1. Island Club

0

,

Cancel

Open app

Search

Island Club

3.3 (16 reviews)
Closed • Closed

Island Club Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Island Club

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Arch on Breaker's Beach Deck
Bridget S.

We had our wedding at the Island Club in Oct 2012 - we had the ceremony on the Breakers Beach Deck and the reception in the Trident room. My father is retired Navy and sponsored our use of the club. Without the Island Club, we would have had to choose between the venue we wanted (beach ceremony) and the party we really wanted to throw. Beach weddings are a cost premium in San Diego. With the Island Club, we got a top notch party and beautiful picturesque beach wedding. Did we have Navy base access problems? Yes, but not on the day of and not at the fault of the Island Club. Would I have liked to have been contacted by Island Club and told who to contact before I received an out of office email reply 10 days before my wedding telling me my coordinator was on maternity leave? Yes. Would I have preferred not to have to work with Greta the last 10 days before my event? Yes (Karen was wonderful). Would I have liked it if they didn't have those ugly pink curtains? Yes. Did any of that matter in the end? No. BOTTOM LINE: The venue is outdated, sure, but the natural beauty of the location, the day of service, and price made up for any troubles we had. We were a little worried about the food after having gone to a catering fair for the Navy bases, but our food was all rave worthy. The service staff was on top of it and were very kind to us and our families. We had a wonderful event and are happy to share our experience and encourage others to take advantage of our advice, but not hesitate to book there.

See all

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Dung N.
2960
3327
15719

9 years ago

Helpful 8
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 1

4 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 1

14 years ago

Helpful 6
Thanks 0
Love this 4
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Helpful 10
Thanks 1
Love this 5
Oh no 1
Photo of Jill B.
379
6
26

7 years ago

Helpful 5
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 1
Love this 3
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 1

14 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 1

9 years ago

Helpful 4
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of J B.
0
1
0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 8
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 1

14 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 1

Ask the Community - Island Club

Review Highlights - Island Club

“Greta and Erin were great to work with and helped make all of the details exactly what we wanted!”

Mentioned in 11 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Wedding Planning 4,152 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Flavor Chef Catering

Flavor Chef Catering

(219 reviews)

It was genuinely such a pleasure to work with the Flavor Chef Catering team for our wedding earlier…read morethis year. Throughout the process, we communicated primarily with Madison, who was always kind, thoughtful, and professional during our interactions. Based on our research of catering teams in the northern San Diego County area, we were already leaning towards Flavor Chef based on their reasonable prices and menu. The team was able to fit us in at the last minute for a tasting, which is what truly sealed the deal. Everything we tasted was delectable, but more importantly, the team treated us with kindness and respect. Chef Derek explained every detail of the dishes and was incredibly accommodating if we wanted to tweak anything. For example, we had a few vegetarians and vegans attending the wedding, and the team was able to make about 10-15% of the appetizers (pork belly bao buns, bacon-wrapped dates, and poke crisps) suitable for these attendees. We also wanted the citrus flavor of the salmon to be stronger, so the team made a note to add more squeezed Valencia orange and to add more citrus-infused oil on top of the salmon. Our guests also raved about our food on the wedding day. Among the standouts were the bacon-wrapped dates, citrus risotto, and beef short-ribs. Several people went back for seconds. One of our guests wrote in our wedding album, "the food was actually good!" He later told us that he had been to plenty of weddings where the food fell short. He said what stood out about our buffet menu was that the ingredients were simple and locally sourced but expertly crafted and incredibly flavorful. We also had a goal of mango sticky rice as one of our desserts, which a family friend was helping us with. Even though the Flavor Chef team was not directly involved in this dessert, they were willing to cut all the mangoes fresh on site for no extra charge to make sure the mangoes didn't oxidize before dessert time, which we were incredibly grateful for. We also rented dishes and utensils from Flavor Chef at a more competitive rate than was being offered by the venue's recommended rental company. Flavor Chef also included vendor meals for a fraction of the price of the buffet meal, which really helped us with our budget. At every step of our interactions with Flavor Chef, we felt the team went above and beyond to make our day as special and memorable as possible. We would highly recommend Flavor Chef to anybody considering them for their special event. The quality of the food and the kindness of the staff speak for themselves!

Amazing experience with Chef Diego, who came early to set up and cater our small dinner party…read more Planning the menu was very easy and Flavor Chef folks were super responsive. We had not anticipated such an amazing experience given it was for a small dinner party (10 ppl) versus a big event like a wedding or retirement party. The appetizers were amazing and dinner was perfect. We will definitely be coming back for any future needs. Everyone in our dinner party loved the food and the experience. Basically, we are all super fans!

Culinary Kitchen Catering and Events - Baby Shower Grazing Table

Culinary Kitchen Catering and Events

(26 reviews)

I hate to do this, as I understand what a bad review can do for a small business.. but after seeing…read morethe other reviewer who stated that JP backed out of their wedding (who, I'm not affiliated with in any way), I think my experienced needs to be shared, as I hope this will help other couples. I gave JP (owner) an incredible amount of grace throughout the process and yet, he still managed to screw us. It was not a single issue, but a failure on multiple levels. THE SHORT VERSION: 1) he was very unprofessional overall in his communication. 2) he backed out of bar service a few days before our wedding and ghosted us after the wedding without a refund, 3) without exaggeration, some of the food at the wedding was inedible THE LONGER VERSION: The tasting went amazing. Ashley (who no longer works there) was extremely communicative. They asked for 50% as a deposit (which is pretty high) but the food was really good so we accepted. However, the tasting was the only good thing about our experience... 1. He was unreachable for months leading up to our wedding. The company phone number was either not taking calls, or went straight to voicemail. No response to emails. He finally got back to me about one month before our wedding (we thought we got scammed at that point). I gave him the benefit of the doubt despite all of this 2. He backed out of providing bar services a week before the wedding. I knew something was off when he wouldn't provide us with an shopping lists for our cocktails, despite following up. A few days before our wedding, our coordinator told us that his bartenders did not have proper certification and without one, could not serve alcohol (note: this was merely an RBS certification... EVERY OTHER bar service that we spoke with met this requirement). I specifically asked at contract signing if they were certified. Also, JP did not inform us that he was dropping out. I had to text him myself for confirmation, as I was unsure if he was going to hire other bartenders, if they would obtain the certificate, or if he was dropping out. Only then did he tell me he would not provide bar service. Again, this was 7 days before the wedding. He also took 3 more days to clarify exactly what service he would no longer be providing, when we obviously needed to know asap as we were scrambling to secure another bar service Even though this certification is the minimum requirement for many venues, he tried to pass the blame onto the venue, stating that he never encountered this requirement before (how is this possible? As a wedding caterer, he should have been familiar with these requirement, whether or not he met them). Huge red flag. Despite this, I didn't make this an issue 3. He promised to refund us for the bar service but ghosted us after the wedding. I disputed the charge and he finally responded, threatening to sue. 4. He was unreachable on the morning of the wedding. Again, poor communication.. 5. The food failed to meet even our lowest standards. The 50% deposit really had our hands tied and we couldn't back out despite the red flags. As long as he showed up and served food that was remotely close to our tasting, we'd be happy. However, he totally skimped out on the quality and quantity. For example, our passed appetizers were smoked salmon bagels. I'm not sure if he used old bagels or what, but the bagels were stale and rock hard. My friend tried to bite down on one and immediately spit it out. My aunt had to warn guests not to eat them. He swapped out some of the items that we paid for with inferior options (ie: we paid for a fig and honey roll... he just added a basic dinner roll). Guests told us they were confused that our menu did not match the food. Some guests got half a dinner roll (meaning they didn't have enough) The main entrées did not match the quality or size of the original dish we were promised at the tasting. I understand that preparing a meal for 2 people is not the same as 100 people, and there is inherently a drop in quality on the wedding day. However, this was completely different. Many guests attested that the salmon entree was inedible as it was incredibly dry and overcooked. Look at the photo of the tri-tip I uploaded and the difference between what we were promised and what we received We asked for leftovers to be packed but never received them. All in all, I was super understanding and even allocated 15% as tip for his team despite his poor communication. Despite this, the fact that he never gave us a refund for the bar service is appalling.

We chose Culinary Kitchen for our recent wedding in Julian, CA this past June and my husband and I…read moreare incredibly thankful that we got to work with Ashley and JP for our big day! Food and catering service were some of our highest priorities to get right during our wedding and Culinary Kitchen was phenomenal every step of the way. Our communication with Ashley and and JP before, during, and after the wedding was exceptional. From the very beginning, Ashley was very responsive and regularly checked in with us, which helped me feel less overwhelmed by all the catering decisions we needed to make. I tend to err on being extremely detail oriented and I asked tons of questions early on. Ashley was so patient and thorough with each email I had sent over even before booking. Before choosing our caterer, we did 3 different wedding caterer tastings and Culinary Kitchen easily was the best of all three (we're still thinking about the gochujang meatballs and the cavatappi pasta with fennel sausage!!). On our wedding day, the food service ran seamlessly and our guests often commented on how good the food was (guests were actually trying to sneak chicken tenders off the kids plates because even the kids meals were so good). Their team also helped us serve our desserts, did our bartending, and rented/placed all of our table settings, all at very reasonable prices as part of the entire catering package. The team also went above and beyond to accommodate all of our guests' special dietary needs while still helping us stay within budget and recommending a cohesive menu. One last thing - we did A LOT of research on different San Diego caterers before our wedding (I think we sent out inquiries to at least 10 other caterers) and Culinary Kitchen's catering packages felt the most "upscale" and comprehensive without leaving us feeling nickel and dimed for every line item. I truly felt like their team was on our side the whole way. THANK YOU Culinary Kitchen for catering our wedding day!! We wish you guys the best of success!

Four Seasons Foods

Four Seasons Foods

(73 reviews)

I was fortunate enough to coordinate a wedding that included Four Seasons as the food/service…read morecaterers. The staff was absolutely amazing and attended to every guest request. But more than that, was the amazing food menu. I can't even express in words how amazing the appetizers, dinner entrees were. And it wasn't just me. I must have gotten at least 15 or more guests absolutely raving about the food. One guest even said it beat any home cooked or restaurant food she had ever eaten! And that is not an exaggeration! From the very beginning, Sierra made sure all of my clients requests were met and the communication was the outstanding. Billy (chef) doubled up on outstanding with the most amazing, flavorful, unique and tasty appetizer and dinner menu. You can definitely taste the love and effort he puts into his cooking. And last but not least....the staff! Absolutely the best! And served with a smile! In my opinion this is an unbeatable team. Highly recommend them to anyone who would like to have an unforgettable event with the best service and most amazing food. Thank you Four Season! You knocked it out of the park!

I only have positive things to say about the Four Seasons Foods Catering team! Over the course of…read morethe many months we spent planning our wedding, my husband and I were blown away by the expertise and professionalism of Sierra, Billy, and every other member of their team. Leading up to the wedding, Sierra promptly and thoroughly answered any and all questions we had regarding menu, the bar, linens, etc. On the day of the wedding, Chef Billy and the other chefs/staff created a beautiful and delicious meal that they cooked on site. We are so grateful for all they did to help make the day a success and would recommend them to anyone searching for an exceptional catering team. Thank you all so much!

Island Club - wedding_planning - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...