Went in to check out the cooked section because we didn't feel like cooking. We got a couple of things to try. Stuffed flounder, eh, not great, empanadas were also eh and there was a fried grilled cheese that was good, not great. Next time I'll purchase something to cook on my own. The store was very clean and there were a ton of things to pick from. The staff were very nice. read more

Jeff's Seafood - Raw fish section - Seafood Markets Near Me - Halesite, New York

See all

Love stopping into this wonderful spot to by fresh seafood, cooked food and other gourmet treats. Great spot to pick up items for beach or picnic at park. Staff is friendly and establishment is very clean. Breakfast sandwich always yum. Coffee is great! Live that the crushed olive is there as well.. read more

Jeff's Seafood - Fried egg on fresh soft sourdough with mozzarella, fresh tomatoes, salt and pepper. Melts in your mouth. - Seafood Markets Near Me - Halesite, New York

See all

Amazing place!! Seafood is so fresh and delicious! Place is clean and well stocked. It's my go to place now for seafood but I look forward to trying the butcher section as well!! Staff is also very friendly and accommodating read more

imitation seafood without being labeled should be a crime! Jeff's "the gourmet title word is just a lure for this business " imitation crab same garbage as they have in king Kullen low grade farmed shrimp for shrimp salad I walked out upset and hungry as was told this is what customers prefer? came in for quality almost bit the hook no pun intended best to you should be Jeff's imitation seafood regards Alan read more

Gourmet is a lure for business If you're selling imitation crab and low quality farmed shrimp in your food it should be advertised as such! If I wanted imitation seafood I could go to king Kullen market Wasted my time going in there. Glad I asked before I wasted my money as well Left hungry and upset Will never go back read more

Ordered fried calamari and fish and chips and it was very disappointing. calamari was tough and chewy with no flavor and the fish and chips were not any better. the batter was flavorless and dry. So disappointing. read more

I'm liking Jeff's more and more every time I come her with bf. Today we bought a beautiful piece of swordfish and 6 scallops which I brought home and marinated. Last week, we bought a piece of salmon which was great! The guys who work here are very nice 8/3/20 I have a love and not so love relationship with Jeff's depending on who's working that day. Today, not so good. The kid who was helping me wasn't wearing his mask over his nose. Bad!!! I asked him to please cover his nose with his mask and he wasn't doing it so I insisted and suggested he get a tighter mask. Other than that, he should be watched. There's no one senior here though. At least we burned off his germs while searing the tuna!! read more

See all

Best fresh fish, and soup to have. The market is beautiful and lots of choices. Literally can get everything for dinner all at the one spot

I had a hankering for a fried fish sandwich for lunch so I called in my order at Jeff's. In general I love the new Jeff's but it can be a little pricey. But the sandwich and fries was $12 which I view as good value. The fries were great and the fish was fresh and excellent. The fillet hung out past the roll and the roll was large. If you feel like a fresh fish sandwich I highly recommend. read more

A+++++ sandwiches are excellent. Philly cheese steak is on another level. Will not be disappointed.

Fresh seafood & the best fresh fish sandwiches. Great owners & you can taste the ocean. read more

Jeff's Seafood - the outside of the restaurant - Seafood Markets Near Me - Halesite, New York

This place blew it. Was once the only decent fish monger in the area when it was the old location. They sold it, moved down the road, combined it with a pointless market and doubled their prices. Add to it the quality and selection of fish is downgraded and they staffed with a bunch of kids who don't know halibut from tilapia. So sad to see a good place die. I retried it multiple times but now avoid it and go to Whole Foods. Miss the old Jeff's :( read more

If you want the highest quality Sea Food, this is the place. Their prepared foods are also amazing. They make the best soups, their dry rubbed ribs taste like they came from Rib House. No matter what you eat here, it is over the top. read more

Check out the new space-south of the small shop we've gone to for so many years. Besides fresh fish, there's great meats, hot foods, and great soups. Open about a year? Go see for yourself. And always answer questions about preparing the fish. Very nice people working there. read more

Jeff's is our go-to seafood joint. I don't know that Jeff's is head-and-shoulders above a lot of fish counters in the area, but when I asked around who everyone uses for fish, I can see why nearly everyone said Jeff's. The fish is fresh, the prices fair. I have pretty high standards when it comes to fish joints, I grew up in Freeport, going to Two Cousin's, once a week during Lent. And 2C was one of many great fish shops on the Nautical Mile back then ... when local flounder was cheap and plentiful ... anyway, Jeff's passes muster, I like it. If you're missing Jeff's Surf and Turf (now another SoBol, yawn), they do have some stuff at regular Jeff's, you gotta ask. Four stars, plus one for recommending that we grill our scallops, hot damn are they good read more

Consistency great selection of fresh seafood. The shrimp, cherry stone clams, salmon, tuna is all terrific. But I have to say I have never had better baked clams than those at Jeff's Seafood. All I can say is they are phenomenal! And with the move up the road the market atmosphere in the larger space presents many culinary options and awesome service. read more

Outstanding! The best fish market around. Everything they make is top-shelf. Never disappointed and highly recommended. Bon Appetit! read more

I will say the shrimp mac and cheese was good. The lobster bisque is a little bit marginal. I got a couple of pieces of steamed lobster from the fresh seafood section, and was shocked to pay $75 a pound. This isn't East hampton. That is ridiculous. But I live and learn. Not rushing back. There was so much hype about this place, it's a glorified little market with ridiculous prices. read more

The best seafood! Always the fresh catch, just off the boat, fresh fresh fresh and local everyday. We love Jeff's so much! Would not buy our fish anywhere else. And in addition to the fresh local seafood, scallops, clams, and all else their shrimp cocktail and homemade cocktail sauce are wonderful! We also highly recommend their homemade garlic basil oil great for marinating fish or for dipping a fresh baguette. read more

I just left Jeff's and I'm so unbelievably disappointed by the service of this place. For the price you'd assume there would be no mistakes and everyone behind the counter would know how to make a sandwich. It took about 35 minutes to make 5 sandwiches. Nobody knew what they were doing... I heard them ask what goes into a Cesar salad wrap.... $15 for a sandwich that forgot to add the simple lettuce, tomato, mayo. I went to to check out and the young boy behind the counter was confused when we asked him to put our stuff in plastic baggies to leave. I had high hopes and heard great things but I don't think I'll be going back. read more

We picked up food from Jeff's Thursday before Christmas. There was a line out the door, we expected this, but it moved very quickly. The place was clean and the guys behind the counter were friendly and helpful. We brought home Crab-Corn Chowder, Lobster Bisque, Baked Clams, Shrimp-Vegetable dumplings, Crabcakes and Flounder Stuffed with Crab, everything was excellent. Usually we prepare & cook but were in the mood for an easy feast to heat & serve and it was perfect. read more

Another excellent Long Island fish market. Always a very good selection of fresh locally caught seafood. Owner is very hands on, I see him in the place pretty much every time I go there and he is extremely knowledgable, friendly and professional. Yes, as has been noted, he hires a lot of teenagers to work behind the counter but I'm not exactly sure when this became a bad thing. Lots of daily specials; I am especially happy to report they have revived a great little neck clam special they had stopped doing for a while; buy 3 dozen get one dozen free... read more

Jeff's Seafood - Seafood Markets Near Me - Halesite, New York

We ordered three dozen oysters for our SMALL superbowl party and they were super fresh. We had a mix, I believe, of west and east coasts and JEFFS prepared them expertly. They provided us with some lemons and laid them out on circular ice platters that made it super easy to eat and serve. Each one was cleaned and scrubbed and shucked to perfection and he even provided some oyster juice on the side in case I wanted to freshen them up. Again, I didnt expect to have them prepared and set up so properly. When my wife returned I was hoping that she left a good tip! The price was also VERY REASONABLE and I called days in advance to check on availability of which they told me to call the day before or a couple in advance and tell them what I wanted if I wanted them cleaned and prepped for pickup. I have also bought large pieces of fish here for dinner parties before. Always best just to come down and let the guys know what you are doing and for how many and how your plans look, and then they will suggest something. Stick with a pro. read more

The seafood itself still deserves 5 stars. Great selection, so fresh and fair prices. But these days, safety is just as important and I'm surprised that Jeff's doesn't seem to care that much about their customers' health. I went in last week for littlenecks, which were great. The main guy behind the counter was masked properly but at least one of the boys in the back working on the soft shell crabs had his mask down under his chin. I gave them another chance on Father's Day but was appalled at the lack of safe practices. It's a tiny tiny space and the sign on the door says two customers only at a time. We were waved in though, as was another customer. Soon there were about 5-7 customers in that small enclosed space, WAY too many. Why go against your own posted policy? Some employees had masks, but the main guy behind counter had no mask at all and was talking loudly, explaining how to cook something. Perfect way to get people sick. A customer then pulled his mask down and started loudly asking questions. No one told him to fix it. By that point my wife was feeling unsafe and so was I, so we left and took our business elsewhere. Every store has to make adjustments for safety in the wake of COVID. There's just no excuse for this and I'm sad because I did love their seafood. It's not worth putting my health at risk though. read more

This is a small place with a small selection of what looked to be only the freshest seafood available. This is just what I want in a seafood market because I am more focused on freshness than a huge selection. The striped bass and soft shell crabs made an excellent dinner. See you again soon. Possibly tomorrow! read more

Thanks for the pisser clams fresh out of the water. DE LI CIOUS! Alll nine dozen. We steamed them and then gobbled them up. Super fresh, lightly salted from the water they were just pulled from. read more

Great seafood. Got Alaskan King crab legs and shrimp cocktail to celebrate New Year's Eve at home. Crab legs were frozen, but pre-cooked for a quick meal preparation. Shrimp were firm and delicious! read more

I used to enjoy going to Jeff's for years, but I recently went into his new store to buy some soft shell crabs and was shell-shocked (no pun intended) to see that he is charging $10/crab for tiny ones. I ender up finding another local seafood market charging $6.99 and bought half a dozen. Maybe he's offsetting his prices with the cost of his new location and cost to build, but I am no longer a customer until his prices get more aligned with reality (inflation and all). read more

Our go to for fresh fish and shellfish. It's a little pricey but always great quality. Try the tuna fish salad. It's the best in Huntington. read more

We've been going to Jeff's for our seafood for years. It is always fresh and reasonably priced, and the people are courteous and friendly. We get lobsters for Christmas, and crab stuffed flounder often. I have never been disappointed in the quality or customer service. read more

We had the fish and chips the other night. Terrific! Nice fresh fish and French fries with a delicious crust! Everything else they offer is also great with very nice counter people. read more

Super helpful. Super fresh. What more could you ask for? Thank you for making my oyster shucking Saturday perfect.

After shopping at Marty's Seafood (review available), a little south (on New York Avenue) from Jeff's Seafood, I ran into someone who was having a blast playing with my dog and told me that Jeff's Seafood was much better. I decided to try it. Hum... I did not think that the selection at Jeff's was as good as Marty's. In addition, I've always liked the fact that at Marty's, the workers always remember all patrons and give you suggestions as to how to cook the fish, season it, etc in addition to being friendly. At Jeff's, there was two teenager kids behind the counter. Hum... And Jeff's place is super small too. I was at Jeff's and there were about 7 people and all squeezed in the little store area. Marty's is more open and airy with a couple of tables inside for those who would like to eat there. I can't find myself switching from Marty's Seafood to Jeff's. I just did not find the quality of the fish to be better, did not find the locale to be any better and did not think the service was any better. I will stay loyal to Marty's Seafood. read more

The first thing you should notice about a fish store is the smell. IT SHOUDN'T SMELL LIKE ANYTHING! (odor = rotting fish!) Jeff's is completely odorless :) Jeff's is awesome. Selection is a bit limited, but you can order anything and they'll get it for you. Cash only. ;) read more

This place is the real deal with fresh fish and yes, odorless. I'm super picky about fish - if there is even a hint of fishiness/seawater taste to my fish I will throw it away after cooking it and taking one bite (this happens with supermarket fish, and the places on Rte 110). It's never happened with anything bought at Jeff's. They are also very polite in the store & over the phone. I once called to see if they had scallops and the guy said "yes, but they seem to be going fast today. Do you want me to save you some?" Wow! I said yes, I wanted 10 biggies, and when i got there they handed me a paper bag with my name on it (and most of the case scallops were gone, so it was a good idea they offered that!). I love old-fashioned neighborhood service like that (and i don't go in all the time, so i wasn't getting the "Regular" treatment). read more

I completely agree that Jeff's doesn't smell like anything. The place is completely odorless (not even a cleaning solution smell to the air). The only things I'll ever ask for at Jeff's are; local and fresh (possibly whole, but not necessary). Jeff's constantly has fisherman running up into the place with the days catch, so I know that the fish is fresh. I would never buy fish from the seafood counter at the supermarket, and only buy local fish from Jeff's. read more

No issues with the fish at all. Lots of variety and all fresh, as always. My criticism is with the staff and how they wore their face masks. Some were wearing their masks properly, covering their nose and mouth. Some staff were wearing their masks improperly by covering their mouth, but not nose. Hint, you breathe far more through your nose than your mouth. But, the owner was not wearing a mask at all. He was walking around the store among staff and customers. Seriously? You're the boss, set the right example. read more

Superb market. Ultra-clean. Fabulous quality seafood. Highly compliant w/Covid-19 guidelines. Friendly & knowledgeable staff. Definitely recommend. Headed there now! read more

Went to Jeff's on July 3rd to get lobsters. Asked them to please steam for me. (Only 1$ extra) When I picked them up they were beautifully packed individually, placed in a sturdy pan with a large container of melted butter and lemons! They were the RAVE of my dinner -easily over 2 lbs each! The MOST DELICIOUS lobster that I have EVER tasted. We are still stuffed! Will do it again soon! If you ever need a recommendation.....!! Thank you so much! Robin O'Leary. Huntington read more

I buy seafood from Jeffs at least once per week and am very pleased with the food. However I'm a little upset with my visit to Jeff's on 6/10/20. I can't for the life of me understand why they ask customers to wear masks before entering(which I believe is the right thing to do), yet the employees have their masks below their nose. I don't get it. Is it a cool thing? Did they already have the virus and don't feel the need to wear the mask? Does the boss not care? Please explain. read more