Permanently closed. Modest accommodations but spectacular location. These folks were very kind to…read moreme many summers and even one fall over the course of a decade.

We stayed here for one night for a wedding on the island. This was one of the few B&Bs where you…read morecould rent only one night instead of being bound to renting for the entire weekend. The rates were great--probably one of the lowest on the island. While the B&B is on the outskirts of downtown area, its only a 10-15 min walk to the landing dock for the ferry. The rooms are small but comfortable, and the place is pretty quiet. I thought we would hear our neighbors, but we didn't. The place has that old historic charm, with rooms and bathrooms being functional, but nothing fancy. The breakfast was the usual--bagels, muffins, coffee, juice. I'd recommend snacking on this and then heading into town for a real brunch. Overall, a great deal at that price and lcoation!

Incredible stay for 5 nights at the Lightkeepers Inn. Great location, outstanding service. If you…read moreare thinking of staying in Edgartown, stay here! We loved every minute of it

When I first made the reservation here, I was not completely familiar with the geography of the…read moreisland. I was a bit hesitant afterwards, as their location in Edgartown is several miles away from the ferry terminal. However, after our stay, this was not a concern. Edgartown is somewhat quieter and a bit less 'touristy' to me (though the town largely caters to tourists). One thing that drew me to this property also was the expense vs. ratings. Many other similarly (or lower) rated places were much more expensive. It is all relative on the island, but this, to me, was a good value. I was a bit apprehensive also about getting checked in, as our ferry reservations were such that we would barely arrive by their 5 p.m. front-office closing time. They confirmed that they could leave the key in an envelope for us, but that always seems slightly problematic. However, it all worked out and we did arrive at 5 p.m. The innkeeper was assisting other guests so our key was in an envelope anyway, but she showed up about 3 minutes later to ensure everything was fine and took time to explain anything extra about the room. The site is about 1 block from the edge of the town's commercial district, so walking anywhere in town is easy. Parking is not expansive, but you just need to park parallel to a fence adjacent to your room. This was never a difficulty while we were there. The area was quiet also; not much noise to disturb you. The room itself was well equipped. There was a small kitchenette and a dinette table, along with a sitting area (with a fold-out couch). When the couch was folded out, the room was a bit cramped (but that is when you're sleeping, mostly). The couch-bed involved an air mattress that was easy to inflate. The adjoining bedroom was also a bit small, but adequate. Everything was clean and appeared well-maintained. In all, the only limiting factor here was room-size, but I was also unwilling to pay $100 (or more) a night for more space. It was a slight compromise, but worth it. If I returned to the island, I'd consider staying here again.

Wonderful Nantucket Whalers Home renovated & decorated with charm & class. Lovely cheerful rooms,…read morechic public spaces & luxe amenities. A marvelous breakfast rather European in feeling, a fun " happy hour" where you BYOB but they supply the mixers & bites to chocolates chip cookies, home made & topped w/ coarse sea salt- it's a quiet, stylish spot in ACKs most historic neighborhoods. They also own 21 Broad.. On Broad street- another winner. Check Out The Charm

We stayed at this bed and breakfast for 2 nights in the spring, and had a wonderful experience. The…read morestaff is friendly, welcoming, and helpful. We had to make a change to our reservation and they were able to accommodate our request. The room was small, but very clean, stylish, and comfortable. The patio area was very nice. The location was excellent and we were able to walk to or bike to anything and everything we wanted to on the island from here. The food was delicious as well. The staff was also kind enough to gift us with a nice bottle of wine in our room, as we were there celebrating an anniversary. Lovely experience and would be happy to recommend to others and return there myself.

so far extreme disappointment we were supposed to met at…read moreferry, we were not.Called hotel and one eventually sent. eventually checked into room which was smaller then any junior suite i have ever seen ( does not even have a closet or a bath) and over 80 degrees. apologies given since AC broken through out the hotel, but they are "working on it" so i guess that's alright mattress does not even cover frame so extreme care needed getting out of bed, painful ankles remind one not to get out of bed casually. upside is it is in Nantucket so we can go elsewhere for a lovely dinner it gets better turns out our suite with 2 rooms and patio (as booked) turns into a small standard room. so short stay made shorter trying to get proper room

One of the nicest hotels I have ever had the pleasure staying in! We had our own private suite with…read morebedroom, living room, dining/kitchen area, enormous bathroom, washer and dryer, and even our own outdoor space. It was almost like renting our own little nantucket cottage with a private entrance to our suite from the neighborhood outside. The service was impeccable as well as all the little, decadent, included perks. Every morning there are amazing pastries in the reception area. I got an assortment of danishes, croissants, and muffins thinking to just sample a bit. I ate it ALL. Each room gets their own drip coffee and nespresso machine. In the afternoons they set out cookies, and in the early evenings are wine and cheese. There are also complimentary bicycles, which allowed me the chance to check out quite a few of the local beaches and lighthouses nearby. One afternoon we went to the pool and enjoyed our private cabana and snacks, drinks, and even fresh fruit! They even provided us with sunscreen and signed copies of nantucket-y beach reads. Seriously, they've thought of everything. Such a relaxing vacation and I hope to come back one day!

Finished a 4 nite stay the first week of October. Outstanding accommodations, caring, attentive…read moreand thoughtful staff throughout the stay. Josie was simply a highly professional and accommodating person. She truly understands what it means to make people feel special and was able to handle a few of our requests with ease! We stayed in a top floor suite with two awesome deck areas overlooking water street. The room was clean and well appointed, bedding was overly comfortable . There are no elevators , so be prepared to get some great exercise if your lucky enough that access the third floor. The property is very well maintained. Great location too. Very central access to waking Edgartown - and easy access to the many island highlights. Side note : Being a huge fan of JAWS, I was so delighted to determine this property was shooting location along Water street it was shown in the scene where Brody walked to the hardware store across from the bike store which now houses a great coffee shop. So close to the Chappy ferry as well. Highly recommend this property -

Quite simply, "Thr Best". This historic B&B is perfection. The decor is exquisite, the location is…read morecentrally located, and the cleanliness couldn't be better. But, it was hostess, MaryGail, who made our stay unforgettable. We will always associate Martha's Vineyard with memories of her graciousness, generosity, warm laughter and beautiful spirit. She makes you feel welcomed and at home, as if you're visiting a friend. Bravo to The Christopher for having such a wonderful person as their manager. The only caveat to booking at The Christopher is the very steep narrow staircase to the upper floors. A second handrail would be a good safety measure. These stairs would prohibit some from being able to access the upstairs rooms.

There is something about the Cliffside that is pure magic. I came here originally because I was an…read moreavid reader of Elin Hildebrand novels. But I came back because of her ex- husband Chip, who runs the place and makes every guest feel like they're family. . . Jimmy, the bartender, who will go out of his way to get the ingredients for your favorite drink if they don't have it and then make you a vat of it to bring to your room . . . And Ben, their secret weapon at the front desk who can get you even the most impossible of dinner reservations. Being a guest at the Cliffside is like being a part of the most beautiful of families during the duration of your stay. And whoever is reading this, I urge you to ignore the negative reviews. I have travelled the world and stayed at many 5 star establishments, but I've never been anywhere that's come close to recreating the magic that you will experience during your stay at the Cliffside.

Great location for the view. Pool, gym and hot tub and proximity to Galley Beach. Sadly very noisy…read moreboardwalk style walkways on both sides of the room with foot traffic starting at 7am. Staff have shared info on quieter parts of the property.

Staying here for a few nights while at the vineyard for a work meeting. It's a central location,…read moreperfect walking area for coffee, shops and more. Check in was smooth, the room is cute and has comfy bedding. I stayed in room 306. It has a wonderful Balcony and a small wet bar area which is great for a person with food allergies to have a little set up. It is close to the ferry walkable if you are mobile and able. If you have any mobility issues I would suggest taxi even though it is close all the streets to get there are brick or cobblestone and very uneven which made for a treacherous short walk for me in the dark. Not the business issue just an FYI.

A group of friends and I visited this spa while on vacation last July. We figured it would be a fun…read moregirls' outing. Overall, I'd say that the experience was below average to average. The amenities were pretty basic and the facilities were dated. Perhaps the hotel side is nice, but the spa needs a bit of renovation. I don't plan on returning anytime soon.

The good: - close to the beach…read more - they technically have a pool. It's small so your proximity to splashing kids is likely - clean rooms and bedding - small convenience store with last-minute beach items like swimsuits and sunblock The could-be-better: Rented a room for my family of four. The room came with two bath towels. We generally need six; one for each person and another for hair, etc. Came back to the room after room service and one was missing. Took a trip to the front desk, where the manager eyed me warily as I approached. "Can I get an extra bath towel?" "Didn't room service come to your room?" "They did but were missing a towel." "How many do you have?" (Getting annoyed) "Five but missing one." "Why do you need another one?" (Getting very annoyed. Consider telling him to just give me another towel.) "Medical reasons." (Hands it over grudgingly while watching to see if I steal a complementary mint as well) - rooms are upgraded from the 60's. Not a lot of storage for suitcases and the like, - bathrooms are small. After a while, the overhead light turns off and a UV light kicks on, giving you a complementary sun tan or skin cancer, depending on your point of view. Assume this is an odd way to sterilize the rooms...? - loud in-wall ac/heater. Bring earplugs for a quiet sleep. This place is probably fine if two people are staying overnight. For a family of four, the quarters are tight and there just isn't room to feel spread out.

I booked this hotel last minute for the weekend (Off-season) and it was around $85 per night which…read moreI feel is a great deal. The gentlemen at the desk were very nice and helpful with check-in. They have snacks and drinks in the lobby for purchase. My room was so cute. They did really well with the furniture and the pillows/bedding. The bed was so soft and the pillows actually have some plush to them. I hate flat pillows. They also have enough pillows (4 per bed plus 2 decorative smaller pillows that were also very soft). The room was very clean and the bathroom was also very nice. I really love how it's decorated and actually gives beach vibes over your standard chain hotel. There is a good fridge that kept my drinks cold and a full size mirror! I feel like the full length mirror is dying in some hotels so I was happy to see it. There is ample parking and it's super quiet at night. Check out was relatively easy and the guys were nice and quick to offer recommendations. Overall, I will definitely book this place again.