever experienced!! My steak sandwich was raw and bloody. When I went back in to return it I was given an attitude. I then was given a receipt showing the refund amount for the whole combo since I returned the chips and everything. Later looking at my bank account I see they changed the refund amount and only refunded me the sandwich. When I called I was given a stupid response by the owner who acts like a child and is not able to handle customer satisfaction properly. I how have to call corporate fue to lack of competent ownership and management. Needless to say it is definitely one place I will bece go again. read more

Ordered food on line ... waited till 10min after the order was supposed to done. I ordered 4 giant sandwiches. i went inside to pick up order and it wasn't ready. I had to wait inside another 40min for my food. There were other people going in and out with their food. I asked a couple of times when my food was going to be ready. Horrible customer service !!!!!!!! No one even apologized. read more

I wanted 2 try out this place and thought it would be a step above Subway....it wasn't. Very disappointed. My meal was not only expensive but also very bready. They do not offer mozzarella cheese...I gave it 3 stars because the young man behind the counter was so polite. read more

Almost every location is stingy with their meat! Paid 17 dollars for a giant sandwich and it was sprinkled with chicken! Step up your quality and quantity! read more

Tremendously delicious. I go there weekly and find the bread softer than any sub competition. Cold cuts are the tastiest and service is outstanding. Each employee I have interacted with has gone above and beyond to make it an enjoyable visit for me. There are different sizes, I prefer the Giant (largest). The shore points system allows you to spend toward free sandwiches and coupons can be emailed to you. What are you waiting for? Go there already read more

Worst cheesesteak ever!!! Figured a Jersey sub shop would do a better job. So close to Philly yet so far away. Tasted like steak ums and green peppers. So bad. Went back To try an Italian. Nothing special at all and WAY OVERPRICED. Why go here when you can go to any deli and get a better sandwich at a better price. out. read more