Jersey Mike&#x27;s Subs

I normally do not like to post negative reviews of local businesses but I have to say this. This is…read morethe second time In a row I have gone in and ordered an egg and cheese on a roll for my daughter. The cost is almost $7 dollars which is normal these days, but they literally put a half an egg on the roll. I was too far away to go back in and say something. My daughter couldn't even eat it because it was basically a $7 roll. There was hardly any cheese as well. My advise to the Deli is make sure you give the customer what they pay for. I will not being going back and they basically stole my money.

Usually go in for an egg sandwich, I am so tired of sometimes getting a fresh roll and other times…read morethe roll is not fresh. I actually ask for a fresh roll and even then I don't get one that is fresh. They tell me it is soft, but soft doesn't always mean fresh. On top of it all, Service is very slow. probably will not come back.

See all

Bayport Deli and Convenience

4.5(8 reviews)

0.7 mi

The sandwiches are so pricey and the guy was honestly pretty rude the guy who made my sandwich I…read moredon't know if he woke up on the wrong side or the bed or what but had a nasty attitude.

Great family owned operation; sandwiches are great, service is on point…read more Give them a try if you are in the area.

See all

Furci's Fine Foods

2.8(40 reviews)

0.2 mi

•$$$

WE GOT A NUMBER OF HALF TRAYS. WORTH EVERY PENNY!!! easy…read morepickup, excellent advice for heating and serving, loaded my car for me. best of all--we didn't have to cook!

Quality artisan Italian fare , very high prices and a little bit of an attitude. This place would…read morebe perfect in East Hampton or Manhasset but most Sayvillians are priced out of this market. If I hit the lottery, I would shop here every day, but until then I must say goodbye after years as a loyal customer. Guys behind the counter seem to make up the prices as they go; poor customer service. Farewell my friend, I will miss your your crab cakes most. Very clean store and perfect for high end catering. Minus 3 stars for unreasonably high price points.

I'll take one of everything.

See all

Fried artichokes. So garlicky and delicious

Firehouse Deli

3.3(26 reviews)

0.6 mi

•$$$$

I really like this spot. It's small with a very limited but creative list of sandwiches and they…read moremake a solid BEC too. It is stocked with the essentials and not much more. Very friendly service and best prices in the area. Big fan!

Friendly Many options…read moreFair price Coffee creamer flavors I never heard of and are awesome Parking ample Accessible A must try

THANK YOU Firehouse Deli for making the most delicious chicken salad

See all

Chicken salad, BLT & American cheese

Crosstown Chef

4.5(8 reviews)

1.2 mi

Crosstown Chef is a new deli that opened on Montauk Highway, right before you get into the main…read moretown of Sayville. Its the next street over from the restaurant "Off the Block". I live a few streets over and I've never been happier to have such a quality deli this close. I have had breakfast and lunch multiple times from here. I have had egg white wraps, breakfast burritos & french toast for breakfast. I have also had a couple different sandwiches for lunch (El Guapo is so good, it's a must have), along with their iced coffee. Everything I have had has been 5 stars. The quality and portions of food is amazing. They have a very nice store, with a handful of tables to dine in. There are "to go" sandwiches freshly made that come with a bag of chips. Super convenient if you are in a rush and don't have the few extra minutes to wait for them to make a sandwich. Service is fast, and the staff as well as the owner are super friendly. I have had a couple of nice convos with the owner, you can tell how much he cares about his store. Go check it out!

Hungry man breakfast had 2 pieces of bacon - SKIMPY!!!! - Cheese was stuck to paper that sandwich…read morewas in - other items I bought were not up to par with other delis - I guess dinner must be better - will NOT go back .......P.S. I brought home the Philly Cheesesteak and it WAS PITIFUL !!!!! How long has this place been there ??? It's a miracle they are still open.

Mandarin Salad

Chicken Milanese

See all

Grab n Go

Friendly Bagels of Bayport

3.2(43 reviews)

0.0 mi

First time going here today and the bagels are fresh. Service is friendly. Atmosphere is great…read more Lots of little treats and homemade cream cheese. Definitely recommend.

if you're gonna charge $3.50 for a bagel with butter actually put butter on the bagel. this isnt…read morethe first time this has happened. I don't even understand how this place is still open

Inside

See all

Breakfast

Off The Block Kitchen & Meats

4.4(571 reviews)

1.2 mi

4.5 stars. It's a…read moregood thing I was sitting down because the (black garlic aioli 5-cut burger) made my knees buckle when I bit into it. There is something very special about this offering. And it's worth the $25 price tag. All of the food was perfectly executed. My only complaint is that the decor/service/ambiance do not match the high price tag of the food. I'm willing to pay for this level of food but I wish it was in a nicer setting. I didn't even get a steak knife. The open kitchen is very cool.

Definitely not worth the money or the wait. We waited over an hour just to be seated, then another…read morehour after ordering before the food came out. The restaurant was extremely crowded and very loud. For a table of four, we only ordered two appetizers. Only two of us ordered steaks a 24 oz Prime Porterhouse and a 24 oz Prime Ribeye, both $85. The other two meals were one burger and one chicken sandwich. Our total still came to $359.97 before tip. The steaks were well seasoned and flavorful, but unfortunately cooked unevenly. At $85 each, I expected them to be cooked properly and consistently. The service was also disappointing. We were never offered water, and when we ordered a bottle of wine, they didn't even have enough wine glasses for the table, so some of us had to use champagne glasses. The calamari was delicious, crispy with a little spice, and the wings were juicy and flavorful. Those were probably the best part of the meal. Overall, for nearly $360 before tip for four people with only two steaks, one burger, one sandwich, and two appetizers the experience did not feel worth the price.

Friday Afternoon FTW

Fried chicken special with Skillet Macaroni & Cheese

See all

Rosé

Bagel Express Sayville

2.9(61 reviews)

1.7 mi

Great easy spot in the heart of Sayville. The egg everything bagel is outstanding. I like to hollow…read moremine out and fill it with vegetable cream cheese which they make in-house house Just a sidenote very busy on Monday. Get there early!

Worlds most on unorganized bagel shop…read more The staff always seem to be overwhelmed and every time I'm there something goes wrong with someone's order. It just so happened that I was the unlucky customer after giving my order to the wrong person my sandwich was slapped together incorrectly to just push me out the door. I finally got home and ready to have a nice breakfast I open the soggy paper of my sandwich to see I pile of slop on a roll. One bite and threw it in the trash. Steer clear of this grumpy bagel shop

Other locations

Storefront.

See all

Prices.

Cornucopia Natural Foods

4.5(85 reviews)

1.9 mi

•$$$

We were on Long Island visiting family and stayed in Ronkonkoma. All of the friends who still live…read morethere were talking about Station Yards and how fabulous the plaza is to visit and the shops to frequent. We stopped in Cornucopia to pick up some fresh produce and see what else the store had to offer. I swear I bought the best bananas I've ever had in my life. The selection is varied in each section of the store; it is well lit, very clean and when you get to the counter, the nicest people are there to help you check out. We will return the next time we are in the area.

I hear a lot of people talking about this coconut cult, yogurt, so I tried some and I do like it…read moreand do feel like it may be helping my tummy feel better. It might be also due to the lack of lactose in this particular brand. It is hard to find, but always in stock here Cornucopia. That is what initially drew me here. The store is has an organic earthy tone, layered wood displays with mute tones. It feels like shopping in a cozy enchanted forest. With fresh things growing everywhere. They seem to have a little bit of everything. I enjoy the FRESH goodies at the counter as you check out, they are all amazing. Something else to check out is the app called to " TooGoodToGo" it has $10.00 surprise bags for here so you can also add a great deal to the trip and wait for your exciting surprise. So even though it was the coconut colt that brought me into the store, I find myself coming back more and more. I enjoy the shopping experience and excellent customer service.

See all

Outside

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

12 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Michelle A.

0

56

26

3 years ago

BTW I NEED YOU TO READ THE BOTTOM PART OF THE REVIEW! I've heard many of the stores are very helpful with gluten. It's should be taken seriously! I'm shocked and surprised this carefree lil girl is incapable of understanding ****FARMINGDALE****PLEASE READ REVIEW BELOW EXTREMELY IMPORTANT!! They're nothing more than a 1 THIS REVIEW IS ABOUT FARMINGDALE. BE AWARE OF UNEDUCATED NASTY EMPLOYEES! I just watched the most disgusting video of a nasty employee making fun and disrespecting a girl with celiac disease! All she asked was to please change their gloves before they handle her bread. No big deal. That Spanish girl snaps in her face a few times then tells her to get out this isn't McDonald's. Well dumba$$. You sell gluten free for a reason. Horrible people & place to ask for a simple request and who would want to eat! I've been there. If had heard that I would've called I'm going to inc the link and time of the video. I think you should watch it and retrain your staff. I have posted this review everywhere. Social media, on all stores listed on Long Island! You need to retrain that uneducated nasty girl. Teach her how serious it is to not change gloves! Then fire her and the girl laughing with her! The fact not one manager or asst manager came out is why they get away with crap! Farmingdale Jersey Mikes hires very uneducated and nasty Karen's! They sell gluten free but refuse to change gloves while touching the gluten free bread. They'll tell you to leave this is fast food. I hope many others share this and watch the video. I'm surprised the girl who ordered first blow up! Apparently these dumb girls don't care if a customer dies or gets severely sick! Parents must be so proud of the garbage they raised !! Once you retrain. 107.23 is where it starts. I hope managers see it and corporate! Beginning https://youtube.com/clip/Ugkxvj1DLwaRQQ0e9EZvgGHx6UZhG8gY0ieJ?si=7xraPeUprTk2Z352 Last Bit. https://youtube.com/clip/UgkxujabonkBMvIiIfWAHP4qnMP3eB4UM4um?si=07UuskqLLKM2KyKQ I think these entitled brats 25-26 & under, are seriously in need of classes! They need to be taught about Health issues like allergies, celiac disease etc.... read more

Zach D.

0

1

0

9 years ago

Where can I even start with this place. Well first off, the most important part of any restaurant is its food and Jersey Mikes subs are better than good. After I ate my first sub from this place it left me wondering when can I get another one? Another important aspect of a restaurant is its customer service skills and Jersey Mikes isn't lacking in that department. The Employees truly know their craft and if you don't know what exactly you're looking for they give plenty of good recommendations. Also while I was waiting for my sandwich to be done I had a nice conversation with one of the employees. In most other restaurants or other fast food places I usually don't experience that good interaction with the person making my food they just do it and that's it. Jersey Mikes is a great addition to this area and I'm looking forward to eating there in the future. read more

Rosario C.

0

1

0

8 years ago

Sandwiches were exquisite, filling, great tasting meals that were made with great speed. It has a great atmosphere, and the man that served me, John, was respectful and provided me with top class service. If you are looking for a good bite to eat, this is the place. It has food for the whole family! Highly recommended read more

William E.

0

1

0

8 years ago

Nothing but great service and great subs. I've been going here almost every day for lunch in between my school periods. I have a couple of special orders that these guys never forget, sometimes knowing what I want as soon as I walk inside. John and Bianca have especially made the experience wonderful. read more

Johnny B.

18

3

8 years ago

I luv this store, people say dat shit is expensive but don't be a poor bit a*wigga boy & you can get yourself a sub** sandwich*. I had a sub 2 days ago it was not good.... it was great%%##. thanks jersey mikes for making me a fatty. Ok send me cupons now mikeal,,No cap mop**** read more

Cathy H.

0

8

0

6 years ago

Will no longer eat at ANY Jersey Mikes until the employees from Staten Island Jersey Mikes who turned their backs on police and refused to serve them are fired!!! These incidents need to stop! Disrespect for our police should not be supported...boycott ALL Jersey Mikes. read more

Maddy M.

0

1

0

8 years ago

My first time at Jersey mikes and I was super satisfied, The whole crew was so bright and warm I felt like I was at a friends house. They catered to all of my needs, even passed by my table and refilled my cup. read more

Alejandra S.

87

1

0

8 years ago

Great and friendly staff very helpful! As a first timer I was very happy with the portion! I most definitely recommend Jersey Mike's Subs to my family and friends read more

Danielle C.

0

7

0

9 years ago

Amazing. Staff is always so friendly. Great sandwiches. Awesome new addition to the neighborhood. Highly recommended.

Ryan B.

0

1

0

8 years ago

Food was great, service was great. Manager John provided great service and I will definitely be coming back again.

Matthew Gino Jensen G.

93

1

0

8 years ago

Steak and cheese, can't get any better then this.

B G.

0

83

4

8 years ago

Fresh bread and tasty cold cuts.

Jersey Mike's Subs - hotdogs - Updated October 2026

People who viewed Jersey Mike's Subs also viewed

Back Country Deli

3.1

(27 reviews)

Good local spot! Especially in area with no other food/Delis nearby. Quick grab and go deli with no…read morecomplaints!

9 dollars sausage egg cheese and felt like i was eating a egg and cheese sandwich. Spot decentread more

Go Burger

4.3

(223 reviews)

Good place for lunch -veggie options available- efficient and good service. Pleasant Ambiance! Good…read morevalue

Got takeout tonight. Ordering online was easy and efficient. This was my husband and I's first…read moretime trying Go Burger and it absolutely exceeded our expectations! The burgers were juicy and cooked very well. French fries were perfect. Onion rings were some of the best we have ever had and the dessert was spectacular. If we could give you more stars we would.

Bayport Deli and Convenience

4.5

(8 reviews)

The sandwiches are so pricey and the guy was honestly pretty rude the guy who made my sandwich I…read moredon't know if he woke up on the wrong side or the bed or what but had a nasty attitude.

Great family owned operation; sandwiches are great, service is on point…read more Give them a try if you are in the area.

Subway

3.1

(8 reviews)

Employees are very nice , they are also fast, food is always amazing. The inside is also very nice…read moreand redone

So this place is close 2 my job and convenient, and I've overlooked a lot because of these factors…read more 2day I had a not so lovely bread sandwich. There was hardly any filling. The bread was a bit stale 2 boot. So, with that in mind, my co-workers and I will find another place 2 put in2 our rotation of dinning venues.

Giacalone's Deli

3.7

(26 reviews)

I paid $33.72 for 3 sandwiches, none were heros. The quality is very basic, I remember this place…read moreuse to have a better vibe. I barely got the attention of the ladies working there, like eye contact when taking an order so I know you are listening and take notes would be nice. I think this is the last time I'm coming here, no pickle with my sandwiches and no macaroni salad offered. Fast food may just be the way to go. They also forgot my extra cheese

No prices posted anywhere in the entire establishment. I ordered the "Coogie" on a hero. Roast…read morebeef, melted mozzarella cheese and brown gravy on garlic bread. Menu online says $11.95, yet woman working there charged me $21.00 for that hero sandwich and a 20 ounce soda. Shame on me for not asking the price before ordering, but an even bigger shame on them for having the audacity to charge what they did. They've lost a customer for life. I will never step foot in there again. If anyone reading this post does go there, you've been forewarned. Bring your paycheck.

La Bistro

3.8

(121 reviews)

Used their catering services at work. Bummed I didn't get any pictures but we had a big variety of…read morethings and everything was delicious. Everything from penne, alla vodka, chicken parm, eggplant parm, sliders with garlic knots as the bread, salad, chicken cutlets, plain cheese pizza, etc. All were really good.

I came here with my two-year-old and we sat down to eat. The girl at the counter told us she would…read morebring the food to our table, so we sat at an empty one. We ordered two slices and an order of six knots. She brought the two slices, and I simply asked to confirm if the knots were included in the order. She gave me the nastiest look and said, "I only have two hands, geez." I was honestly taken aback and said, "Whoa, that was rude." When she came back, instead of handing the food to us, she placed the knots on the empty table next to me like we were animals. I was in complete disbelief. She was rude for absolutely no reason. I was just confirming the order. Never again. Just flat out disgusting. And my toddler begged me for pizza and I had to get up and ask for a refund because there was no way we would just sit there and eat in a rude uncomfortable environment. What happen to humanity!

Go Burger

4.3

(205 reviews)

Food ALWAYS very good Burgers are excellent…read more Fast service I highly recommend Always dependable for a good meal. No issues ever

I really like their food. I think they're awesome. They have a lot of nice things, but their only…read moresetback is their French fries really suck. They're greasy limp, and they really need to switch to either crinkle, cut or a thicker potato and learn how to make French fries.

Inferno the Restaurant

4.4

(208 reviews)