Large selection. Get ready to take some time deciding! There are Grab and go prepared foods as well as a deli section we can order sandwiches as well as hot foods. There's also a section with bread and pizza. If I eat at lunch I usually go for a sandwich. My typical go-to is honey turkey with Swiss lettuce tomato oil and vinegar. Hot. I like the fact they toast the bread a lot of other places microwave the meat and put it on the bread. Just be aware that the price is can be a bit high. My sandwich was $14. But this is New York read more

See all

This place is one good reasons I am enjoying my new workplace. Anything short on my pantry for a week food plan needs, I could get it here quickly. A block away from my new office, a very convenient store. As all knows, this chain is popular for Italian groceries . Plenty of choices. It also has meat section , vegetables section , and its popular bakery. Pricing is predominantly on a bit higher in comparison to American grocery store. Service is quick . Ambiance is happy. I will keep coming for convenience and popularity. read more

See all

Sandwiches was fresh. The bread was so soft. Great portion size for reasonable price. read more

Iavarone Bros - Delis Near Me - Garden City, New York

2/28/26 I love the vast selection of prepared foods. While I do not love their high prices, they do have quality items. My sandwich on semolina bread was delicious but could have been packed a bit more for the price. The almond cake was surprisingly good. I def enjoyed the baby stuffed artichoke and the pasta salad with mushroom/broccoli. I'd go back for sure, and bring my 401k! read more

Iavarone Bros - 2/28/26 receipt - Delis Near Me - Garden City, New York

See all

WHO LOVE IAVARONE BROTHERS? IIIIIIIIII DOOOOOOOOOO. MEEEEEEE OVER HERE, I love Iavarone's Restaurant and Supermarket in New Hyde Park, but my job ordered this on Tuesday 10/07/2025 from the Garden City location. I absolutely enjoyed the wraps and the quinoa salad. Delicious. Iavarone's you are an establishment that always puts your customers first and thank you for the amazing food. "Wait I have an recommendation" try the prosciutto bread from there bakery. You will fall in love, it's hot and it has big pieces of prosciutto in it and ofcourse the restaurant and Supermarket is always immaculate. read more

See all

A century plus of love, great good and Italian hospitality has now expanded to Garden City, New York. I was at Panera Bread on Franklin Ave in Garden City and remembered my friend Augie mentioning the new store recently opening in the area. So a half mile and 3 minutes later I was on 7th Street and passed the Starbucks and Bagel place locating the newest Iavarone Bros store, then parked in the back. This store is more compact but better organized than the Lake Success store. The bakery section is bigger. It has more cakes, pastries and bread and it looks beautiful. I was dying for a NY egg sandwich ( 3 eggs scrambled, cheese, spk on a roll) but sadly they don't do hot breakfast here. The two gents at the deli however were awesome and helpful. I asked for egg salad; one walked me to the fridge but they were out. I got the tuna salad which was fresh and just right. The spinach feta pasta salad also was delicious. The seafood section carries great quality items. I picked up 2 lbs of scallops and 3 lbs of Atlantic swordfish. The gentleman at the counter was outstanding. Every employee who walked by said GM and offered to help, which was a nice touch. I love that they have a Japanese sushi chef preparing boxes of sushi and sashimi. The cheese section was appetizing as always. The Italian soda selection is awesome. Loved walking by the fruits. Bright, colorful and gorgeous displays. The hours here are slightly different from the other locations. M- F 8-8, Sat 9-6 and Sun 10-4. Please park in the back. It's free. Welcome to another lucky neighborhood Iavarone Brothers Quality Foods. read more

See all

Wow! Very classy looking marketplace! Love how easy it was to walk around and see what they carried. Great sandwiches, pizza, bread, produce, seafood, pasta and pastries. The prepared foods lack consistency, are either very good, or mediocre. I had a flyer for $2 off IB Store Salads and the cashier refused to honor the promotion. Certain things like this just gives me a headache! Improvements are desperately needed in the parking lot. Parking spaces are too tight between cars and lots of bumps/potholes. There's no way you can use a shopping cart to get around. Better off just carrying your groceries to your car! read more

See all

Lots of expired items left out for purchase . Ridiculous no excuse won't go back. Loud music playing too very annoying

This is the the condition of the blueberry pound cake I purchased from your store. We opened it the same day we purchased it and found it covered in mold. This is not a matter of a product being a little past its prime; it was clearly old and unsanitary when it was sold. My pregnant wife, who has a severe mold allergy, ate a piece before we noticed the mold. The fact that you sold a product in this condition, especially one that could pose a serious health risk to a vulnerable individual, is a profound failure of your standards. This is a matter of food safety and your establishment poses a risk to people who have vulnerability with their health read more

Iavarone Bros - Moldy Sugar Free Blueberry Pound Cake - Delis Near Me - Garden City, New York

See all

I like the food but some of the young kids at check out make it a singularly unpleasant experience. Rushed, impersonal and with zero "f*;ks to give. read more

Ordered homemade chicken parmigiana. It was so tough that I threw it in the garbage. What is wrong with your butchers? This is chicken for God's sake. It should be cut correctly by the butcher's department. I should have bought it back and told the manager to try to eat it. Waste of hard earned money. read more

Great addition to 7th street! Abundance of prepared foods to facilitate a stress free dinner after work, plus grocery offerings as well. We sampled a few sides- sushi. cucumber salad, pasta with broccoli and mushroom, meatball, and broccoli rabe. We enjoyed everything and felt costs were fair. Will definitely be back to sample more goodies! read more

We used to come here every 2 weeks to buy our favorites, especially the grazing board and the charcuterie. We like buying prepared foods for my elderly mom and for easy dinners during the week. Lately, our favorite prepared meals from Iavarone in Garden City has been super salty. I can't give them 5 stars for that reason alone. It's become a hit or a miss now with them. read more

I shopped Iavarone Bros yesterday . I parked in there lot .One Hour parking ! You got to be kidding . I parked 12:30 and got a ticket @ 1:35 . You can't have restrictions when you're shopping. It's just more revenue for Garden City! read more

Smaller Iavarone market with a focus on prepared foods. Great spots to pick up a quick meal for lunch for dinner. The prepared foods counter seemed larger than other locations. They have grocery items too, but the selection isn't as vast as other Iavarone locations. Same quality as you'd expect at the other locations. read more

Stopped in Ivarone today because I wanted fresh stuffed shell for dinner. While we were there my husband picked up a lobster tail pastry. We were so disappointed. The stuffed shells didn't taste fresh. The stuffing was not creamy at all. It was thick and pasty. The pastry was soggy. So disappointed after spending the money. The sausages and the Italian bread was good. Then to top things off when we got to the car we had a ticket. Ugh. Don't know when I'll be going back. read more

They had a vast selection of prepared foods. I tried the rigatoni bolognese and found it was too salty. This was a month ago. I hope they changed the recipe since then. It makes me hesitant to try other dishes. Other than that, it was clean and friendly. The checkout line went fast. read more

They offer some great prepared food and great desserts. Many other good selections available also.

the consistency of their quality of food is not good. You cannot depend on an item being good all the time. The lentil soup is loaded with lentils at first then you order it again and its watered down. The shrimp salad is also changing. Also some good items just disappear. I loved the barley soup but now its not there. Someone has to change their product availability and make things high quality ALL THE TIME. read more

When the Garden City store opened up last year, everything was delicious, but my last two visits got a thumbs down from the family critics. Biggest disappointment was the Chicken Iavarone. If this is their signature dish, it's not going to attract repeat customers. WAY TOO SALTY to the point that half the dish was tossed out. Chicken Francese looked nice until it was tasted. Another disappointment, with a heavy dose of salt ruining it. Pinza style pizza slices were better tasting. Zucchini with breadcrumbs was just OK. No complaints about the fresh ravioli bought on a prior visit. But all in all, the management could be doing better with the prepared foods that look very nice, but don't meet the taste test for good Italian cuisine. read more

I love you guys, but the lack of staff behind the counter between 4PM and 7PM has turned me off after my 3rd time in two weeks. Cashier said the counter staff is used for deliveries and catering during those hours. I'm going elsewhere unless it's on a weekend. read more

Great service from a young man named Luciano. He knew all my questions and was so kind and the food was great.