So here's the deal: most people who do reviews of landlords have an axe to grind. They rarely…read morehighlight the good and dwell on the bad. I think Certified Properties did an okay job though, and hopefully this review serves to help others considering one of their properties.
I lived in a Certified Properties of Tompkins County [CPTC] apartment with one other person from 2012-2013. Our apartment, which was two blocks from Cornell, was a steal for this market: $450 a month per person for a two bedroom, one bathroom upper story apt. in a quaint old farmhouse that had been partitioned.
CPTC did an excellent job of maintaining our apartment when we notified them of problems. One day, our front door lock broke, leaving me locked in the apartment. I had a meeting to go to in a few hours time, but after calling Certified, they came right out, took the door off, repaired the lock, and the repairman was friendly and knew what he was doing.
Whenever we had an issue, they responded with professionalism.
However: in June, when we received the place, it was in a horrendous condition. The windows had been left open and hundreds of tiny gnats had died and fallen to rest on our living room floor. We cleaned that up, but...it wasn't fun.
Next, when we left the apartment, even though we personally cleaned everything according to their instructions, we got charged a massive cleaning fee, taken out of our security deposit. Eventually, I got most of it back by making our case, and after management admitted that a clerical mistake had been made, but only after repeated calls and emails.
Moving forward, tenants should always do two things: take lots of photos on an iphone or whatever when moving in, and take lots of photos of the state of the apartment when moving out.
All in all, CPTC is a professional company, especially if you're a good tenant (no parties, responsible care for the property etc), but do your due diligence, learn your tenant rights, and take photos to document conditions so as to combat future claims that may or may not be correct.