I enjoyed myself! Food/Drink: Typical sandwich you would expect. Sammy's are juicy and delicious. A bit messy but delicious. Appetizers: None. Bread: Bun is a little flat, it's your typical $1 store. The lettuce wrap gets even messier but a good alternative. Dinning Area: Average size, open concept. Plenty of seating! Prices: Relatively inexpensive. Parking: Large, shared lot, wrap around just off the main road. Bathrooms: Bathrooms were clean and one person, sizeable. Atmosphere: During the weekday night off season, summer still pretty steady, but not unmanageable. Staff/Attendants: Cashier was Great and highly motivated, very nice dude, and relatively attentive. Awesome experience! 8/10 read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Beavercreek, Ohio

The service is FAST and right on spot. I worked in a NJ sub shop called the White House...subs made exactly like the Philly subs and Jerseys makes theirs just like the original subs from up north... it's the rolls...dough made up north and it's the water that makes it SO...SO good. They also offer lettuce, tomatoes and onions sliced THIN...you add red vinger...oil and oregano with red pepper flakes and that's a sub..the best you'll ever eat read more

When there is 9 workers on staff when you enter the door, you know it's going to be a next level experience. These workers were attentive and exemplified the "Mike's way" while executing my sub Mikes way. Classy. Hidden gem of a J Mikes. Keep it up, fellas. read more

Five stars for all the folks that were served during the day of giving, this place had 10-12 people working, you know that's special. Line of people was 30 deep, but wait was only 30min for a cold sub order. I am still at 3-1/2 for the subs. I like their subs, starting to grow on me, but there are several other sub places I like better. read more

Always get good food here! The meat, the bread, and the toppings are fresh and delicious. Each sandwich is made exactly how you want it. I love the Parmesan Rosemary bread! The staff is friendly and accurate. My only complaint is the restaurant can get very loud. I'm not sure if it's the kitchen or just a combination of things. I love going to Jersey Mikes..I get a great sandwich. (I like the ham-provoke. read more

My usual sub place. Me. The Philly cheesesteak. My wife. The Italian. Never had a bad sandwich. Very efficient customer service. Meats are sliced in front of you. The Italian subs are truly outstanding. Excellent online ordering. My points for free sandwiches add up fast. Opens early, at 10:15. I go to both the Far Hills and Wilmington location in Kettering. read more

It's hit or miss on service here. The staff is typically friendly but orders are not always prepared on time. If ordering in person, the food is good and accurate. Orders online or through the app are generally messed up in some way. Either they aren't ready on time or inaccurate. It's rare the orders are correct 100%. Stick with in person ordering and you'll be good read more

I just went in for lunch to pick up a pickup order and got to my car and they didn't put any cheese in the sandwich. I specifically put substitution instructions in the order but there were 20 people in line and they obviously don't care to read the entire receipt order. I wasted my time waiting for the order and I wasn't going to waste time going in to fix it. Do not order during any busy time or you will regret your order. read more

I can't walk out of here until I post a great review for the outstanding experience I just had here. I stopped in for a quick lunch. As always, my JM sub was perfectly prepared to order and extra tasty. However, what made this experience especially enjoyable was the enthusiasm and friendliness of all three crew members. They all had genuine smiles, and chatted cheerfully with each customer. They ensured that each sandwich was made exactly to order, and took pride in customer satisfaction. A great experience- great food and super employees. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Beavercreek, Ohio

We tried Jersey Mike's Subs in Raleigh NC and I felt in love with it (I was like this is the best buffalo chicken wrap ever) I found out that I have a Jersey Mike's 30 minutes from the house, so while we were shopping I decided to use the app to order. My order said pick up at 4:06pm like 20 minutes after. I arrived and the lady said.... oh we haven't even make them yet, excuse me not, I'm so sorry, we are busy but I will make this right away. Then I asked for no blue cheese and please add ranch. They put it on the sub and then she says just give it to her on the side. Today is Monday Jan 20, please give some training of courtesy to your employees. This is why you get a one star from me and I won't be back! read more

This was actually the Huber Heights location that just opened. We got a footlong Italian sub split into thirds. Very tasty, but also very messy read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - The Italian sub. - Sandwiches Near Me - Beavercreek, Ohio

Big fan of Jersey Mike's, but this franchise in Beavercreek, OH has some of the worst service I have ever experienced.

I wanted to have Jersey Mike's again when I went to the Fairfield Commons mall a week ago. I thought it was be another solid meal, and it definitely lived up to that expectation. The service was superior and I was impressed it their service. It taste like Mexican food and I would have it again. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Beavercreek, Ohio

This is hands down the best sub shop in Beavercreek. My wife and I stopped in here for the first time and we were pleasantly surprised! My wife got the Club Sub, which is made with freshly sliced provolone, ham, and turkey and mayo. You can of course get the sub the Jersey Mike's way. I decided on the Big Kahuna Cheese Steak. It's made with grilled onions, peppers, mushrooms, jalapeños and melted white American cheese. Oh my gosh it was amazing. We both got them as Giant and they live up to their title. They're a bit more than Subway but, in my opinion, definitely worth it! If you have the chance to stop by for a sub, please do! read more

Awful. I ordered a steak sandwich. It was dripping with grease. Literally dripping. My stomach is upset after eating it.

Great subs. This location might be a bit more consistent quality than the other locations, but it is one of the busiest. Original Italian Mike's way is my jam. read more

First time trying this place. The bread was so stale I couldn't enjoy the sub at all.

Updating my last review from 2015 since I originally only rated it four stars. This is the best chain sandwich shop in Beavercreek, hitting 5 stars in taste, quality, and especially the excellent customer service. I ALWAYS have friendly service here... It's pretty remarkable. I still get the Reuben each and every time, it's so darn good. read more

Excellent cold and warm subs, and yes it gets crowded, but they move fast. And well it's worth the wait Quality meats and toppings Staff are awesome and personable read more

I get Jersey Mikes almost every day that I work in the office because it's so convenient and delicious. I've never been disappointed in a sub I've gotten there. I usually get the normal cheesesteak or the Big Kahuna. My boyfriend gets their cold subs and loves them too read more

You typical Jersey Mike's. Meaning if you've been to one, then you've been to this one. They are very consistent which is a wonderful thing. The service here is good, and the food comes out super fast. The restaurant is clean, and there's a good sized parking lot that's shared with Winan's and a smoothie place. I would come back. read more

Jersey Mike's is a franchise, but a good one at that. Subway has gone down quite a bit. Their sandwiches are mostly bread with precut meats. The vegetables are average and not fresh looking. If you ever had a port-a-subs sandwich, this is the same thing. They have cut to order meat and give you plenty on there. The vegetable choices aren't as many as Subway, but that's okay. I always get it Mike's way, which is onions, lettuce, tomato, red wine vinegar, olive oil blend and spices. No fancy bread choice, but what sandwich doesn't taste good on a French roll. Don't settle for a blah sandwich, come here for a good deli sandwich. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #13, the original Italian Mike's way - Sandwiches Near Me - Beavercreek, Ohio

See all

"Welcome to Jersey Mike's"! The first thing you hear when you walk through the door. I was eager to try the new Gluten Free sub as I was newly diagnosed with Celiac Disease. I stepped outside my comfort zone and ordered a Pastrami Rueben on the gluten free roll. I miss the pumpernickel/rye that usually accompanies this dish. I was very pleasantly surprised! The bread was light with the perfect amount of sauerkraut. Pastrami was cooked Perfectly and wasn't dry. Listen. If you want a great sub, go to Jersey Mike's. If you want a gluten free option, go to Jersey Mikes! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Gluten Free - Sandwiches Near Me - Beavercreek, Ohio

Love love the fresh east coast bread and sliced deli meat, just tried the chicken cheesesteak and it was amazing ! Nice staff read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Beavercreek, Ohio

Had a few subs from Jersey Mike's Subs today. First I had the Jersey Shore's Favorite which was absolutely fantastic with provolone, ham, and cappacuolo. Next I tried the Grilled Pastrami Reuben which was loaded with fresh pastrami and had Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and of course Thousand Island dressing. Lastly, I had to get the Big Kahuna Cheese Steak since I'm kind of a big eater. It came with mushrooms, peppers, jalapeños, and extra cheese. This bad boy was about 15 inches long! I definitely recommend them if you haven't tried already! read more

So I'm not usually a fan of chain delis or restaurants for that matter however this place was outstanding. I actually came here twice and tried the steak and cheese with peppers and onions- it was delicious!! I also had a club sandwich ( I believe it was the number 9). It had roast beef, turkey, Swiss, and bacon then was piled high with lettuce tomato and other toppings- the meat is cut right in front of you so that you know it is extremely fresh. Based on the sandwiches I had, I really don't think you could go wrong with anything here- just make sure you bring your appetite because the sandwiches are huge! I would highly recommend this place if you are looking for a quick bite to eat!!! read more

If I could give a half star, I would. The service was slow, employees were not educated on their ingredients, they were not efficient like an assembly line sub shop should be ran. The iced tea machine spat a clump of coagulated tea into my drink. This happens when equipment is improperly cleaned regularly. Basic food service handler safety is apparently not performed at this facility. Not impressed and would not recommend. read more

This place is chaotic, 7 people working. Close to my hotel. Go in twice in a week, order 4 subs. I guess they think you should have to all open every bag and touch every sub to identify them. I even asked on second trip can you mark the subs with what they are, forget the number, means nothing to us. They did neither again. Won't be back. Sandwiches taste fine, steak even though it's chopped up, still has tough pieces. Won't be back solely on customer service. read more

No matter how many people or what time it is they're always quick and friendly. My favorite is the Philly cheesesteak it's soo good and is always delicious. They've never messed up my order it's my favorite new go to spot now. read more

I'm a vegetarian and asked for their vege sandwich. It was vege alright more like a salad sandwich. I know there was cheese somewhere in there! read more

There are few things as excellent on this earth as a well-executed sandwich. The combination of savory meat, salty cheese, and crunchy veg, all wrapped up in a fresh-baked bread that walks the balance between crusty exterior and soft, pillowy interior....sandwiches can be magic, children. Subway, if you read my reviews, has my eternal ire for defacing proper sandwiches. Luckily for me, Dayton has no shortages of other sandwich shops, though I hadn't visited Jersey Mike's before, despite its proximity to one of my favorite smoothie stops. So, en route to a freelance writing meeting down in Xenia, I decided to stop by and see if Jersey Mike's could hold a candle to some of the other sandwich shops in the area. First thing to note: Jersey Mike's has a deli slicer right on the counter. And, what's more, they use it. Every meat and cheese for my Italian was freshly cut, in front of my eyes. There were no pre-sliced meats or cheeses here, pulled out of deli cups or the like. These guys started my sandwich right. The bread at Jersey Mike's is a soft, white loaf, which could have used just a touch more crust for my taste. That said, it held up well to the sandwich interior and kept everything together nicely. I could have done with a little stronger dressing, personally--the oil/vinegar/seasoning blend that comprises Jersey Mike's dressing was a touch weak; some mustard might have helped, but none in sight. Overall? Jersey Mike's is affordable, quick, and so much fresher than many of the other sandwich chains around. They're worth your lunch! read more

I love the order online and pickup feature they offer and how you can get points towards a free sub. I have eaten at this location twice, I had the club supreme sub the first time, pretty good, I wasn't crazy about the turkey but it worked okay with the roast beef and bacon. The second time I went I had the cancro special and it was amazing. The sandwiches are pretty big and quite hearty. They use a tougher bread, be aware, if your used to the Italian bread from sub-way its not that soft. This is good though keeps it from getting soggy. Give em a try I think you'll like them. Update: Ordering ahead of time online is hit or miss. Sometimes it's ready sometimes it's not. Good thing is they are fast so the wait isn't long. Not waiting at all is the goal though right. read more

They use their stale bread for delivery orders, and the last 3 orders they did not include oil or vinegar on the subs. Very, very disappointed in ho they treat their delivery customers! read more

I've been looking for a 'good sandwich' shop for lunch time meals, that aren't too expensive, but taste good and are filling. I'm tired of going to places like Subway or Jimmy Johns. The quality of those places is terrible. At the same time, I do not want to go to Penn Station or more "fried" or cooked food place. What I'm looking for is a solid, Italian Sandwich place that also has a couple of 'warm sandwich' items that aren't heated in a microwave. Jersey Mike's is a decent place. It's better than Subway and Jimmy Johns, though not 'great'. It's average. The two things that stick out to me are the following: 1. The size of the sandwich. - This is my largest complaint. There's a problem when the "regular" is about $7 and then the next largest size is a 15 inch sub, going for like $13. Really? So you are either left to choose between leaving yourself hungry, or over-stuffing yourself/paying $13 for a sandwich. This is a brilliant/dumb move. Brilliant because JM is probably making a killing financially off those $13 sandwiches, but it's just dumb from a customer-service standpoint to not offer a size in between. The fix? Offer a sandwich around $8.99 for a 12 inch. Then, customer gets more 'full' and doesn't have to pay an extra $5 for 3 more inches. 2. TIPPING ON THE CREDIT CARD MACHINE I think another reviewer mentioned this below, but this is just tacky. It puts the customer on the spot, and makes the customer 'look bad' for not providing a tip. Would this not make me go here and eat? Of course not, nobody says you have to tip. But is it a little awkward? Yes. Here's the thing... You are cutting some meat, and putting it on bread. Why do you deserve a tip for that? Your sandwiches are arguably over-priced already, so don't ask customers to tip your staff. OVERALL: Besides those two gripes above, I still will eat there from time to time. It's not a bad place, it's just not "great". I'm not blown away as if this were to be my 'go-to' sandwich place. It's decent, but overpriced. I'll continue to eat there until and (if) a better place comes around. read more

A small group of us came in during the lunch rush. I've worked customer service before for years so I was trying to be understanding however, there seemed to be no rhyme or reason to the "team" behind the counter. We waiting in line for nearly 45 minutes waiting for our sandwiches. There was a huge lack of communication between the employees and the customers, the employees didn't know they're own products when asked if their pickles were dill or sweet they responded, "I'm not sure" and didn't even attempt to find the correct answer. The young man making the sandwiches moved PAINFULLY slow for having such a long line and long waiting time. And to top all of this, when I went to fill my drink with the unsweetened tea, there was a long gooey tea booger hanging from the spout. DISGUSTING!! Had that dirty tea glob not been hanging from the spout I would have consumed the filthy tea. I will not be returning and I do NOT recommend going here at any point of the day. read more

My favorite sandwich shop in Dayton/Fairborn/Beavercreek. The Italian Mike's Way is something I crave! So good!

I had my first Jersey Mike's Sub recently. Wow, so much better than ALL the rest. I have never had such a great tasting sub in the Dayton area, period. I wish they were closer to my home, PLEASE build one in Riverside!! read more

I like JM, but I'm not really a fan of their bread. Also they tend to really put a lot of mayo on their sandwiches. Other than that I'm usually pretty happy with them and this location is no exception. read more

I just found this shop a few days ago. The food is great but even better is the customer service. The workers make a personal connection and it doesn't seemed forced. It's great to see the meat cut in front of you. Ingredients are fresh. I will definitely be back and recommend to others. read more

#13 is as yumy as htey come, the Italian sub. SO GOOD.