I think of myself as a pretty open minded person. When debating with friends about sports,…read morepolitics, current events- I always try to respect everyone else's opinions, allow myself to possibly have my mind changed, or agree to disagree sometimes. That being said- there is one debate where I will not give an inch, will not back down, will not be dissuaded or told I am wrong: Supreme has the best grinders- full stop. Every aspect of every grinder I've ever had from them (that number is probably nearing four digits, since I've been coming here since the early 90's) has been flawless. The fresh bread, the meat, the cheese, the crisp shredded lettuce- all comes together to form THE perfect grinder, every single time. I can't think of a single other restaurant where I've never thought, "Eh, not their best." A supreme grinder will hit the spot day in and day out. The grinders aren't the only place Supreme shines though- the pizza is out of this world. Living in southeastern Connecticut, I'm well aware that I'm spoiled when it comes to pizza. Within a stones throw, there are a half dozen excellent options. When I get that craving, though, Supreme is always my top choice. As good as the meals are, half the fun is going to pick it up. Tim, Nick, and the rest of the staff create a friendly, fun, and vibrant atmosphere where something as simple as picking up lunch makes you feel like you're visiting family. Oh yeah- Don't forget the rice pudding!

I went to Supreme Pizza in Waterford CT, unfortunately my experience was disappointing…read more I ordered a small turkey club with light mayo and oil and vinegar, but the oil and vinegar were never added to my sandwich. While it is clear that they take care of their regular customers, they also need to pay closer attention to and accommodate new customers as well. Because of this experience, I was disappointed and will not return when visiting Connecticut again.

This is probably my favorite pizza place in Connecticut…read more I always get the buffalo chicken pizza, it's phenomenal . The pizza here tastes fresh, and it isn't greasy. I could eat 5 slices and it won't mess up my stomach afterwards like other places.

The food was excellent here. The pizza and the garlic bread were highlights. The reason we gave…read morethis place 4 stars was because the service was one of the worst I've ever experienced at any restaurant. I hate to comment on service as a person who was a waitress for ten years, but it was unbelievably bad. I hovered between 3 and 4 stars from this review because of how bad the service was. I ended with four because the food was very good.

We've been coming here since the 1970s and have never walked away dissatisfied. They've been in…read morebusiness for more than 60 years. You will be warmly greeted and treated with kindness. They have an extensive menu and everything we've ever had was absolutely delicious. We've had pizza, fried clams, salads, and many different sandwiches and grinders. Yesterday we had a small sausage/pepperoni pizza and a Chef's Salad. FYI: the salad is large enough for 3 or 4 people, if you care to share. The ambiance is casual. The restaurant is very clean. There is road parking out front and a smallish private parking lot along the side and in the back. There is a back door entrance if you park in back. There are many good things to say about Ocean Pizza in New London. We highly recommend them. Actually, I can't believe we haven't left a review before. They certainly deserve the 5 stars we're giving them.

Ocean Pizza is one of those rare, family-owned restaurants that immediately makes you feel at home…read morethe moment you walk through the door. There's something special about a place where you can sense the care, history, and pride behind the counter, and this is exactly that kind of spot. The atmosphere is welcoming, the service is genuinely personal, and you can tell the staff takes joy in what they do. I ordered a classic pepperoni pizza, and it arrived hot, fresh, and absolutely delicious. The crust had that perfect, old-school texture you only get from a place that's been doing it right for years. The pepperoni had just the right amount of crisp, and the cheese was melted beautifully--simple, traditional, and incredibly satisfying. We also tried the onion rings, and I have to stop and highlight them: Who is still making onion rings fresh these days? These folks are--and you can taste the difference. Golden, crisp, and not the least bit greasy. It's the kind of side that reminds you why homemade is always worth it. I was dining with friends who ordered the chicken salad and the fish and chips. Both dishes were generously portioned and prepared with the same level of care. The fish and chips in particular drew a lot of praise at our table. If you're anywhere near New London, don't miss this gem. Ocean Pizza is the kind of place that reminds you why family-run restaurants are so treasured--great food, warm people, and a sense of tradition that keeps you wanting to come back. Highly recommended.

Want to visit a place no one in the family will complain about? This is your destination!…read more We stopped here for lunch after 25 minutes in the car waffling on where to go. I remembered we stopped here a couple of years ago and it's time to return. I had the chicken parm grinder with fried peppers and it was so melt in your mouth tasty I could eat it again right now. The cheese was gooey and stringy while keeping the chicken crunchy (how did you do that?). My son had the gluten free pizza with bacon and ate the whole thing. Nice crunchy crust, pizza wasn't too watery as gluten free sometimes is. Excellent meal and friendly service. Solid choice in the area!

I am new to Waterford and gluten-free diet. Always wanted to visit Crown Pizza. I was starving and…read morealone. The server was amazingly knowledgeable. I got a small vegetable pizza on gluten free crust. It was outstanding! One of the best pizzas I've had on a very long time. Crown Pizza has a great atmosphere, busy but relaxing and quiet.

We haven't been to Recovery Room in quite some time but stopped for a late lunch. It's still as…read moregood as we remember. The chopped pasta salad is always a go to item on the menu. Definitely add the blackened chicken and it's a great meal or shareable item. We also shared the buffalo chicken wrap, which had good tang and was enhanced with some nice crispy bacon. The fries that came with that sweat were some of the best I've had in recent memory.. Our server was ultra attentive, checking on us very frequently to see if we needed anything. She was truly amazing. The decor is a little bit dated, but it maintains a homey atmosphere. Our table top had some cracking on it from age. The restaurant is very clean. We won't stay away so long next time. Their pizza has always been very good so we'll have to try that again.

We were a party of 8 I ordered a sausage pizza , the group had various items, chicken tenders,…read morespaghetti, wings etc. Everything came out in a timely manner the food was hot and fresh . The drinks and atmosphere a vibe. Our waitress was cool, patient and attentive.

Parking available in the front when we arrived and additional parking in the back. We were the only…read morecustomers when we arrived so were quickly seated. We ordered our drinks. They had a more extensive drink menu available with various mixed drinks and wine. The servers/waiters were attentive without being too invasive. The caprese salad was delicious and filling. The PEI Gorgonzola Mussels were good. I was expecting more of a gorgonzola flavoring so it missed the mark slightly for that. They were perfectly cooked. The short rib was tender and the grilled swordfish was amazing without any of the sides. The warm apple crostata should definitely be shared with others. It was warm, flaky, and balanced well with the caramel drizzle, whipped cream, vanilla gelato. This place is perfect for an intimate dinner, bar seating, or group! Plenty of space for all!

Had the chicken parm and a garden salad. Loved the salad but I felt the chicken was a bit on the…read moredry side.....but still, pretty good. Atmosphere was welcoming and the staff were super friendly. I will be back next time I am in the area.

Parker and his crew have elevated College Pizza AKA Fred's Shanty!…read moreTakeout orders are always correct. My wife says that their gluten-free pizza is the best she has ever had.

Very good. Nice crust. Fast and friendly service. Easy to order online from their extensive menu…read more We will be come back.

Food is amazing. I love the chicken parm that Raphael makes. I found out from the owner that they…read moreuse a locally sourced baker for their grinders/garlic bread, wings are made in-house, and dough is made in house, fresh and daily. What can be better than that? Oh right, their generous Italian dinner portions!

This is the driest pizza EVER ! almost NO SAUCE!…read moreI called and and explained my disfatiction With my pizza.i was hung up on after hearing all kinds of yelling and cuss words in the back round! after that they would not answer my calls!!! new owners? NOT THE SAME ! Not even close! I will NEVER buy pizza here again EVER!!!!!​

I was passing through on my way back to Boston and stopped in for a bite. Amazing tomato pie and…read moremy friends had a pizza and sandwiches. Delicious. Going to make a trip to Mystic and will definitely make a special stop there for lunch again.

I stopped by Illiano's Real Italian Pizzeria while in the area with my family. There's plenty of…read moreparking outside, which is always a plus. Inside was well lit, but overall it felt a bit dirty. The bathroom especially was filthy, which definitely set a bad tone. The staff was friendly enough and ordering was easy. I grabbed a few slices to get a feel for the place. The pepperoni slice was fine, nothing bad but nothing memorable. The buffalo chicken slice was probably the best one. Decent flavor, not the best I've had, but okay. Then came the four cheese slice. Mozzarella, ricotta, blue cheese, and another cheese that was mentioned too fast to catch. Unfortunately, this slice had a piece of hair on it, which was pretty gross. I brought it to their attention and while they did replace it, they didn't seem overly concerned. The replacement slice was hair free but extremely salty and very blue cheese forward. I couldn't finish it. Overall, the food looked better than it tasted. Nothing was terrible, but nothing stood out either. Between the cleanliness issues and the hair situation, I'm not sure I'd come back based on this experience.

I had not had there pizza until recently and it was the best pizza and reasonably priced. It was…read moreNew Haven style thin crust and delicious. I would definitely recommend it.

Ordered a chicken, bacon ranch grinder with sweet potato fries from this restaurant. The overall…read moregrinder was good . It had a Hefty amount of bacon on it and plenty of lettuce and tomato. The Only thing I would suggest is to cut back on the seasoning they put on the chicken itself. There is Way too much on it making it super salty. Food was delivered to me by friendly staff.