Very excited to find a 5 star restaraunt in downtown riverhead!!! Sheila and Marco are the gracious owners of this upbeat establishment. Pastas, cheeses and breads are all home made to perfection. Our waiter Julio was very attentive and provided a delightful experience. Food was so delicious and very special venue......highly recommended Ed S read more

Simply amazing! From first to last bite! I would have licked the bowl if I wasn't in a crowded restaurant! A must try!! Okay read more

The food was amazing especially the veal and risotto. Our waiter Julio made our dining experience even more amazing. The ambiance is beautiful and it's the perfect place to dine read more

Excellent food and service ... beautiful restaurant! We will be back ! Thank you Julio !

We were looking forward to trying this place for the longest time and weren't disappointed. First, parking is ample and the space, while very open, is cozy and inviting. The bread was fresh and fragrant and the cocktail/wine selection gives you a great way to begin this meal. For appetizer, my wife had the trio of meatballs and I had the misto di verdure. Each meatball was a unique bite of different meat combined with the perfect complimentary sauce. They were light, fluffy and full of flavor. The misto was an incredible array of grilled vegetables combined with olives and the freshest parmigiana reggiano - and I can't forget the fresh baked breadsticks. This was a meal in itself - and I commented to my wife that I could wile away the afternoon eating just this along with nice glass of red wine! For entrees, we each got a pasta. My wife got the Paccheri Broccoli and Salsiccia and I got the open faced Lasagna. Both dishes were so flavorful and the fresh pasta was very evident in each dish! Chef Marco stopped by our table a couple of times to ensure everything was to our liking. It's clear he takes a tremendous amount of pride in putting quality dishes on his tables. Needless to say, I will be returning here often and look forward to larger gathering dinners so that we can sample more of Chef Marco's incredible cuisine. read more

Outstanding... Amazing food Amazing staff Went for lunch and everything went great... 100% will go back A must go if you are anywhere near there read more

Ate there a few times. Very good food. Unique decor and hope it lasts. Several restaurants have failed in this location. Maybe thin one is a winner. read more

Food very good Service needs upgrade Ambiance of exterior needs a lot of help. It could have a negative Impression resulting the decision If not going I. To try. The interior is very nice. Modern, attractive & clean!!! read more

Amazing!!! The food is absolutely to die for! Start with the Caesar salad and the cheese board you won't regret it. I then had the chicken franchese with rosemary potatoes. My companions had penne vodka & rigatoni with meat sauce so I had to try.. Any of these will not disappoint. Finish with a deconstructed cannoli and a cappuccino or espresso & you will be like you're back in Italy read more

Unfortunately, I have to give -1 star. Came on a Saturday night with my girlfriends and daughter. The place was completely empty. By the time we got our appetizer it was 45 minutes later and completely cold. Then literally 32 seconds later our entrées were served. Our entrées were luke warm as well. The service was terrible. My daughter ordered lemonade and I love how they charged us $3.50 for water with two slices of lemon in it and tried to call it lemonade. Literally, the only thing that was good was the bottle of wine. When we asked to speak to the manager, she did not even have the decency to come over and speak with us. We were so excited to come to this restaurant after all the positive press. Such a complete disappointment. I would never go back and definitely do not recommend this place. read more

Finally, Fine dining in Riverhead!! I don't know what was more enjoyable, the staff or the cuisine. It reminded me of a Manhattan eatery right here in Riverhead. Fresh artisan breads, house made pasta, fresh seafood and Maine lobsters. I Highly recommend the Fra Diavlo or lobster ravioli. Whether you're in town for a visit or local to the area, I highly recommend stopping in and experiencing Insatiable Eats for yourself. Thanks Marco and Sheila!!! read more

Really great fresh ingredients, homemade, delicious Italian food Gluten free friendly, very friendly staff and the chef even came over to let me ask him questions. read more

This place is authentic Italian and there pasta is home made I don't understand how is not packed all the time, there food is hands down on of the best in the East End take it from a person that goes out to eat 5 out of 7 days a week .And Julio our waiter is always so attentive and caring I absolutely love this place. read more

Everything was great the food was amazing and the staff was fantastic I would def go back...we loved everything about this place 5 star all the way! read more

Insatiable Eats - Caterers Near Me - Riverhead, New York

Let's start with the drinks. Ordered a Jack and Coke and no Jack Daniel's. Had the mussels for an appetizer and they were very good. Now the main course. Linguine with white clam sauce. Entree had about 8 clams and a blob of linguine about the size of a baseball. Very salty and sandy. No flavor other than the salt and sand. Dessert was very good. Had the cream puffs covered with chocolate. Have been looking forward to trying this restaurant but was disappointed. Next time will just order an appetizer and dessert and skip the main course !! read more

My wife and I ate there last week. The food is incredible, especially the pasta dishes. The staff was friendly and very efficient. I will definitely be back. Ted from Southampton. read more

Great authentic Italian / Sicilian food. Pasta was out of this world. Chef marco was a gem of a guy. Can't wait to go back and try other items. read more

Dined as a 4 top on a Saturday Night about 6pm. They were just starting to get busy. Maybe just a little too busy for this newly opened establishment. We were greeted and sat right away, water and drink orders were taken then there was a lull for quite some time. Not sure if the bartender was struggling or there was lack of servers but we waited and waited some more. The current menu is for lunch and dinner but is apparently changing to include a more formal dinner menu as of next week. Appetizer of breaded mozzarella and pomodora sauce, (Yummy) finally arrived then drinks. We dined on two pasta dishes , one with sausage and another with short rib (delicious). We also had the rib eye specials which were cooked perfectly. Unfortunately no room for dessert. All in all we had a good meal, pleasant servers but just a shortcoming in their timing. We wish them much success and hope to return again for another try. read more

We came here for an early dinner. The service and food was amazing. Fresh pasta was delicious. The kind and friendly staff were so accommodating. Above and beyond service. Beautiful decor and great atmosphere. We will definitely be back. read more

We thoroughly enjoyed our meals there last night. I had the lobster ravioli--pasta was wonderful and each had a nice amount of lobster meat. The servers were very attentive throughout the experience. The prices are on the higher end, but this is not just your standard Italian place. If you are a foodie, you will really enjoy it. read more

The food was actually pretty good, nothing amazing , but everything was fresh and tasty. I would have given 4 stars, but minus one for charging extra for using a credit card without disclosing beforehand - not written anywhere - the bill actually came with higher prices on it. read more

We have had two dinners at insatiable eats and we loved both meals. It is our new favorite Italian restaurant close to our home. Julio was our waiter and he had great recommendations with food and makes a bad ass margarita too. We recommend this place highly and it's a must try! read more

Food is amazing. I believe I saw the pasta was home made and it really was amazing. The service could be better, but they are new and still working everything out. The restaurant itself is really nice inside! read more

Insatiable Eats - Dinner Menu - Caterers Near Me - Riverhead, New York

Absolutely perfect! I had the truffled pizza along with an amazing cocktail I can't get enough of instaible eats restaurant the staff and owners really make you feel like part of the family. We love it here! read more

Insatiable Eats - Truffled pizza! Tartufina bianca Absolutely delicious perfect place for great food and drinks. - Caterers Near Me - Riverhead, New York

Wonderful food by the talented Marco Barilla. We were 4 guests so we had a chance to experience a variety of entrees. The presentation of each dish was beautiful and we were not disappointed in the taste. Cannot wait to return to experience more! Thank you Marco for bringing your delicious food to Riverhead. read more

This place was fantastic. We got into town late and they were very welcoming to have us as their last customers. Pasta was delicious and fresh. Chef Marco was extremely welcoming and passed by to check if we were enjoying. I felt like I was visiting Italy. Definitely going back. read more

Went there Fri nite with a 6:15 pm reservation for 4. Server James was nice. Ordered 2 apps, one came in 30 mins I had to ask where is second app that came 30 mins after that. James said he would take it off bill.My friend had a dirty martini Had to send it back had so much olive juice it was putrid. James said he would take that off bill. Our food came 7:35 exactly. We had to make it to Suffolk theater at 8:00 for show We did inform James about that. The food was not impressive it was bland and disappointing. I should of known when we got the stale bread it was not a good sign. We rushed out paid bill of over $300 didn't wrap it up well between food not being good and just making it to show. We realized we got over charged by a lot we called 20 min later from theater they did not want to be bothered I left message and number no one called me back. I did tell them I think there was a mistake with bill. I called sat sun Mon each day they said they would call me back. I spoke with a manager who said they were looking into it. Called again last night manager said he called me and left message. He did call but did not leave message and told me he was too busy to go over bill it was in office all ready to go over and to call him in morning. Unbelievable!! SMH We go out 3-4 times a week to eat and we will never return to this restaurant. Diners beware!! To be continued....... read more

The service, the food and the setting inside is fabulous. The outside building keeps the secret hidden inside. Go in and you will be thrilled. Thank you to all! read more

Terrible service, tasteless food, and the entire atmosphere is really weird. Nothing about this restaurant is good.

Went there for lunch yesterday and it was nothing short of wonderful!! I had the lasagna with short rib meatballs, ragu and ricotta. The meatballs were small and there were not many of them but they were a complete delicacy. The dish was served in a frying pan of sorts. The pasta lined the bottom and up the sides forming a crust up near the top. Everything else was on the inside of the crust. Very different but terrific. Everything is homemade on the premises. The pasta, the cheese...everything! The dish was $24 and well worth it in my estimation. Grigor was our waiter and the service was excellent. It was the best meal I have had in a long time. Since it was my first time there, I cannot comment on other menu items. However, based on yesterday's experience I would strongly recommend this restaurant. read more

I went to Insatiable Eats for the first time and I had a terrible experience. The water was brought out and one of the glasses had a lip stick stain on it. It took 30 minutes to get a beer and the waiter forgot to get the other drink. 45 minutes into waiting we asked where the food was, considering there were only three tables of people. We decided to just pay for what we got and call it quits after waiting an hour. The service was terrible. It was a waste of time and money. The second drink still never came.... read more

Awful The service was terrible. The waitress said she was new so she couldn't answer any questions about the menu. The food was worse. My husband ordered the chicken francese and I ordered the chicken Milanese both were 36.00 a piece. It came with spaghetti. That's it. I ordered a Diet Coke which after she forgot to bring it I asked again. She came back to the table empty handed and said the machine wasn't working. She never refilled our water glasses. The chicken francese was unedible. The flavor was a bitter lemon taste which lingered on the palate. He couldn't eat it. My Milanese was very bad also. It tasted like someone threw red wine all over it. It needed salt so I had salt packets in my pocketbook which I used to give my dish some flavor. There was no salt or pepper shakers on the table and no Parmesan cheese either. Wasn't offered either. Save your money and just go to the pizza parlor down the road. So with the appetizer the bill came to 91.00 and with the tip we paid 111.00 for 10.00 worth of food. We had no drinks or dessert. Totally felt ripped off. Won't be returning. I don't know where chef Marco was but he's not much of a chef if this is what his food tastes like. Yuck all the way around. read more

Was really craving Italian food so thought to give this a try since it is close and new however I was really disappointed. When we were seated there were maybe 3 other tables taken in the whole building, we assumed since it was not busy the service would be top notch but we were very wrong. Our waitress checked in on us when once during out 2 hour dinner, our waters were never refilled and it felt like we were being ignored. We also ordered two entrees no appetizers and it took over an hour for us to get our meals. From the time we sat to the time we left we spent an hour and a half waiting and 30 minutes eating. If you are in a rush definitely do not go here. Also the prices were CRAZY for a small bowl of pasta it was almost $30. For the two entrees the bill was over $60 it was insane, and for the quality/portions it is not worth the spend. I would definitely not recommend this place nor will I probably go back because of how sour my first experience was. Beware. read more

Gorgonzola gnocchi was excellent. Really enjoyed the food. Appetizer was good but a bit pricey for what it was. We got served super quick.

Everything was amazing. If you haven't been, go! If you have, go back! Save room for something sweet at the end, the chefs special was a perfect mix! read more

The food is delicious! It was my first time trying this new restaurant on Valentine's Day with their prix fixe menu and it was phenomenal. Everything was cooked perfectly and the service was great I m. I will definitely be back again! read more

See all

I so much wanted to love this place, but our experience was just awful. The space itself is nice, if not particularly cozy inside. And our drinks arrived with pleasant banter. The one appetizer we shared took 25 minutes (Fritto misto), but it was delicious (the seafood was cooked perfectly, batter was flaky, crispy and not oily at all. Zucchini was garlicky and creamy) and the portion was enormous. The risottos (we both ordered the same entree) came out 5 minutes later, just as we started on our appetizer. And after all the hype (my friend has had it before and the waiter swore by it), it was a total letdown - the rice was so overcooked, the grains split, the overcooked asparagus was a brown mushy mess. The 4 small shrimp were dry and chewy. I ate 1 shrimp and a few forkfuls of rice and went back to the appetizers that was barely diminishing in size. My friend ate a little more, but also reverted back to the appetizer. The waiter came by asking if we wanted to take it home, never asking why we have barely touched it. And then asked if we wanted the check. We said we wanted another round of drinks. For 20 minutes we sat talking over a tower of dirty plates that we stacked when the waiter reappeared with the check. To our question about the drinks he replied "we ran out of one of the wines you had". We were charged $150 for this experience. I can only presume that on this Thursday night the chef and owner wasn't there. read more

Ok so we figured we'd give this one more try after the service failure the first time I've written about. What a difference! Attentive and quick service this time. Pastas were delicious and salad could have fed two people. The osso buco was also very good. Definitely should give this place a try. read more

It may not be fair to review since we went during their soft opening. The wife and I went out for our wedding anniversary and thought we would check this establishment out. Firstly, as we entered the place we were told the heat wasn't working, and it was December and indeed very cold. We were going to leave but we're assured that we would be well taken care of. Long story short, food was limited, cold and waaaay overpriced. It's been over a year and we're never going back for a second helping of overpriced mediocrity. read more

We stopped in once for lunch and everything was delicious! We went back again for lunch and it was even better! All the pasta is homemade! The appetizers were amazing and the dessert scrumptious! Great drinks too!Excellent service! Chef Marco does a great job! Can't wait to go back for dinner! read more

See all