I'm sitting here still stunned. I ordered a sandwich from this location Mike's Way. I guess today that meant using a liter of olive oil. Really don't think it was possible to make a sandwich using this much oil. 75% of the outside of the bread was covered in it. The inside? Swimming. I find that JM usually uses way more than the local mom and pop places, but today was just silly. If you like your sandwich with more oil than the Middle East, this is your spot. I, for one, will not be back. read more

Ain't no thing like a Jersey thing baby. Whenever I'm looking for a great sub I know I can always put Mike's on my foodie finder radar. And while it's true that all these shops tend to vary from store to store, this particular location is definitely a solid choice for any hot or cold sandwich option you happen to be craving.   On my first visit here I grabbed up a 56 Big Kahuna Cheese Steak which came loaded with Grilled Onions, Peppers, Mushrooms, Jalapeños, and Extra Cheese with Tender Juicy Beef Steak for the win. Can't never go wrong ordering that classic hand held deliciousness.   2nd visit had my mouth watering for an Italian sub which they stacked nicely with Ham, Provolone, Prosciuttini, Cappacuola, Salami, and Pepperoni. Plus I added Banana Peppers and a bag of Miss Vickie's Jalapeño Chips to help keep my super delicious Italian Sandwich company. Both visits left my cravings well satisfied and they even get bonus points for fast, friendly, and efficient service here. Come And Get Your Munch On!! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Shake Hands with Big Kahuna Cheese Steak!! YUMMMMMMERS !! - Delis Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

See all

Honestly, you should probably choose one of the many local delis instead of this place - we wish we had. We opted for Jersey Mike's because my son requested it after a practice. The online order was missing an item. In addition, I after a few bites of my sub, I noticed a short, grey hair in it. Beyond gross. I never leave reviews but couldn't let this slide. This place has gone downhill in terms of quality and service ever since it was bought by private equity but that was the last straw. We won't be back - avoid if you're in the area. read more

ordered food from here over phone app. been doing so for years. walked in 10 minutes after due. place empty. one employee idle. i let him know my name for the pick up. He looks around. finds the two sandwiches lying on the shelf above the oven. grabs them slowly and then tosses them on the counter. No bag for $30 worth of food i bought. As for the beverages, chips etc? All are supposed to be in the bag. "You can get it yourself" he drawled. i do. i leave. i get home. one of sandwiches is full of onions and peppers. Hate both. i'd expressly asked for none. i drive back. i hand him the sandwich. i explain the error. i just ask for the $10 or more refund. Now he's going through the receipt and claims that yeah, it's full of onions and I did indeed ask for none. But he adds that i had asked peppers be omitted from the other sandwich not this one. I'll omit the few more exchanges that resulted in no remade sandwich and no refund despite the onion error. i'll tell you what else it resulted in: my never returning. read more

Walking into the store at 12:25pm on March 1st whoever was in charge of cutting the deli meat (young man with cross earring) decided he was going to disrespect his own coworker and tell him to get outta the way. So clearly he was already in a bad mood. Then when we didn't hear the other girl asking what we wanted on the sandwich she decided to just take the person behind us. Then proceeded to laugh with her coworker and talk about us while we were standing there. I explained I didn't hear them ask what we wanted on the sandwich and the two coworkers continued to talk and laugh about us while we were standing there. Needless to say I will not be returning to that location. read more

It was a hilarious time. Staff is very interactive and cool. Food was great and came super fast.

I'm surprised that I haven't visited this Jersey Mikes location before today even though I live less than 1 mile away. I really liked the online ordering experience and I was surprised that they had my 5 sandwiches ready in 12 minutes. My Italian sandwich was fresh and very tasty. I need to go here more often! read more

Sandwiches are always great from Jersey Mike's. *If* they are made correctly per order. I've tried reaching customer service twice to simply provide feedback about 3 (out of 3!) incorrectly made subs. Never heard back from anyone. Again the subs were still great- just not what we ordered. We always take out so no comment on ambiance. read more

Place is so dirty it shouldn't be allowed to serve people. Staff is also rude and has attitude. Place is worst jersey mikes I've ever been too. read more

If I could give it 0 I would. Employees are rude and condescending and unable to take accountability for messed up orders. I don't even care about the messed up order the employees were just terrible. I get it I also work in food customer service but my god. read more

Great taste roast beef provolone on wheat Quick service it was ready before I asked for it Friendly clean place read more

Ordered one of the new cheesesteaks over the phone. Asked for Parmesan bread, lettuce and tomato on it. Employee on the phone seemed like he couldn't care less about my order. Come to pick up the sandwich, they forgot the Parmesan bread and no lettuce or tomato in sight. I expect better attention to customers' orders and requests. read more

The Big Kahuna sub was really good. The ingredients tasted fresh, and it was made well. The reason they lost two stars is because the guy in the back dealing with food had his mask around his neck, and the guy working in the front had the mask below his nose. Come on people - this is serious. Respect the rules your customers are expected to follow, and keep everyone safe. If Covid cases spike again, guess which businesses will end up closed again? Common sense and common courtesy - both important. read more

By Far the worst sandwich I ever purchased, large stick balls, stood there watching a kid make it with 1 row of ham that barely covered the bread, 1 row of salami maybe 6 slices and 1 row of super thin provolone, asked if he could put a little more meat on it and with an attitude I would be charged for extra meat. NEVER AGAIN. read more

Where's the beef? Got a sub from Jersey Mike's and it was a bread sandwich. Ordered the stick ball which comes with ham, salami and provolone cheese. It had absolutely no meat on it. Not with $16. No more Jersey Mike's read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - A bread sandwich - Delis Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

The rolls are stale!! Placed 2 orders recently and the buns were very dry especially on the ends. Used to be fresh. Something is going wrong. read more

People that make an effort to come in and place an order should be taken care of first and not have to wait until they fill the online orders. The wait is ridiculous and rude. The online orders just sit there until someone comes in to pick them up and that can be 15 to 20 minutes later. CHANGE YOUR POLICY OR LOSE SOME CUSTOMERS! read more

I understand that business can get busy especially during lunch hours. I fully appreciate the frustration that comes along with being shorthanded. What is unacceptable is a loud, harshly toned greeting announcing to the customers present that I and those in my company will not be served. The obviously busy counter person shouted that they were backed up and would not be able to take or make our order(s) for a while. A better greeting, just as truthful would have been accepted. read more

Arrived yesterday and experienced 6 people in front of me and waited 45 minutes to order since they were fulfilling DoorDash orders instead of taking care of there walk in customers. While waiting - the floors behind their serving counters were dirty and disgusting with food debris all over the place - kinda wondering what else is dirty... going to contact the Chatham Board of Health department on Monday... Skip this place and go to your local deli instead... read more

This place makes classic subs, way better than places like Subway. Always had good food here except once the roll was kind of stale. I remember the original in Point Pleasant when I was a kid, but there is no way to compare then and now, especially as I would only eat the roast beef and the only topping I would have with it was salt. The quality of the meat seems good, again better than other chains. I like the Jersey Shore Favorite, the original Italian and of course the good old roast beef (but now I like it with everything). Cheesesteak (Mike's Famous Philly) was OK but excellent cheesesteaks are hard to come by. It's best to order via the app because you'll stand there for a while otherwise and I've noticed some of the help with incorrectly worn masks. read more

Awful service. If I could give 0 stars I would! Save yourself the trip and go to your local deli!

Just moved to town. Will never visit this place again. Every single staff member had a chip on their shoulder. The girl with the orange hair, nose ring and glasses seemed put out when customers ordered food. She rolled her eyes when I asked a question about my sandwich. I asked for the owners name and they said they don't franchise out. I went to the website and it says they do. Hard to believe the bum in the back was the manager of the joint, but then again maybe not. If he was in fact the store manager I can understand why it's so poorly run. read more

Ugh. Came here and ordered a turkey sub and got sick :( My experience at the actual location was great - quick service and the crew was helpful in explaining my options. The turkey sub I got was good....but things just went downhill from there. Sorry, wouldn't come back here again for that reason. read more

Just left after trying Jersey Mikes for the first time. Sadly, I was highly disappointed. I believe this used to be a subway at one point. I had their tuna sub. Unfortunately, it tasted like the same low quality tuna as the previous occupants. The thing that really got me was the lack of sanitary standards. My bread was placed on the board as is, while the person that was in line after me had wax paper placed in between the board and the bread. I think the standards set by management should be in place for all customers. I don't think I'll be returning to this particular location. Go try and maybe you'll be one of the lucky patrons who gets his/her sandwich made atop the wax paper. ENJOY??? read more

Workers are very slow. Place is so dirty. Orders are called in and not even ready when people walk in to get their order. And they have 3 people working there. Sandwiches all came out sloppy.pretty sad. read more

I order on line today for 2 giants sub. Pickup was 1.04 Got there at 1.02. They had not started my order. Two other customers came in and just they and work on there order 1st and they were out of the door by 1 . 10. I ask why and they said just I'm sorry for wait. Got my order at 1.18 Hey just tell me next time it will 1.18 Not happy since I have order there at least 1x a month Jersey Joe C read more

I've been to about a dozen other Jersey Mike's in this state and I've come to expect a standard of service and product. I was helped by a new employee or a veteran but either way, customer service was lacking tremendously. A training issue or personality shortcoming? Doesn't matter... There's no excuse or reason to place someone in a customer-facing position if they aren't cut out for the job or not ready or trained properly. I hope they read this and grow. read more

After purchasing a couple subs and coming back for a drink later in the day. The staff was very helpful and kind.

The guys that works here are friendly and do a good job. It's a solid Jersey Mike's. I've never seen it dirty and I've been there often. Doordash for some reason cut them off and that makes me pissed. read more

I went to the green village shop and they did not have any bread. Was very upset. I go there for lunch always and the people did not seem to care or give any sort good customer service read more

This particular Jersey Mike's has been open for several months now, and they still don't have their act together yet. Every time I go it's very disorganized and DIRTY! And again today, there was a sandwich on the floor behind the meat case - it looked like maybe one of the workers dropped it and just left it there, or somebody threw it there (paper wrapper, a receipt, meat, melted cheese, pickles, etc...) and yet the three workers continued to step over it while nobody bothered to clean it up. This store is in a good location and has the potential to be a really great place - the one in Bedminster is a good example. Perhaps they need some corporate training? read more

Bruh, I'm not gonna lie. This place is the bomb. Awesome service and hella good food. You can sign up for "shore points" for free and it gives you rewards! I mean, c'mon man, why would you go anywhere else? read more

I'm not sure why this place has such bad reviews - it's awesome! I usually can't help but to get a chicken ceasar wrap whenever I come here, but today I ordered a cheese steak and it was on point. Just the right amount of cheese, onions, & peppers. The bread was super soft and yummy too, which is a big factor in where I get a sandwich from. I will definitely keep coming back! read more

Usually I really enjoy this establishment due to the food and friendliness of the staff, but today was a different story. I called in at 8:45 PM to ask a question, and they didn't even pick up the phone. read more

Welcome to Chatham, much better than the over-rated, over-priced Italian place next door.

These guys are the best! We needed two boxes of subs in a pinch and they delivered them with fast, courteous service.

I have been to a number of Jersey Mike's throughout New Jersey. This one is truly exceptional. I was unable to get in during their opening week because it was fairly busy however decided to stop by on Sunday just to see how it was coming along. The service was excellent and the manager make sure he greeted everyone coming in and made them feel at home. When asked what I should have he even made some suggestions to me. We tried three and they were all very very good. This is a welcome addition to the Chatham area and complements the many other establishments nicely. I will be back read more

Subs are just okay. On the expansive side for what it is. Friendly staff and fast service.