Extremely rude condescending waiter. Didn't like first dish (don't order the lobster ravioli unless you don't want any lobster and A TON of pesto). They replaced it with my second choice (boring spaghetti to be safe). They charged me for both dishes. Never had that experience. Were very rude. And they autotip $20. One glass of wine, pizza, spaghettti and forced charge for no lobster ravioli $104. Worst experience of our trip. read more

First the positives: very nice ambience, quick seating, excellent servers and delicious food. Sadly I found the negatives to negate what I like about the place: $26 for an Espresso Martini is excessive. And the fact that there is a 20% "manual gratuity" added to the bill - even for a table of two - isn't even the worse part. The fact that they slip it onto the bill without telling you, is. read more

See all

Came here for a special dinner after being gifted a gift card for this spot. We were really excited to get everything we could on the menu, but honestly it was just sub par. We had a great time, super nice service and it's a small and semi casual spot. Its alright, good for a bite at the hotel. read more

Il Sole Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Carolina, Puerto Rico

See all

Excellent food. Fun atmosphere. The garlic bread and spaghetti bolognese are amazing! Delicious gelato! The staff is friendly and efficient. Highly recommend! read more

See all

Very pricey and lacked flavor on the pasta dish. Pizza looks much better than the other offerings. I ordered the ribeye linguine. What a let down. It was flat on flavor, more than likely boxed pasta and maybe an ounce of shredded mystery meat. It was a terrible meal and the over $35 price they have on this made it that much worse. They should be ashamed of themselves. It's almost as if they knew. Not once did they check in on me until it was clear I pushed the plate away. Yes. I ate it. I was starving and didn't want to waste the money. But this is most certainly in the top 3 worst Italian meals I've ever had. Skip this place or go for the pizza. Never again for me... read more

Il Sole Pizzeria - Ribeye linguine. Where's the beef?! - Pizza Near Me - Carolina, Puerto Rico

Seated right away. There was No wait. Beverages served right away. Customer service is great. Will update with pictures of food. read more

Il Sole Pizzeria - Menu 6.15.24 - Pizza Near Me - Carolina, Puerto Rico

See all

Visited twice during our stay. Pizza and fried calamari both nights. Pizza is New York style solid - you will not be disappointed. Also - Service here - unlike other dining options - is alert and friendly. You need something - you get it fast. No extra time waiting for anything. Bring the kids... read more

Menu as of 1/1/2025. Hours are incorrect on Yelp. They are open 4PM-10PM Mon-Sat. Ordering carryout from the bar. Food looks and smells great. Very busy with a small footprint. They have tables out in the hallway to add capacity for new years crowd which is great. read more

Il Sole Pizzeria - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Carolina, Puerto Rico

See all

The food is decent and authentic enough but not outstanding given the price is too high due to location in the Fairmont. We had gnocchi and veal parmigiana which was huge and $50 and they charge $12 for bread and $10 for water which was also not disclosed or worth it. Overall the bill was doubled and food was basic quality so avoid. read more

What a great little restaurant attached to the shopping arcade at the Fairmont El San Juan Hotel. We've been in PR for about 2 weeks and we're craving something other than Caribbean food. They have a decent menu with everything one would expect from an Italian restaurant. Very nice wine selection as well as a full bar. The hubs and I shared the soup of the day and I must say, it was as good as homemade. Full of fresh vegetables and lentils. For my entree I had my normal go to when eating Italian, spaghetti bolognese. The pasta was perfectly al dente and the bolognese was incredible! The place is small but we had no issues getting in sans a reservation. I almost forgot, the prices are crazy reasonable. The soup was $8 and the pasta was $16. Not bad considering it's location attached to the hotel. They do offer take out if you wanna go back and chill in your room. read more

Il Sole Pizzeria - Soup of the day, lentil and it was better than homemade! - Pizza Near Me - Carolina, Puerto Rico

See all

Pizza was great but we were charged $9 for water with no warning! This is not Europe.

The pizza crust is cooked around the edges however not in the center. I like thin crust pizza but not when the dough is almost raw. Told the waiter we would like it crisped up but couldn't help us the pizza was already cut. Such a waste. read more

Food and service was great. Fresh pizza right from the oven. Chicken parm was delightful. Salad to start was very refreshing! Seems to be very underrated for how good it was. We sat right at the bar to avoid any wait and it worked out well! read more

Man this place stunk. I see the temptation of a cheaper place to eat while at a resort but a) it wasn't that cheap and b) it wasn't worth the money. We stopped by once just to see the menu and heard the desserts and came back the next day where the desserts were entirely different. Which...fine. I understand daily specials but I was disappointed. To order to go, we ordered at the bar 2 desserts. One chocolate souffle and one lava cake. It was over 30 minutes before we inquired and were told the "system" glitched and our order was never placed. Another 15-20 minutes before we got the order, paid, then went directly upstairs where we found the desserts were a melted soggy mess. It clearly had been sitting around before it was brought to us. I think the bartender knew we weren't going to be getting a bunch of drinks=a bunch of tips, so he just never bothered to check. After eating one which was mediocre, we realized the second dessert was identical. I called the pizzeria and they told us souffles and lava cakes are the same thing which a) no they aren't b) why did you list 2 specials if they are the same thing? We ended up getting a refund for one, but each was bout $10 and we had literally a 2 minute walk from the restaurant to hotel room and it couldn't even hold up that long. Maybe the pizza is fine, but the to go dessert experience was miserable. If you want a sweet, just go to the chocolate store a few doors down. read more

Il Sole Pizzeria - Souffle=Lava cake - Pizza Near Me - Carolina, Puerto Rico

Great dinner place. Best dinner we have had. Our waiter was amazing! Juan was very personable, pleasant, and attentive. Great recommendations. Lucas was very pleasant and helpful. Best meal we had in Puerto Rico. read more

See all

Great little hidden gem inside The Fairmont. Excellent svc, pasta, salad,, cappuccino. Gets busy after 7'00

Food was excellent. Server was awesome. Not sure why the reviews aren't better, highly recommend for tasty and fresh food.

Definitely five stars for this fantastic pizza place in the El San Juan Hotel called Il Solé. The pizza was perfectly cooked and absolutely delicious as was the potato and leek soup, the wine and the tiramisu for dessert. Highly recommended and will definitely come back. read more

See all

Service was great. Salad, pizza and dessert were delicious! Picky family, zero complaints.

This restaurant needs to be audited for their manual tipping policy. They unknowingly charged us a 25% tip and brought us the bill. I asked if the tip was included and he (Jesus) said, no, you can add the tip on when you pay at the machine. He brought me the machine only and handed me the machine with the tip menu. I then told him I needed to see the receipt. He gives me the receipt and I noticed it already had a $80.50 tip (25%). I said what is their tipping policy. He said 25% is mandatory. I asked where the policy is and he said it's not posted. I asked if it was a company policy or a personal policy. He said it was the company policy of the restaurant. I asked him if the casino knew they were charging their customer a 25% mandatory tip and then trying to get them to tip even more by not giving them the receipts. He told me he would quickly go back and remove the charge. I asked him if I could speak to the manager about their tipping policy. He told me don't worry about it. We'll take care of it. I was adamant that I wanted to speak, whoever was running the place and he told me the person running it was Luca. After having to ask several times Luca comes up and I ask him the tips policy and he told me it ranges from 20 to 25%. I asked him what dictates how much they charge and he said they just decide what to charge. I asked him if that was a policy and he told me, no, they choose how they do what they do. I asked him if the casino knew that they were charging their customers excessive amounts for tip and I was told sorry we will take care of it. Someone at this casino needs to audit this restaurant and all the employees, who work there and how much they're charging your customers. read more

Il Sole Pizzeria - 25% tip. 5 people. - Pizza Near Me - Carolina, Puerto Rico

Place is quick with service and very accommodating. Food is delicious. We got a complimentary garlic bread lentil soup and chicken parmesan. read more

Il Sole Pizzeria - Lentil soup & garlic bread - Pizza Near Me - Carolina, Puerto Rico

'Simply the Best' everything. If you are a fan of octopus you will not be disappointed 'Simply Perfect''. Cáprese salad 'Simply the Best' Pizza and the crust 'Simply the Best' Gnocchi with shrimp 'Simply the best' Service and management ' Simply the Best' II Sole is real deal Italian expect to pay real authentic prices. Chilled Panna water is the bomb. The service 'Simply the Best' Sad sad sad and shame on those 1 stars, Lava cake to go and you did not expect it to melt 1 star? The bar gives you Panna water and you think it is free 1 star? Lobby Bar $20 Pina Colata and the prices are too high at II Sole? Make a reservation this is not Domino's. Do not expect to walk up during peak dining hours and get a table. Reminder this is not Dominos. Calm down you are on vacation. Try to sit and eat especially the pizza fresh out the stone oven. Try not to order to go sit and enjoy. The price is the price and you are on vacation. Spending top dollar at the Fairmont. I give real deal reviews and II Sole ranks in my top Italian restaurants. The Octopus appetizer is #1 of any appetizer that I have reviewed. Perfect prep nothing fancy. Cheers and 'Simply the Best' read more

See all

The waiter was fantastic, so friendly and attentive. Had the rice balls and fried calamari and both did not disappoint. Shared gnocchi and vegetables pizza and both also were delicious. The pizza crust was spot on. We ended with two separate servings of gelatos and it was perfect way to end the meal! Will definitely go back. read more

See all

IL Sole was surprisingly very good. We were a little concerned by the lack of customers but went in anyway. The servers were friendly and attentive and we started with the caprese Salad which was very good as the tomatoes and mozzarella were crisp and fresh. For our entrees we had the to pumpkin ravioli and spaghetti with seafood and both were delicious. If your staying at the Fairmont or walking by and feel like some Italian give this place a shot. It won't disappoint. read more

This is inside the El San Juan hotel. There were lots of additional taxes and an automatic tip. We were just two people ordering two entrees with a mojito. Total came to $86! I will say both of the items we ordered for our meal were good. read more

Rip off. Sat at the bar for 5 min and he pours led a glass of water. We were meeting friends who decided on a different restaurant. The bartender charged us $10 for water we didn't even drink!!! read more

absolute terrible service. The website says go to OpenTable. OpenTable says they are not a partner then we get to the restaurant and the manager is a complete jerk asking if a reservation was made explain to him the situation and he says well that's not his problem I showed him I was on the phone for 17 minutes with Fairmont Hotel, trying to get them to make a reservation after realizing they are no longer partners with OpenTable only to walk over with my family and for the manager once again, say that is not his problem atrocious service zero level of hospitality read more

Food is below average, service is even worse. On top of that they add a mandatory 20% tip on to the bill, it explains why service is so terrible. read more

Good Place great food!!!! Customer Service is good feel like home. The menu is perfect if you like italian food this is the place.

Went to this place for a pizza to go and was met with a rude person telling us they were "...closed and that's why the door was closed." The doors were not closed and this person essentially walked us out like we were trespassing. The restaurant was full and they were still running food to tables. I have never felt so rebuffed at a restaurant ever before especially when walking in politely and just order something quickly. HUGE DISAPPOINTMENT - ABSOLUTELY AVOID!! read more

We loved Il Sole. All of the guys working in the restaurant are so kind and helpful. They don't just have great food. The gelato is amazing and they make a delicious mocha latte! We popped in to Il Sole for something at least once a day during our week long stay at the Fairmont. This restaurant is a definite asset to the hotel. read more

As expected, since this place is connected to the Fairmont it is over-priced. My husband and I split the Caesar salad which tasted like a grocery store bag of salad with stale croutons... wish I sent it back since I think it was about $17. I had the chicken parm which was pretty good. The sauce that came with the pasta was watery. My meal arrived a good 10 minutes before my husband's. He had a pizza which was pretty good. read more

Great food and service. Very kind and attentive waiters. We had a variety of meat cuts with chicken and side dishes that were just great. If you are in the area and want to have casual dining I definitely recommend you to pay a visit. read more