For #FirstTasteFriday, I decided upon this place. What's so crazy is I've never visited this place and just drove by it for years without ever giving them a thought and I was so glad that I did. When I first walked in I had looked on their above menu to see what all they offered. Of course pizza was the main thing as well as calzones and other fine edibles. I also noticed they offered wings, which I wasn't going to get at first as most pizza places bake their wings and not fry them. Just for GP I decided to ask them how they cooked their wings, were they baked or fried?? He said fried. Ruh Roh was what I said in my mind. Now I have to try these wings. The only problem I had which I can't really take off for was the timing. As the restaurant wasn't crowded, I had a 10-15 minute wait on the wings. Now when you're used to going places that get them out to you in 5 minutes, that's one hell of a change, especially if that's what you're used to. So I waited patiently while I was on the phone anyway, so no harm no foul. Once I did get them, I was HIGHLY IMPRESSED!! I ordered the mild, lemon pepper wings and they were pretty fabulous. They could run with some of the other well known wing spots and that's no joke. I'll change my rating after I try their pizza. If the wings are any indication of how their pizza will taste, I'll start going and getting a pizza wing combo. As of now, this is my new go to spot for wings. read more

I have always been a fan of Italian Pie, they have some of the best pizza in Dacula. Tonight I ordered an 18" Meat Lover pizza. When my husband got home with the pizza, I discovered that it was not what I ordered. I called back to let them know that they gave me the wrong pizza. After explaining the issue, the young man says yeah we've been having a lot of issues with our online ordering. He then says come back and I will "probably" be able to help you. My husband goes back with the pizza and was asked by the cook what the issue was. My husband explained what happened and asked for either a refund or the correct pizza. The cook got very defensive and starts yelling at my husband saying he's the cook, he did not make a mistake. My husband tries to diffuse the situation by agreeing and told him that we did not receive what we ordered, it must have been a computer error. My husband called me and told me to try to order the same thing again online and see what happens. I tried ordering again and this time it said my order was $1,600. I sent the screenshot to my husband so he could show them that their system was faulty. At this point the cook starts cussing and tells my husband to get the FUCK out. This type behavior is appalling and WE WILL NOT EVER SPEND OUR MONEY HERE AGAIN!! I attached the screenshot for reference. read more

Italian Pizza Pie - Pizza Near Me - Dacula, Georgia

Grabbed Italian pie for a lunchtime bite.. My first time tasting it Ordered a cheese pizza, and pepperoni The cheese pizza was ok.. The crust could stand alone on the pizza By itself, slightly salted..Good consistency Cheese and tomato sauce slightly above mediocre The pepperoni pizza made me question if they were running low On pepperonis I didn't see many, Maybe the world is ending? and they wanted to save some for after the apocalypse Not sure? But, it was just a nudge above mediocre Final thoughts: It wasnt bad.... Nor was it something I would crave in the future I don't believe my appetite Will lead me back here The crust made it ok to try read more

See all

Amo italian pizza,pero ultimadamente es un Desastres con las pizzas. ya es la segundas vez que la pizza llega queda y mal cortada. La primera vez no dejé un mensaje por que pense que la persona que la hizo tuvo un mal día. Pero tengo amigos que me han dicho lo mismo y un domingo como hoy quería deleitarme con una rica pizza de italian pizza pie, y fue un total fracaso. comi lo q pude junto con mi esposo y mi niña. Espero Y mejoren. por que son los únicos que para mí venden la mejor pizza. I love Italian pizza, but ultimately it's a pizza disaster. This is the second time the pizza arrives messy and poorly cut. The first time, they didn't leave a message because they thought the person who made it was having a bad day. But I have friends who have told me the same thing, and on a Sunday like today, I wanted to indulge in a delicious Italian pizza, and it was a total failure. I ate what I could with my husband and daughter. I hope they improve, because they are the only ones who, in my opinion, sell the best pizzas read more

See all

Multiple times I have ordered online ahead of time and my order was not even started by the time I went to pick it up. Today, my husband and I both tried calling to place an order and no one picked up the phone for almost 20 minutes. I eventually ordered when I got there and had to wait for my pizza, instead of quickly picking it up and heading home after a 12 hour shift. read more

The pizza is amazing the size is better bigger than most, the restaurant is clean and the service is awesome

Zero stars. Why does nobody pick up the phone?? Once you get inside there's 3 people there and no one managed to pick up when I called at least 10 times. read more

I have been very disappointed on several occasions with their pizza. It should not be that difficult to produce a good pepperoni pizza. It's always something wrong with Italian Pizza Pie, it either burnt, not enough ingredients or paper thin crust. I wish that we had more options for good pizza in Dacula (closer to hwy. 316) read more

I have ordered from this particular location, for a minimum of 10 years. I have always been incredibly happy. It's one of the few places that I never have to ask for extra stuff., Because it's always loaded! However, I ordered at the end of the evening, maybe 30 minutes before they closed, and did it online, my pizza was not what I ordered. I ordered a medium pepperoni pizza, with pineapple added to it. What I got was green pepper and banana pepper, with pineapple and no pepperoni. And, even though it was not what I ordered, it was NOT even covered with the amount of toppings that I have Always received, in the past. This is the first time I have called ANY business, concerning being unhappy. Sadly, it made the experience even worse. I was told that the only thing they could do was make me another pizza, today. And, if I did not want one today, that was all they could do, for me. Sadly, I won't be back. And, it's not really about the money, it's about the lack of caring about their customer. That says more to me, than anything. read more

Italian Pizza Pie - This was supposed to be pepperoni pizza with pineapple. no pepperoni, and not much on it, even though it was not what I ordered. - Pizza Near Me - Dacula, Georgia

I have been a big fan of Italian pie for the past 7 years, but seriously a visit at this location today at 3 pm on a Wednesday with 5 staff members and only one other patron (a guy eating a slice) has me thinking customer service is non-existent here. Today we came here and ordered a large cheese pie with basil. The staff member was friendly, and she took my order. We are waiting and waiting, and the place is completely dead, with zero customers because the other guy left. They had two-pickup orders and they were picked up in the first 5 minutes of us being there. After 10 minutes I am wondering what is going on and noticed that the cashier goes to type on the kiosk screen and puts in an order that is sent to the printer at the pizza station. No one was calling in any orders, so I knew that she must have forgotten to send my order to the pizza station printer. Exact at 20 minutes the pizza comes out and the manager comes and asks if everything is okay, and apologizes for the wait. Five people working, no orders, and they can't own the fact they accidentally forgot to make our food? I worked as a kitchen manager and would have taken responsibility and made things right. Anyhow, total lack of accountability here, and the dough is now extremely thin, about the thickness of a quarter, except for the crust at the edges is normal. I have eaten Italian pie dozens and dozens of times and it has never been this thin. It typically takes about 10 minutes to bake these. On a positive note, the Pizza was good, though one person could easily eat an entire large cheese pie themselves. After this experience at the Dacula location. I will not be visiting here anymore. The only location I can recommend is the one at Lawrenceville Highway, they are always consistent. It appears that reviewer Kevin J. had the same experience at the Dacula location too. Then look at reviewer Eric B, who ordered a Calzone that came out completely burnt. I don't see how a company can have several locations, but all of the locations do whatever they want. Consistency and excellent customer service are key. EVERY single employee needs to be trained at their Lawrenceville Highway because that seems to be the only location that is doing something right. read more

Italian Pizza Pie - pizza boxes on the wall - Pizza Near Me - Dacula, Georgia

See all

Ordered via DoorDash. The Italian with Extra cheese and cheese and bacon. Delivered great. Very little sauce if any on either pizza. The crust was soggy but not greasy. So at least that, but no flavor. What pizza place doesn't put sauce? Just disappointed because I was really looking forward to it. read more

Italian Pizza Pie - The Italian with extra cheese - Pizza Near Me - Dacula, Georgia

See all

Italian Pizza Pie was once a true local treasure, and as you can see from our previous 5-star review, at one point we often ate lunch here several times a week in addition to ordering take-out pies. Fortunately IPP apparently survived Covid's financial strain that many small businesses didn't, and as a matter-of-fact have grown to over 6 locations according to their web site. Though unfortunately, this growth & success came at a price, and the onetime great food, customer service and attention to detail that was so consistent has largely gone, and the wonderful manager has apparently been promoted (great choice, but unfortunately there's no-one to backfill his 'watching the shop' like he did) as when we see him it's only for a few moments before he runs out, presumably to go peek-in on another location. The pizzas and stromboli are still usually good, just not as consistently so, thus it's a little bit hit-or-miss. I'm TAKING OFF a star and updating this review as a result of our stopping-by for lunch last Friday just after 3PM. Although the sign right by the register states that lunch is served 'til 4, the teenager at the register dismissed it saying the sign was wrong and it's "been like that for over a year" (suggesting the wrong sign has been in place for over a year, but they haven't fixed it AND won't honor it). Sad to see the quality and customer service that once made this local pizza joint extraordinary deteriorate with growth, but it's still a solid, if comparatively overpriced option vs the many chain locations nearby (protip: check your order before you leave to make sure it's not burnt or incorrect). read more

We usually love this place but this location was very disappointing. We ordered on Uber eats. The pizza had no flavor although it looked really good. And the New York cheesecake was TERRIBLE. Literally washed my mouth out. The Oreo cheesecake was amazing though! read more

The pizza I ordered was pretty good. Their special Italian pie 12 inch. Plenty of the veggies and the meat toppings were adequate. That being said seems like the sauce which I didn't really see much of was very bland. For almost $17 I want some flavor read more

Sorry but I cannot order anymore from this location. This leaving their store is just a big insult to Italians everywhere. Are they blind or just want to piss you off. My friend owned a pizza restaurant but moved, this would have never left his restaurant. I'm not paying for this Hockey puck they sent me. It's in my garbage can where it belonged at their shop. Can't recommend the Decula location, their Lawrenceville hasn't tried to pull this on me. read more

Italian Pizza Pie - Ordered a Calzone, I got this... - Pizza Near Me - Dacula, Georgia

I wouldn't eat here if they paid me to eat here the staff is very rude especially the guy with the long hair that makes the pizza he is very, very rude and he needs to learn some respect for customers with that being said I want to support this place ever read more

Ordered a cheese pizza mixed with sausage and pepperoni. No sauce, I thought a pizza consist of pizza crust, tomato sauce, cheese and a topping if ordered. Gonna give a call, so it doesn't happen again. read more

I've had it with this outfit. We like the food but the service and overall arrogance by the counter help can't be tolerated. Today was the last straw when we tried to have them add a meatball to kids Alfredo and they said they couldn't. After not getting any valid reason why, we cancelled the $125 order and called Johnny's down the street which accommodated everything. I hope you figure out how to treat customers before you have none left. I regret supporting this organization through Covid and doing everything I could to help a local business survive. Poorly run businesses deserve to go out of business and you can add Italian Pie to that list. read more

First timer looking for a dine-in restaurant experience. It didn't take long for us to just do take out. But, in the spirit of patronizing local business we ordered. Bad decision. Long story short, the counter workers were rude, the pizza was burnt and the brucshetta was soggy. read more

Italian Pizza Pie - Burnt pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dacula, Georgia

See all

Ordered a Italian Sub this afternoon and had Grubhub deliver. Ordered Mayo, no mayo added. They charge .60 for each topping. Not specialty toppings, regular toppings. Lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles. $2.40 on top of the $8 sandwich price. Very little meat on the sandwich, the meat that was there was spoiled. I took a bite and spit it out. Went back and had them refund my money. They only refund the list price and not the taxes. When I asked for my refund the guy literally sighed like I was bothering him. I won't ever be going back. read more

This place has amazing pizza. It's December 2020 during a Global pandemic, when infection rates couldn't be higher. The staff doesn't even attempt to protect customers or themselves. They are not wearing masks, or gloves. Masks are not recommended for entry. They do not have a curbside pickup option, which is ok. I would feel comfortable going inside if safety measures were being practiced. I walked in, and an employee was on break, and jumped up and went straight for my order without washing his hands first. ( Are you kidding me?) That in itself turns me away and I have been supporting them for some time now. For those reason, I do not recommend this place and will not be going back. read more

We ordered 1 calzone and 1 chicken alfredo.. at 11:20 it was supposed to arrive by 3:20 but did not arrive until 4:12. OK so its 8 miles. The food was cold hard and disgusting. We had to make an additional order to Freddy's. I will never order from this place again!!!​ read more

Muy buena comida Italiana, pizza, Pasta, ensaladas y mas.. buena atencion, varios ambientes..

So nice to see them still open and turning out great food during 2020! The chicken already pasta and Greek salad was great, but the Calzone is still my favorite! read more

What happened to this place? The pizza is really bad...it tastes very salty and greasy! If I wanted food like this I would go to Dominoes and pay much less for it. If there was a rating worse than 1, I would give that instead of the 1. read more

We drove forty minutes home too find out the wings we ordered was wrong I explain that too the kid and they wanted us too drive forty mins back too change the wings out also they had me on hold for twenty mins just too hang up on me wouldn't recommended read more

Hate to do this because have ordered literally hundreds of pies from the Lawrenceville store for my work and had nothing but great food and service. But ordered Uber eats today from Dacula and was brought not only the wrong pizza, but was also missing one entire pizza. When I called to get things rectified I was treated extremely rudely by the manager on duty, called a liar, and told that I didn't know how to use the Uber eats app correctly. I was not offered to have correct pies delivered - instead I was told I could come get them or shove it and I would have to take it up with Uber eats if I wanted a resolution. I hereby resolve your company has lost at least $300 of business a month from my company, I won't reward bad customer service. read more

The pizza is not very good :( service is great but the pizza just doesn't taste right.

Best pizza around!! The cheesy bread is better then I have ever tasted before! This is the second time I have had lunch here and both times the service and food was outstanding!!! The pizza topping are fresh and food is always hot. Check it out. read more

Amazing food!Tastes just like real Italian food.Quick order and no lines inside.Food is cooked to order and freshly made..

I usually don't write reviews but this one deserves one. I ordered the garlic parmesan wings and a caesar salad. The wings were disgusting. First, they look like they aren't even done cooking (but they were). There was no flavor whatsoever on the wings. I had a plate of grease. My 10 year old son can season food better than this. My salad came with no dressing on it at all. I have never ordered a caesar salad from any place and it came with no dressing on it. To make it worse I paid extra for an extra caesar dressing. Guess what? No caesar dressing pack. They should really be ashamed of the food that they sent out to someone who paid their money. Never will I order from here again. read more

For a local pizza joint can't go wrong. They have some other dishes that good as well. Fast service.

I have always said that good pizza is all about the crust. The crust here is good. The toppings on the pizza we had were fresh and plentiful. We will definitely be back here for pizza. We had the takeout but the small dining area is ample enough. Prices are average for this quality pizza. read more

Outstanding place! Been here a few times already, each time the staff is friendly and always ask to please come back and if everything was satisfactory. My wife enjoys the fact that you can buy by the slice, which around Atlanta seems to be rather difficult. Yes, their pizza is good but my staple here is their Spaghetti and Meatballs! Yeah! I know what you are thinking, get off yer arse, boil some water and fix your own! however, Italian Pie makes a mean and rather large dish. For three times in a row I go to order a pie, maybe a Calzone, but each time I end up with the Spaghetti and Meatballs! Italian Pie, a great independent owned addition to Dacula. Give Pie a try! read more

I go to this place twice a week it's so good. Perfect every time. My go to order is a veggie slice and the garlic rolls. Huge slice. So good. read more

Continue to give this place another try. As I said in my earlier reviews, I went to the original location religiously and loved this pizza place. Loved the Dacula location for some time, but felt it had fallen off quite a bit over the past year or so. Tried again tonight and again, this place messed up: - Got the order wrong. Gave us the wrong thing - Virtually no sauce on the pizza, very dry - The crust isn't like it should be or like it was before. Instead of crisp on the outside and Fluffy inside it is now hard throughout, a big letdown as the crust was once our favorite part. I'm not a pizza snob. I want this place to be great because It is in my backyard vs the Lawrenceville one which is far away. Can someone come in and teach this new manager that skimping on sauce doesn't save money because we just don't order! read more

Chicken Alfredo is #Bomb. The wings and pizza are ok nothing special. The interior can use some updating for sure.

I love this spot! Pizza is amazing, fresh, good proportion and worth the price! Not to mention their spicy Hawaiian wings is sooooo delicious !!! read more

This is a great find for us...just 3 mi from the house. Authentic NY style pizza. Crispy crust, no flop, great sauce and great cheese. The wings are killer too! read more

For the $31 I paid for two medium sized pizzas, I could have cooked the whole staff at Italian Pie real pizza and set the standard. The toppings on the pizza were not sufficient. The pizza dough was bland. The onions were partly raw. It didn't have enough sauce and it had no trace of any herbs. Putting italian in the name of the shop is a disgrace to real italian food. Maybe I'm just a pizza snob. Now speaking in terms of the Dacula area, Italian Pie is a miniature step above Luigi's but both are faux italian food anyway. Customer service was good though, I must admit. read more

Italian Pizza Pie - Pizza shouldn't be this limp. Talk about pizza dysfunction. - Pizza Near Me - Dacula, Georgia