Jersey Mike's Subs

Hands down the best sandwiches in Caldwell--no question about it. Dave's Delicious Deli lives up to…read moreits name with every bite. The ingredients are always fresh, the portions are generous, and the flavor? Out of this world. You can tell they take pride in every sandwich they make. But what really made my visit unforgettable was the incredibly kind service. One of the women working there offered me a free can of soda, just as a thoughtful gesture. It's that kind of small-town kindness that makes you want to come back again and again. If you haven't been to Dave's yet, you're seriously missing out. This place is a gem.

Sad to see that Dave's has closed! We've had the sandwiches here a few times and although we're not…read morefrom the area it's always our top option when in the area. Their eggplant sandwich was just perfect - tangy, saucy and highly flavorful!

Dave's Delicious Deli - Our MegaItalian sandwich. Ham, hot ham capi, salami, pepperoni, and provolone. This one is topped with everything, and roast peppers.

Our MegaItalian sandwich. Ham, hot ham capi, salami, pepperoni, and provolone. This one is topped with everything, and roast peppers.

Homemade white pasta fagioli soup. Seasoned with garlic and fresh herbs. Served with toasted bread for dipping.

See all

Eggplant, garlic roast peppers, red onion, melted mozzarella, and balsamic vinegar.

Caldwell Marketplace

4.7(41 reviews)

2.9 mi

It really is a great place for QUALITY meets and QUALITY service. Love the variety…read more.... If I'm not ordering from Crowd Cow, I'm most likely cooking meat bought at Caldwell Marketplace.

Excellent thin chicken cutlets and really not a bad price! Will be back to try other things! I…read morelooked around and saw really nice Italian specialties and the staff were friendly!

See all

Fairchilds Market

3.4(113 reviews)

1.8 mi

Fairchilds Marker is a unique blend of 50% delicatessen, 50% liquor store, and 25% gift shop. I'm…read moreobviously not very good at math, but Fairchilds Market's owners have done a very good job creating a diverse menu of tasty freshly cooked-to-order custom burgers made from Pat LaFrieda-sourced beef, signature sandwiches, trademark sloppy joes, wraps, and salads; carrying a good selection of locally-sourced or unique liquor; maintaining a small but well-curated gift section that carries a variety of eclectic home décor items; and establishing a cozy, welcoming environment that ties it all together. I had the Natasha signature sandwich ($11), a breaded chicken cutlet served with caramelized onions and a light Russian dressing on a crispy baguette, with a bag of Joe Chips and my dining companion went with breakfast for lunch and had a veggie omelette ($10) with a side salad. Both of us were very satisfied with the taste and portion sizes of our food. The process of ordering and paying for your meal is unique in that you have to queue up at the counter to wait for someone to take your order and prepare your food, then line up again to pay the cashier for your meal. The seating area occupies less than a quarter of the space, so seating may be difficult especially because the ambiance encourages people to linger long after they've eaten and table turnover is low. While Fairchilds Market is only open for breakfast and lunch, they also offer a small selection of prepared foods to go -- soups, chicken wings, etc. -- for dinner at home. Fairchilds Market's liquor selection emphasizes locally-sourced items, including a wide variety of locally-produced craft beers (e.g., Carton, Man Skirt, Magnify, Cape May, and Fort Nonsense, just to name a few); locally-distilled liquors; and hard-to-find low-volume wineries. The modest home décor section features charming and unique serving dishes, games, and other gifts for you to browse through while you're waiting for your food. We'll be back!

Fairchilds is not what it used to be. No butcher anymore, quality of wine is down, and they close…read moreat 4pm. Lost identity and purpose.

Come in and check out our wonderful selection of single vineyard wines and craft beers.

Great soups, salads & sandwiches ...especially one of NJ's best Sloppy Joes

See all

We cater too. Sandwich and dessert platters for your individual or corporate needs.

Calandra's Italian Village

3.8(855 reviews)

3.0 mi

When I asked my daughter where she wanted to celebrate her birthday; she said Calandras. We made…read morereservations and got there early so sat at the bar for cocktails. It was a very lively place to be and the server was such a delight. We had a sangria, a mimosa and a bullet 95. All excellent! In fact I had another sangria with dinner because it was so light and refreshing. My daughter loves arancini and theirs was perfection. The right amount of crunch on the outside with the tastiest sauce. She remembered a fancy grilled cheese that her dad made when she was younger. He told her it was mozzarella en carozza and ordered it for us to share. Omg, it was amazing. Grilled cheese for adults! I was getting kinda full from the drinks, appetizers and the most incredible bread (our server sent a loaf home with us-their ovens truly make a difference) so I ordered a side of Mama E's meatballs and risotto. Both were so very good and a couple of meals for me. My husband thoroughly enjoyed his sole oreganata. The right amount of seasonings and the sole was cooked perfectly. It was delicate and flakey as it should be. My daughter picked the tortellini Alfredo and loved it very much. We were too full for desert but the server was super nice and brought a scoop of ice cream over a brownie and sang to my daughter. All in all it was an excellent meal, the service was amazing and the restaurant was everything we wanted it to be to celebrate a Milestone birthday. Weather permitting, you can opt to eat outside, inside or by the bar area if you want a more lively evening.

We had an early dinner at Il Vecchio Cafe. It is very pretty inside and the staff is very friendly…read moreand attentive. The bread brought to the table was fresh although on the cool side. It comes with fresh cheese. Olive oil, red pepper, salt, and pepper are at the table. We ordered an eggplant rollatini appetizer which was three good size rollatinis, plenty for two people, even maybe 3-4. For entrees, we ordered short ribs and a salmon filet stuffed with crabmeat. The waiter asked how I wanted the salmon which I thought was odd for a stuffed filet. The entrees were both good, the short ribs were nicely done and seasoned. The kitchen or waiter made a mistake and brought me a piece of salmon, not the stuffed one I ordered. It was thick so I thought maybe it was stuffed but seared closed. As I cut in, I saw it was plain salmon. It was OK but very dry and not what I ordered. I cut into the middle, thinking maybe it was just stuffed in the center. Nope. I also then realized the side veggies were not what was on the menu (because they brought the wrong dish). I let the waiter know and he apologized. Mistakes happen and I was not going to insist on a new dish when I had eaten about 1/3 of this one. They did bring over a small cup of shredded crab meat and a sauce. Again, mistakes happen but what irked me was they didn't even adjust the price, charging me higher price for what I ordered, not the lower priced dish they served. I was not looking for a free meal or even a free dessert, but you don't correct the price on what you served??? Again, staff was all nice, but this is my second time there and second eh experience. Calandra does have a nice restaurant up the road, Med Grille, and that is always top notch.

Paccheri Salsiccia

See all

Paccheri Salsiccia

Marra's Italian Specialties

3.7(38 reviews)

1.8 mi

Food is great ,old school days love it.Service could use a little more attention.And the Ambiance…read moreis like being at home.

We received our appetizers and finished them. Server never took our entree order because she was…read moretoo busy putting away utensils. I was seated with my back to the server's station, and the 2 servers were having a conversation while slamming the utensils in the tray I couldn't even hear my tables conversation. and the worst was the server poked me in my back several times I was livid. To the owner of this restaurant please move the server's station out of the dining room.

Hot honey calamari

We also had some delicious fresh bread and butter and some pickled carrots, a great accompaniment to start...

See all

Bread

Eppes Essen Deli & Restaurant

3.5(344 reviews)

1.9 mi

This was my grandfather Seymour's favorite Jewish deli, and I can't believe I've never been here…read morebefore but now I understand why he loved it. I had the Pistol pastrami sandwich one day, and the next day I had to come back to get it again! And of course ordered extra to share with my family and friends. The pickles and coleslaw served when you sit down were excellent. Matzoh ball soup and lox platter delicious as well. The staff are very friendly and there is a comforting nostalgic ambiance. Can't wait to come back.

Oy Vey... Fuhgeddaboudit!…read more Listen, I'm Italian, I know what it means to pay for good food. But $31.19 for this pastrami sandwich? Nu, come on! Then another $4 for a Snapple that costs about $2 normally. That's some serious chutzpah right there. The sandwich was small, the pastrami portion was nowhere near a respectable half-pound, and the quality? Oy vey. Nothing special at all. And before anybody gets offended, let's be honest: this ain't Katz's, my friend. If you're gonna charge like Katz's, you better serve like Katz's. For $35, I expect a sandwich that makes me say "mamma mia!" Instead, I'm saying "fuhgeddaboudit." Nu? Never again.

Sloppy joes

Gorgeous

See all

The Classic

A J's Lunch Box

4.5(40 reviews)

3.3 mi

Great place for breakfast or lunch. Super nice people and fantastic food. That's a terrific…read morecombination.

Called and placed an order for Cheesesteak Plain and a Slam Dunk. While running around in Jersey on…read moreerrands. Really enjoyed the sandwiches from A J's Lunch Box. Something about the bread when it is fresh, soft and chewy. Filled with meat and gives me the feeling of being in Philly for one of their CheeseSteaks sandwiches. Reasonably priced and have been ordering from them for the past two days via the phone and picked up the food. Will be back again.

Menu page 1

Menu page 2

See all

Specials 7/6/2026

Nana's Deli & Restaurant

3.9(111 reviews)

2.2 mi

We visited Nana's because we just wanted a quick bite to eat (and I liked the name since my…read moregrandkids call me Nana!). There were so many choices and the prices were reasonable and the food was delicious! They are definitely better cooks than this Nana! Lol.

Stopped in for their viral tuna salad: 9/10 I was warned it…read morewas sweet but I do enjoy a sweet tuna so I was excited to try. I wasn't dissapointed. The tuna itself was nice and cold and very flavorful. If you don't like a sweet tuna though I suggest you stay away. I myself liked it a lot. The rye bread was also a show stopper. One of the best I've ever had. Soft with perfect amount of rye flavoring. Now for other items. chicken noodl soup: 4/10 Didn't live up to the tuna status at all. Noodles were thick and too many of them. Looked like canned noodles. Broth was too salty. Liver Salad: 3/10 Now I like a liver patte which this isn't, it's more of a chopped up salad. I personally didn't like it at all. It didn't taste bad it just had a bland dull irony taste. Coleslaw: 1/10 Needs to be wetter. Either mayo or vinegar. Also had no taste. The place itself was very clean and inviting. The guy who helped me I believe his name was Hector and he was super helpful and friendly. Would try again just because of him. Overall not the best experience taste wise for some things but the Tuna and the overall experience will have me coming back.

See all

Tony Boy's Sandwich House

4.0(112 reviews)

1.9 mi

I personally would like to give less than 4 stars but.... Since this is a sandwich house and not a…read moresalad house - they will get 4. I've ordered here with coworkers and everyone loves the angry bird, the drunk, alas I ordered a salad with grilled chicken. I thought the chicken was forgotten, But, no. The sad chicken was mixed in the salad. And seems like it was leftovers that didn't fit in sandwiches. The salad was good but I expected a side container of chicken or a cutlet sliced on top. I will order again but ... come on give me some chicken.

I ordered from here, and I have to say, I really enjoyed it. I got a turkey sub with the works:…read morelettuce, tomatoes, onions, oil, vinegar, salt, pepper, and oregano. Everything was fresh, the bread had just the right amount of crunch, and the sandwich was made perfectly without being soggy. It was honestly chef's kiss! The prices were reasonable, and the customer service was friendly and welcoming. I'll definitely be back!

See all

Uncle Jerry’s Sandwich Shop

5.0(12 reviews)

0.8 mi

It took a little bit of effort to find Uncle Jerry's, but it was worth it. This little sandwich…read moreshop is tucked away on the 1st floor of an office building on Eagle Rock Ave in Roseland. There's a room where you order which is also the kitchen, then there's a larger room next to it with plenty of tables. There's a good sized sandwich menu along with daily specials. I decided on the Chicken Salad Wrap which was outstanding! It's made with arugula, cranberries, and goat cheese. So tasty! Everyone here was super friendly and Jerry pointed out that they're also open for breakfast. Definitely is a place I'll be visiting often!

Sandwich was awesome fresh bread taste great... Definitely recommend.I will be back and order the…read morechicken cutlet next time . I ordered the sloppy Joe.

Quadruple turkey club

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Mary J.

2 years ago

Jimmy the manager is the greatest guy !!! So personable and down right friendly Your establishment is a much better place with him as an employee. Cherish this guy as long as you can, they don't come much better than him !! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - sandwiches - Updated October 2026

People who viewed Jersey Mike's Subs also viewed

Paulie G's Deli and Grill

4.7

(124 reviews)

Can't believe I'm gonna say this. The sammich was better the next day…read more It was big enough for lunch for two days and it was actually better (IMO) on day two. Great staff, damn good sammiches!

Chicken cutlets are great - the sandwiches on different breads hit differently so pick wisely. The…read morefrench bread is too hard for me. The bruschetta is my fav chicken cutlet sandwich on a sub. Simple and delicious. Service especially on nice days can get backed up, they get busy here. Front and back entries. No eating area from what I can tell unless I missed stairs or something outside?

Eppes Essen Deli & Restaurant

3.5

(344 reviews)

Millburn Deli

4.3

(927 reviews)

I love Millburn Deli! This is my preferred location, although I am not surprised to see they now…read morehave many locations across NJ. Millburn is the flagship store, so naturally there are menu items exclusive to this location. I've noticed that the hours of operation here are slightly different than all of the others (this one opens and closes earlier). There's minimal parking in front of the store, rarely available. Your best bet is to park on the side of the store in the small parking lot. It's free for the first 30 minutes, but there is a meter. I love that the lot is also connected to Taylor Park, a cute neighborhood open space with a fountain. The 5 stars continue to stick for me because I've never had a bad sandwich here. My favorite two are The Griller #8 (with extra pesto or garlic mayo, depending on my mood). And the Friday Joe is always a hit! This time I opted for the Egg Salad sloppy joe with red onion. They could be more generous with the pickles. But the sandwich is a hit! I always appreciate that if you ask to sample anything, they're more than happy to oblige. The service is efficient and even if it's crowded they move pretty quickly. It can be a bit overpriced, especially if you want to substitute or add anything. But it's always satisfying and worth it in the end.

Over the weekend I made my at least 5th order here. Every time it is very predictable no matter…read morewhat I get., excellent!!! They have to put a lot of thought and love into everything that they put out. Home of the best Sloppy Joes!! From sandwiches to salad to iced tea and desserts I highly recommend this place. I had to take the time to leave a review this time because I felt it was very overdue. The gobbler sandwich is yummy, The Godfadda, The Gossip Girl, I also have had an egg salad with layer of tuna salad Sloppy Joe-that is amazing! The Cobb salad is also a fave. My friends rave about all the sandwiches they have tried. They are very friendly behind the counter and the order takers are fast and efficient. It gets crowded but moves fast.

Habit Burger & Grill

3.6

(77 reviews)

I've only been here twice and one time was when it first opened. This is in the same location as…read morethe Kentucky fried chicken used to be which I used to go to occasionally. It's a pretty decent burger. I usually just get the regular burger, but I might wanna try something else. If you're looking for a quick hunger fix then don't hesitate to stop

We used to go to this location a lot and it was solid early on but the last couple times have been…read moredisastrous. My family and I stopped in tonight for a quick bite on the way home from work. They weren't very busy but it still took nearly 10 minutes for someone to take our order. We initially used the kiosk but it wouldn't let us use the free charburger coupons we received from the corporate office for our previous trip in which the food was horribly overcooked. The woman, who appeared to be the manager, told us someone would be with us before deciding to take the order herself because the cashier was trying (slowly) to get other orders together. She then proceeded to quibble with us over what items apply to the coupons we were trying to use despite my wife showing her the email with all the details. We wound up just getting a burger and a kid's meal because it wasn't worth the hassle and my wife lost her appetite fighting with someone over a free sandwich. While we waited, the manager proceeded to berate the cashier for moving too slow during their "busy time" (though we were the only ones in the building) and they proceeded to argue in front of everyone for a good 15 minutes. In his defense, he was trying his best. In her defense, he was moving way too slow. Regardless, that's not a conversation you have in front of customers and it was clear the drama distracted both of them from doing their job properly. My burger was somehow undercooked (a 180 from our last visit) and the fries tasted like the oil hadn't been changed in a while. The lettuce was brown and my daughter's chicken bites were mostly breading. It was a total disappointment but not nearly as bad as a manager/supervisor giving a man who seemed to be disabled an impromptu performance review and threatening to hire a replacement for everyone to see. I wound up feeling horrible for the cashier as the argument extended past us eating our food. My wife sent a complaint over to corporate but I can't envision a scenario where we'd return to this location. I'd never campaign for someone to lose their job, especially in these tough economic times, but the manager either needs to not be in that position or given a lesson on professionalism. I'm all for dinner and a show but this was ridiculous.

Town Hall Delicatessen

3.7

(146 reviews)

Pretty good! We've been meaning to try this spot and I'm so glad I finally was able to order ahead…read moreand grab to go. I must say parking sucks- there is a lot right next to, but there was a dark skinned man sitting in the lot basically patrolling. He told me I can't park there after I said I was running into deli to quickly pick up.. I found this a major turnoff. I'm 9 months pregnant might I add and the deli is basically on a narrow steep road with minimal spots. Not ideal. I also wouldn't consider the Area extremely safe so I didn't want to park too far away. I ended up just parking illegally and running in. I ordered (a whole) Favorite Joe, fries and macaroni salad. Everything tasted fresh once I got home and was good! I wouldn't say it's better or worse than Millburn deli - I can appreciate both places having a quality sloppy Joe!! If you're in the area, I would recommend you stop in!!

I want to love this place…read more Seems extremely scant on the vegetarian side. Pound cake seems lovely. Wonder if they make them fresh. Seems like a lovely local place, close to the train station and on the way to the farmers market.

Jersey Mike's Subs

3.0

(40 reviews)

12/21/24 Afternoon Visit: A young woman behind the counter cheerfully welcomed us to Jersey Mike's…read more She explained to us the different sandwiches. This young woman had a personality that totally lit up a room. (Sorry, I didn't catch her name). She chatted with us as she prepared our two roast beef and provolone subs to go. This young woman worked quickly preparing the sandwiches. Anyway, we brought the subs home. They were absolutely delicious. Exactly how we requested they be prepared. Jersey Mike's is located next to Mighty Quinn's off of Rt.3 West in Clifton, New Jersey. A large parking lot is available.

Ordered online and when I got there a few minutes after the scheduled time it was ready, that was…read morethe only positive. Ordered an Italian with lettuce and added banana peppers, with no oil and vinegar on it but red wine vinegar on the side (12.26 after tax). Hardly any lettuce or peppers on it and the container on the side had oil and vinegar. Also a large piece of the bread was ripped off. Really terrible. Also, when looking at the reviews the owner is clearly paying for positive online reviews because multiple positive reviews state the exact same (specific) review

Livingston Diner

3.1

(115 reviews)

The diner scene in Livingston is thriving with two outstanding choices. The Ritz is excellent with…read moreattentive, friendly service and food that's sure to delight any palate. It's my usual spot and I hit them up every week or two. Dinner's great, breakfast's great, lunch is great. Their soups are also amazing as are their baked goods and pretty much everything they sell, except for liver. I hate liver. Ewww So I was on the other side of town and figured I'd try to be disappointed by the other diner in town which couldn't be nearly as good as their counterpart. I was wrong. Food and service were great and for comparison, it's hard to tell which is better. Since I've been going to the Ritz for the better part of 2 decades, it gets the nod but again, the Livingston Diner is pretty damn delicious, too. Kudos to both!

We went here for brunch on July 4th. We were greeted right away and we were seated right away. I…read moreordered the Lox platter and it was excellent. My sister ordered the chocolate chip pancakes and she liked it. My BIL ordered the French toast and he liked it. My mom ordered the soup of the day and it was fine. My dad ordered the two egg platter with sausage. He liked it. The dining room was bright and clean. I will definitely come back here again.

QDOBA Mexican Eats

3.0

(73 reviews)

This is so amazing , the food is to DIE FOR , the costumer service is impeccable. I love it hereread more

Both times we've been there has been great. Open kitchen served "cafeteria style" I haven't been…read morethere this year so I hope it's as good as it's been!

Dave's Hot Chicken

4.3

(189 reviews)

The menu was a little confusing to me! But the person working at the registry was helpful and…read morepatient! There are plenty of seatings! My boys enjoyed the food soooo much! Food came out hot and fresh!

Decided to try it since everyone is head over heels for this place but I sadly didn't really find…read moreit flavorful. I tried there new chicken bites with spicy barbecue sauce and it really didn't stand out for me. The sauce was not at all spicy and it just wasn't great barbecue. The chicken had pieces of cartilage and was very chewy. The fries were OK. I did also try one of their tenders, and I didn't like that most of the "spicy "seasonings were truly just powder rather than having seasoned the meat before cooking it. It's nice that you have the option to either go up to the register or order on the screen, it allows more people to put an order at the same time. There is a lot of seating inside and plenty of parking since it's in a strip mall

Natale's Bagel Nosh

3.5

(35 reviews)