I love that Jersey Mike's has a mini. Due to medical issues I can not eat much at one time and it's not always convenient to bring home leftovers. Everything is fresh and made to order. The staff will also sometimes have suggestions. While I usually get my sub to go, I would have no trouble eating in the restaurant as it is clean and well lit. read more

I placed my order online so I cannot really talk much about service. However when I picked up my order I wasn't greeted, I was only asked what the name on my mobile order is. I ordered a #7 in a tub, Mike's way (no onion) bacon and extra pickles. While it was delicious, there was definitely not extra pickles...only about 4 pickle chips. Sub in a tub is definitely the way to go if you're watching your carb intake. I'm full! read more

The subs are fresh and prepared in front of you. The staff is friendly and the company does lots of charitable work. I love the place.

Great experience, I have been here before, but not in a while. Service was fast, friendly, and accurate. Kailah made an amazing Italian hero. Delicious. The tables were clean and the music relaxing. The servers are constantly working, keeping the line down. There are plenty of patrons coming and going. I'll be back. Thank you. read more

See all

Friendly staff. Clean & bright. Great subs at a great price. What else could you want?

Jersey Mike's has the best subs around, hands down! Everything's fresh and there's plenty of it on every sub, no matter which one you get!

My Sister and I tried these subs and we love them! We usually get lunch here every weekend. The staff, especially John are so welcoming and friendly. They even know our orders, so when we go in they ask if we want our usual and then they make it to perfection. All in all a great place with great food, service And employees. And place is clean and all covid protocols followed. PS My personal favorite is the #44 Buffalo Chicken cheese steak! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #56 Big Kahana Cheesesteak left #44 Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak right - Fast Food Near Me - Bayport, New York

The online ordering is convenient and do a limited time they were giving 25% off those orders when you chose to pick up; That being said, the ordering customization process needs help, the store seems like a sub-par Quiznos meets a half-asses Subway. When you're in New York I don't see why anyone would voluntarily and eagerly continue to go to Jersey mikes when we have some of the best (and only) Delis in the country. It's not a bad spot, but I don't see a smaller hero at $9 making its way into my heart not routine anytime soon. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Chicken cheesesteak - Fast Food Near Me - Bayport, New York

See all

Meh, it's okay. I think they are overpriced for sandwiches, but my husband absolutely loves their subs. He was so excited when one opened up locally. They're definitely better than Subway with their food, but I find the service friendlier at the Subway we go to. We've done subs a few times via Door Dash for both pickup and delivery and the food is always pretty consistent. For me it's a 3 start experience, but hubby says 5, so I'll be kind and give them a 4. :D read more

Lets make this fast like jersey mikes is a fast food chain and is one of the best chain around. Very fresh clean and delicious. The staff is very nice and polite and make one hell of a great sandwich. Thank you for your service. See you soon. read more

I love Jersey Mikes. I live in Queens and unfortunately we don't have any near by, so whenever I'm back on Long Island visiting friends and family I always make sure to stop in for my favorite sandwich, turkey and provolone "mikes way" (lettuce tomato onion oregano oil and vinegar) I like this place much for than subway because the coldcuts are actually fresh and sliced when you order in front of you, not just sitting pre-cut in a bin. This location in particular has very friendly staff and they are very fast when you order either in person or for delivery. Definitely check them out! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Fast Food Near Me - Bayport, New York

Gino & John Gabe the best customer service I've ever had from a sandwich shop. My buddy and I said we were going fishing so they individually wrapped the lettuce, tomato, dressing on the side and shrink wrapped the sandwiches so they wouldn't get soggy. Love this place. Highly recommend read more

There is a lot of hype surrounding Jersey Mike's Subs. Prior to going, I took a look at the menu online since I've never been. I decided I wanted to try the BBQ beef sandwich. Of course, this location didn't carry that sandwich. Most of their menu consists of different variations of cheesesteaks and I wasn't feeling that. I tried the Club sub "Mike's Way" which is lettuce, tomato, oil, vinegar and additional spices. It was so good, fresh, and the service was good. The price does reflect this as it is much more expensive than Subway. $9 for a 6inch. However, they do pack it on and I was full after. If you're lucky enough to find a coupon, you can get buy one sandwich, get one free. Next time, I'd try one of the cheesesteaks. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Club Sub "Mike's Way" - Fast Food Near Me - Bayport, New York

Let me begin this with a fun anecdote. When I moved to NY from NJ (seems like another lifetime ago) I went into a shop somewhere in Queens and ordered something and asked for it on a hoagie roll. The guy was like what the hell is a hoagie, you mean a hero?! And I was like, what the hell is hero?! You mean Superman? Anyway, this place makes great subs, heros, hoagies, grinders, and even sandwiches. It is not really the real thing, I mean you will obviously get a better cheesesteak off South Street in Philly, but these guys at this shop do a great job. The touch of nostalgia is great being a Jersey boy and all. It's got the chain feel to it because it is. It reminds me of a MUCH BETTER subway. I'm always happy with my herogie or whatever you want to call it I get from here. read more

got 2 heroes with meat on them couldn't taste the meat just the dressing because their was barely any meat on them not worth $20

The sandwiches are as good as it can be. But I do have 2 points of criticism (not complaints). Only 2nd time here but they don't have black pepper and instead offered oregano. I wasn't sure if I heard right because each employee from the person making the sandwich to the condiment person to the cashier all mumbled. I had to keep saying "what?". I am not hard of hearing but these kids need to speak up and be clear. I have to go other affiliates and know the routine and know they try to be quick but felt bad for the old lady behind me cause she was not a regular. Again, why doesn't the store have black pepper? read more

I love this restaurant. The hero's are always so fresh. I specifically use this restaurant because of John. He is the most amazing customer service man I have coke across in forever. He is always happy, always gets my order right and just is a delight. I call when I order and he is always so pleasant to talk to. Thanks John for being amazing. I recommend this restaurant to everyone. If you need to know anything or questions about the menu then John is your guy. Everyone is nice there. I just feel that he goes above and beyond every single time. A++++ You want a fresh hero with fresh bread this is your place. read more

Hoagies and grinders, hoagies and grindershhhhhaaagies and grinderrsss!! Yes!! I am a freakin fan of jersey mikes... I have been seeing their ads for at least 20 years during family vacations... never stopped... so glad I went bc I am going back... it reminds of when I was a kid and had a hero for the first time... the meats not as cheap as subway but it's not delfiores ( poke store).. the bread is delicious and the staff and store is great... I had the Italian hero!!! Good old fashion Italian. Huge!!!!! My son had buffalo chicken hero. My other son ordered his own combo.. very most... everything is done to order in front of you... and that's the down fall. One slicer and one grill... I kept one star due to the quality of meat.. can't wait to go back and try others!! read more

See all

Good subs. Cold cut subs never disappoint. Become a Shore Points member and get points for free subs. Good quality and friendly people. Many employees been there quite a while so that's a positive thing. Bayport takeout getting really expensive, but the subs here are worth the extra cost. read more

Decided to try this one day on a recommendation from a friend. The staff was friendly and the wait time for the sandwiches/wraps to be made was quick. It was more expensive than I expected for what was ordered. (I would rather pay the same price for one of my favorite sandwiches from a local deli.) I tried their tuna - it was a bit watery and had a lot of pepper in it which I personally was not a fan of. Overall, the options are limited, not great, and exactly what you would expect from a "fast food" sandwich joint. read more

This has become my pandemic go-to for Saturday lunches with my sister. It's always clean, "safe", service is quick and the staff is great. John is fabulous- he is always welcoming and friendly. read more

I have read through other reviews, and while I agree that the staff at this location have a tendency to be rude, and the prices a bit high, I feel that the food is worth it. Before going, you need to have the expectation that you are going to spend more than at Subway. The major difference is, Jersey Mikes packs their subs. Not just with vegetables, but with fresh meats and cheeses. I have been here many times and have never felt like I did not receive my moneys worth. There are coupons in a number of places, including the back of grocery store receipts. The best ones are for buy one, get on free. However, this is the area at this location that costs them a star. Employees get agitated when they see you using one of these coupons. They act as if the money is coming directly out of their pocket. But, if you can get past the employees, I would recommend this place over a Subway restaurant any day. read more

This place was fine. Our food was good until I got sick from it. My boyfriend got chicken and I got beef. Nothing happened to him, but my mom and I got diarrhea after sharing a sandwich. It got bad enough that I had to leave work early that day. read more

2nd time ordering from this location; everything was fresh; we received the correct order and it all was prepared on time; we will be going back ! read more

I was so hoping for this place to fill the void of the missing hero shops of yesterday. After a lot of fan fare and advertising I was tempted to try. It's not terrible but here is my honest feedback. The meat is your typical franchise low end low cost cold cut. It's not the high end boars head type that you would get and for the price they charge you would expect better quality. The price. This is the most egregious part of Jersey Mike's, are you ready for this 16 Dollars for the large Sub. What?? (A long drawn out Whhatt?) Normal size after tax is about 10 bucks, still crazy. It's just way too high for the quality, now they are fresh cut so it's a step above subway, but we know how much Subway charges. The wait. Because they fresh cut the wait can often be far too long. I waited over a half an hour for three sandwiches. No kidding. The staff. They seem preoccupied and untrained. They often forget what you ordered by the time it gets to the register. I am unapologetic about the following statement, the one thing that really irks me is when a service employee says 'what did you order again?' There hasn't been one time in the three that I've been here when the person ringing me up doesn't make me go through my whole order again. Lots of room for improvement here. But sadly the price:quality:service ratio is broken here. With such a high price they need to up either the quality or the service. Worth a try or if you are desperate for a sandwich and don't want to go to the less than impressive Local delis. read more

Food is good and fresher than Subway. But the prices reflect that. Much more expensive! The store itself is clean and bright. Staff ok but not particularly friendly. Parking good since it is in a shopping center. read more

See all

I paid 25$ for two subs that were not full size. They don't even have a toaster ...... Also might as well got subway. Better food for a better price. Sorry. Tj hero's is way better but sadly they're closed on Sunday! read more

Love Jersey Mikes !!!!! Prices are good, service was excellent, worth the slightly higher price then Subway and other sub shops !!!! Store clean, FRESH bread, meat, ect... !! We had an overall great experience and will be our family's go-to sub shop !!! AMAZING SUB'S AND FRIENDLY SERVICE !!!!! THANK YOU JERSEY MIKE'S OF BAYPORT !!!!! read more

First time ever trying any Jersey mikes . Overall I give it a five star based on clean service and food was proper . Nice job ! I will be back read more

I love Jersey Mike's and was so excited when they open a store in Bayport. The store is clean, the staff is amazing and my sub is always fresh. read more

Over priced. Ordered an Italian sub. No flavor. Ham looked like it was pressed . Wouldn't go there again read more

Omg Jersey Mike's was so good ... bayport location.. John the manager was great. Had so many people going out the door and ran out of bread. He still handled it well. Give him a raise. read more

Courteous staff and their hero's are quite tasty and fresh. In fact, they are better than some of the "local delis" in the neighborhood. The dining area is always kept clean. Overall, a very pleasant experience. I've had the Italian hero, the meatball hero and the cheesesteak hero and all of them were delicious. read more

This was our first visit to Jersey Mikes and we were super pleased! We ordered 4 different heros so we could sample a variety. All were delicious and generously sized (regular size was our choice). The ruben was the best ruben I remember ever eating. My husband raved about the phillie cheesesteak too. So pleased to have a franchise opened in our area (Bayport) and I see many more visits in our future. John, the owner/manager was delightful and helpful in guiding us in our selections when he learned of our tastes. We took our orders home to eat but the dining area and surroundings were very clean. Great eating experience! read more

Best service I've experienced in a while. They helped me after I made an error with my order. Thank you so much guys!

My favorite sub spot? HELL YEAH!! This place never seems to disappoint. First experience with Jersey Mikes was surprisingly in California, and once I heard they moved into my neighborhood, it was game over Subway. MUST, MUST, MUST try this place if you haven't already!! HIGHLY RECOMMEND #9 MIKES WAY!! read more

Ordered for the 1st time last night since my regular hero shop is closed Mondays. Ordered over the phone. Out of 3 "subs" they got one wrong. It cost me nearly $27 for what i consider 3 half hero's and one was given to the dog,(he liked it). Yes the bread is fresh, the cold cuts good and works (mike's way) were right but give me a TJ's hero any day over a Jersey Mike's sub. I get full hero, Boar's Head cold cuts, the works and exactly what I ordered for a better price. I shan't be returning. It might be considered great in New Jersey but on Long Island there are better choices. read more

Jersey Mikes is the perfect place to grab a bite to eat on the go, lunch or dinner, all at a reasonable price. Sandwiches made with quality meat and fresh vegetables. Regular subs go for around 8, mini's for about 6, and giants for 13-15. John, the manager, does a great job keeping the place clean and works tirelessly to provide great service. Highly recommend eating here. read more

Love this jersey Mike's it's my go to after work. Staff is cool & quick with orders. Get #44 if you don't know what to ge.

Loved the service. The people were great. Food wss delicious. Knocks the other one out of the park. Everything was so fresh. The atmosphere was enjoyable. read more