Hi everyone, I really enjoy the birthday cake ice cream at Jeremiah's Italian Ice. It's one of the best desserts I've ever had. They have a great rewards program that makes it easy to redeem points. The staff are always so friendly here as well. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Stuart, Florida

Jeremiah's is definitely worth a stop if you're craving a frozen treat. The frozen custard was exceptionally fresh, rich, and creamy, and you could really taste the quality. I kept it simple with chocolate Italian Ice and vanilla frozen custard, and the combination was outstanding. Sometimes the classics are all you need. What impressed me most was the huge variety of Italian Ice flavors and the number of custard and ice combinations you can create. The selection is impressive, and it looks like you could come back over and over without trying the same thing twice. I ordered a medium, and it was surprisingly generous. It was more than enough for me, so keep that in mind when ordering. The cashier was friendly, welcoming, and patient while I looked over all the flavor options. The atmosphere is about what you'd expect from this type of dessert shop--clean and comfortable, but nothing that really stands out, which is perfectly fine since the focus is on the product. Overall, great quality, excellent flavor selection, generous portions, and friendly service. I'd definitely be back to try more combinations. read more

We love Jeremiah's! My favorite Florida icee shop, they've got all sorts of custom flavors from tropical to decadently to just plain old sweet. My favorite flavors are Cookies and Cream, Bahama Mama, or Cookie Dough mixed with vanilla soft serve. We recently tried their Strawberry Shortcake frozen cake--pretty tasty treat that's lasted us a while! This location has a unique carry out window, which I like when I'm grabbing a quick pint to go. A good amount of indoor seating compared to their other South Florida locations, plenty of room to throw a kids birthday party here. Very clean inside too. The staff is friendly and quick to serve, but I never feel like I'm being rushed. And there's ample parking out front or to the side. Be sure to download their app, they give the best freebie deals and birthday rewards. Never change Jeremiah's! read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Order out front, sit out front or take to go! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Stuart, Florida

The best Italian ice and ice cream! The strawberry shortcake and birthday cake was phenomenal. The service was extremely quick and I can't wait to come back to try more. Highly recommend to italian ice and ice cream lovers. read more

See all

So we came here to try an ice cream place as we finished dinner at an Italian restaurant. And what goes better with Italian food than ice cream right ?? We walked up to the counter and learned we can only order from the outside counter. So the wife went inside and I ordered the Oreo gelati. I was thinking it was the same as Rita's ices as it was going to have gelato with the ice. It was soft served ice cream with ice. Either way; I watched them make it and it was very big. Tons of Oreo pieces on top and in the middle of the thing. Definitely not a healthy option lol. My wife and I slammed that thing down. I will also say we got plenty of samples of the other flavors and cake batter was amazing as well. I'd come back. I wish it was just a gelato instead of soft served. read more

See all

Today was my first time trying Jeremiah's Ice and I had a pleasant experience. I appreciated that it wasn't overly sweet and that there were so many choices. They have frozen ice, gelati, and ice cream in addition to toppings. I am lactose intolerant, so I didn't do an ice cream or any add on's. I ordered the Strawberry lemon, and it was perfect for a hot day. The girl at the counter explained about their rewards program on the app, definteerly a must if you frequent here. Stop by and try some you won't regret it. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Strawberry lemon - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Stuart, Florida

Finally we have an Italian place in Martin county that delivers high quality across the board including the custard! We went with the Orange Mango Tango and it was one of the best Italian ice/ Custard combos I've ever had. Each bite had both an awesome amount of custard and ice and it was a perfect treat to end the night after dinner and is recommended to split between 2. Highly recommend stopping by and visiting the Jeremiah's team. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Orange Mango Tango (Orange,Custard,Mango,Custard) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Stuart, Florida

First time here and everything that we tried was super tasty! My daughter got the Oreo Mud pie which she said tasted exactly like the name! Also got two gelato's one mango and one watermelon the salt ice cream melt in your mouth along with the Italian ice flavor really hit the spot! When walking up we mentioned it was our first time and customer service offered of us free samples if we wanted to try which I thought was really awesome! The vibe sitting outside enjoying it is definitely south Florida lol relaxing and good music. There are two small tables and a nice sit around area. read more

See all

On our last trip to PSL we discovered Jeremiah's. I am from Philly, so when it comes to Italian Ice, no one can do better in my mind than Rita's. Needless to say I didn't have high expectations for this place since my standards were high. I can proudly say that Jeremiah's exceeded my expectation and is now my favorite Italian Ice ( water ice to us Philadelphians). They have an array of flavors and different Italian ice/soft serve options. The P-Nutty, mango, watermelon, and froggy frog ( mint chocolate chip) are some of the recommended flavors. read more

Best Italian ice I've ever had and you get so much for $4 and some change. Friendly staff. We've been 3 times this week if that says anything. And they sell by quests which I think I saw it was only about $10. Maybe I could be wrong. read more

So happy that my favorite place has come to town. Great service despite the HUGE opening rush. Never disappointed in the product; great quality soft serve and great quality Italian ice. Doesn't get better than that. PS: I love that this location has both indoor and outdoor ordering and seating available! read more

This place always does a great job and they have a very friendly and welcoming staff.

so happy jeremiah's made it to stuart. we had where we used to live and loved it so was thrilled to see it open today. great gelatis and awesome staff! now to get a gym membership :) read more

Quick service, delicious as Jeremiah's always has been. Nice outdoor and indoor seating area.

Had to check out what an ice cream Italian ice was Yummy and big servings The sprinkles were different read more

very good service amazing options. Food is delicious and I would recommend anything but I would also have a favor to ask. Maybe you could get a bunch of sodas and have a float option as well to make floats with your Italian ice or soft serve just think about it. Awesome dessert! read more